Related
I am unable to run apps like "tez" , "bhim" on pixel experience rom installed in redmi note 3. Apps say that my phone is rooted but its not. I confirmed it by installing"root checker" app. My device is not rooted. is there any solution for this problem? is it because of permissive Selinux?
Magisk
arnabbandopadhyay said:
I am unable to run apps like "tez" , "bhim" on pixel experience rom installed in redmi note 3. Apps say that my phone is rooted but its not. I confirmed it by installing"root checker" app. My device is not rooted. is there any solution for this problem? is it because of permissive Selinux?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Install magisk 15.3 or whichever is latest and hide all the apps that don't require root in magisk hide, after that clear data of playstore and apps like tez etc. I used this method, it is working perfectly fine.
Hit thanks if a solution works. it will encourage us to answer queries.
yachandra said:
Install magisk 15.3 or whichever is latest and hide all the apps that don't require root in magisk hide, after that clear data of playstore and apps like tez etc. I used this method, it is working perfectly fine.
Hit thanks if a solution works. it will encourage us to answer queries.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I dont want to root my phone. Will magisk root my phone?
Easy & fast track method is just flash Magisk.zip and enjoy any app in any custom rom.
...but it will root your device!
arnabbandopadhyay said:
I dont want to root my phone. Will magisk root my phone?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it will root your phone. But there won't be any root detection problems. I use snapchat, Tez etc on my phone
yachandra said:
Yes it will root your phone. But there won't be any root detection problems. I use snapchat, Tez etc on my phone
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is it safe to use banking apps on rooted device?
Yes it is safe to use banking apps on rooted device , if you're concerned about safety just don't install cracked apks or apps from outside other than playstore and use jio security or any such antivirus app
Simple method: you don't have to root the device. turn off play protect and find my device. You will get the OTP and you will be logged in. Then turn play protect and find my device on. (Tested only on Google pay. Don't know about BHIM).
May be because of unlocked bootloader
arnabbandopadhyay said:
i am unable to run apps like "tez" , "bhim" on pixel experience rom installed in redmi note 3. Apps say that my phone is rooted but its not. I confirmed it by installing"root checker" app. My device is not rooted. Is there any solution for this problem? Is it because of permissive selinux?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hi friend i was also faced the same issue , on my asus zenfone max pro m1 with pixel experience 10 plus and lineage os 16 and 17, using magisk couldnot help.
On Angler (Nexus 6p) I flashed the latest stock rom. (After a complete wipe) Afterwards I flashed TWRP and unzipped Magsik. Subsequently I did update to the latest version. After that I changed the packagename of Magsik manager. Furthermore I installed Xposed framework. Afterwards I enabled root hide for the TAN app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.starfinanz.mobile.android.dkbpushtan&hl=en
This software is meant to give you the tan without using sms services.
Still, the app crashed right at the start without any error notification. Android Version is 8.1 and Magsik is v16. While I did the test, the bootloader was unlocked and TWRP was still the recovery. Can these two things affect the verification of the Banking app? I tried this several times ago in the past, but I was never to make this app running.
If anyone would be able to give helpful advice here, it would be very much appreciated.
Best,
scarline
I have heard that DKB Tan2Go does not work with newer Android versions like Oreo 8.1.x at all.
I can also confirm that. I tried it on a Sony cellphone. The cellphone was not rooted and with a completely new and 'clean' ROM. It was to no avail.
A friend has been forced to buy a chip reader. I am fortunate to be able to use normal TAN lists at the moment. If the DKB tries to exclude me from online banking, I will change the bank.
DKB Tan2Go seems to be one of the worst and most insecure apps ever. The reviews in Google PlayStore confirm this conclusion.
Maybe there will be a solution someday?
