I have to choose between a refurbished Samsung Captivate or Motorola Atrix 4G.
Which way do you suggest and why?
ATRIX. Since it has the latest tech and specs and will get more updates. The ATRIX is wicked fast.
Sent from my Atrix 4G with XDA Premium App
its that a question?! lol captative have 2 years atrix have months oO
phoophan said:
I have to choose between a refurbished Samsung Captivate or Motorola Atrix 4G.
Which way do you suggest and why?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I suggest Atrix if you like being future-proof, and useful accessories.
Samsung Cappy if you can't wait for more ROMs to pop up. Also, if you're going to buy a phone based on the screen, the Cappy.
I owned a Captivate myself, and if you do end up getting it, put a ROM on it ASAP! The captivate has horrible GPS problems, and some kernels and ROMs try to fix that, but they still can't fix it completely. Also, on start-up, prepare to wait a couple minutes for everything to load.
phoophan said:
I have to choose between a refurbished Samsung Captivate or Motorola Atrix 4G.
Which way do you suggest and why?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Artix, hands down. I have both, used the cappy for a while and now have had the atrix for almost a year.
My experiance with the cappy, it has bad battery life, horrible gps but great for graphics. I also agree if you go with the cappy put a rom on it quick. The cappy is very easy to mod and return to stock if needed. I turned mine into a cappy touch for the kids to play on.
My experiance with the atrix, great battery life, I go all day music, calls, text, wifi and 4g internet, rss feeds, email, facebook, gaming for maybe an hour a day and at the end I still average about 30%-40% battery left. For me that is the game changer. Plus there are not many phones out there with dual core, and 1GB of memory.
atrix, of course this is the atrix subforum..so you should expect more bias here. though i see no real reason to choose a single core over a dual core this late in the year.
people talk about future proofing like it's insurance against buyer's remorse. in a way that's true, but vague. in a specific way think about what you're using the smart phone for. most people would want to utilize the phone to the fullest, or at least play the latest games. you plan on getting the latest apps then having the latest phone is usually a must as most developers will develop their games for high end phones.
cerowand said:
... now have had the atrix for almost a year.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's quite a feat considering the phone was released 5 months ago.
I've never used a Atrix, but the price on the Atrix dropped more and faster than the Captivate ... I think that implies something.
Why do you have to choose between those two? Two superior phones are around the corner: Galaxy S II and Thrill. That's the tough choice I am facing. Both dual core, 1GB slow RAM or 512 MB RAM that's twice as fast plus a 3D screen.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
quarlow said:
That's quite a feat considering the phone was released 5 months ago.
I've never used a Atrix, but the price on the Atrix dropped more and faster than the Captivate ... I think that implies something.
Why do you have to choose between those two? Two superior phones are around the corner: Galaxy S II and Thrill. That's the tough choice I am facing. Both dual core, 1GB slow RAM or 512 MB RAM that's twice as fast plus a 3D screen.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Or get an ATRIX it has 1 gig if fast ram.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
Clienterror said:
Or get an ATRIX it has 1 gig if fast ram.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As fast as the SGS II: single channel. Thrill has dual channel, and the highest quadrant score on ant stock phone. SGS II with have dual 1.2GHz cores.
The captivates GPU is better than atrix, so gamers choose captivate.
Ask the same question in the captivate forum for a bunch of people that had both and chose captivate. The audience is important.
IMO, The captivate us more future proof, as long as the Nexus S (another option to consider now) is the dev phone. Once Ice Cream Sandwich releases, the Captivate will have it long before the Atrix.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
quarlow said:
As fast as the SGS II: single channel. Thrill has dual channel, and the highest quadrant score on ant stock phone. SGS II with have dual 1.2GHz cores.
The captivates GPU is better than atrix, so gamers choose captivate.
Ask the same question in the captivate forum for a bunch of people that had both and chose captivate. The audience is important.
IMO, The captivate us more future proof, as long as the Nexus S (another option to consider now) is the dev phone. Once Ice Cream Sandwich releases, the Captivate will have it long before the Atrix.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Um, more future proof? Sorry, but how do you figure that?
Also, long before the Atrix? We have an unlocked bootloader now, so I don't see how that's a valid argument.
Sinful Animosity said:
Um, more future proof? Sorry, but how do you figure that?
Also, long before the Atrix? We have an unlocked bootloader now, so I don't see how that's a valid argument.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Um, I think I explained it.
Not fully future proof, but more than the Atrix.
I was running gingerbread on my captivate when the Atrix dropped. In the world of Android releases 5 months is indeed a long time.
Unlocked bootloader is no help without a dev following to use it. So many early adopters in the dev community skipped the Atrix and have already moved on. ReadesignGears just to name one.
Someone else already noted if you are looking for ROMs and dev improvement get the captivate, so I even other Atrix users see that point.
