[Q] Tech21 impact case or Spigen SGP Neo Hybrid - Galaxy Note 3 Accessories

I recently asked a question about what extended battery/case to get but my friend had asked my if he should get the spigen neo hybrid or the Tech21 impact case. The Tech21 has better protection but the the design is bland, the Neo Hybrid has interchangeable bands. Cons of the Tech21 is price at $44.99 or $34.99 (t-mobile version). Next are the buttons (I previously had a Tech21 case for my T-Mo GS2 the buttons for power volume were hard so I'm thinking the buttons on here are the same.) Those are pretty much the cons of the Tech21. The cons of the Spigen are that when you drop it it will have a better chance of the screen cracking. So what should I give to my friend?
Thanks

asian_android said:
I recently asked a question about what extended battery/case to get but my friend had asked my if he should get the spigen neo hybrid or the Tech21 impact case. The Tech21 has better protection but the the design is bland, the Neo Hybrid has interchangeable bands. Cons of the Tech21 is price at $44.99 or $34.99 (t-mobile version). Next are the buttons (I previously had a Tech21 case for my T-Mo GS2 the buttons for power volume were hard so I'm thinking the buttons on here are the same.) Those are pretty much the cons of the Tech21. The cons of the Spigen are that when you drop it it will have a better chance of the screen cracking. So what should I give to my friend?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have both. My Neo Hybrid is my daily just because of how sleek and nice it looks get tons of comments. The Tech 21 makes the phone a little more round but is a very snug fit I have the grayish clear one. I'm not too fond of it, I also have the Body Glove Black/Brushed Aluminum Case which is very thin more to protect from scratches than drops.
Sent from my SM-N900P using XDA Premium 4 mobile app

Related

What case do you have?

So I'm not a big case person but I found a light slim case that you can hardly tell and I love it so much thought I'd share it . Let me know what you got or going to get!
Sent from my Nexus 10 using xda app-developers app
Otterbox Commuter -- its a thin, solid case, which I like.. and was only ~$26, which I also like.
otter box as well
I have a Incipio Feather case coming in soon. I tend to be pretty responsible (keeping my fingers crossed) with my phones and I like that the case helps avoid scratches without adding too much size.
I got the Otter Commuter as well.
Spi-Gen Sante Red
Sent from my Galaxy S4
White SGP Neo Hybrid
-Sent from my TMO Samsung Galaxy S4 using Tapatalk 2
I ordered a Cruzerlite bugdroid circuit for mine.
i HAAAATE cases, but alas, i must since my kids will destroy my phones.
i have Spigen S4 Case Neo Hybrid.
yyhd said:
i HAAAATE cases, but alas, i must since my kids will destroy my phones.
i have Spigen S4 Case Neo Hybrid.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Haha yep. Same here.
Otterbox commuter. I wanted a sleek metal case but was concerned about interference.
Really pleased with the otterbox, they have made major improvements since the last time I saw one a couple years ago. Slides easily in/out of pockets.
Awesome simple case and VERY cheap!
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B000SV5HGS/ref=redir_mdp_mobile/179-8729360-7560856
Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk 2
Man I wish I had seen that Neo Hybrid before I ordered my Cygnett UrbanShield Carbon Fiber Case.
I just ordered the Spigen Ultra Air case from Amazon. Looks very nice and not bulky.
cruizer lite here
i have three cases, all made by spgen. Neo Hybrid, Slim Armor and an Ultra Fit (got this one free).
I'll most likely go with the Neo Hybrid but we'll see how it fits and if it offers enough protection
I currently have a Rearth Ringke Slim (Black). I ordered the Aero UAG case and waiting on that. That is a cool looking case. I originally had ordered the Spigen in Slate Blue, but after seeing the UAG, I cancelled the order (about $30 with shipping from imarine.com)
That thing looks like it's made to be taken through combat... good grief. I don't want my phone to remind me of MIL-Crates though had enough of that over there...
SPG Neo Hybrid blk/yellow. Awesome little case keeps it very slim and gives good grip for such a thin phone.
Currently have the Otterbox Commuter. I normally use the Defender series but I couldn't find one local. Might get a Defender down the road. The Commuter is slim, but slick.

