Update: so I've had the phone for about a week now. All I have to say is that this phone has blown my expectations. I'm getting service in places my Nexus 5 never did. The phone always prefers LTE which is awesome. The nexus 5 always drops down to 3G and doesn't connect back LTE automatically. The oneplus X always stays on LTE and if drops to 3G, it switches back to LTE as soon as it picks it up again.
I guess it really has to do with antennas being integrated onto the metal frame. I would say reception is on par with the Galaxy S6 or LGG4 or a little better.
I'm considering getting this phone, however, I've never used a oneplus phone before. Can anyone comment on their RF performance in comparison to other phones. For example, G4 & S6 have really good RF performance, the iPhone 6 not so much. Where does oneplus fall?
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
mawells787 said:
Hello,
I'm considering getting this phone, however, I've never used a oneplus phone before. Can anyone comment on their RF performance in comparison to other phones. For example, G4 & S6 have really good RF performance, the iPhone 6 not so much. Where does oneplus fall?
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's really great, i always got 4G and every bars in France
mawells787 said:
Hello,
I'm considering getting this phone, however, I've never used a oneplus phone before. Can anyone comment on their RF performance in comparison to other phones. For example, G4 & S6 have really good RF performance, the iPhone 6 not so much. Where does oneplus fall?
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's Snapdragon not MTK Gps is also working fine according a reply on OnePlus.net
Poor Reception
Hi,
today i got my X: great built quality so far, but it lacks reception.
On my HTC One M8 i got nearly double reception then with the 1+ X.
Anyone here could confirm that the reception is that poor?
Thank you
Chris
bytemission said:
Hi,
today i got my X: great built quality so far, but it lacks reception.
On my HTC One M8 i got nearly double reception then with the 1+ X.
Anyone here could confirm that the reception is that poor?
Thank you
Chris
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is it just the mobile network?
Could you look up the signal strength?
It is displayed under settings -> about the phone -> status -> Signal strength (in my Xperia S)
There is a dBm and an ASU value.
Could you compare them to your HTC One M8 and post them here?
I will check this also when my device arrives in the next days...
Related
Hi fellas.
I am out there looking to replace my iPhone with an Android phone and really love the S3 from what I've read so far. My biggest concern by far will me is the reception ability of the phone on Att network. Where I work at the signal is weak and very marginal. I constantly go through signal and no signal moments depending on the room I'm in. Because of this I'm looking for a phone with strong reception.
Being an iPhone user. How does the S3 compare reception wise to the iPhone 4 in areas of weak signal?
And two. Which other android 4.0 phones are better? From what I've read seems like the One X is slightly better. True? Is there any site with a good breakdown?
Thank you!
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using Tapatalk 2
DaRacerz said:
Hi fellas.
I am out there looking to replace my iPhone with an Android phone and really love the S3 from what I've read so far. My biggest concern by far will me is the reception ability of the phone on Att network. Where I work at the signal is weak and very marginal. I constantly go through signal and no signal moments depending on the room I'm in. Because of this I'm looking for a phone with strong reception.
Being an iPhone user. How does the S3 compare reception wise to the iPhone 4 in areas of weak signal?
And two. Which other android 4.0 phones are better? From what I've read seems like the One X is slightly better. True? Is there any site with a good breakdown?
Thank you!
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm also in a similar situation and I had the HTC One X for about a week in a weak signal area. The signal/data speeds were awesome compared to my Atrix and a substitute 3GS I'm using now.
I have horrible reception at my house and the SGS3 is actually amazing. My H+ speeds are 5mb down, and bluetooth in my truck is so much nicer
please do not compare sammy signal receiver with iphone....
those two are different league...
iphone receiver s**t
you ll be amaze with this beast
androb0t said:
please do not compare sammy signal receiver with iphone....
those two are different league...
iphone receiver s**t
you ll be amaze with this beast
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sorry but that sounds like a fan boy response. Because my experience with Samsung phones has been weak at best when compared against Motorola's for reception ability which I use to use before the smartphone era. Granted I agree technology change fast and Samsung is doing a lot right lately.
But thanks for the other responses. Making me feel a lot better about getting the phone.
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using Tapatalk 2
For those of you have it already how's the reception? Is it any better then the s3?
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
pyaa said:
For those of you have it already how's the reception? Is it any better then the s3?