My overall point was to wait for the better hardware. But if you want more Atrix vs Captivate stories check the posts in the Captivate forum about 4 months ago, as the 30 day return window was closing on early adopters.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
quarlow said:
Um, I think I explained it.
Not fully future proof, but more than the Atrix.
I was running gingerbread on my captivate when the Atrix dropped. In the world of Android releases 5 months is indeed a long time.
Unlocked bootloader is no help without a dev following to use it. So many early adopters in the dev community skipped the Atrix and have already moved on. ReadesignGears just to name one.
Someone else already noted if you are looking for ROMs and dev improvement get the captivate, so I even other Atrix users see that point.
My overall point was to wait for the better hardware. But if you want more Atrix vs Captivate stories check the posts in the Captivate forum about 4 months ago, as the 30 day return window was closing on early adopters.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, silly boy, Designgears is back He's developing a ROM for us too. And you can't compare you guys getting Gingerbread to us.
Times have changed, and it seems like you haven't kept up with the news. We even have a CM7 alpha. Which we're getting a lot quicker than the Captivate did.
Granted, the locked bootloader was a problem. But no longer.
Also, the person that talked about the dev improvements, was me. A device like the cappy shouldn't need dev improvements to be usable after it powers up.
quarlow said:
Um, I think I explained it.
Not fully future proof, but more than the Atrix.
I was running gingerbread on my captivate when the Atrix dropped. In the world of Android releases 5 months is indeed a long time.
Unlocked bootloader is no help without a dev following to use it. So many early adopters in the dev community skipped the Atrix and have already moved on. ReadesignGears just to name one.
Someone else already noted if you are looking for ROMs and dev improvement get the captivate, so I even other Atrix users see that point.
My overall point was to wait for the better hardware. But if you want more Atrix vs Captivate stories check the posts in the Captivate forum about 4 months ago, as the 30 day return window was closing on early adopters.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I own a Captivate, a Nexus S, and an Atrix. I can tell you right now the Atrix blows them away--I have tried them side by side.
If you want the same TouchWiz ROM with a different theme, horrible GPS, and a 3 hour battery if you actually use your phone for games, get a Captivate.
If you want a good phone with decent battery life, a high resolution screen, and a perfect GPS, with OFFICIAL Gingerbread, get an Atrix.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Sinful Animosity said:
Well, silly boy, Designgears is back He's developing a ROM for us too. And you can't compare you guys getting Gingerbread to us.
Times have changed, and it seems like you haven't kept up with the news. We even have a CM7 alpha. Which we're getting a lot quicker than the Captivate did.
Granted, the locked bootloader was a problem. But no longer.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's awesome that DG is back, you guys are in for a treat.
Back to my original question: why are those two "old" phones your only choice? If its a matter of cost, wait a month and get a brand new phone: Attain or Thrill, they won't be much more. If you are locking yourself into a two year (possibly 12 months if your bill us enough each month) I would say don't choose either at this point. If you have this choice because a friend just upgraded and they have those two phones sitting around, then try both. Make your own mind up, don't listen to me, or anyone else here. YOU will be the one stuck with the phone for the next while.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
quarlow said:
That's awesome that DG is back, you guys are in for a treat.
Back to my original question: why are those two "old" phones your only choice? If its a matter of cost, wait a month and get a brand new phone: Attain or Thrill, they won't be much more. If you are locking yourself into a two year (possibly 12 months if your bill us enough each month) I would say don't choose either at this point. If you have this choice because a friend just upgraded and they have those two phones sitting around, then try both. Make your own mind up, don't listen to me, or anyone else here. YOU will be the one stuck with the phone for the next while.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If he wants a Droid NOW, these are the two best options, IMO. LG Thrill has been pushed back, and Attain is still nowhere in sight.
Sinful Animosity said:
If he wants a Droid NOW, these are the two best options, IMO. LG Thrill has been pushed back, and Attain is still nowhere in sight.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They are not here now, but lately att has been giving 2 weeks or less from announcement and availability. RadioShack will be selling both phones in August. Thrill was pushed back like 2 weeks, still August.
The only reason to buy either of these phones now is if you could get them off contract.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
quarlow said:
They are not here now, but lately att has been giving 2 weeks or less from announcement and availability. RadioShack will be selling both phones in August. Thrill was pushed back like 2 weeks, still August.
The only reason to buy either of these phones now is if you could get them off contract.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Link to where the release date is for the Attain?
Sinful Animosity said:
Link to where the release date is for the Attain?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You'll have to trust on that one ... inside knowledge. I haven't seen it leaked on the interwebs yet. And no one will accept the word of a random poster if I gave a date.
Sent from my Captivate running Continuum 5.6
I love my atrix using alien rom with swift key and custom bootscreen and unlocked bootloader
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Related
Anyone switch and have any feedback? Im considering an "upgrade" and just looking for some input from anyone who had Vibrant who switched.
Thanks!
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
shovelhead83 said:
Anyone switch and have any feedback? Im considering an "upgrade" and just looking for some input from anyone who had Vibrant who switched.
