So the quest for a good full body tempered glass screen protector has failed. I have decided to go for a high quality film protector. I don't really care about the strength of the protector, as long as it protects from scratches. What is the most comparable to a glass screen protector in clarity, texture, and smoothness? Right now, the wet application films seem to be the best, such as IQ Shield LiQuidSkin.
Anybody have anymore recommendations/reviews?
Edit: Water/oil resistance would be nice as well...
I've used Skinomi protectors for a while now, really good products and not that expensive.
I used both IQ Shield and ArmorSuit MilitaryShield, both are very good. The only difference is the shape, ArmorSuit doesnt go around home button and speaker - that makes it easier to apply, plus those places get damaged easier on IQ Shield. Quality wise, they are both great.
Be sure to get the right IQ shield version, there are 2 for s7 flat, full coverage, and "case friendly" with cuts at the corners. Those corners (upper left in my case) were first who got dusty beneath, so i had to replace it.
Maybe ArmorSuit is wiser choice overall, since it doesnt cover 100% of the glass so its case friendly without corner cutouts (it does cover the whole screen).
lakicamm said:
I used both IQ Shield and ArmorSuit MilitaryShield, both are very good. The only difference is the shape, ArmorSuit doesnt go around home button and speaker - that makes it easier to apply, plus those places get damaged easier on IQ Shield. Quality wise, they are both great.
Be sure to get the right IQ shield version, there are 2 for s7 flat, full coverage, and "case friendly" with cuts at the corners. Those corners (upper left in my case) were first who got dusty beneath, so i had to replace it.
Maybe ArmorSuit is wiser choice overall, since it doesnt cover 100% of the glass so its case friendly without corner cutouts (it does cover the whole screen).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How is the feel of the protectors? I heard they are kind of rubbery.
Actually they are not - they feel glassy. Regular protectors feel more rubbery.
Related
O.K. Peeps, after not installing clear coat because of its poor coverage, and after getting exasperated with i.s. because of the white screen edge issue, I ordered the "clear protector" from ebay. This comes with seperate screen shield, and so avoids those installation issues. The material seems slightly harder than the i.s. equivalent - which had "pitted" from use of the stylus. The only issue I have had is the inability to stick the top edge of the back shield effectively. I had the same problem with the i.s. I feel this is a design fault - they should make the shield for the top edge come down slightly, instead of the back going up slightly, if that makes sense. Overall though pretty good.
However I received a set of three Boxwave protectors today, and though I didn't mind the clear protector screen shield, would rather have a slightly clearer and harder surface. Wow! The boxwave is easy to put on and looks great. As a tip, when applying run a hot tap and get the room steamy, stops dust floating around. I have managed installation with only one ginger hair stuck beneath the shield ( shaving debris ).
Pretty happy with my protection now. Clear Protector gives I would say 98% coverage, doesn't cover the usb arear, and small areas at the corners. However it loses marks as despite hours of trying I still can't get those back top edges to stick properly. I'm gonna shoot clear protector an email and see if I can't get a replacement.
Boxwave 10/10.
If the sticking issue was addressed, this would be the perfect protection solution, imho.
A
clear protector over IS?
mooro1973 said:
This comes with seperate screen shield, and so avoids those installation issues. The material seems slightly harder than the i.s. equivalent - which had "pitted" from use of the stylus.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what do you mean it had a separate screen shield? does it mean for the front, there are 2 pieces (1 for screen and 1 for area around screen)? Any orange peel effect? So overall you would recommend clear protector over IS?
sna said:
what do you mean it had a separate screen shield? does it mean for the front, there are 2 pieces (1 for screen and 1 for area around screen)? Any orange peel effect? So overall you would recommend clear protector over IS?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes there are two pieces for the front.
Less orange peel.
After a couple of weeks of being in a silicon case, and a little saliva (!) the back edges have also imrpoved.
It is far better than i.s.
Hi
Can you post some pictures of Clear Protector? I've ordered and applied I.S. but like almost everyone I'm really disappointed!
mooro1973 said:
Yes there are two pieces for the front.
Less orange peel.
After a couple of weeks of being in a silicon case, and a little saliva (!) the back edges have also imrpoved.
It is far better than i.s.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good to hear, have ordered.
Got sick of trying tempered glass that just wouldn't fit. Thus far I've tried two with two more on the way.
