[Q] Is it just me but is our power button way sensitive? - AT&T Samsung Galaxy S II SGH-I777

Do you think the power button is way to damn sensitive!!!!!! For like 2 weeks I thought I was having processor problems with my phone resetting, but then after a little testing I noticed the power button on our phones require little pressure to activate it. You can seriously just hold your phone over the button without applying any pressure and it will activate. I noticed having a good case helps with the problem. I have a Trident case and a Casemate. The Trident case is practically unusable because the phone will constantly reset with it on. Whats your guys thoughts?

I don't find I have that problem, could be a defective device
Sent from my SGH-I777 using xda premium

Well I dont think so.. Mine seems fine..

I just put pressure on the button for a while, & if it required any more pressure to work I'd say it wasn't sensitive enough. I think it's just right for me.

Defective device, my power button is fine.

Interesting, I don't have to click in the power button to activate it. So consensus says defect?
Sent from my AT&T I777 running AOKP build 33

jthatch12 said:
Interesting, I don't have to click in the power button to activate it. So consensus says defect?
Sent from my AT&T I777 running AOKP build 33
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes because I have to push mine to get it to work. Better than the inspire, which you have to jam your finger against to get it to work.
Sent from my SGH-I777 using xda premium

Related

Is my power button broken?

Sigh...
Whenever I press my power button, I have to press it directly in the middle to get the screen to turn on. If I press the button towards the edge (left or right) the button just pushes down (becomes flush with the phone frame) and there is no click and the screen doesn't turn on. Not being picky, I just have to press the button more than 3-4 times and it feels loose.
Is anyone else's phone like this? Would help if someone could post a picture of the plastic tab underneath their power button. It feels like mine is broken.
I dunno about you but sometimes my power button won't even work. I have to take the case off, remove the battery, put it back in, then restart the phone to get it to work again. Kinda strange...
i was thinking i had the same issue earlier, then i just reseated the back and now all is well... now if i can get the rubberized black case from sprint i will be in full effect!
If you take the cover off, you will see that the button is a very small rubber and it lines up with the power button on the case, so you have to press it in the middle
So does this fix apply to power buttons that are really easily pressed too?
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
devgrp said:
If you take the cover off, you will see that the button is a very small rubber and it lines up with the power button on the case, so you have to press it in the middle
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've actually taken the case off and pressed the button to see if the phone would turn on. Yeah no go. It's like it locked up or something.
My evo 3d has a super sensitive power button.. it does not click at all. If I hold my phone in a land scape i accidentally turn it off if i even rub my finger over it. The design of the power button is terrible
I am exchanging this phone tomorrow hopefully I wont have any further issues
Brandon_m25 said:
So does this fix apply to power buttons that are really easily pressed too?
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got a case off eBay that has the power button recessed...paid $6 Also managed to get a 32 GB SD Card for $21
My mom's is super sensitive too and is pressed when holding in landscape, also has no click. Should she take it back or has anyone opened the back and fixed it?
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
Reason I really want to know is cause she got one and gave her ogevo to my sister and she misses her og. So I talked her into trading me her 3vo for my og.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
My power button was driving ne crazy. I couldn't get it to work consistently when trying to turn the screen off, and I would sometimes get the reboot/power off confirmation box while using the phone, like the button was somehow being held down.
I found that if I pulled the top left corner of the back from the fully locked position just slightly, the button worked much better.
By this afternoon, I was tired of repositioning the back every time I took the phone out of my pocket. I went to a Sprint store, and they tried a new back. That didn't solve the problem, so they swapped my device for a new one. Problem is 100% better now. Feels great now and works perfectly.
Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk
I had the same problem with mine. Got it home from just buying it and couldn't turn it back on. Thought the battery was dead so plugged it in and presto, it came on with a decent charge still on it. Then I couldn't turn it off or put it into sleep mode. Took it back to the store 1 hour after buying it. RS exchanged it immediately, so no issue there. The new one had a definite click to the power switch where the first one had no click at all. Working great so fa.
Cool, I'm gonna get her to take it back before we switch then. Thanks guys
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
Mine is fine love how they redid it so no more broken or squeeky buttons smooth no issues love it .
ranger61878 said:
I got a case off eBay that has the power button recessed...paid $6 Also managed to get a 32 GB SD Card for $21
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Could you point me in the right direction for that kind of case?
Sent from my Shooter