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Let people use it for a while. They haven't even had for more than 12 hours.
computingwarren said:
Let people use it for a while. They haven't even had for more than 12 hours.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, technically it shouldn't take more than a few seconds. Put the phones in the same spot, and check the signal strength in dBm.
I agree, those that have it the rest of the world is dying to know!
How is the signal? Is it the same radio that's in the GS3?
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Curious to know from those who upgraded from HTC Thunderbolt with frequent LTE disconnects if the issue remains, which points to network issue, or eliminated but it'll probably require at least a week to confirm.
Coming from GNex, plz let it be better then that :fingers-crossed:
I'd like to think it is slightly better because the size of the device means the antenna can be farther from anything that will cause noise or something. Guess we'll find out tomorrow.
IamPro said:
Coming from GNex, plz let it be better then that :fingers-crossed:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I really hope it's got a better radio than the GNex. I've been limping along with that thing for the last year. I'll go from a 20 megabit connection to no data without even moving locations.
I kind of hated ordering the Note2 blind, but I've been waiting for a note to arrive on verizon since the note1 came out. If the radio is lousy, well at least I can draw with it.
Sent from my GT-N8013 using Tapatalk 2
another curious verizon customer. Been on htc devices since joining verizon and samsung's cdma woes are well documented. I want the note 2, but need reception.
pyaa said:
For those of you have it already how's the reception? Is it any better then the s3?
Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Much better than the GS3 I had, even when I was using all the different types of radios that were available.
Data connection is faster too. Most likely as a result of NOT using a piece of $hit snapdragon SOC.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using xda premium
mzahiri said:
Much better than the GS3 I had, even when I was using all the different types of radios that were available.
Data connection is faster too. Most likely as a result of NOT using a piece of $hit snapdragon SOC.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think my rezound has a snapdragon SOC, and it has no problems with reception or data speeds. Get up to 40 down and 15 up on it.
Samsung has a history of bad radios on Verizon. It's really the only potential negative of this device.
nrfitchett4 said:
I think my rezound has a snapdragon SOC, and it has no problems with reception or data speeds. Get up to 40 down and 15 up on it.
Samsung has a history of bad radios on Verizon. It's really the only potential negative of this device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
great reception. i also think this has to do with no only better hardware but more landscape inside the phone offers better attenna replacement.
over all phone is awesome, im having no issue one handing it
mi7chy said:
Curious to know from those who upgraded from HTC Thunderbolt with frequent LTE disconnects if the issue remains, which points to network issue, or eliminated but it'll probably require at least a week to confirm.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I upgraded to the DNA and I haven't had a single data drop, unlike my Thunderbolt which had them several times a day.
BlueHarford said:
great reception. i also think this has to do with no only better hardware but more landscape inside the phone offers better attenna replacement.
over all phone is awesome, im having no issue one handing it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
cool, going to head over to verizon store and play with it and dna and look at signal strengths. I only get 1-2 bars in the hospital so if its worse, I might not have signal.
The rezound had good 4g reception but average 3g reception; the galaxy s3 had good 4g reception and below average 3g reception. Anyways I hope folks provide good feedback and 4g, 3g and cellular reception for the note. Very interested in this phone (though it is bigger than I would like). To be honest I would go with the DNA if it had a large battery. Don't take me wrong I think the note has a lot of nice unique feature I just wish it was a bit narrower.
BlueHarford said:
great reception. i also think this has to do with no only better hardware but more landscape inside the phone offers better attenna replacement.
over all phone is awesome, im having no issue one handing it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i have my galaxy nexus and my note 2 side by side and signal strength is the same with a slight edge to the note 2. I am looking at the signal strength in options and not the bars.
I have notes 2 and DNA side by side at the possibly worst corner in terms of cell signal.
Note 2 is extremely unstable. keep on switching between LTE to 3G to no signal (the round circle with a cross over the center. usual stop sign)
while DNA has a full bars for CALL. and 1x for data. It is slow, but it is stable and usable.
SHAME ON YOU SAMSUNG. Why put such a stupid radio chip on such a good device otherwise.
randpost said:
i have my galaxy nexus and my note 2 side by side and signal strength is the same with a slight edge to the note 2. I am looking at the signal strength in options and not the bars.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only matters when you are in weak signal areas. If you're seeing -70 to -80 DBMS or lower you're in a decent area. What the Gnex couldn't handle was the weaker areas. Where my rezound was -85 or so the Gnex was -100 or worse. I'll post something when I get back to my office. I'll do a compare and post it. If the Note 2 is anything like the Gnex it will end up the same way with me. Returned! I don't care how cool the phone is.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
jiwengang said:
I have notes 2 and DNA side by side at the possibly worst corner in terms of cell signal.