[Q] To get a case and a glass cover?

First I'd like to introduce myself, I'm InfamousChicken, or you can call me Tim if you prefer. I can't wait to divulge myself into this community and talk with people and make some friends, now onto my question.
I am buying the Galaxy S4 next week, and I wasn't sure what I should get case wise. I was thinking of getting the Otterbox Commuter, along with getting Glass.tR Is this a wise choice and will it keep my phone and screen safe?
I'd post links if I was allowed to, but with 4 million users I understand they may not want that!
Thanks guys!
Hi Tim, welcome to XDA! You may want to check out the Accessories forum: http://forum.xda-developers.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2317
There are a ton of case-specific threads/posts with very helpful reviews and pictures. Personally, I use a red Spigen Neo Hybrid and I love it. There's a ton of photos/reviews in that forum, so check them out.
ttupa said:
Hi Tim, welcome to XDA! You may want to check out the Accessories forum: http://forum.xda-developers.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2317
There are a ton of case-specific threads/posts with very helpful reviews and pictures. Personally, I use a red Spigen Neo Hybrid and I love it. There's a ton of photos/reviews in that forum, so check them out.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I was looking through that. How do you feel like that is for protection, and how do you feel that is protection for your screen incase you drop it face first?
Yes I also have the neo hybrid case and glasstr by spigen lovly combo. Im sure its good w/a commuter case as well
Sent from my galaxy s4 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
InfamousChicken said:
Thanks, I was looking through that. How do you feel like that is for protection, and how do you feel that is protection for your screen incase you drop it face first?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It has a very minimal lip surrounding the screen, so if it were to fall completely flat, I don't think there would be much for protection. However, most drops land on corners or edges. In that case, I think the Neo Hybrid provides very adequate protection - at least for me. I typically use phones without a case, as I think cases cover up the beauty of the phone and add bulk. This case feels and looks amazing, better than the pictures IMO. The only downside I can think of is the slim cutout of the headphone port.
What about the Spigen Slim Armor case, would it be as equally good or better than the commuter?
The slim armor is on sale if you bundle it with the glass screen protector, 40 dollars for both. That's what I would do.
sent from my galaxy s4
Hi Tim, Welcome!
I decided on the MIME Ghost Glass for my GS4 for 3 main reasons instead of the Spigen glass protector. To note, I have the Spigen Neo Hybrid case.
1st reason: Spigen glass has a hardness rating of 8H-9H and the MIME was a solid 9H rating (Gorilla Glass 3 i think is a 7H-8H). That means it takes something harder to scratch it.
2nd reason: Spigen has a thickness of .40mm and MIME was .32mm. This i noticed after I installed the glass... The MIME Ghost Glass STILL sits lower then the rubber edge of the Neo Hybrid case so setting it face down, the glass still doesn't touch the table, and it BARELY sits below the case edge leaving me to believe the Spigen glass would be even with or sitting past/above the edge of the case.
3rd reason: I don't think that Spigen has a lifetime warranty with their glass protector. MIME Ghost Glass does. It's lifetime but its not replacement its 60% off your next glass it the first one you bought gets scratched/cracked.
I hope this helps your decision.
Eric
this may be a dumb question, but what is the advantage of a glass screen cover as opposed to flexible plastic one. i just ordered 6 matte/anti-glare covers on ebay for like $5 and they're great. fingerprints are a thing of the past, not that it was that big of a problem with the bare screen. but what is so much better about the glass? i've never covered a phone with a glass screen cover, but i'm definitely interested in why i should be.
it is glass... simply put. It feels just like the gorilla glass so it feels and looks like you have nothing on your phone!
Plus it protect ur screen much better than a plastic protector. I think u get around 3-4 hardness when then spigen glass ones get 8-9 hardness. If u drop ur phone on the screen the glass screen will crack before ur phone screen. Yea its alil pricey for 1 but its worth it
Sent from my galaxy s4 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
Eric214 said:
Hi Tim, Welcome!
I decided on the MIME Ghost Glass for my GS4 for 3 main reasons instead of the Spigen glass protector. To note, I have the Spigen Neo Hybrid case.
1st reason: Spigen glass has a hardness rating of 8H-9H and the MIME was a solid 9H rating (Gorilla Glass 3 i think is a 7H-8H). That means it takes something harder to scratch it.
2nd reason: Spigen has a thickness of .40mm and MIME was .32mm. This i noticed after I installed the glass... The MIME Ghost Glass STILL sits lower then the rubber edge of the Neo Hybrid case so setting it face down, the glass still doesn't touch the table, and it BARELY sits below the case edge leaving me to believe the Spigen glass would be even with or sitting past/above the edge of the case.
3rd reason: I don't think that Spigen has a lifetime warranty with their glass protector. MIME Ghost Glass does. It's lifetime but its not replacement its 60% off your next glass it the first one you bought gets scratched/cracked.
I hope this helps your decision.
Eric
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sold on mime glass, my only question now is, what should I get with it to make a solid combo that will keep my phone safe. I guess it is true that in a drop, people are more worried about shattering their screen.
But It's either Spigen Neo Hybrid case.
Otterbox Commuter
Spigen Neo Galaxy S4 Case Slim Armor
or the WorkMate by cygnett
Which is sturdier of the 3? Which spigen neo is sturdier?