Hands Down Must Have App

This will save your power button. This app uses motion detected by your proximity sensor to turn your phone on.
Just installed it and it works awesome. Works so good you can just hold your phone and wiggle your thumb in front of the sensor and it turns on. All with the same hand
Here is the link to it in the market. Enjoy
https://market.android.com/details?id=net.maicas.android.wsleep
Hit up my THANKS if you liked it.
Hmm... I'm giving this a try now. I'm worried how it will function in my pocket. Also, I'm more comfortable using my phone in my right hand.and reaching the sensor with the right hand isn't totally comfortable. But, I'll play with it and see how I like it. Cool app anyways. So thanks!
How much extra battery does it use ?
Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk
jgalan14 said:
How much extra battery does it use ?
Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Don't know. Only had it installed for a couple of hours.
Been testing this for a while now. Doesn't use any battery so that's awesome.
I had to use this on my O.G. Evo because i had worn out the power button from flashing too much. Seems like it worked ok but at times it would lock up where I couldnt get it to turn the phone on to save my life. Ofcurse I'm sure they've gone thru plenty of updates since then.
Sent from my PG86100 using xda premium
I prefer screen off and lock
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
coffeehandle said:
I prefer screen off and lock
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's what I use but it doesn't have the option to turn the screen on by tapping the sensor. I might have to check this other one out.
Why do I need to "save" my power button? That doesn't make sense, lol. As long as you're not bashing the power button to turn it on you're fine..
Tried out all ways to reliably trigger the prox sensor with one hand.
Finally fingered it out Holding the phone in my left hand, I can use my forefinger to double tap the edge of the phone just over the prox switch.
I don't have any real use for this....but it is pretty cool!
A pretty slick maneuver I found was to quick draw from my holster,then hold the phone towards the bottom, then do a quick double swipe over your sleeve then your unlocking thumb is in the right place!
zadias said:
Why do I need to "save" my power button? That doesn't make sense, lol. As long as you're not bashing the power button to turn it on you're fine..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is for people who'd rather rub the paint off the area around their prox sensor than wear out the power button. Nice to have choices, I must admit!
Mike
This would be helpful for the seidio extended battery since the power button doesn't really work
mikeyxda said:
This is for people who'd rather rub the paint off the area around their prox sensor than wear out the power button. Nice to have choices, I must admit!
Mike
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wouldn't the difference be that you have to just lightly tap the proximity sensor while you have to actually press down on the power button? I don't foresee any paint rubbing off around the sensor.
clankfu said:
Wouldn't the difference be that you have to just lightly tap the proximity sensor while you have to actually press down on the power button? I don't foresee any paint rubbing off around the sensor.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It works about half an inch from the phone also so no need to touch
Cool.
But shouldn't this be in the EVO 3D Themes and Apps forum?
mattfmartin said:
This will save your power button.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Save the Power button but totally drain your power. Battery power.
No way I'm running an app that will force my sensors to be on at all times.
I've been using this for a few hours now and it doesn't seem to be draining the battery.
Cool app, testing now.
Edit: Im on a G2, and it works sweeeeet. Still testing.
Sent from my HTC Vision using xda premium
zeuzinn said:
Save the Power button but totally drain your power. Battery power.
No way I'm running an app that will force my sensors to be on at all times.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Suit yourself, doesn't drain whatsoever.