Thanks!
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
im trying to see if I should wait for the Galaxy S2, GX2, or htc Sensation too.
Sensation and Galaxy S2 both have more Ram the the LG, but the LG is out now...
All 3 use are different duel core processor.
I definitely dont think you should go for the mytouch 4 with the LG out now and others on the way.
trying to decide which of the 3 duel core phones to go for myself.
if you are looking for a phone now, its the LG hands down. If you are willing to wait, then you are in the same boat as me. not sure between the LG, HTC, or Sammy
Ya, the htc is supposed to be out in June or July. But my son's mytouch slide is having issues. So I'm considering upgrading and giving him my phone.
Sent from my SGH-T959 using XDA App
Switch from the vibrant I'm on the g2x nd lovin it by far the fastest phone I have ever owned. I've owned a lot I'm a phone whore... I'm still going to get the galaxy s 2 when it comes out phones are like pokemon gotta catch em all
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA Premium App
If you can wait ............wait for the S2 the hardware is something to wait for. Over the next 10-15 months all the phones will go through a huge change. All the new phones hardware will have the capacity to run windows 7 (not that they will) but think about it ....the phone I have now has the same power as my windows 2000 computer 7 years ago............ amazing time.........
The vibrant has too much going for it to pay for an upgrade now. Especially in my mind the uncertainty of the AT&T takeover, or as i call it, when we all get screwed.
The g2x is amazing. I want one. But I also know my phone is dang good and only better phones are going to roll out... More GHz and more dual cores.
The next phone with a perfect 4"screen, 1.3+ GHz dual core on a good/cheap network may change my opinion... In the future.
S2 for sure. There is nothing to discuss, and nothing to think about. That is just the way to do it. Period.
S2 has a answered my prayers. I have been waiting for a freakin 4.3 SAMOLED phone to come out. Sammy only had the 4" galaxy S - Vibrant last year with talks of "dual core."
I'm glad that they didn't rush it either- because that would have been a huge liability waiting to happen.
Instead, they listened to our gripes.
1. 32gb memory- on bigger model
2. FFC - badass
3. FLASH!!!!
4. 8mp camera
5. 4.3" Capacitive Touch
6. Super Amoled!!!!!!!!
7. Gorilla glass?
8. External SD support up to 32gb
9. 4g !!!!!
10. GingerBread official.
11. Mod edit: to much info mate...keep it to yourself.
Seriously, it blows anything out of the water that is out there and will be out there in the near future.
Plus, Tmobile is getting is.
I'm going to buy 10 of these just in case zombies attack, then I'll just sit back and relax.
Anyway, /shameless Plug.
you get the picture.
GL with your decision.
A better way to go about this is, do you plan on rooting your new phone and installing custom ROMs? If you you do intend to do that, then i think Samsung has proven they could careless about you or the dev community so long as you buy there product.
We all know HTC shares there source code and there is a herd of diehard HTC fans who will mod the crap out of the Sensation.
I just picked up the G2x yesterday after i seen that LG has already released source code for not only the OS but kernel source code as well, and with cyanogen himself doing the CM7 port to the G2x, it will and should be community supported greatly as well
A thing that sold me on the G2x is that it supports AT&T 3G bands, so if its still my main phone if the merger goes down, it'll be a fully compatible device and i wont need to buy a new one to take advantage of AT&Ts extended coverage
So in the end it really just boils down to:
How long can you wait?
Do you intend to mod your phone?
Galaxy S2 hands down.
It will have a lot of ROMS for it since it has an unlocked Bootloader just like the Vibrant. The HTC Sensation does NOT. It also has lots of memory internal, and a 4.3 Super Amoled PLUS. Everything else you can compare to the HTC Sensation of G2X as all 3 have relatively similar "rest of the phone".
I'm on a g2x lets hope that the galaxy 2 does not have the normal sammy problems like on the vibrant I have a bitter taste for them now
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA Premium App
I just got the G2x.
I'll miss the awesome SAMOLED, but #NeverAgain
-bZj
as you can see from the second post in this thread, I too am trying to decide between gx2, gs2, sensation...
i see tons of people saying the samsung gs2 will be the best thing ever. So yes, Sammy does have awesome hardware (look at our vibrants). But, will it be cheap plastic? and who cares how great the hardware is if the Software sucks balls? (like our vibrants). Yes, our developers are awesome, but they are having to run circles around Sammy's terrible software writing...
I am not saying this is the case with the gs2, as im thinking about it too, just wondering these things...?
Thank you guys so much for your responses. It was exactly what I was looking for, different opinions. I needed to get a phone because two of the phones on my plan were injured. My son chose the "sidekick" not a bad phone, but I tried to talk him out of it. But whatever, it was cheaper.(good for me). I chose the G2x. And I gotta say, WOW! And for those wondering, the screen is just as good. Colors even seem a bit deeper. Quadrants (whatever) but 2200 out the box. The 4g is way better than my 3g. You tube on HD without a stutter. Couldnt pull that off before.