Note 2 is extremely unstable. keep on switching between LTE to 3G to no signal (the round circle with a cross over the center. usual stop sign)
while DNA has a full bars for CALL. and 1x for data. It is slow, but it is stable and usable.
SHAME ON YOU SAMSUNG. Why put such a stupid radio chip on such a good device otherwise.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not what I wanted to hear
Do you have dBm readings that you could post for a comparison? The data switching between 1x, 3G, and 4G could be fixed in an update hopefully.
geoff5093 said:
Not what I wanted to hear
Do you have dBm readings that you could post for a comparison? The data switching between 1x, 3G, and 4G could be fixed in an update hopefully.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the dbm on N2 was jumping from -120 to -98 to -75 and the data connection is ON and OFF. That is frustrating.
My location (my cubicle) here now is like a stress test case in terms of cellphone cell strength in a weaker environment.
IN good coverage, everyone is happy. Both phones are -75dbm and stable.
In weaker ones, N2 can't hold on to a data connection.
I really want to love it, but in this checkbox, there is no competition.
It does perform well in battery category tho.
And by the way, refer to your other post, the screen is not brighter than DNA screen. even put to full brightness. It is just so pathetic putting them side by side to compare.
I will continue test until this evening. If the data connection weakness is confirmed, I have to take N2 back to store. I feel it will make my wife crazy to see me carrying both giant 5 inch phones each costing more than 600 USD combining all costs...
Well the LG G2 is officially announced and LG has announced that the G2 is coming to Sprint.
Sprint Launch Confirmation press release: http://newsroom.sprint.com/news-releases/sprint-to-bring-unlimited-data-experience-to-lg-g2.htm
Official G2 specs: http://www.engadget.com/2013/08/07/lg-g2-officially-announced/
The new device, which runs Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean, comes with a larger display than its predecessor, packing a 5.2-inch 1080p IPS panel. It also offers a 2.26GHz quad-core Snapdragon 800 SoC. Additionally, you can expect to find a 13-megapixel camera with optical image stabilization (as well as a 2.1MP front-facing cam), 24 bit/192kHz HiFi playback, a non-removable 3,000mAh battery, 2GB of RAM and your choice of 16GB or 32GB internal storage. It'll come in white and black, and LG tells us that the G2 will be rolling out to markets around the world over the next eight weeks, and we have confirmation that all four major US carriers have committed to adding the device to their lineup.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The specs sounds quite amazing for the follow up to the Optimus G and I'm glad Sprint will be selling the G2.
I've been checking this out on youtube ...and yes she's a beast
I have a question for LG Optimus G owners.
How are the radios in the LG phones? Its seems everyone agrees that Motorola are the best. my HD gets a lot better reception than my Samsung's got. How would you guys rate LG's reception?
Sent from my XT926 using Tapatalk 2
rebretz000 said:
I have a question for LG Optimus G owners.
How are the radios in the LG phones? Its seems everyone agrees that Motorola are the best. my HD gets a lot better reception than my Samsung's got. How would you guys rate LG's reception?
Sent from my XT926 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You will get no useful data by asking that question here. Instead, look for reviews directly comparing the reception of devices in a controlled environment using a Femtocell.
aero449 said:
You will get no useful data by asking that question here. Instead, look for reviews directly comparing the reception of devices in a controlled environment using a Femtocell.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Really, people can't give their own assessment of the signal strength they get? I'd find that more useful, getting input from people's everyday use then a test. It's like benchmarks. Actual day to day use is much more relevan than a test.
Just got this phone last week because my s3 died. The s3 always stayed on 4g lte everywhere i went in town. This phone goes from 3g to 4g if i go from room to room in my house. It's. Very annoying but i have 14 days to trade this phone back in. I really like this phone over the s3 but the reception it's not on point like the s3. That's just my experience so far.
Sent from my LG-LS970 using xda app-developers app
bonebeatz1234 said:
Just got this phone last week because my s3 died. The s3 always stayed on 4g lte everywhere i went in town. This phone goes from 3g to 4g if i go from room to room in my house. It's. Very annoying but i have 14 days to trade this phone back in. I really like this phone over the s3 but the reception it's not on point like the s3. That's just my experience so far.