Neo Hybrid or Slim Armour?

I am torn between these 2 cases from Spigen
From what i have read the Slim Armour offers more protection and a bit more bulk however the Neo Hybrid is obviously slimmer and looks better, although i suppose the looks go on personal preference
Just wondering if anyone has any of these and would you recommend them?
I would recommend both cases. I prefer the slim armor though since I've dropped every phone I've ever owned multiple times. It is more protective, buttons aren't loose and the overall fit is tighter. Like a perfect glove. I still use my Neo though. I love the look and use it on quick trips to store etc.
I had a new hybrid before. And it's a nice case however, the plastic ring around the outside was pretty flexible and it eventually broke. So I ordered a UAG case for my note 3.
I also recommend both cases. I have the white slim armor and I have 2 neo hybrids. A satin silver and a champagne gold. Both are great cases but I'd trust my Slim Armor more to take a fall. The white Slim Armor is $12.99 in the US if I'm not mistaken
Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk 2
xXJay_RXx said:
I also recommend both cases. I have the white slim armor and I have 2 neo hybrids. A satin silver and a champagne gold. Both are great cases but I'd trust my Slim Armor more to take a fall. The white Slim Armor is $12.99 in the US if I'm not mistaken
Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wonder if slim armor is smaller than the bounce...
I bought and received the Slim Armor case from Spigen in Slate color and man, this is a quality case. It fits snugly and perfectly. Everything is flawless. This is probably the nicest case I've ever had.
It does add some bulk to the phone but it's not a whole lot.
KOKJ said:
I bought and received the Slim Armor case from Spigen in Slate color and man, this is a quality case. It fits snugly and perfectly. Everything is flawless. This is probably the nicest case I've ever had.
It does add some bulk to the phone but it's not a whole lot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does anyone know the actual thickness of the case in millimeters???
nijkap said:
Does anyone know the actual thickness of the case in millimeters???
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I measured mine and it was 13mm. This case definitely adds some bulk to the phone. Holding just the phone naked is ok, but it is not as comfortable with the case on for me.
Just a question : do you have some signal loss with the case put on the phone (either wifi or gsm) : how many DB (decibel) do you lose on the signal while putting it ?
My neo hybrid came in last night and boy is this case slippery.
Don't think I'm going to use this case for over a week.
Sent from my SM-N900P using xda app-developers app
Slim armour
I would suggest the slim armour one as this is the case I have been using from last 6 months and believe me it has never showed me any signs of worries at all..It is very finely gripped on the phone...and creates no issue of the signals and works really very fine....I dont have any hard experiences with Neo hybrid...so cant say some wrong about it..but slim armour is one of my favorites and I would highly recommend this one...!!!!
From my personal experience of playing around with both cases on a friend's note 3 I'd say the slim amour is your best bet for everyday protection with no worries. ....The neo looks better but doesn't fit as snug and imo it's more of a eye candy case yea it looks great but is slippery and almost has zero lip around the screen..If you get both I'd only use the neo when at home or maybe a night out to eat ..something along those lines...Both are great but slim Armour for protection with some added bulk or neo for good looks slim feel but you sacrifice that extra piece of mind.
Sent from my SM-N900V using Tapatalk
I like my neo hybrid.
I took a look at the slim armour and I dont really like how it looks.
The neo hybrid is enough protection for me. It doesn't add bulk. Most importantly to me it looks like there is no case at all (in slate at least)
There is probably a 1mm lip on the screen. That might be a problem for you but I like the fact that the lip isn't too high. Just gets in the way of using the phone.
I don't find it any more slippery than no case. And my case fits pretty dam snug.
I would recommend both cases. Neo Hybrid looks better and doesn't add bulky. Slim Armor fits much better with the phone and the quality/price is better than Neo Hybrid
Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk
I have the Spigen Slim Armor in Slate and the Neo Hybrid in Champagne. I love both the slim armor more. However I'll keep both the slim armor for best protection while looking premium and the neo for when going to office conference or something formal and extravagant because it adds more pinaché. The Neo is way slimmer than Slim. Neo barely adds and bulk to back and slight mm to side. So if you're wanting slimmer profile go neo. However beware the back holds on to your oily finger prints.
Sent from my SM-N900T using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Schwuar said:
I am torn between these 2 cases from Spigen
From what i have read the Slim Armour offers more protection and a bit more bulk however the Neo Hybrid is obviously slimmer and looks better, although i suppose the looks go on personal preference
Just wondering if anyone has any of these and would you recommend them?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I ordered both of them and I would recommend the slim armor over the neo hybrid. They both are pleasing to the eye, granted the neo hybrid looks a bit nicer but the build quality was suspect imo. The plastic frame and super cheap buttons were a recipe for failure on a "legitimate" drop. But the slim armor has more protection a little more weight but between that and the EXCELLENT tactility of the buttons make it the ultimate case for the Note 3 imo and looks just as nice
Sent from my SM-N900P using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
My caseitis kicked in again and I ordered the slim in slate. Standing by for it to get here.
Sent from my SM-N900T using Tapatalk
Jfree3000 said:
My caseitis kicked in again and I ordered the slim in slate. Standing by for it to get here.
Sent from my SM-N900T using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You won't regret it.
Sent from my SM-N900T using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
cheers all, going to go with the Slim Armour and maybe the Neo as well, will have a think about it
has anyone had any experiences dealing with spigen straight from their website in the UK? rather than using ebay
Slim Armour with ZeroLemon!
Well I am experimenting again! Slim Armour with integrated ZeroLemon 10A battery! Watch this space!

Read the reviews. Looking for the cases with the best grip.