1080 vid recording (I was told) not tested yet.
Fast fast fast processor.
FFC (untested yet)
8mp camera with flash.
Feels much more solid and better made than Vibrant.
Stock against stock. Hands down its better. Guess I will have to wait on dev community for customization results. Maybe I will try to figure out how and root it tonight to remove some bloat.
I will miss my Vibrant (but my sis in law will be happy).
Oh! And I heard today the merge with ATT may not happen. Yay!
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
shovelhead83 said:
Thank you guys so much for your responses. It was exactly what I was looking for, different opinions. I needed to get a phone because two of the phones on my plan were injured. My son chose the "sidekick" not a bad phone, but I tried to talk him out of it. But whatever, it was cheaper.(good for me). I chose the G2x. And I gotta say, WOW! And for those wondering, the screen is just as good. Colors even seem a bit deeper. Quadrants (whatever) but 2200 out the box. The 4g is way better than my 3g. You tube on HD without a stutter. Couldnt pull that off before.
1080 vid recording (I was told) not tested yet.
Fast fast fast processor.
FFC (untested yet)
8mp camera with flash.
Feels much more solid and better made than Vibrant.
Stock against stock. Hands down its better. Guess I will have to wait on dev community for customization results. Maybe I will try to figure out how and root it tonight to remove some bloat.
I will miss my Vibrant (but my sis in law will be happy).
Oh! And I heard today the merge with ATT may not happen. Yay!
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
man i started colecting money for when sgs 2 come out to buy.. and are you sure about the merge not going to happen?? i hope this dont happen
Nope not sure. Just heard from Tmobile.
Sent from my LG-P999 using XDA App
kboater said:
as you can see from the second post in this thread, I too am trying to decide between gx2, gs2, sensation...
i see tons of people saying the samsung gs2 will be the best thing ever. So yes, Sammy does have awesome hardware (look at our vibrants). But, will it be cheap plastic? and who cares how great the hardware is if the Software sucks balls? (like our vibrants). Yes, our developers are awesome, but they are having to run circles around Sammy's terrible software writing...
I am not saying this is the case with the gs2, as im thinking about it too, just wondering these things...?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
can anyone comment about the build quality of the Galaxy S2, or if the software/coding/file system will be terrible like it is on the Vibrant?
Is the Galaxy S II officially coming to T-Mobile?
BigWorldJust said:
Is the Galaxy S II officially coming to T-Mobile?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unknown. And if it doesn't, it's not going to have AWS/Tmo 3g or 4g support.
Anyone saying S2 are idiots who dont wanna be in the iphone crowd but want an iphone.
Murdered Out Vibrant w/ FFC
Bionix-V 1.3.1 w/ Blackout Theme
kboater said:
All 3 use are different duel core processor.
trying to decide which of the 3 duel core phones to go for myself.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Duel.
Does that mean they are fighting?
Or keep my Atrix? Is it going to be that good?
dldennis76 said:
Or keep my Atrix? Is it going to be that good?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's personal preference.. I like the amount of dev attention the atrix is getting. They both are great dual core phones. I use webtop also.. one choice there.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
I will likely be making the switch for the larger screen. I will miss the LED Notifications and the Finger Print Scanner.
Of course this all assumes ATT prices it competitively. (doubtful)
I would buy a unlocked one but the center button is terrible the 4 android buttons are better. I have read the battery life is terrible on s2
Sent from my MB860 using XDA Premium App
Hold out for a Nexus Prime... supposedly coming in October. Pure Google experience! Just hope that the latest rumors that it is supposed to be exclusive to Verizon prove false... hard to believe Google would do this, alienating all current Nexus owners & devs.
i have had the samsung galaxy s2 for about two weeks, and although it has an amazing screen and its the fastest device i have ever use - it's battery is awful.
I switched back to the atrix for now.
for people waiting for the nexus prime, keep in mind it will almost be as big as the dell streak.. huuuuuuge. like a tablet phone lol. i cant wait to see what it is like though, i will most likely be waiting for it since i dont even use my phone for calls xD
rectangle said:
i have had the samsung galaxy s2 for about two weeks, and although it has an amazing screen and its the fastest device i have ever use - it's battery is awful.
I switched back to the atrix for now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you switched back just because of the battery life?.. personally i HATE samsungs phones, but the nexus S was a nice looking device, never used it but yeah. sgs2 looks nice as well, idk if id trade though.
I've been waiting for the SGS2 but I will probably add it as a second line and use it as my daily driver and then turn my Atrix into more of a PMP and Hotspot.