Sent from my LG-LS970 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup, that's true. I've noticed that as well. I have the LGOG while there's 3 GS3 in the family. The GS3 holds onto the 4G LTE connection much better while LGOG drops it. It also doesn't reconnect quickly; I've had to toggle airplane mode so that I can reconnect to 4G LTE. I shouldn't have to do that. If the service it available, it should stay connected.
My LGOG doesn't connect to the 4G towers that are in Baltimore City (yes, I do have it set for 4G/3G), I have updated the profile and PRL multiple times, toggled airplane mode on and off multiple times and it stays on a 3G data connection, sometimes the 3G connection is so slow downloads and uploads take a long time. I'm hoping under SoftBank's ownership, SoftBank can vastly improve Sprint's 3G and 4G networks before the G2 comes out. I would love to switch from the OG to the G2 and have better 3G and 4G network performance than what Sprint currently has.
I'm happy with Sprint's new Unlimited Guarantee for Life but would like to see faster and more reliable data speeds on the 3G and 4G networks.
Thanks for the replies. If GS3 have better data connection than LGOG then I may steer clear of it and possibly get the Moto X Developer Edition on VZW.
Sent from my XT926 using Tapatalk 2
Good luck with the x man.
Sent from my LG-LS970 using xda app-developers app
rebretz000 said:
Really, people can't give their own assessment of the signal strength they get? I'd find that more useful, getting input from people's everyday use then a test. It's like benchmarks. Actual day to day use is much more relevan than a test.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
People can, and have, but at best you're getting limited sample size in unrelated markets to your own with wiggle room for signal attenuation depending on the person's grip, weather conditions, or the structure they're residing in. In short: just about as useful as testimonials for homeopathic remedies.
At worst, you're dealing with different phones reporting different bars for the same signal strength with the potential for different carriers, different protocols (Wimax/LTE/HSPA+), different modem drivers, faulty 3G/4G handoffs in addition to everything I listed previously.
I really hope they decide to throw the G the 4.2 rom thats running on the G2, the features looks pretty nice. The phone itself looks pretty sweet, I like the idea of having the volume buttons on the back. I wonder if LG has improved the camera on the G2?
bonebeatz1234 said:
Just got this phone last week because my s3 died. The s3 always stayed on 4g lte everywhere i went in town. This phone goes from 3g to 4g if i go from room to room in my house. It's. Very annoying but i have 14 days to trade this phone back in. I really like this phone over the s3 but the reception it's not on point like the s3. That's just my experience so far.
Sent from my LG-LS970 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How did you get it so early, international version?
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
rebretz000 said:
I'd find that more useful, getting input from people's everyday use then a test. It's like benchmarks. Actual day to day use is much more relevan than a test.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, me thinks. Some people live under the cell and have upper quality signal 100% of time and can't tell and difference and could care less if its Moto or Coolpad
Others live in sorts of suburbs, farms, countryside and their signal is poor no matter if it Moto or LG or Nokia.
aero449 said:
reviews directly comparing the reception of devices in a controlled environment using a Femtocell
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can't find ones. Could point me to test of Moto Atrix HD vs LG Optimus G?
ksweeley said:
Well the LG G2 is officially announced and LG has announced that the G2 is coming to Sprint.
Sprint Launch Confirmation press release: http://newsroom.sprint.com/news-releases/sprint-to-bring-unlimited-data-experience-to-lg-g2.htm
Official G2 specs: http://www.engadget.com/2013/08/07/lg-g2-officially-announced/
The specs sounds quite amazing for the follow up to the Optimus G and I'm glad Sprint will be selling the G2.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All 4 major US carriers will be carrying the G2 when it hits the States though i don't know if anyone has listed a specific date. (most seem to think early September so that it is top of the heap for a while being king fish with the Snapdragon 800)
My only concern so far is this: I like to run occasionally and I wear my phone in one of those sports arm bands... if the combo power/volume buttons are on the back, won't they be pressed against my arm and therefor prone to accidental presses? They aren't exactly flush with the back of the phone.