In the mean time, went to try the armor suit full screen. I don't particularly like this type of skin protector but for the time being it'll do.
Pretty much the same thing as Zagg, Skinomi, etc
Made a video of the install HERE
Super easy install and edge to edge protection
Had the same idea as you. Also using the armorsuit while waiting for my tempered glass order to arrive.
Pros:
- full screen edge to edge coverage
- accurate cutouts for camera, home button and sensors
Cons:
- wet application (takes a few hours to fully dry)
- has a soft and rubbery feel with noticeable orange peel
- slight reduction in screen sensitivity
Got an armorsuit actually fits really well
Does not fit all the screen. To short from side left to right. About 2.5 millimetres missing on each side.
Ive got the full body one installed and love it for the most part. The rubbery feel gets a lot better after some use. Love how the device is pretty well protected, but still naked. I use to love cases, but with how nice the new S6 and S7 is I decided nakeds the way to go.
I found the ArmorSuit Military Shield great, provided I didn't want to use a case. Because, for me, a case is more important than a screen protector, the ArmorSuit doesn't suit me. It lifted up when used with my Otterbox Symmetry.
I waited a few weeks to review these to be able to give a more in depth review.
Zagg Curved HD: http://www.zagg.com/us/en_us/invisibleshield/samsung-galaxy-s7/glass-curve-samsung-galaxy-s7
This is Zagg's tempered glass, edge to edge screen protector. As most of you may know, yes it is dot matrix and therefore the adhesive is only present around the edges of the screen protector.
The application process was relatively easy. Washed my hands to make sure oil is off, aligned the top cut outs first and the rest of it fell in place. I would say it was a near perfect install based on where the home button, camera, sensors are in relation to the cut outs of the screen protector.
I first used it for a week with the RhinoShield bumper case. I am comfortable to say that the bumper case went quite nicely with the screen protector. there wasn't any major lifting except for one of the top corners where there was VERY minor lifting visible. The screen protector wasn't going anywhere even with the bumper case on. The protector felt nice when in use, finger glides just like the gorilla glass.
Onto the not so good points.
Significant loss of sensitivity. I couldn't wait to rip it off but I really wanted to give it a fair chance so I left it on for another week without the bumper case to see if it makes a difference. It didn't. I don't know how, but over time it actually got worse. Made typing and browsing really annoying. I guess because the glass only adheres around the edges, it also left a tiny bit of space between the the protector and the actual screen, therefore when I type it would make this tapping sound. The protector also adds a little bit of thickness to your phone, therefore the home button will be a bit depressed. And because of this bit of added thickness, even with the raised edge lips from the rhino shield bumper case, when my phone face planted in my bathroom, the Zagg protector cracked slightly. Now of course this could be different if you have a more heavy duty case which a more pronounced raised lip around the edges.
Rhino Shield bumper case: http://www.evolutivelabs.com/collec...cts/galaxy-s7-bumper-case?variant=12325884673
There is a video on youtube showing the protection that this bumper case provides, specifically for the s7. Mod Edit: Link removed. Page contains affiliate sales links. Not allowed on xda thanks!
There are more that shows the case with other phones. Their claim is it will protect the phone up to 11ft drop.
As I said above, if you are looking for a case that is somewhat friendly with the Zagg curved HD, this case would do the job.
Besides that, I must say I love this case because it's very light, adds very little bulk yet have a lot of real users backing up its level of protection.
The front and back of the bumper case have raised lips, more so on the back especially on the 4 corners. The buttons of the case are a tad bit harder to press in comparison to the Spigen I reviewed earlier, but it's still pretty responsive.
The only negative is that for some reason, one side of the case seems to be a LITTLE loose (side of the power button); it's not as snug as the other side. From a quick google search, It seems like the same issue exists with other phones and someone posted a response from Evolutive Labs saying that because the case is not made of TPU material, they purposely made the case not as snug such that it's easier to install the case . I am going to email Evolutive Labs about this and I will update this thread when I hear back. I must say tho this looseness is not noticeable when you are using the phone so it doesn't bother me. In fact it makes me feel more comfortable putting the case on with a screen protector since it's not going to bite into the screen protector as much.
Considering the Rhino Shield's price, would you say it's good value?
