I get to step 12 on the htcdev website and everything looks normal yet nothing on my phone changes (no screen asking me if i want to unlock the bootloader). I just got this refurb today and am desperately in need of titanium backup to restore some important info. Has anyone seen or heard of this problem? I would love to get suggestions on a possible solution.
THanks for your help!
hendav said:
I get to step 12 on the htcdev website and everything looks normal yet nothing on my phone changes (no screen asking me if i want to unlock the bootloader). I just got this refurb today and am desperately in need of titanium backup to restore some important info. Has anyone seen or heard of this problem? I would love to get suggestions on a possible solution.
THanks for your help!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Short Answer: off the top of my head, is the device updated to the latest hboot version? Probably will need the latest hboot version to complete the htc unlock process.
Long Answer: I don't have the HTC steps for their specific unlock method memorized. In order to help you, I logged into their web site, created an account and went as far through the steps as possible without completing their method as I'm already unlocked through the revolutionary method.
Step 10 is the step where the hash code from the device is submitted to HTC. I'm not able to see any step beyond Step 10.
The more information you're able to share, the wider group of individuals you'll allow to provide solutions. If you're able to share with us the specifics of Step 11 and Step 12, we might be able to provide more detailed help.
Keep us updated! Hope that helps!
Im having the same issue unlocking my white evo 3d. came with the lastest firmware out of the box and now step 12 says successful and nothing happens on the phone, very frustrating ive tried getting new unlock bins and nothing im running windows 7 and am very familar with rooting other devices. Any advice would be wonderful
Fixed this stupid issue today myself:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1239821
^First post; basically update the phone w/ an RUU and redo the whole unlocking process.
I wasted 4 hours of my life on this ****. grrr
joestuff said:
Im having the same issue unlocking my white evo 3d. came with the lastest firmware out of the box and now step 12 says successful and nothing happens on the phone, very frustrating ive tried getting new unlock bins and nothing im running windows 7 and am very familar with rooting other devices. Any advice would be wonderful
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your white EVO came with 2.3.4 out of the box? Mine didn't. Shut down the phone, remove battery, then boot into bootloader by holding volume down and power. Once in bootloader tell me the bootloader version. If it is 1.40 like mine was you can use revolutionary. You guys are probably stuck at that step because you don't have the 1.50 hboot and probably have a lower hboot. If it is lower than 1.50 do the revolutionary method.
Sent from Dorian's EVO 3D
I just wanted to chime in and say for anyone having the issue of the HTC Dev root method not working for them on steps 12 or 13:
flash error due to too many links
flash failing
flash hanging on sending Unlock_code.bin
flash appearing to send successfully, but still no disclaimer screen appearing
All of these problems were solved for me after by updating my phone to 2.08.651.3 via HTC software update in the Android OS.
Thanks to dastin1015 and lchupacabras for the suggestion.
I just got a new 3d yesterday, it came with 2.08.651.2 and I got hung up on step 12 as mentioned, it looked like it flashed but I got no unlock screen on the phone. I updated my phone to .3 as mentioned by bleaktrotter and I'm having the same problem...currently downloading the .2 RUU....?
bradbarton said:
I just got a new 3d yesterday, it came with 2.08.651.2 and I got hung up on step 12 as mentioned, it looked like it flashed but I got no unlock screen on the phone. I updated my phone to .3 as mentioned by bleaktrotter and I'm having the same problem...currently downloading the .2 RUU....?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did u check your hboot version? If u have 1.30 or 1.40 its been suggested to run the "revolutionary" method to get s-off.
Sent from my "Up all night, sleep all day" Evo3D
hboot is 1.50... i did the RUU to .2 and re did the process and just got the unlock screen...hmm
Here's some additional references:
mpgrimm2 said:
(XDA) TwoLazyG's [GUIDE] Unroot your HTC unlocked EVO 3d (Hboot 1.50 & Stock RUU's)
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1388501
(XDA) jdeoxys's [How to] Restore evo 3d to latest stock RUU on hboot 1.5
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1337379
Copy of Original HTC Unlocking Instructions form HTCdev.com (plus some extra notes) http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1437684
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Got my issue with this solved:
Stock Hboot1.50 HTC Unlock/ RUU 651.3 flash problems http://forum.sdx-developers.com/?topic=18852.msg236519#msg236519
So you guys are saying fully update my phone, and then use the htc unlock? Firmware, software, everything?