ReggieSmith said:
All 4 major US carriers will be carrying the G2 when it hits the States though i don't know if anyone has listed a specific date. (most seem to think early September so that it is top of the heap for a while being king fish with the Snapdragon 800)
My only concern so far is this: I like to run occasionally and I wear my phone in one of those sports arm bands... if the combo power/volume buttons are on the back, won't they be pressed against my arm and therefor prone to accidental presses? They aren't exactly flush with the back of the phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The volume buttons need to be pressed pretty firmly as I understood it, and the Power button is surrounded on the sides, thats how it will not be pushed down on a table etc. Even so, I bet it would be easier to accidently push the buttons when they are on the sides of the phone.
rebretz000 said:
I have a question for LG Optimus G owners.
How are the radios in the LG phones? Its seems everyone agrees that Motorola are the best. my HD gets a lot better reception than my Samsung's got. How would you guys rate LG's reception?
Sent from my XT926 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The radio wasn't -bad-, but Motorola is certainly far better. The trick was to disable scanning for LTE (CDMA only mode), really gave a good boost to the OG's signal and battery,might I add. Since I don't currently live in a 4g area, I had no use for LTE
Sent from my NookColor using xda app-developers app
Well, Verizon and At&t are getting theirs Sept 12th & 13th. Let's hope Sprint's and T-Mobiles version isn't too far behind.
---------- Post added at 07:34 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:31 AM ----------
toastyc12 said:
The radio wasn't -bad-, but Motorola is certainly far better. The trick was to disable scanning for LTE (CDMA only mode), really gave a good boost to the OG's signal and battery,might I add. Since I don't currently live in a 4g area, I had no use for LTE
Sent from my NookColor using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From what I hear the original LG Optimus G had a great radio. 3G performance was of the top devices on Sprint while the 4G ranked just a bit behind GS3. We'll see how this device goes. Motorola is really good with EvDo technology and owned a lot of Sprints legacy equipment on the cell towers. I still haven't seen any device out perform Motorola's Photon in terms of network performance.
I really want to get this phone, but my main concern would be the signal strength. I have very poor cell signal where I work. Only the iPhone 4s and Galaxy S4 maintained an acceptable signal at work. Other phones seem to constantly switch between 4G-LTE, 4G, G, and even E. Anything below 4G being unusable.
So how is this phone when it comes to the signal strength? Anyone else out there have a similar issue as me, and found the HTC One (M8) to show great reception?
xT29c said:
I really want to get this phone, but my main concern would be the signal strength. I have very poor cell signal where I work. Only the iPhone 4s and Galaxy S4 maintained an acceptable signal at work. Other phones seem to constantly switch between 4G-LTE, 4G, G, and even E. Anything below 4G being unusable.
So how is this phone when it comes to the signal strength? Anyone else out there have a similar issue as me, and found the HTC One (M8) to show great reception?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I live in a dead spot for ATT coverage. My GS4 would only show 1-3 bars but the G4 LTE worked all the time. So far (one day) the One M8 shows about the same number of bars, and I've had no trouble with the connection. So bottom line (at least so far) I'd say it is equal in performance to the GS4.
HTH
Imo about the same as gs4, better than m7, WAY better than nexus 5. M8 WiFi better than any phone I have ever had.
Sent from my HTC One_M8 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
I've read reports that the cellular reception is not as good as previous Galaxy phones or other phones around from the last few years.
What is your experience of this? Are you getting good signal strength?
mwatson said:
I've read reports that the cellular reception is not as good as previous Galaxy phones or other phones around from the last few years.
What is your experience of this? Are you getting good signal strength?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree the reception on my edge is very spotty
I drive a 400 mile route daily and have lots of opportunities to test. I'm on Verizon. In the last 3 months I've had the s6 edge, note 4, one m8, droid turbo, and lg g2. Functional signal strength is noticeably lower than the others on the s6 edge, though very close to the note 4 and m8. The droid turbo seemed to provide a slightly better signal strength and a friend of mine who still has the turbo can attest to that. G2 was good as well. I'd give the turbo and g2 an 8/10 on signal, and the other 3 phones I've mentioned 7/10. Unfortunately, people seem to have a pretty wide variety of experiences with signal strength. I've read a number of places that people thought the note 4 had amazing signal. I still have mine and it's nothing to write home about. The note 4 and s6 edge are very close from my experience in terms of signal quality - for whatever that's worth. In spite of the lacking reception, I've not experienced it making a big enough difference to impact usability on a daily basis. Just an annoying inconvenience once in a while.
I am in China now. Noticed that 4G reception using China Unicoi is weak. It bounces back and forth between 1 and 2 bars. Phone was bought in Hong Kong unlocked from CSL Telecom company.