RebDovid said:
Considering the Rhino Shield's price, would you say it's good value?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hard for me to give a personal opinion since our canadian dollar sucks right now, therefore after conversion it's actually 30-35 cad with shipping.
If I am in the states tho, I would definitely pick this over the other cases that are in the same price range based on the level of protection it provides while being a minimalistic case.
I think they would gain a lot more interest at $20 usd with more color options but then with more color options it may end up increasing their production cost.
When I first got my S8+, I was worried the back glass would scratch easy (turns out I was right ), so I wanted to protect it, even though I knew I would have a case on it. I've seen dirt get between phones and cases before and cause horrible scratches.
I first tried a clear wet application skin from BSE, but I could never make it look right. The midnight black shoes every imperfection and bubble, whereas my wife's Orchid Grey looks perfect with the skin on. You can't tell it's there, even on the sides.
So I began thinking it would be nice if someone made a tempered glass protector for the back. The sides are curved, but so is the screen, and there's plenty of TGSPs on the market. But I couldn't find any.
Then last week I saw one on Amazon. It comes with a full screen TGSP, a TGP for the back, and a TGP for the camera. Link is below.
It appears the back protector is like other TGSPs. It has no glue on the middle, just along the edges. That's not a big deal, as I would apply it like I did my TGSP. I would remove the adhesive strip on the edge and use LOCA to adhere it fully to the phone. Most camera lens TGPs get horrible reviews on Amazon, so it would likely go in the trash.
I'm trying to decide what to do. Here are my pros and cons, but I wanted everyone else's opinion, and also want to know if anyone else has any experience with this set. Again, I'm currently using a TGSP for the screen, so this is a question about the TGP for the BACK.
Pros:
*Protection for the back cover as well as the front.
*Protects from scratches and adds some drop protection
*Protectors are both glass, so it would still feel like a naked device.
*Back protector is Crystal clear, and with LOCA, would show off the beautiful black back glass without any bubbles, glare, etc.
*Glass doesn't get marks and dents like wet application protectors.
Cons:
*It would (probably) be too thick to use a case, so increased chance of damage if dropped.
*These TGSPs typically use cheap oleophobic coatings, so it would still be a fingerprint magnet on the back.
*This would leave a ridge around the screen and the back protector, so it MAY make it uncomfortable to hold.
*No protection for the side frame
*It will scratch (but can always be replaced
*I wish the cutouts were more precise. I'd like three separate cutouts for camera and sensors, not one big one. Would make it more seemless.
Again, looking for other thoughts and opinions and any experience.
No offense, but if all you have to say is that you go naked and have no scratches, or that you don't like screen protectors, then please don't reply. I'm not interested in a screen protector debate. I'm only interested in your opinions about this particular set and using a protector on the back. Also, I know about the liquid nano stuff and have no interest in it. I've seen all the reviews.
Thanks!
JimBird Tempered Glass Screen Protector Front + Back + Camera Lens Protector For Galaxy S8 Plus S8+ 9H Anti-Scratch Anti-Fingerprint https://www.amazon.com/dp/B073S4YZW1/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_MohHzbHWHA99A
Mr. Orange 645 said:
When I first got my S8+, I was worried the back glass would scratch easy (turns out I was right ), so I wanted to protect it, even though I knew I would have a case on it. I've seen dirt get between phones and cases before and cause horrible scratches.
I first tried a clear wet application skin from BSE, but I could never make it look right. The midnight black shoes every imperfection and bubble, whereas my wife's Orchid Grey looks perfect with the skin on. You can't tell it's there, even on the sides.
So I began thinking it would be nice if someone made a tempered glass protector for the back. The sides are curved, but so is the screen, and there's plenty of TGSPs on the market. But I couldn't find any.
Then last week I saw one on Amazon. It comes with a full screen TGSP, a TGP for the back, and a TGP for the camera. Link is below.
It appears the back protector is like other TGSPs. It has no glue on the middle, just along the edges. That's not a big deal, as I would apply it like I did my TGSP. I would remove the adhesive strip on the edge and use LOCA to adhere it fully to the phone. Most camera lens TGPs get horrible reviews on Amazon, so it would likely go in the trash.
I'm trying to decide what to do. Here are my pros and cons, but I wanted everyone else's opinion, and also want to know if anyone else has any experience with this set. Again, I'm currently using a TGSP for the screen, so this is a question about the TGP for the BACK.
