Related
I just want to know what you guys think.
I'm going to be using Bilboa's kernel on both so it's basically just which ROM is better?
I'm asking because tomorrow I have a state sponsored test and when I finish I'm going to be bored and I want to experiment with one these two ROMs. So what should I flash?
UI - GPS = MIUI
Android + bonus - GPS = CM7
Tough decision, my opinion. Neither will have great battery life.
I found MIUI to be sooo beautiful but it kept getting unstable and weird on the XDA app and some other white background apps (color) but I'm on cm7 and its great and a little more stable
PS
Watch my video review on miui for a good though
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA Premium App
Alanrocks15 said:
I found MIUI to be sooo beautiful but it kept getting unstable and weird on the XDA app and some other white background apps (color) but I'm on cm7 and its great and a little more stable
PS
Watch my video review on miui for a good though
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I saw it the other day.
Meee weee lmfao
I'm thinking CM7 but it's not officially supported, but MIUI is now officially supported. hmmmmm idk
iCaptivate said:
I saw it the other day.
Meee weee lmfao
I'm thinking CM7 but it's not officially supported, but MIUI is now officially supported. hmmmmm idk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know your thinking Officially supported=bad ass
No it doesn't I found cm7 a lot more smooth and stable for me.
That being said I have a lot of apps compared to you guys so results will vary
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA Premium App
oh hey, why not try them BOTH?
s15274n said:
UI = MIUI
Android + bonus - GPS = CM7
Tough decision, my opinion.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MIUI has working GPS?
Comparing MIUI to CM7 is like a joke coz MIUI is nothing more than a cartoon theme.
MilkPudding said:
Comparing MIUI to CM7 is like a joke coz MIUI is nothing more than a cartoon theme.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A cartoon theme??
Haha!
Miui has the great looks that cm7 will never have. yeah sure you guys can change your themes... But can you change them so it affects EVERYTHING?
boot animation.
Lock screen
Icons
Font
Dialer
Mms
Theres thousands of themes, where... Well cm7 has probably a hundred.
Sucks to be you.
Emama said:
MIUI has working GPS?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1, has MIUI a working GPS?
And another quick question for you guys: which version of MIUI did you flash on your phone?
I found the one on xda forum: MIUI 1.4.8 (Beta 6) 2.3.3
or the one from SGS MIUI sourceforge : MIUI9000_RC4_VIB <-- for the Vibrant
I want to try that amazing ROM but I need your help finding the good version to flash!
Thanks
MilkPudding said:
Comparing MIUI to CM7 is like a joke coz MIUI is nothing more than a cartoon theme.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i lul'd at this.
xriderx66 said:
A cartoon theme??
Haha!
Miui has the great looks that cm7 will never have. yeah sure you guys can change your themes... But can you change them so it affects EVERYTHING?
boot animation.
Lock screen
Icons
Font
Dialer
Mms
Theres thousands of themes, where... Well cm7 has probably a hundred.
Sucks to be you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My phone has the built in theme chooser.. but I also have the flashable themed zips that are VERY professional (and change everything)... AND, my phone doesn't look like an iPhone (MIUI).
I really prefer the stock android look CM7 brings to the table. Everyone has a preference, no need to knock one over the other. That goes to the person who called MIUI a cartoon theme too, MIUI is sexy... just not MY preference.
In my mind,neither CM nor MIUI,the battery life is the key point to me when I choose a rom to flash.
Since they use the same kernel you could set up Cm7 and do a nandroid.....then flash MIUI and set it up.....then do a nandroid for MIUI. Then you can switch back and forth in less than 5 min!
In my opinion MIUI is less buggy than CM7. MIUI went official and they have fixed almost everything. The only problem i have is that GPS does not work. The battery life is average if u flash version 1.4.15. MIUI's UI is so beautiful compared to CM7.
Again, our comes down to ui, stock android with features, our android that slept with iphone.
Latest cm7 releases are stable, just no gps/poor battery.
i like miui
Actually, both stuffer from similar problems, just that miui will have it fixed, whereas cm7 is unpredictable, but maybe cm7 can take and borrowfrom miui?
I've been using miui a my main rom for about a month now and love it to death. I'm not having any stability issues with all of my Apps. Granted the GPS blows but the Vibrant GPS has always sucked the big one. If I need to use GPS that bad I just put my sim in my G1 which has ****ing amazing gps.