Nsandhu23 said:
So you guys are saying fully update my phone, and then use the htc unlock? Firmware, software, everything?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope. You need to I.D. your phones Hboot version first.
- Hboot 1.30 or 1.40 : use the revolutionary.io Full S-Off Method (Official RUU updates will kill the exploit).
- Hboot 1.50 : Your stuck using the HTCdev.com unlock method (S-On, Unlocked bootloader, mostly rooted). I used Zedomax's Guide from HtcEvoHacks.com but had some issues that weren't due to Max's guide and had to run the RUU (Rom Update Utility).
My issues: Stock Hboot1.50 HTC Unlock/ RUU 651.3 flash problems http://forum.sdx-developers.com/?topic=18852.msg236519#msg236519
Here's some links I'm gathering:
Evo3d Useful Thread Links: 01-11-12 http://forum.sdx-developers.com/?topic=18827.0
mpgrimm2 said:
Nope. You need to I.D. your phones Hboot version first.
- Hboot 1.30 or 1.40 : use the revolutionary.io Full S-Off Method (Official RUU updates will kill the exploit).
- Hboot 1.50 : Your stuck using the HTCdev.com unlock method (S-On, Unlocked bootloader, mostly rooted). I used Zedomax's Guide from HtcEvoHacks.com but had some issues that weren't due to Max's guide and had to run the RUU (Rom Update Utility).
My issues: Stock Hboot1.50 HTC Unlock/ RUU 651.3 flash problems http://forum.sdx-developers.com/?topic=18852.msg236519#msg236519
Here's some links I'm gathering:
Evo3d Useful Thread Links: 01-11-12 http://forum.sdx-developers.com/?topic=18827.0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay thanks I'll check which hboot I have.
i hav same issue with my GSM version , anyone can fix that , it stuck on step 12
i'll found how to fix this problem and feedback as fast as i can
Ok after 5 hours of trying to unlock my bootloader, all you have to do is install the 2.17 RUU.exe and then go into fastboot and unlock using the htc method.
phonghoangka said:
i hav same issue with my GSM version , anyone can fix that , it stuck on step 12
i'll found how to fix this problem and feedback as fast as i can
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also I have same issue with GSM version http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=22947122#post22947122
If you find the solution post it please.
Related
So I've been following the progress of the Evo 3D for a bit, decided ok I'll get one, and now am at a loss. I've tried every method posted on this site to try and unlock my phone, the TWRP method, Revolution, HTCDEV method, all of them, and none of them are working for me. With the HTC DEV method, I flash the unlock code.bin and there it stops. Tried running the RUU and I get errors, Revolution doesn't even support my hboot version and TWRP is also for older hboot versions. The only one I haven't tried is a method listed in the Express rom thread, there is supposedly a file called reboot3d.zip but the file isn't there anymore for me to try. I'm at my wits end. All I want is to flash a new rom and recovery, unlock my wifi tether and remove some bloatware, why is this so difficult? Has anyone had any success with an unlockable phone by any means? Please, any help would be appreciated.
Fltblkvic
fltblkvic said:
So I've been following the progress of the Evo 3D for a bit, decided ok I'll get one, and now am at a loss. I've tried every method posted on this site to try and unlock my phone, the TWRP method, Revolution, HTCDEV method, all of them, and none of them are working for me. With the HTC DEV method, I flash the unlock code.bin and there it stops. Tried running the RUU and I get errors, Revolution doesn't even support my hboot version and TWRP is also for older hboot versions. The only one I haven't tried is a method listed in the Express rom thread, there is supposedly a file called reboot3d.zip but the file isn't there anymore for me to try. I'm at my wits end. All I want is to flash a new rom and recovery, unlock my wifi tether and remove some bloatware, why is this so difficult? Has anyone had any success with an unlockable phone by any means? Please, any help would be appreciated.