DKB TAN2go works with Magisk:
1. Install the TAN2go app (but don't open it)
2. Add the TAN2go app in Magsik Manager in the menu "Magisk Hide"
3. Reboot the phone (I don't know if this is necessary)
4. Open TAN2go, works fine.
**** DKB and this stupid security features which bring absoltuely no security.
That's exactly what I tried - without success. I read that it only worked with an old, obsolete version of Tan2Go. However, I could not find this version and I'm not sure if it still works at all. Did you have the latest version of Tan2Go from Google PlayStore? According to DKB, the recent Tan2Go does not work with devices that was once rooted or had a CustomROM. Even if you go back to stock the Root Counter changed and DKB Tan2Go will never work on this device. Unfortunately, I have to confirm that.
I am working on it to change the bank, because of that.
exaveal said:
DKB TAN2go works with Magisk:
**** DKB and this stupid security features which bring absoltuely no security.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Indeed!
Yes, I have installed the latests version of LineageOS, latest version von Magisk and the latests version of the TAN2go app.
I tried that to no avail. I heard once the root counter has a value other than 0, one can't go back. Probably it is also the Sony bootloader and it is different with other devices?
exaveal said:
Yes, I have installed the latests version of LineageOS, latest version von Magisk and the latests version of the TAN2go app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a Xiomi Mi5 rooted with Magisk and Tan2go used to work for the last year or so. But yesterday I tried to make a transaction and BOOM! App crashed without an error message. Tried to use a newer Magisk, tried reinstalling the App, nothing helped.
The worst thing is that I do not know if some of my programs have a battery checker or a screen reader plugin that I am not aware of, or if Tan2Go suddenly detects my root. Regardless, crashing without an explanation is like the worst programming practice ever.
Since I do not need this kind of ****e in my life I will probably change Bank, I mean what good is an internet Bank if you cannot do transactions over your mobile device?
Well, willy-nilly I try to use the only other option from DKB: the German TAN Generator. Every other bank equips you with such a device, if they want you to use it. The DKB does not. Actually, I ordered the 3rd TAN Generator and fully paid for it. The first one drains the battery within days. The second one let me type in all the numbers and for no reason the TAN code does not show up on display.
These devices are very annoying anyway, because you have to type in a lot of numbers for every money transfer, the characters are very small (on the laptop) and you have to carry the TAN Generator + the DKB debitcard all the time. Of course this is less secure.
I would change the bank immediately, but want to keep the Visa credit card. I have higher limits on it. That's the only reason. As soon as I found an alternative bank in Europe, I will leave the DKB for good.
It dont worked with Lineage 14.1 but with 15.1 unoffical build on Samsung S4 together with latest Magisk .Rom from here
https://www.cyanogenmods.org/forums/topic/lineageos-15-1-for-galaxy-s4-lte-android-8-1-oreo/
Works for me
Just tried again. It hasn't been working for me in the past. When downloading & opening the app, I had the same problems.
Then I simply followed the above advice: downloading the app again, didn't open it, hide with Magisk, reboot and opened the app - worked well and was able to register for tan2go.
I am using Lineage 16.0 and Magisk v18.0
DKB already updated their app - they patched it
kyodhin said:
Just tried again. It hasn't been working for me in the past. When downloading & opening the app, I had the same problems.
Then I simply followed the above advice: downloading the app again, didn't open it, hide with Magisk, reboot and opened the app - worked well and was able to register for tan2go.
I am using Lineage 16.0 and Magisk v18.0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The app version from September (version 2.3.0) does work, the newer app version from 4.4.19 (version 2.4.0) does not...
Tested working combination: Magisk 18.0, Magisk Manager 6.1, DKB version 2.3.0
Can confirm that, working with magisk and 2.3.0. Not working anymore with 2.4.0.
I have another Tan app from another bank and with the new version it also stops working. Seems that magisk is now quite to popular and they working on better detection. Magisk hide is useless on the recent version of these tan apps.
That really sucks. No way to get 2.4.0 working. Hoping for a magisk fix. Are the magisk developer informed that there are problems with magisk hide? I think others will have similar problems too.
I successfully got 2.4 working again, after it got updated and refused to start.