Sent from my T959 using XDA App
^ agree with every word.
I haven't been on a different rom than miui for over a month.
I have been running CM7 and MIUI on my SGSII but i cant make my mind up which one to stick to.
I like some things on CM7 but i also like the UI of MIUI, how easy would it be to merge both roms togeather with what i want from each rom?
I would like to use CM7 as the base as it seems to run nicer than MIUI but i like MIUI's mods and notification drop down but dont want MIUI's homescreen, also i think CM7's camera is alot better than MIUI's, also a few other bits that i cant remember.
Only problem i have is lack of knowledge about making roms etc, if anyone does have this knowledge and agrees with me and would like to make a rom like this i would help the best way i can etc.
What are your thoughts?
Sent from my GT-I9100
djsimonr said:
I have been running CM7 and MIUI on my SGSII but i cant make my mind up which one to stick to.
I like some things on CM7 but i also like the UI of MIUI, how easy would it be to merge both roms togeather with what i want from each rom?
I would like to use CM7 as the base as it seems to run nicer than MIUI but i like MIUI's mods and notification drop down but dont want MIUI's homescreen, also i think CM7's camera is alot better than MIUI's, also a few other bits that i cant remember.
Only problem i have is lack of knowledge about making roms etc, if anyone does have this knowledge and agrees with me and would like to make a rom like this i would help the best way i can etc.
What are your thoughts?
Sent from my GT-I9100
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe using cm7 and trying to find a launcher that looks as miui?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Yea i have thought about that, maybe someone will do this merge once both roms are at stable release
Sent from my GT-I9100
afilopou said:
Maybe using cm7 and trying to find a launcher that looks as miui?
Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yep, I would go this way. try CM7 with Go Launcher EX for example...
Use CM7,
Install this theme for Theme Chooser: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1189723&highlight=MIUI+CM7
Install Go Launcher EX+MIUI theme
OR
Install this launcher: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1220695
You can find more themes for QQLauncher:http://forum.xda-developers.com/search.php?searchid=89487960
Miui uses CM7 as a base and builds off it so its already merged (kinda).
Your best bet would be to pick the one you prefer, and fix/replace the things you dont like with after market apps.
I know this isnt what you wanted to hear but im afraid it's your only option.
afaik there has never been a miui/CM7 hybird.
By the sounds you want to -
Install MIUI
Install ADW launcher from the market and use that
Get a copy of the camera APK from CM7 and use that instead of MIUIs camera (sure I did this back on my SGS1)
You can pretty much get what you are after then.
Yea i know miui is already based on cm7.
Think i may use miui and then change the launcher and try and pick a few system apk's from cm7 that i want.
I take it cm7 apk's will run fine on miui seen as its running the same base?
Sent from my GT-I9100
I prefer CM7, I don't like the interface of MIUI. (yes, I just said that)
I want Android, not some iOS-nonsense.
No offense to bmarko, your doing a great job porting it.
I seriously dislike the TouchWiz UI. It's very boring and dull, I love the way stock Android looks with its dark and light blue theme, very minimalistic and intuitive and I hate the way TouchWiz is just black grey and a mixture of other colors. I'm using NovaLuancher but it only changes the home screen, I'm looking for stock android settings menu and notification/status bar. Is there a solution to this yet? Putting stock ICS on the Galaxy S3? Or are there any launchers or skins that make the settings menu and notifications look like stock ICS?
No one? I'd also like to know.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
Check themes and apps section.. If you can't find any themes, then no.. Just hang on... There will be 100 theme releases soon where all is "aosp" and every rom is AOSP themed. Cm9 and aokp will sure also find its way some day
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
norpan111 said:
Check themes and apps section.. If you can't find any themes, then no.. Just hang on... There will be 100 theme releases soon where all is "aosp" and every rom is AOSP themed. Cm9 and aokp will sure also find its way some day
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Forgive my ignorance but I've been a iOS user since the first iPhone and I just switched to ICS because I was sick of the iPhone. What is AOSP? I know what CM9 is, what would you recommend me to install on my phone?
AOSP stands for "Android Open Soruce Poject" it is basally the barebone android OS made by Google for all to see. Many roms are based off of it, as the code is release soon after googles flagship nexus devices.
I like aosp too but dont yiu guys think it makes the phone look cheap? I find touchwiz icons classy..