I'm also looking to see if they do end up releasing a SGS2 variant with the keyboard that's been leaked:
http://www.droid-life.com/2011/07/26/atts-samsung-galaxy-s-ii-outed-with-keyboard-in-tow/
The Atrix is perfect for me because of WebTop. I use it for work when I go to client's businesses, a lot more efficient that carrying a laptop. When (if?) the prime comes to AT&T, I'll use that for personal use, and switch SIMs for when I need the Atrix.
stratax said:
for people waiting for the nexus prime, keep in mind it will almost be as big as the dell streak.. huuuuuuge. like a tablet phone lol. i cant wait to see what it is like though, i will most likely be waiting for it since i dont even use my phone for calls xD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If it's as big as the Dell Streak, then **** that Verizon can have it...
Sent from my GT-I9000 using xda premium
I heard the Attain is coming out mid sept. After my experience with the SGS1, im gonna pass. Samsung sucks big, hairy, infected, baboon balls.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
stratax said:
for people waiting for the nexus prime, keep in mind it will almost be as big as the dell streak.. huuuuuuge. like a tablet phone lol. i cant wait to see what it is like though, i will most likely be waiting for it since i dont even use my phone for calls xD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Geez. How many times do I gotta tell people a buttonless 4.5" inch screen will be about as big as the atrix overall. Unless it has half inch bezels.
I voided my warranty and your mum.
pukemon said:
Geez. How many times do I gotta tell people a buttonless 4.5" inch screen will be about as big as the atrix overall. Unless it has half inch bezels.
I voided my warranty and your mum.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hahaha i know right, you couldnt even fit that in your pocket. have fun with a fany pack people ;D jk..
Deggy said:
I heard the Attain is coming out mid sept. After my experience with the SGS1, im gonna pass. Samsung sucks big, hairy, infected, baboon balls.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What do baboon balls look like when they are infected? LOl ewwwww
I thought about the same thing OP. Realistically the top phones out right now are the iPhone 4, Atrix, Galaxy S2, and Optimus 2x. And...the next wave of super phones that are coming out will be around October. This will include a bunch of devices that Samsung and Motorola, among others will release to compete with the iPhone 5.
My advice is keep your Atrix and make the switch once the next big transition to dual core phones happens because you'll be wasting money and it's pointless to switch for such little improvement.
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
ill stay with my atrix, im patiently awaiting cm7 to come out of beta and have everything work cm7 hauls ass compared to any rom right now for atrix becuase its 100% blur free
Not worth it imo. You get a bigger screen with less res, worse battery, slightly better processor (but seriously Tegra2 is more than good enough esp overclocked), superthin if thats your cup of tea.
As others have said, wait till the next generation comes out Q4. Atrix to SGS2 is incremental at best. As I hate the SGS2 form factor and really love qHD resolution of atrix, it would be going backwards IMO. The only thing about the atrix that lets me down is the little bugs with VOIP/SIP stack and bluetooth as well (e.g. if you're using BT headphones for music, notification sounds keep coming out of phone not BT).
Now if you're not game to root and flash custom ROM then the balance tilts a fair bit, stock SW wise the SGS2 is noticeably faster than the stock atrix IMO.
^ only reason this is true is because sgs2 is stock clocked at 1.2ghz, but has terrible battery life. I am oc'd at 1.3ghz with better than stock atrix battery life
Sent from my MB860 using XDA App
Overclocked and better than stock battery life??? How does that work?
Posted on another forum but was curious regarding XDA members.
are you guys planning on getting the ATT S2 come october 2nd even though the nexus prime is supposedly close? or is the S2 just not worth it at this point? no bashing (im actually contemplating on buying one myself).
I will be at the store when it opens on Oct 2. Even though we're getting it late it will still be a top 5 phone for the next year.
sent from my captivate running firefly at Tranquility base
I'm waiting for the Galaxy Note.
RMXO said:
I'm waiting for the Galaxy Note.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Note looks incredible, but not sure how I'd carry that around...
will wait for Note how big it is in real, and than decide. AT&T is little bit too late for me to be excited because I am using int. version since early June.
IpodLover77 said:
Posted on another forum but was curious regarding XDA members.
are you guys planning on getting the ATT S2 come october 2nd even though the nexus prime is supposedly close? or is the S2 just not worth it at this point? no bashing (im actually contemplating on buying one myself).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I plan on getting one. Even though it's already a few months old, I feel like it's one of the most "future proof" of current phones on the market right now.
Things like Exynos CPU/GPU, 1 GB ram, NFC, effectively maximum speed HSPA+... My Captivate runs quite comfortable at 1.3 GHz w/ Cyanogenmod and still beats the pants off of any stock Android device currently available in the States. That's 2+ versions of Android ahead of what it launched with (2.1 Eclair), and a 30% overclock of what the stock chip came with. By similar logic, the GS2 should last through Ice Cream Sandwich and beyond...
The Note looks awesome but if I wait for it then something better will be right around the corner, besides, been sitting on this upgrade since July
sent from my captivate running firefly at Tranquility base
im just waiting to see how much the unlocked versión is gonna cost
I'd guess around 600 bones.
sent from my stock Infuse at Tranquility Base.