Grip seems to be overlooked sometimes when searching for the perfect case. The Tech 21 Tactical, my current case, does not have the same grip as the S5 version.
On the hunt for a thin to medium case with nice grip. Sweaty hands in the warm months and gloves in the cold ones. Considering the Incipeo Dual layer in black for the soft touch back. Had one on my old LG.
Spigen (never owned one) seems to offer some nice cases if you pick the right color. Considering the Spigen Tough Armor or the Neo Hybrid, both in black. The Neo Hybrid is a handsome case. Not sure about the quality of drop protection and grip. The Armor appears to be more robust, but how is the grip?
Would love some feedback from the community.
Thank you.
John
PS. The Zagg Glass Curve looks promising. Calling tomorrow.
I always recommend otterbox cases.
In the past they have been a little bulky and a bit slippery. Great cases. Very protective. I read the recent reviews of the S7. Looking for something that is softer. More give when you grip it. You feel it sliding or slipping and grab it and it stays.
Spigen Neo Hybrid is a nice case (have one on S7 and wife has one on S6) but doesn't match your grippy requirement. Especially not for gloves.
Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Tapatalk
Just gonna bump this first those looking. The tech 21 non tactical is very grippy.
Sent from my SM-G930T using XDA-Developers mobile app
One from Spigen does a good job
Hi,
Below a link to the case I got:
http://www.spigen.com/products/galaxy-s7-case-liquid-crystal-liquid-crystal
I was previously a user of the Samsung transparent case for S5 (don't have the name at hand but there was only one model originally from Samsung) and that one was super grippy. Made a world of a difference on smaller ships and sailing boats - you could just put it down on anything and it stayed glued to it.
The Spigen one for S7 isn't as sticky but does the job. And it's transparent so the natural silver color of the phone stays there and looks good. Both in the hands and on a table surface the case does a respectable job.
Hope this helps
Cheers,
Jakub
I have the tech21 impact clear and the evo check. The impact clear has decent grip on the sides but it is not flexible tpu-like which the evo check reminds me of. The impact clear is more hard shell on the back which is not as sticky as the evo check. Both are comfortable in the hand. Not sure about the protection level though. Thinking both may be weak for phone drops.
Seido surface case would be good for you
Grippy with details entry protection
I have used them for years
www.shopandroid.com/seidio-surface-with-metal-kickstand-case/4A123A22991.htm
I am using SGP Urban Armor,grips pretty good.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

What Case Has Provided The Best Protection? This is For The Regular S7.