Following the steps from this post made it work again (German):
https://www.android-hilfe.de/forum/...trotz-magisk.901517-page-2.html#post-11532359
I installed Magisk 19.0 (beta) but contrary to the above mentioned post I left my Magisk modules installed as they were before the update.
Both the Magisk modules as well as TAN2Go 2.4 are now working again.
I had to authenticate the new TAN2Go installation by adding it as a "new device" using SMS verification.
I was not able to get it to run with the above mentioned instuctions.
Device: Nexus 6P (angler), ROM: LineageOS 15.1-20190419, Magisk modules: MagiskHide Props Config (required for ctsProfile test), Busybox for Android NDK (required for MagiskHide Props Config).
DKB Tan2Go crashes immediately when started.
Same for me. The above instruction doesn't work.
Downgrade to 2.3.0
I experienced the same problem. Had to do an important transfer yesterday. And of course Tan2Go-2.4.0 crashed. I'm using Magisk v18.1.
Today I did a downgrade via Aptoide to 2.3.0 and had to register the smartphone again via SMS. This worked without any problems.
To avoid the update problem and keep with 2.3.0:
Start Titanium Backup
Select the DKB Tan2Go App
Long click on the App.
Connect with Google Play Store (forced)
Long click the App again.
Disconnect from Google Play Store
Hope it helps. I don't think there's much to change in the DKB Api. I'll use 2.3.0 until they block it via the API.
If more people confirm the proposed solution with Magisk v19, I'll try it maybe.
I got it working with v2.4.0, but don't know which step was the solution. Switching to the "Canary" channel of Magisk or hiding the Magisk Manager in the settings. I think the last one was the solution.
Can you guys try and give feedback?
Don't forget to uninstall and install the app before testing again.
musv said:
If more people confirm the proposed solution with Magisk v19, I'll try it maybe.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the same issue. Hopefully it can be fixed via Magisk one day.
Worked with T2G 2.4, 19, 7.1.1
Walhalla said:
I got it working with v2.4.0, but don't know which step was the solution. Switching to the "Canary" channel of Magisk or hiding the Magisk Manager in the settings. I think the last one was the solution.
Can you guys try and give feedback?
Don't forget to uninstall and install the app before testing again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi Walhalla,
Hi All
In Settings "General">"Hide" via other apk name it worked for me. V19.0, v7.1.1, Tan2Go 2.4
It looks like it should with Magisk, but I can't seem to get it to work. I have pay hidden, using magisk 17.1 and passing safety net. It sticks at card verification. It says "verifying with bank", then kicks me to the payment screen where it says "verification needed". Clicking on that gives me a momentary waiting circle, but nothing else happens. I've tried it with 2 different cards. US998, RR oreo 8.1.
nola mike said:
It looks like it should with Magisk, but I can't seem to get it to work. I have pay hidden, using magisk 17.1 and passing safety net. It sticks at card verification. It says "verifying with bank", then kicks me to the payment screen where it says "verification needed". Clicking on that gives me a momentary waiting circle, but nothing else happens. I've tried it with 2 different cards. US998, RR oreo 8.1.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's not an issue with Pay. If Magisk was being blocked by root/unlocked bootloader, you would get a message when you first fire up Pay that your phone can't be verified so "Google Pay can't run on this device".
Have you contacted your bank to make sure they support it? If it's not being verified with your bank, sounds like you need to call them. For the last few years, my bank didn't. It wasn't until this past year that they actually allowed it.
I'm not sure what the issue was. It wasn't with the bank(s). I was having the same issue with all the cards I tried. Eventually did a wipe and it worked.
nola mike said:
I'm not sure what the issue was. It wasn't with the bank(s). I was having the same issue with all the cards I tried. Eventually did a wipe and it worked.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well that's weird. Glad it's working though! :good:
After installing Google Pay, hide it using Magisk Hide, and Hide Magisk Manager in Magisk Settings. Then remove phone permission from Google Play Services and Play Store. Now you can register Pay on your rooted phone. After registration is complete, you should allow phone permission to Play Services and Play Store. This trick works always, I've tested with multiple custom roms with and without selinux enforcing.