Fltblkvic
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the htc device method should work are you sure youre typing in the command this way
fastboot flash unlocktoken Unlock_code.bin
and are you using linux mac or windows as your computer operating system to do this
I assume u are getting stuck at step 13 with Hboot 1.50 unlocking. Htcdev method is the only method.
What is ur current Sw version. 2.08.651.3, 2.17.651.5, etc?
You need to run the matching full Sw Ruu or a more current one (exe or zip version), then the code will work. The Guide/flashing notes in my signature may help u.
Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk
mpgrimm2 said:
I assume u are getting stuck at step 13 with Hboot 1.50 unlocking. Htcdev method is the only method.
What is ur current Sw version. 2.08.651.3, 2.17.651.5, etc?
You need to run the matching full Sw Ruu or a more current one (exe or zip version), then the code will work. The Guide/flashing notes in my signature may help u.
Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
A few of these pop up everyday huh?
Hi All
Hoping someone has the good grace to help me out here.
My Indian 3G variant Flyer was updated OTA to Honeycomb which unfortunately resulted my tablet basically locking at the white HTC logo screen.
I've followed a number of tutorials here with no luck trying to get it back to GB.
Tablet Info:
Locked and S-On
Hboot - 1.11.0003
Microp-0950
Radio-3809.07.004.06_m
eMMC-Boot
The issue I am running into in when I run the GB RUU for my tablet.
I get the Error [140]: Bootloader Version Error.
Would appreciate some help or where to from here please.
Was your flyer rooted or anything prior to attempting the update?
Flyer
Unsure unfortunately, I bought second hand and was running stock GB, but it did have the Revolutionary Hboot.
your hboot now says s on but you were s off prior? That does not make sense to me
Flyer
Yes that how it stands at the moment, was on Stock GB then updated to OTA HC.
Nothing but the white HTC screen after that.
Followed Globatrons HC downgrade tutorial and now just get stuck at the RUU install procedure with the Error [140] Bootloader Version Error.
Appreciate the replies mcord.
Couple of things
Sure you have correct ruu
Which downgrade procedure
What steps in the downgrade procedure did you accomplish
Oh man, you are testing me, I've looked at multiple threads concerning downgrading. I'm sure I followed this How to return to S-On after revolutionary first and foremost.
And got through to the RUU install, then that's when I get the error.
Im pretty sure that my RUU (RUU_Flyer_hTC_Asia_India_2.27.720.1_Radio_20.3504.30.089BU_3809.07.04.06_M_release_205504_Signed) is the correct one but I'll check my cid again to make sure.
I am nottesting you just trying to figure how screwed you are
Ok so you were s off when you tried OTA, first mistake
After it failed you attempted to return s on, second mistake
Sounds like you succeeded in pushing s on hboot through recovery but now your ruu won't run because you show a hc system that is newer than the ruu you are trying to run
I think
I think you want to try to gain soff using revolutionary first
No problem, just a figure of speech .
Yeah, like I said bought second hand so was unsure of the unlocked/locked state. But after going through these issues, Im learning to become very comfortable with Fastboot and the guides here.
Ok, so how do I gain soff with revolutionary without booting into Android and no adb?
Again, I appreciate the help mcord.
Not sure this works but try this
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1194709
If not maybe htc dev unlock
I am concerned that you will not have USB debug enabled and that could be a problem
Do you know if a ruu exist for your device for hc
Yeah I've looked at that, the issue is 'Note: The device should be fully booted to android now, do not go to the bootloader or fastboot.'
I'll have a look at the HTC Dev Unlock but unsure if they even do it for the Indian Flyer.
Was thinking the same thing in that I may have to wait for an HC RUU to become available, which I do not think has happened yet.