Was just Wondering What Case Has Provided You With The Best Protection With Your Phone? Was Just Wondering Cause I Have The Otter box Commuter And Just Wanted To Make Sure I Chose The Best Case That Will Protect My Phone. Thanks for the feedback! I will hit that like button.
Any cheap rubber or plastic case that is higher on all four sides than the screen will protect the phone amazingly. After that it is just a matter of style and materials to your preference IMHO. A 1 dollar case off ebay or aliexpress will protect the phone fine. It might look like crap but it will protect the phone AFAIK.
Do you care only for protection or also for compactness?
First of all make sure the case you want to buy is military grade tested.
For pure protection you should buy a case with a front tpu cover like poetic revolution, otterbox got one i think as well.
If you care for protection but also for compactness then i would go for UAG, Evutec or otterbox symmetry or spigen slim armor if on limited budget. There are more, i am just naming a few.
Go with the "Unicorn Beetle" case. It's compact and hugs the phone great. Great protection, screen protector and comes with a strong holster. I've had this case for all of my phones. Great product and the price is right on ebay for about 17 to 25 dollars!
http://www.ebay.com/itm/SUPCASE-Uni...172310?hash=item2caedb5b16:g:ifEAAOSwgY9Xd~CX
amirprog said:
Do you care only for protection or also for compactness?
First of all make sure the case you want to buy is military grade tested.
For pure protection you should buy a case with a front tpu cover like poetic revolution, otterbox got one i think as well.
If you care for protection but also for compactness then i would go for UAG, Evutec or otterbox symmetry or spigen slim armor if on limited budget. There are more, i am just naming a few.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just want protection.
HolyGhostBoy1 said:
I just want protection.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Then aside of defender i'd check these as well (full protection):
http://www.poeticcases.com/revolution-59
http://www.lovemeicase.com/index.php?route=product/product&path=87_165&product_id=55357
http://www.lovemeicase.com/index.php?route=product/product&path=87_165&product_id=55346
midnightrider said:
Any cheap rubber or plastic case that is higher on all four sides than the screen will protect the phone amazingly. After that it is just a matter of style and materials to your preference IMHO. A 1 dollar case off ebay or aliexpress will protect the phone fine. It might look like crap but it will protect the phone AFAIK.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I completely agree with you. My case who had raised sides, protected my phone from a 2 ft drop on tiled floors. Dropped on bottom left corner first, then stopped screen down. To my amazement no crack or scratches on the front & back glass.
My case:
https://www.amazon.com/Ringke-Snug-Fit-Tailored-Ultra-Thin-Coverage/dp/B01ACAUFR0
I use the incipio dual pro on mine and it has survived many accidental drops Adds a tiny bit of size but I personally like the grip and size much more with the case on. Also power button and volume buttons on the case feel great and I never accidentally press them.