If we want to reuse root features should we give phone permissions again ?
If we want to use Google pay again later should we re hide magisk and permissions ?
JackFrost said:
After installing Google Pay, hide it using Magisk Hide, and Hide Magisk Manager in Magisk Settings. Then remove phone permission from Google Play Services and Play Store. Now you can register Pay on your rooted phone. After registration is complete, you should allow phone permission to Play Services and Play Store. This trick works always, I've tested with multiple custom roms with and without selinux enforcing.
Sent from my Moto G (4) using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my Redmi 4 using Tapatalk
Yes and No
cneeli78 said:
If we want to reuse root features should we give phone permissions again ?
If we want to use Google pay again later should we re hide magisk and permissions ?
Sent from my Redmi 4 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Phone permissions have nothing to do with root features, I didn't exactly understand what do you mean by reuse root features but I don't recall any root solution app or framework asking for Phone Permission. If you are asking about granting phone permission to Google Play Services after Google Pay registration, you should do it, it's not recommended to deny phone permission to Google Play Services. And once you hide Magisk you don't need to change it's state as Magisk will continue to work as expected whether it's hidden or not.
JackFrost said:
After installing Google Pay, hide it using Magisk Hide, and Hide Magisk Manager in Magisk Settings. Then remove phone permission from Google Play Services and Play Store. Now you can register Pay on your rooted phone. After registration is complete, you should allow phone permission to Play Services and Play Store. This trick works always, I've tested with multiple custom roms with and without selinux enforcing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it's working
JackFrost said:
After installing Google Pay, hide it using Magisk Hide, and Hide Magisk Manager in Magisk Settings. Then remove phone permission from Google Play Services and Play Store. Now you can register Pay on your rooted phone. After registration is complete, you should allow phone permission to Play Services and Play Store. This trick works always, I've tested with multiple custom roms with and without selinux enforcing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks.its working
You are welcome
Arokia said:
Yes it's working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Karthik Arun said:
thanks.its working
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is a thanks button you can press if I could help you
JackFrost said:
There is a thanks button you can press if I could help you
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Am I doing something wrong? I did everything but when I deny phone permissions I get a pop up saying its required to open google pay and cannot get passed that
raguilera510 said:
Am I doing something wrong? I did everything but when I deny phone permissions I get a pop up saying its required to open google pay and cannot get passed that
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you by any chance remove phone permission from Google Pay app? You need to turn off telephone permission from Google Play Services and Google Play Store. Google Pay app needs phone permission to verify the phone number, don't turn off phone permission from Pay, do it for only play store and play services. Hope that helped.
Does not work
Once I renable telephone permission for Google Play Services, googlepay does not work anymore. Asks me to register and then I cannot register as I dont pass the security test. I am on lineage os 15.1
Non rooted lineageOS
I am a real newbie but i do use google pay a lot.
Will google pay just work on lineageOS that wasnt rooted or with magisk install, only with an unlocked bootloader. Or will i need extra work to do before i can use it?
kekekelasomot said:
I am a real newbie but i do use google pay a lot.
Will google pay just work on lineageOS that wasnt rooted or with magisk install, only with an unlocked bootloader. Or will i need extra work to do before i can use it?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Extra work? There's no extra work to install Magisk. It's part of the instructions when unlocking the bootloader and installing TWRP. Magisk Hide (part of Magisk Manager) lets Google Pay work.
When you unlock the bootloader and install TWRP (which you need to install ROMs), the next steps in the process include flashing three files IN TWRP: the no root checker, the no encryption and Magisk. I'm not clear why you would just stop short of finishing the process.
Unless you use Magisk Hide, simply unlocking the bootloader will cause Google Pay to then fail -- even without installing TWRP or a ROM.
Unlocked bootloader by itself -- without Magisk Hide (a part of Magisk) -- will cause Safety Net to fail. Google Pay will not work.