Pros:
*Protection for the back cover as well as the front.
*Protects from scratches and adds some drop protection
*Protectors are both glass, so it would still feel like a naked device.
*Back protector is Crystal clear, and with LOCA, would show off the beautiful black back glass without any bubbles, glare, etc.
*Glass doesn't get marks and dents like wet application protectors.
Cons:
*It would (probably) be too thick to use a case, so increased chance of damage if dropped.
*These TGSPs typically use cheap oleophobic coatings, so it would still be a fingerprint magnet on the back.
*This would leave a ridge around the screen and the back protector, so it MAY make it uncomfortable to hold.
*No protection for the side frame
*It will scratch (but can always be replaced
*I wish the cutouts were more precise. I'd like three separate cutouts for camera and sensors, not one big one. Would make it more seemless.
Again, looking for other thoughts and opinions and any experience.
No offense, but if all you have to say is that you go naked and have no scratches, or that you don't like screen protectors, then please don't reply. I'm not interested in a screen protector debate. I'm only interested in your opinions about this particular set and using a protector on the back. Also, I know about the liquid nano stuff and have no interest in it. I've seen all the reviews.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was thinking about the same thing, this post is very helpful.
Mr Orange, I am thinking on the same lines as you were. Did you end up buying the JimBird TGSP? If so, what are your opinions of it and how well did it work for you? It seems like something simple to offer, but so hard to find. Thanks!
I cant find a good case for ROG 3 on flipkart of Amazon. Which case are you guys using? where did you buy it from??
I am using Lighting Armor case as I need to use the air trigger. If you do not care for the function of air triggers (dual & slide), can get IMAK case from aliexpress.
I'm also using the lighting armour , I like it ok it drains power but I still like it
I am using the average tpu case that is available for rog 3, i had to make cut out for the side mounted type c ports though
I'm using this: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4001345047036.html?spm=a2g0s.9042311.0.0.5d6e4c4d4DwYCq
It's not perfect, but provides enough all around protection, the cutouts are in place.
The included tempered glass screen protector is of good quality, but the black border covers a few pixels on the sides.
It's pretty cheap, I can recommend buying it to protect your ROG Phone 3 - as I said, it's not perfect, but good enough.
Using this one with a tempered glass in the front and a silicon film in the back
I have ordered this IMAK transparent black TPU case with extra corner shock-proofing along with these IMAK clear soft hydrogel films for front & back protection.
Hopefully shipment arriving to me by early next month.
Used to use the lighting armor case until the slippery uncovered aluminium side caused me to drop the phone yesterday, now the phone has a dent on the top right corner of the frame. Lighting armor has the best look of all the cases out there. Now using Zshow case which should prevent it from hitting the screen flat down if I ever drop it again. I'm lucky the phone didn't fall face down with the lighting armor case which would have guaranteed a cracked screen.
I have the imak tpu case too but it cause the tempered glass to lift.
Besides the tempered glass being lifted issue, what's your experience/ feedback regarding your IMAK TPU case (is it with extra corner protection)?
Imak case is quite loose around the air triggers, power button, volume button and side port. Top 4 corner airbags are the problems as they can be depressed quite easily and this cause the screen protector to lift up. You will know when you hold the phone on your right hand with your palm resting with the bottom right corner for support, and this can cause the screen protector to lift.
I'm getting the hydrogel film screen protectors - Hoping that screen lift is not an issue.....
What's your experience or opinion regarding the general damage/ drop protection with this case?
Quality, overall fitting & feel?
It will protect if dropping on the corners as well as face down. However dropping on the back might be a problem because the camera lens are protuting out (although the case cover the camera lens). Placing the phone on the table will also result in wobbly phone when using.
---------- Post added at 06:15 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:13 AM ----------
Quality, would say it is better than those generic cheap tpu case (which has worse fit than imak), feel wise, it is slippery on the back.
I just received this: Foluu ROG Phone 3 Case through Amazon. £6.71. To hold it without the phone it doesn't feel great and whilst over the standard case it comes with its bulkier I feel so much safer knowing my camera wont get scratched when I put the phone down. It also raises of the front screen by a minuet amount so there is a bump as you move your finger about. I'd rather that than a nasty scratch though so happy with it.