I would suggest waiting a month or so after your carrier gets it to put a custom ROM on it. By then a lot of bugs well have been worked out and there will be some great tutorials available.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA
Totòòò said:
I like aosp too but dont yiu guys think it makes the phone look cheap? I find touchwiz icons classy..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no, because you can customize it to your liking. there are thousands of options.
to the op download a launcher and it might imprve your experience.
I doubt CM9 or other stock ICS ROMs will have features like smart stay or s voice...if they do include them, that would be awesome!
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
CM9 for SGS3 would be custom to suit the S3.. So I'm sure it would include all the features unique only to the S3....
I think the TouchWiz 5 UI is quite nice, MUCH better than the 4.0 on my SGSII, however, I use Nova launcher because S launcher is driving me crazy
Nevertheless, AOSP is still much better, and as the SGSIII is a hugely successful and famous device, so it won't take long for the first AOSP roms to spread from the ground Just have a look at the SGSII
cheers
own4d said:
CM9 for SGS3 would be custom to suit the S3.. So I'm sure it would include all the features unique only to the S3....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think not
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Hello every1
I have been a fan of CM roms since I can remember having an Android phone, always loved the feeling of a clean Android Software.
Too bad samsung always packs touchwiz on its software, I hate its launcher, the icons, the settings menu, notification bar... Everything on it!
The problem I ham having is that going with CM based roms nowadays implies having to leave most of the amazing features of this phone behind, like its amazing camera, CM camera works, but not 100%, keeps giving me trouble and the picture quality cant be compated to Samsung roms.
Does any1 know a Samsung rom with the 100% looks of JB Android ?
Best regards
You could always grab the apex launcher....
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
More options in nova
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
katsuru said:
Hello every1
I have been a fan of CM roms since I can remember having an Android phone, always loved the feeling of a clean Android Software.
Too bad samsung always packs touchwiz on its software, I hate its launcher, the icons, the settings menu, notification bar... Everything on it!
The problem I ham having is that going with CM based roms nowadays implies having to leave most of the amazing features of this phone behind, like its amazing camera, CM camera works, but not 100%, keeps giving me trouble and the picture quality cant be compated to Samsung roms.
Does any1 know a Samsung rom with the 100% looks of JB Android ?
Best regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just for you I will make a Stock SGS3 ROM that looks like stock Android. Will it be completely AOSP looking? No, but it will be much better for you.
b-eock said:
Just for you I will make a Stock SGS3 ROM that looks like stock Android. Will it be completely AOSP looking? No, but it will be much better for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's GREAT. But is it possible to have the Jelly Bean SMS app instead of Samsung's (and same thing for Contacts app) ? The Google SMS app is much better (better looks, silent delivery reports,...), and if you can add Samsung features on it (direct call especially) you are a GOD
Looking forward to it.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
Try using the Rom foxhound 1.3. I'm also a big fan of the aosp look. But I dint want to miss out the wonderful features in the latest iteration of touchwiz, after a lot of search, now in this. Just sharing my experience. Anyways roms are always individual preference!!
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda app-developers app
Or use FoxHound i forgot about that ROM. Has everything you are looking for.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
katsuru said:
Hello every1
I have been a fan of CM roms since I can remember having an Android phone, always loved the feeling of a clean Android Software.
Too bad samsung always packs touchwiz on its software, I hate its launcher, the icons, the settings menu, notification bar... Everything on it!
The problem I ham having is that going with CM based roms nowadays implies having to leave most of the amazing features of this phone behind, like its amazing camera, CM camera works, but not 100%, keeps giving me trouble and the picture quality cant be compated to Samsung roms.
Does any1 know a Samsung rom with the 100% looks of JB Android ?
Best regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can try Romow N4 ROM. It is a Sammy based ROM with NOVA launcher pre-installed, without any bloatwares, dioxidized and rooted to the likes of many. The only reason in my case where I find this particular ROM great is that there are many features included in it such as in-built call-recorder(stalker app I know) 2 camera apps(Original Sammy and a Nexus's I believe?) , no touchwheeze and bloatwares, no lag on keyboard operations(usually found in many custom jelly bean ROMS) just to name a few. I was on CM10 before but found this a tad better especially for the fact that my OEM(China made RED cables) MHL adaptor works fine with this ROM unlike the latter. So you can give this one a try, it has been my daily driver for about a few days now.