Why do you want Lineage OS without root? That's like owning a car with internal combustion engine, but refusing to put in gasoline. (or refusing to charge a Tesla.) You can do it, but to me it doesn't make sense.
You might as well stay on stock unrooted firmware.
I have stock rooted firmware. I'm not using any custom ROMs -- but at least I have root and my Magisk mods.
ChazzMatt said:
Extra work? There's no extra work to install Magisk. It's part of the instructions when unlocking the bootloader and installing TWRP. Magisk Hide (part of Magisk Manager) lets Google Pay work.
When you unlock the bootloader and install TWRP (which you need to install ROMs), the next steps in the process include flashing three files IN TWRP: the no root checker, the no encryption and Magisk. I'm not clear why you would just stop short of finishing the process.
Unless you use Magisk Hide, simply unlocking the bootloader will cause Google Pay to then fail -- even without installing TWRP or a ROM.
Unlocked bootloader by itself -- without Magisk Hide (a part of Magisk) -- will cause Safety Net to fail. Google Pay will not work.
Why do you want Lineage OS without root? That's like owning a car with internal combustion engine, but refusing to put in gasoline. (or refusing to charge a Tesla.) You can do it, but to me it doesn't make sense.
You might as well stay on stock unrooted firmware.
I have stock rooted firmware. I'm not using any custom ROMs -- but at least I have root and my Magisk mods.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you. Just flash magisk and hide google pay using it. From what i under stand is i have root access+ unlocked bootloader+ google pay functionalities. And the reason not to root is just because i want the feel of stock android+some nice modification
Recently had this problem with G Pay also. Found where some just deleted 'cache' and 'data' from Google Play and Play Services. That worked for me too. Of course hide Magisk etc first.
AsItLies said:
Recently had this problem with G Pay also. Found where some just deleted 'cache' and 'data' from Google Play and Play Services. That worked for me too. Of course hide Magisk etc first.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you. That's all I had to do to get it working for me.
Hi, I'm not able to get Google Pay working on my rooted V30. I unlocked bootloader and flashed TWRP, no checker, no encryption, using chazzdave's WTF tutorial. Now have Havoc installed. I have hidden root from play, play services, and pay. I've hidden magisk by scrambling APK. I've cleared cache and data of play, play services, and pay. I've revoked telephone permission for play services and play store, although I had to re-enable play services telephone permission during card setup because pay wouldn't go any further. But nothing. Just error message that root is enabled and cannot proceed.
One of my banking apps which didn't work on root is working after hiding from magisk, but no Google pay. Has something updated and a loophole been closed?
Thanks
Forsh said:
Hi, I'm not able to get Google Pay working on my rooted V30. I unlocked bootloader and flashed TWRP, no checker, no encryption, using chazzdave's WTF tutorial. Now have Havoc installed. I have hidden root from play, play services, and pay. I've hidden magisk by scrambling APK. I've cleared cache and data of play, play services, and pay. I've revoked telephone permission for play services and play store, although I had to re-enable play services telephone permission during card setup because pay wouldn't go any further. But nothing. Just error message that root is enabled and cannot proceed.
One of my banking apps which didn't work on root is working after hiding from magisk, but no Google pay. Has something updated and a loophole been closed?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Use Magisk v19. I believe it's a beta at the moment
Hi guys,
I'm using Miui Eu 11.0.6.0. I'm not sure what had gone wrong.Both ctsprofile and basicintegrity false. At first, I thought it was edxposed issue so I uninstall it, but it still the same issue after reboot.
Is there any way to resolve it? Appreciated.
These are my screenshots.
thomas140 said:
These are my screenshots.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try disabling/ removing the magisk modules and if that doesn't work revert to stock kernel if you're using a custom kernel.
thomas140 said:
These are my screenshots.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Turn on magisk hide in settings and reboot.