Air trigger holes and extra power connector cut out too as well as on the back a nice design
punchuk said:
I just received this: Foluu ROG Phone 3 Case through Amazon. £6.71. To hold it without the phone it doesn't feel great and whilst over the standard case it comes with its bulkier I feel so much safer knowing my camera wont get scratched when I put the phone down. It also raises of the front screen by a minuet amount so there is a bump as you move your finger about. I'd rather that than a nasty scratch though so happy with it.
Air trigger holes and extra power connector cut out too as well as on the back a nice design
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It covers the side? The picture on amazon looks like it is an open side design. I don't see slapping that case will provide a good grip.
lornranger said:
Imak case is quite loose around the air triggers, power button, volume button and side port. Top 4 corner airbags are the problems as they can be depressed quite easily and this cause the screen protector to lift up. You will know when you hold the phone on your right hand with your palm resting with the bottom right corner for support, and this can cause the screen protector to lift.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi mate i suggest to use Asus Antibatteric screen protector It has and awesome response and great oleophobic protection.
Davisk8 said:
Hi mate i suggest to use Asus Antibatteric screen protector It has and awesome response and great oleophobic protection.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am using Asus Original Screen Protector without antibacterial coating. The antibacterial protector is not available in my country. Great protector, no blocking of edge unlike the cheap china protector which has thick black borders and block the edges of the display.
punchuk said:
I just received this: Foluu ROG Phone 3 Case through Amazon. £6.71. To hold it without the phone it doesn't feel great and whilst over the standard case it comes with its bulkier I feel so much safer knowing my camera wont get scratched when I put the phone down. It also raises of the front screen by a minuet amount so there is a bump as you move your finger about. I'd rather that than a nasty scratch though so happy with it.
Air trigger holes and extra power connector cut out too as well as on the back a nice design
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this, I did think about getting this over.
I'm using the magnetic flip case which is great, but no front lip so don't drop the thing like I did, broke my display as the screen protector didn't quite cover all of it and a tiny stone hit the outer edge.
Not the end though as I've bought another, and will get it repaired under insurance consider it a lesson learned.
￡2.32 23%OFF | Safety protective Glass for Asus Rog Phone 3 ZS661KS Oleophobic Screen Protector For ROG Phone 3 Strix Tempered Glass Film
https://a.aliexpress.com/_B0aeTT
This was with the rog case which in all honesty shouldn't come with it.
This is the protector, don't bother with it, I've another coming that has smooth edges, looks decent so will see.
Turns out the one I've ordered might be the same Asus sells.
￡1.59 | For Asus ROG Phone 3 Phone3 ZS661KS / Strix 6.59" 21D 9D Full Glue Cover Toughened Tempered Glass Film Screen Protector Guard
https://a.aliexpress.com/_B0iH9b
the lighting case but I installed a diy wireless charger because I have so many already laying around
[/COLOR]
elmor0 said:
I have ordered this IMAK transparent black TPU case with extra corner shock-proofing along with these IMAK clear soft hydrogel films for front & back protection.
Hopefully shipment arriving to me by early next month.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FEEDBACK
Took about 5 weeks to arrive (from China).
This IMAK case is good build quality and fit over all, could have been a bit more snug - the extra corner padding does not make it look slick, and I am not sure if it is worth it on balance.
There is a 2 mm lip all around the front panel to help with screen protection.
Cut-outs are spot on - including for air-triggers/ 3 mics/ heat vent/ side USB ports. No cut-out for SIM-tray though but it's better this way.
Camera module is fairly well protected.
No issues with air-trigger related squeeze gestures.
The Hydrogel clear gel screen protector had a ?extra notch cut-out just left of the front camera (?? why) but otherwise the rest of the dimensions were spot on. It came as a set of x2 in one pack, which was a nice surprise. Included a helpful set of instructions/ link to video.
I preferred it to be short by about 1 mm all around the edges to minimise the risk of "lift" when the case is compressed in pockets/ when using the squeeze gestures etc.
The touch feel is smooth and has a good response. Visibility through this screen film is fine; no glare issues. I prefer these type of gel screen protectors to glass.
Has anyone come across a case that doesn't need to be removed when connecting to the accessories (eg Twinview, Mobile Desktop Dock)?