I don't get why people think Note is God like phone or something. By the time it comes out, the specs will be mediocre at best.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
I thought the Note wasn't an actual phone. But meant to be something in between a phone and a tablet. I get why it's awesome. The display resolution.
But I'll be picking up the AT&T SGSII when it comes out. Can always sell it later when something much better is released.
I will be getting it on or close as possible to Oct. 2nd I have waited this long and learned my lesson. I WON'T be waiting for the next best phone from attention after this one, I will fork out the cash for an unbranded phone. Maybe the prime or SGS3 IN the near future
Sent from My KickAss Captivated CM7 OC'd 1.5Ghz/Undervolted
I'll be getting it on launch day for sure. I was debating on waiting for the Nexus announcement but the likelihood of at&t seeing a nexus device near launch is slim to none. I know there have been hints dropped about it launching as both cdma and gsm but there is no concrete evidence. So just going by history it will likely be a few months before at&t sees the prime.
IpodLover77 said:
Posted on another forum but was curious regarding XDA members.
are you guys planning on getting the ATT S2 come october 2nd even though the nexus prime is supposedly close? or is the S2 just not worth it at this point? no bashing (im actually contemplating on buying one myself).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nexus Prime/iPhone 5 for me atm... but theres still a 10% chance that seeing the Att Attain in person could wow me into buying it but I highly doubt it. Don't like Att/Samsung giving Americans the middle finger by taking 6 months to bring it to the U.S.
hbkmog said:
I don't get why people think Note is God like phone or something. By the time it comes out, the specs will be mediocre at best.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you actually seen the specs? The note is going to be the best phone in the world bar none. What realistic specs could another phone have that would make the Galaxy Note look mediocre? I can't think of any realistic ones...
ap3604 said:
Have you actually seen the specs? The note is going to be the best phone in the world bar none. What realistic specs could another phone have that would make the Galaxy Note look mediocre? I can't think of any realistic ones...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Smaller screens and lack of a stylus.
All personal preference though.
nybmx said:
Smaller screens and lack of a stylus.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You suck!
LoL gotta admit had me laughing hard though
It's either buy this on release date or wait for the Nexus Prime or HTC Holiday/Raider 4G for me. I've been phoneless since March so I'm not sure that I want to wait much longer for such a trivial upgrade (SGSII -> Prime/Holiday).
What do you guys think?
Is there any trick or loopholes in att contract that we can exploit to get an early upgrade? Or is there any way like may be paying something around 100$ to get an early upgrade?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I897 using XDA App
hbkmog said:
I don't get why people think Note is God like phone or something. By the time it comes out, the specs will be mediocre at best.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because it has potential, higher resolution is a big thing which is the only thing missing from sgs2.
Also 5.3 sounds big, but you never know it may be the sweet spot between a phone and tablet. It is definitely going to replace both my phone and tablet.
And then there is the stylus which is kind of cool to have and might come handy in lots of places.
The only thing which is disappointing is the software. I would have liked to see ICS, but they are shipping with ginger bread.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
or where have you gone?
I just got mine yesterday. Its awesome.
Got mine.. love it but it feels like a freaking tablet compared to the Eris
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using xda premium
My 4 reason for getting a Rezound over the Nexus.
1. Better screen
2. Better camera
3. Build Quality (Nexus feels like a toy compared to the Rezound to me)
4. I actually like Sense.
I got my SGN on the 15th. It is soooo much better than the Eris. Of course it is also 2 years newer.
I really love ICS, it is quite a step up from Gingerbread. After using it the manufacturers are going to have to step up their game to compete. I see no reason to use an after market launcher with ICS.
Droid 3. I had a Bionic first, but had many problems with data with it. It's a common problem with all of the LTE phones at the moment, so I decided to get the best 3G phone that I could get (plus I wanted a world phone), so it was between the D3, the DInc2, and the iPhone 4S.
Love my new Galaxy Nexus!
Too many superlatives to list...now I've got an HTC, two Motorolas, and a Samsung device .
What will I get next year, LOL?
Cheers!
I moved to a fascinate bit had problems now I have a incredible 2 .my wife just became an i-tard so I am playing around with her x2.
Sent from my DROID X2 using XDA App
Got my Galaxy Nexus on launch day, Dec 15th, 3 days before my birthday.
Love, love, love it. Couldn't be happier. Little quirks here and there that could use fixing and a few things I miss from custom ROMs/launchers, but overall absolutely the best phone I have ever had.
Still keeping my Eris around as a music player/alarm clock though. Can't part with it!
Thinking about getting it, but I'm on the fence based on the various reviews.
By the time my thinking is done the next great phone will be announced and then what?
I went with the Galaxy Nexus. Huge step up for me from the Eris. I like how some of the above posters felt the need to justify their purchase over the Galaxy. Thats fine. Fact is they are all pretty great phones when your stepping up from something like an Eris. I loved my Eris but that hardware was seriously tired.