Shaky Loose power button

is your power button do the same thing? shaky and loose!
Nothing like that here. Perfectly nice power button.
ad78 said:
is your power button do the same thing? shaky and loose!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Now that you mention it...my power button wiggles side to side loosely too. Hmmm.
My RAZR buttons are more stable than my HTC Desire Z and my iPhones.
MrFrankfromCM said:
Now that you mention it...my power button wiggles side to side loosely too. Hmmm.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ditto. Wiggles side to side.
Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk
robstunner said:
Ditto. Wiggles side to side.
Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Man..these phone manufacturers should just hire a few people from XDA for field testing..every..single..niggle..wow. We'd have perfect phones - literally. Not even a "wiggly" power button to complain about..haha.
brianbrain said:
Man..these phone manufacturers should just hire a few people from XDA for field testing..every..single..niggle..wow. We'd have perfect phones - literally. Not even a "wiggly" power button to complain about..haha.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did I complain? I just said mine wiggles. There no reason to start problems.
Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk
mine wiggles too. I think it's supposed to..
Actually, a button with a slight wiggle and or movement adds to the tactile feel. A button that is very firm, ridged etc is difficult to find and operate when one needs to operate it without looking.
opensourcefan said:
My RAZR buttons are more stable than my HTC Desire Z and my iPhones.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So you mean same tightness with the volume buttons?
ad78 said:
So you mean same tightness with the volume buttons?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The volume buttons and the power button are the same, exactly the same. They have zero movement lengthwise or side to side but have slight movement up and down.
robstunner said:
Did I complain? I just said mine wiggles. There no reason to start problems.
Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sorry, I didn't realize I was starting a problem here. I honestly felt it was rather funny that we have a thread about a wiggly power button.
brianbrain said:
I'm sorry, I didn't realize I was starting a problem here. I honestly felt it was rather funny that we have a thread about a wiggly power button.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm not rushing to the store to exchange it, however the wife's Droid razr doesn't wiggle like this. Maybe in time.
Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk
This is my 3rd razr over the button issue. The others were loose, hard to press, one even stuck inside the phone and wouldn't come out. A couple of them were flush with the side and had no travel.
This (3rd) unit has a loose power button that is flush on it's top but sticks out on the bottom at an angle.
But seriously - other than the non-replaceable battery and some screen issues, these razrs seem so much better than the Infuse or the S2
Went to verizon and they replaced it. No hassle or whatever. The guy told me its a factory defect. He makes sure the new unit is tight and good.
Very happy with the customer service
Pleased to say that I have a solid power button
Sent from my XT910 using xda premium
The power button in my RAZR was firm and solid out of the box.
After five weeks, it has become loose and shaky. Still 100% usable and I would not say it's broken but loose.
Searching the web, I`ve found similar posts related to Droids and Defys handsets.
Is this behaviour a Motorola feature?
its not really an issue untill it stops working :/ my defy and xt720 all had this but they were ok
aloner said:
The power button in my RAZR was firm and solid out of the box.
After five weeks, it has become loose and shaky. Still 100% usable and I would not say it's broken but loose.
Searching the web, I`ve found similar posts related to Droids and Defys handsets.
Is this behaviour a Motorola feature?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I think so... but dont worry, it will not be a problem.....
My power button does the same thing, it can be moved up and down without any force..
..anyway I think that isn't a casual thing, i.e. not a defect.
It's normal with buttons that aren't exactly plain with the shell to have this behavior as they feel better to touch and they're more comfortable to press.