https://www.incipio.com/cases/smart...ries-case/dualpro-samsung-galaxy-s7-case.html
I got pelican voyager, paid too much for it but it's all I'll need
+1 on the Incipio DualPro.
I also like, in no particular order, the Vena Tough Armor Wave; Diztronic Voyeur Series; Spigen Tough Armor; and the OtterBox Symmetry Clear Series.
djh816 said:
I use the incipio dual pro on mine and it has survived many accidental drops Adds a tiny bit of size but I personally like the grip and size much more with the case on. Also power button and volume buttons on the case feel great and I never accidentally press them.
https://www.incipio.com/cases/smart...ries-case/dualpro-samsung-galaxy-s7-case.html
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you made a good choice! I use my Otterbox Commuter every day. It's always my first choice of case when I get a new phone. Great protection, but not as bulky as a Defender case.
RebDovid said:
+1 on the Incipio DualPro.
I also like, in no particular order, the Vena Tough Armor Wave; Diztronic Voyeur Series; Spigen Tough Armor; and the OtterBox Symmetry Clear Series.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Spigen tough armor are awesome cases. I had one for my S5. Love it.
I have a Rugged Armor for my S7 and love it as well.
I've personally been using a case-mate tough. Pretty good and the buttons feel great.
I'm using rhinoshield with no regrets
Sent from my SM-G930F using XDA-Developers mobile app
Puregear extreme dualtek
Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
Hey, personally, I'm using this Spigen case:
https://www.amazon.fr/gp/aw/d/B01A7ICWTQ?ref=olp_product_details
Really great and give a good protection for the phone.
Envoyé de mon SM-G930F en utilisant Tapatalk
Actually Commuter is a very protective case for your S7. I'm using it too. But you know that there is another series from Otterbox that is more protective but also more bulky than Commuter, that is Defender.
I have an Artech21 Little Rock for my "rugged" case. It's "Military Grade" and whatever other fancy catchphrases you wanna use. But I don't put much stock into those phrases... It's fairly difficult to install/remove. Because of that, the phone won't pop out, even if you were to throw it as hard as you can across the room (that's not to say the phone would survive inside). But the case IS plenty strong. Honestly, my only 2 complaints are that A) the tempered glass is like a half inch more narrow than the screen (but at the time of purchase, not a single tempered glass screen protector covered edge to edge flawlessly (loss of sensitivity, haloing, etc.). And, B) I'm not a big fan of the designs. When other models like the Vivid Arkansas look so damn unique good. The Little Rock just looks super plain. Of the cases I own, the Little Rock is easily the strongest, while the Vivid Arkansas is much thinner, it looks MUCH better. And it still provides plenty of protection itself. And I can't speak for cases I don't own. But the Little Rock is easily the toughest. The Vivid Arkansas looks the best. And while it doesn't provide the hardcore protection of the Little Rock, it has saved my phone on a few drops, one I expected to be bad. But not a scratch

Categories

Resources