MasterFURQAN said:
Try disabling/ removing the magisk modules and if that doesn't work revert to stock kernel if you're using a custom kernel.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tried with stock miui Eu kernel but still the same. Disable all modules and still the same. Magisk hide is on. Hide magisk manager is on too. Weird.
callmebutcher101 said:
Turn on magisk hide in settings and reboot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Both magisk hide and hide magisk manager is on but still both error. Funny.
thomas140 said:
Both magisk hide and hide magisk manager is on but still both error. Funny.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you hide all the google services from magisk ? Try clearing data of magisk and repeating the process. And btw MIUI EU can pass safetynet without magisk so if you really want safetyney pass you can sacrifice magisk.
callmebutcher101 said:
Did you hide all the google services from magisk ? Try clearing data of magisk and repeating the process. And btw MIUI EU can pass safetynet without magisk so if you really want safetyney pass you can sacrifice magisk.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup, I know miui Eu without magisk can definitely pass safetynet.
And ya, I have hide all related Google services and still same issue.
Just not sure what's triggering it.
But something's funny, when hide magisk manager, it still able to bypass those bank app root check although both still false status.lol
Try downgrading google play service. Run magisk from canary channel. Latest google play breaks cts
vjsanjay said:
Try downgrading google play service. Run magisk from canary channel. Latest google play breaks cts
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok. That's surprising. For downgrading, I believe it is related to "uninstall updates", right?
Can disable the update once downgrade?
thomas140 said:
Ok. That's surprising. For downgrading, I believe it is related to "uninstall updates", right?
Can disable the update once downgrade?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes.. Till google makes mandatory.
vjsanjay said:
Yes.. Till google makes mandatory.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Update: you are correct. Once uninstalled update, status back to true.
I made few tests.
1. I tried install Edxposed, status became false.
2. In edxposed manager, blacklist Google play services and play store, still false.
3. Install hidden core module under exposed. Status became true but some government app became forced close.
4.I uninstaledl edxposed related stuff and reboot, status still false. I have to clear the data under Google play service to make status back to true.
So, it seems like edxposed is unable to hide properly like magisk does. No choice but have to abandon edxposed.
Apparently, my bank updated the app with a new feature that doesn't let me access it anymore, it says that the operating system is not supported, i use a custom rom(AEX) in my Redmi 4x, i believe that the rom is the problem, the root is being hidden with MagiskHide and i have no problems with SafetyNet, maybe i can change some parameter in build.prop to make it work? i did something similar to try to run Fortnite in my phone a while ago, any ideas on what parameters may be relevant to that?
It's a brazilian bank(Banco Inter)
Need Solution for this Problem as Well
I have the same problem.
The new app version 8.4.6 is not working while up till version 8.4.5 it was working just fine.
Their support is absolutely clueless on how to help, but as @Levyks said, apparently they are blocking custom roms now.
Is it possible to make the custom rom look as an original rom from manufacturer?
Same problem.
I'm with the same problem...
IMHO has nothing to do with fact whether it's a Custom ROM or a Stock ROM. Any app ( banking apps included ) easily can find out whether present Android OS got tampered or not.
Same problem any help? Can't use my bank app... WhatsApp also can detect I have a custom ROM, any solution?
Incomtus said:
Same problem any help? Can't use my bank app... WhatsApp also can detect I have a custom ROM, any solution?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Many apps like banking / payment apps today detect whether Android is got rooted or not: it's an easy for them to do so.
Same problem here in Lineage OS 18.1. My non-rooted device pass safetynet and CTS by default. But many Banking application had started detecting that I am using custom rom and don't open at all. Then I rooted my device with magisk and enabled 'magisk hide' but no success.
Hi! A solution that worked for me: use the renaming function in Magisk (you can find it in the Settings).
I had the same problem on a Redmi 4X, LOS 16, no working banking app even with Magisk hide. After renaming Magisk, I was able to log in and use it as intended. Also I left Magisk hide turned on.
My guess is that these kind of apps are looking specially for Magisk, and if it's detected, they just won't let you use them.