ICS was the main reason why I splurged. I hated to spend the money but ...Ice Cream Sandwich. Thats all I got to say about that.
dverespey said:
Thinking about getting it, but I'm on the fence based on the various reviews.
By the time my thinking is done the next great phone will be announced and then what?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Then you pick up the Gnex for cheap and be happy with nice specd phone. Now a days its too hard keeping up with phones.
Sent from my DROID X2 using XDA App
Exactly. Trying to keep up with these new phones is like trying to keep up with video games or computers. As soon as you buy the top model, within a month there's a new hotness. I figure by the time my upgrade is available at the end of March there will be another 5-6 new Verizon phones, and so maybe the Nexus, Razr or Rezound upgrade prices will have dropped more by then.
snortman said:
Exactly. Trying to keep up with these new phones is like trying to keep up with video games or computers. As soon as you buy the top model, within a month there's a new hotness. I figure by the time my upgrade is available at the end of March there will be another 5-6 new Verizon phones, and so maybe the Nexus, Razr or Rezound upgrade prices will have dropped more by then.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Right. That said, though, there will not be another Nexus device until the next version of Android (whatever "J" will be.) Here's hoping that Verizon continues to sell them in the future.
I upgraded to Rezound, love this phone!
Just looking for any ex infuse owners that went to the sgs2 to give me they're opinions.
Thanks
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
Previous infuse owner. Get the sgs2. That is all.
Sent from my SGH-I777 using Tapatalk
TOA Duck said:
Previous infuse owner. Get the sgs2. That is all.
Sent from my SGH-I777 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
Sent from my AT&T cellular device.
TOA Duck said:
Previous infuse owner. Get the sgs2. That is all.
Sent from my SGH-I777 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This. Infuse GPS/Wifi has nothing on ours.
TOA Duck said:
Previous infuse owner. Get the sgs2. That is all.
Sent from my SGH-I777 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1
........
Thanks for the replys so far. I know every opinion is different. But the dev dman has both and says the infuse is faster ...
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
garbagecanman said:
Thanks for the replys so far. I know every opinion is different. But the dev dman has both and says the infuse is faster ...
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My experience with the Infuse in web browsers was very sluggish and choppy as well as home screens that use live wallpapers. I don't do much gaming on my android so can't say how that is. It's been some time so I'm not sure if this is accurate, but the battery life didn't seem nearly as good as my GS2 running Unnamed or SHOstock.
Edit: As I no longer have the phone (returned it within a month and went back to my 3gs to hold off until I got this) I cannot say if it still performs like this. I did root, flash, etc, so it wasn't just a stock experience.
tewan said:
My experience with the Infuse in web browsers was very sluggish and choppy as well as home screens that use live wallpapers. I don't do much gaming on my android so can't say how that is. It's been some time so I'm not sure if this is accurate, but the battery life didn't seem nearly as good as my GS2 running Unnamed or SHOstock.
Edit: As I no longer have the phone (returned it within a month and went back to my 3gs to hold off until I got this) I cannot say if it still performs like this. I did root, flash, etc, so it wasn't just a stock experience.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is your sgs2 oc or UV at all. What battery do u get. I'm 1.2 with custom rom and some uving and I get almost 2 days battery on good days otherwise a day easy.
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
garbagecanman said:
Thanks for the replys so far. I know every opinion is different. But the dev dman has both and says the infuse is faster ...
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I strongly disagree.
garbagecanman said:
Is your sgs2 oc or UV at all. What battery do u get. I'm 1.2 with custom rom and some uving and I get almost 2 days battery on good days otherwise a day easy.
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm running SHOstock with Entropy's 12/08 DD, stock battery, not sure about the clocks but I believe they're stock as well. Normally access to a charger is readily available, so I don't bother conserving it as much as some others do (I leave my screen on for 20 minutes before I notice it and turn it off). Because of this, I generally get a day and a half out of it on average.
I can easily go 2 days without a charge if need be, I'd just turn the screen timeout back on to around 2 minutes or so. A while back before tweaking I barely squeezed 2d8h out of it, but now I'd be comfortable going 3 days if I really had to.
Edit: I also keep my bluetooth on, GPS on, and wifi off, data connection stays on and I generally get 2 to 3 bars out here. I have two Google accounts syncing everything except for Picasa. I also use Llama that does cell tower polling (among other things) to automatically change profiles (primarily for volume changes).
There are lots of ex-Infuse owners here. In fact, quite a few developers here are ex-Infuse.
gtg465x was on the Infuse and came here, MikeyMike01 came here for a while but then sold off all of his newer devices and went with an old Focus, I'm here.
From a developer's point of view, the GSII blows the Infuse out of the water. From a users' point of view, the difference isn't as obvious, other than that we have proper Gingerbread and the Infuse is still stuck with half-baked derivatives of the Rogers release. (AT&T leaks have improved things somewhat - but still stuff like MHL support is missing.)