Crappy Power Button

Is it just me or is the power button too flush to find and and too soft to press. I believe I will eventually get accustomed to its position which is a bit lower than on the GS2, but the rounded bezel and flushness seem to make it a bit hard to press sometimes. The volume rocker seems more click for some reason.
Sent from my badass Galaxy SIII.
Nobody?
Sent from my badass Galaxy SIII.
Think that's just u man. No problems with mine. Super sensitive
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
It's just you, you'll adjust to it eventually.
I had pretty much the same issue. Maybe a little worse. My power button had no "click" whatsoever. It would often get stuck in when I pressed it to shut the screen off and would then cause my phone to reboot over and over until I noticed.
This happened way more often than I would expect from a £500 phone, so I called Vodafone and explained the issue. They sent a person to deliver a brand new phone the next day and the power button on this one is much, much better. So if you think you could swing it as faulty hardware, which mine clearly was, then I'd recommend getting it replaced.
Is your power button much flusher than the volume rocker? Mine seems so.
Sent from my badass Galaxy SIII.
I think it's just you.... ive played with over a dozen S3s and all the volume buttons are clickier than the power buttons.
I am having an issue with my top volume button, it seems a bit sticky.
My power mutton is crap also, no click at all. I have samsung's slim case ant it's very hard to press power button. I bought that phone only 4 days ago, so i don't want to send it to repair service, it takes usually about 2-4 weeks
jnr21 said:
My power mutton is crap also, no click at all. I have samsung's slim case ant it's very hard to press power button. I bought that phone only 4 days ago, so i don't want to send it to repair service, it takes usually about 2-4 weeks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You shouldn't need to send it away for warranty repair, the button seems faulty, I would get it replaced. I have similar issues with mine, the power button is spongy and creaks. I will receive a door to door replacement today. Don't sell yourself short mate
yh its too flush, some times i have to double check that if its working and ive pressed it. but i got used to it
my volume up button is very sticky, sometimes press and volume goes full blast when i dont want. kinda annoying, taken button out and cleaned but no difference . not sure if i should send back as im rooted :crying:
Crazy CS said:
I think it's just you.... ive played with over a dozen S3s and all the volume buttons are clickier than the power buttons.
I am having an issue with my top volume button, it seems a bit sticky.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The volume up button broke on mine after 4 days. It stopped springing back up after pressing it. Vodafone swapped my handset, and so far so good.
It is a little worrying to see others having similar issues with their buttons - I assumed mine was an isolated incident.

Volume down sticking on VZW G2

Is anyone else having this issue? If I try to press the "volume down" physical button, if you're applying any "downward" pressure, like say sliding your finger off it, the edge sticks under the physical case and it stays held down. Not sure if this is worth returning it for, but I can see it being a pain if it gets worse. It happened last night and took me a few seconds to figure out why the display wasn't leaving the screen.
fiyawerx said:
Is anyone else having this issue? If I try to press the "volume down" physical button, if you're applying any "downward" pressure, like say sliding your finger off it, the edge sticks under the physical case and it stays held down. Not sure if this is worth returning it for, but I can see it being a pain if it gets worse. It happened last night and took me a few seconds to figure out why the display wasn't leaving the screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually, now that I tested more, if you press either vol up / down on their "edge" (where the + and - symbols are) they both stick pretty easily. Not sure I like this at all. You don't even have to press hard, just press on the edge even with a fingernail. They almost feel like individual rockers more than buttons.
They are rockers for sure. Mine doesn't get stuck when using them thank goodness. I think it feels better with the buttons like that. Imo. I love the buttons on the back and I think I'm the minority in this
Sent from my VS980 4G using Tapatalk 4
hoola20055 said:
They are rockers for sure. Mine doesn't get stuck when using them thank goodness. I think it feels better with the buttons like that. Imo. I love the buttons on the back and I think I'm the minority in this
Sent from my VS980 4G using Tapatalk 4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I like them there, I just don't like how easy they are getting stuck if you press them on the edges. Might just be a bad model, I'll have to stop by the store later.
I hadn't experienced it in daily use but I can make them stick if I press down on the edge like you mention above. I don't usually press it that way so I'm not too concerned.
I've tried to press the buttons every way possible and mine don't stick at all. Maybe exchange for a new device?
Sent from my LG-D800 using xda premium
WizeGuyDezignz said:
I've tried to press the buttons every way possible and mine don't stick at all. Maybe exchange for a new device?
Sent from my LG-D800 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is an issue with the Verizon model. From the looks of your signature, you don't have a Verizon model, thus you're not going to experience this issue. :good:
---------- Post added at 11:06 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:05 AM ----------
I'm having the same issue, but I don't think it'll be a deal breaker causing me to exchange.

Categories

Resources