Bluekz said:
You can try Romow N4 ROM. It is a Sammy based ROM with NOVA launcher pre-installed, without any bloatwares, dioxidized and rooted to the likes of many.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you mean DEODEXED ?
You know that performance-wise, deodexing a ROM is a huge step backwards, right?
I found absolutely no advantages in the ROM mentioned (Romow N4), and everything it provides can either be installed from the Play Store or uninstalled using Titanium Backup. Besides, it probably is MUCH, MUCH SLOWER than a stock, odexed ROM.
The only advantage of deodexing a ROM is to allow for theming the ROM by changing the resources some apps use (like the framework itself).
Simonetti2011 said:
The only advantage of deodexing a ROM is to allow for theming the ROM by changing the resources some apps use (like the framework itself).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True and if you are peformance driven, then after you are done themeing it then you will odex it back.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
b-eock said:
True and if you are peformance driven, then after you are done themeing it then you will odex it back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also true, but that's not something the regular user (which I believe is the case here) will do, or even know how to do. Therefore, my general advice for those who don't know the difference, is to simply avoid deodexed ROMs.
Just use foxhound with an theme
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2
you can simply freeze touchwiz home and use nova or apex or any other launcher out there and still enjoy the other goodies from samsung.
Everyone talks about Apex and Nova launchers but Holo is the best of them all in my opinion it's just not as widely known as the others, check it out from the market (quite similar to Apex actually but better IMO)
Guys i've started this thread to discuss about stock and cm based custom roms
1)which is better in what way
2)battery life
3)gaming performance
4)tweaks available for each
i felt that there is no thread related to this that's why started one
for battery, stock is the best
Stock FTW
Better battery,stable,camera,dialer,music and mms are very good.
Personally I miss tw goodies like integrated task manager button,camera and music player in CM7 so Stock is better for me
Yeah stock is stable, but so is cm7.
However, you miss out on the newer features offered in the cm9/ cm10 /aokp/ paranoid android roms.
I'm using PAC by nims11.
The main reason I personally prefer cm7 over stock is multitasking. On stock if I am using one application and switch to another, then switch back, my place is lost and often the first app has been killed and has to restart. That might be why cm7 supposedly uses more battery (I don't notice a difference personally, but I use my phone a lot)
I'm also not a fan of touchwiz and prefer the customization of cm7.
I love trying new roms no matter what the android version; 2.3.6, 2.3.7, 4.0 or 4.1
Kudos to all the Dev's working hard to make my old crappy ace awesome!
«««««««»»»»»»»
121C4 said:
The main reason I personally prefer cm7 over stock is multitasking. On stock if I am using one application and switch to another, then switch back, my place is lost and often the first app has been killed and has to restart. That might be why cm7 supposedly uses more battery (I don't notice a difference personally, but I use my phone a lot)
I'm also not a fan of touchwiz and prefer the customization of cm7.
I love trying new roms no matter what the android version; 2.3.6, 2.3.7, 4.0 or 4.1
Kudos to all the Dev's working hard to make my old crappy ace awesome!
«««««««»»»»»»»
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
exactly man!! i fell cm7 is the best in terms of multitasking
and ofcourse the themechooser!! i feel cm7 is better..
pradeepjoshua said:
exactly man!! i fell cm7 is the best in terms of multitasking
and ofcourse the themechooser!! i feel cm7 is better..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Seriously?
Apple VS Mango i see
i can add taskmanager button to recent panel
Sent from my ST25i using xda premium
DeadSp1d3r said:
i can add taskmanager button to recent panel
Sent from my ST25i using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How to man? ?can you share??
Sent from my GT-S5830 using xda app-developers app
madman said:
Apple VS Mango i see
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol I like it
Sent from my GT-S5830 using xda app-developers app
I miss my CM7 themes
Sent from my GT-S5830 using xda app-developers app
CM7 is best..
A little bit battery drain than stock but has more costomization for daily use..also has no bugs.. all the things is working and stable..
Actually our opinions always have a touch of personal experience. Some people use the stock based just the way they are & some people tweak it more. I've seen that the sgs II v10.1 has a great multi tasking capability ( atleast for me...) . Kranti.ace has really brought out a revolution as his name says. His rom is pretty smooth & he's promising further improvisation. What else to expect? Just the devs to bring out the better of what's already best...
I used to have beautiful life before. Now I'm in engineering...!
Completely correct.
Sent from my GT-S5830 using xda app-developers app