Oh yeah - GPS on the GSII is a MASSIVE improvement compared to Infuse.
Given a choice between Infuse and GS2 both with contract subsidy - GS2 is a no-brainer. If it's a question of upgrading by paying full off-contract price - not so sure if it's worth it at this point. Better to wait for something else (International GS3 maybe?) or get a GNex.
Entropy512 said:
There are lots of ex-Infuse owners here. In fact, quite a few developers here are ex-Infuse.
gtg465x was on the Infuse and came here, MikeyMike01 came here for a while but then sold off all of his newer devices and went with an old Focus, I'm here.
From a developer's point of view, the GSII blows the Infuse out of the water. From a users' point of view, the difference isn't as obvious, other than that we have proper Gingerbread and the Infuse is still stuck with half-baked derivatives of the Rogers release. (AT&T leaks have improved things somewhat - but still stuff like MHL support is missing.)
Oh yeah - GPS on the GSII is a MASSIVE improvement compared to Infuse.
Given a choice between Infuse and GS2 both with contract subsidy - GS2 is a no-brainer. If it's a question of upgrading by paying full off-contract price - not so sure if it's worth it at this point. Better to wait for something else (International GS3 maybe?) or get a GNex.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thx entropy I know alot of u ex infuse devs are over here now. Alot to think about. My infuse has good bat life. GPS locks kinda slow but is fine for me when connected. And speed wise my single core is just as snappy as dual I would bet. But that's just my opinion as a user and I value your input as a dev.
Thanks
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
Had the infuse for two Weeks. Made a ROM and wasn't happy with performance of device... Also had Atrix. Lg thrill 3d. brought infuse back and spent the extra 100 got gs2. Gs2 is better than all my phones for developing and use.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I777 using xda premium
Screen was bigger however quality is better on the SGS2. SGS2 is way faster, GPS is also a lot better (locks faster).
Camera I think is also better.
There is no question SGS2 is THE PHONE
Guti1977 said:
Screen was bigger however quality is better on the SGS2. SGS2 is way faster, GPS is also a lot better (locks faster).
Camera I think is also better.
There is no question SGS2 is THE PHONE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Only difference is sgs2 cam does 1080p who hoo and they are identical screens no difference in quality? And I have a dslr for pics so camera on a phone doesn't mean anything really. For still or video. Its a phone.
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
For me, even if not for the improvements in development and ability to leverage the I9100 community for development - the GPS was a MAJOR factor in deciding to keep the device and ditch the Infuse. (I was on the fence and was considering returning it after a month since it was such an expenditure.)
The Infuse GPS was OK, but not good enough for me to trust it - I would NEVER have relied on it for navigation in any tough environment such as a city or even an area with good signal but densely packed roads. The I777's GPS is good enough to replace all of my standalone GPS units except for the ones I use while hiking. (In fact, my parents now have my old trusty "Dealextreme Pirate Special" GPS.)
Entropy512 said:
There are lots of ex-Infuse owners here. In fact, quite a few developers here are ex-Infuse.
gtg465x was on the Infuse and came here, MikeyMike01 came here for a while but then sold off all of his newer devices and went with an old Focus, I'm here.
From a developer's point of view, the GSII blows the Infuse out of the water. From a users' point of view, the difference isn't as obvious, other than that we have proper Gingerbread and the Infuse is still stuck with half-baked derivatives of the Rogers release. (AT&T leaks have improved things somewhat - but still stuff like MHL support is missing.)
Oh yeah - GPS on the GSII is a MASSIVE improvement compared to Infuse.
Given a choice between Infuse and GS2 both with contract subsidy - GS2 is a no-brainer. If it's a question of upgrading by paying full off-contract price - not so sure if it's worth it at this point. Better to wait for something else (International GS3 maybe?) or get a GNex.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Another good point
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
Here is my take on the S2 vs Infuse
http://www.wix.com/thephoneguyusa/att-gs2/apps/blog/infuse-4g-vs-galaxy-s2-i-777
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I777 using xda premium
thephoneguyusa said:
Here is my take on the S2 vs Infuse
http://www.wix.com/thephoneguyusa/att-gs2/apps/blog/infuse-4g-vs-galaxy-s2-i-777
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I777 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice write up. Decided for the sgs2 for my gf. Trading her iPhone 4(finally got her on the android wagon) . Kinda sad her first android is on paper a Beter phone than mine but I know my infuse will still hold it's own. I just wanted her to have something that's gonna have more value in the end like her iPhone which retains value. Unlike the infuse which value is only going down fast!
Thanks guys
Sent from my INFUSE powered by ZEUS
I have 2 of each, and besides the video playback being slightly smoother on the sgs2 I can't tell the difference. The infuse has CM7 as does the sgs2 which are both still KANGed. Maybe I can give a good comparison when they join the nightly...