We have to get you recovery
I'm all eyes and ears mate.
No s off no htc dev unlock I think I am out of ideas outside of maybe a gold card of another version of hc but I am no help in making one
Hey no worries, appreciate you jumping in to help out.
I think I am going to have a similar problem my flyer wifi model os due back Friday from repair I had to restock it all cause screen was playing up.Well htc will upgrade it to HC as standard so what would my option be?
Does anyone know if there is an Asia/India Honeycomb RUU available?
LallyNZ said:
Yeah I've looked at that, the issue is 'Note: The device should be fully booted to android now, do not go to the bootloader or fastboot.'
I'll have a look at the HTC Dev Unlock but unsure if they even do it for the Indian Flyer.
Was thinking the same thing in that I may have to wait for an HC RUU to become available, which I do not think has happened yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, HTC dev unlock does work for India Flyer, but nothing to do with India, just chose Flyer WWE
Sent from my HTC Flyer P510e using XDA Premium HD app
Thanks bud, a long shot but I'll ask anyway, will the WWE RUU also work on the Asia/India Flyer?
ok, I've managed to unlock via HTC Unlock Bootloader.
Device Info now is:
Unlocked
S-On
HBoot 1.11.0003
Where to from here team?
So i was having the ghost touch issues on my phone for the past 2 weeks and thought maybe just to take it into sprint. So i had to unroot, RUU, etc and it was having the same issues. Took it into sprint and they said they ran diagnostics on it and nothing was wrong but when i got home it was doing the same thing. But now im updated on 2.89 and HBoot 1.58 and want to know how to root, s-on or s-off doesnt matter, and also downgrade so i can got back to aosp ROMs or Mazda's and also sense ROMs. So if anyone can help it wuld be greatly appreciated. P.S Yes i've searched this topic and it just came up with a lot of different pages and methods so telling me to search before asking isnt necessary.
NexusS4gFreak said:
So i was having the ghost touch issues on my phone for the past 2 weeks and thought maybe just to take it into sprint. So i had to unroot, RUU, etc and it was having the same issues. Took it into sprint and they said they ran diagnostics on it and nothing was wrong but when i got home it was doing the same thing. But now im updated on 2.89 and HBoot 1.58 and want to know how to root, s-on or s-off doesnt matter, and also downgrade so i can got back to aosp ROMs or Mazda's and also sense ROMs. So if anyone can help it wuld be greatly appreciated. P.S Yes i've searched this topic and it just came up with a lot of different pages and methods so telling me to search before asking isnt necessary.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can try my guide which was designed to get you from any build with S-ON to a rooted, S-OFF Sprint ICS configuration as easily as possible. You can probably skip the first step, which is flashing the 2.89.651.2 RUU.exe, since it sounds like they did that already when they worked on your phone.
If they did the OTA instead you could have problems with the HTC unlock, so if that happens just go back and flash the RUU.exe.
Good luck!
ramjet73
ramjet73 said:
You can try my guide which was designed to get you from any build with S-ON to a rooted, S-OFF Sprint ICS configuration as easily as possible. You can probably skip the first step, which is flashing the 2.89.651.2 RUU.exe, since it sounds like they did that already when they worked on your phone.
If they did the OTA instead you could have problems with the HTC unlock, so if that happens just go back and flash the RUU.exe.
Good luck!
ramjet73
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks ramjet73, definitely wanna try but is the wire trick actually safe to do?
NexusS4gFreak said:
Thanks ramjet73, definitely wanna try but is the wire trick actually safe to do?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. I've never heard of phone that was damaged by it. The SD card may get corrupted but that can always be reformatted.
ramjet73
ramjet73 said:
Yes. I've never heard of phone that was damaged by it. The SD card may get corrupted but that can always be reformatted.
ramjet73
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay ill try, again thanks for your help and the guide ramjet73!
Unable to downgrade HBOOT 1.53.0007 to 1.49.0007
Hi, yesterday I decided to "upgrade" my sister's HTC EVO3D GSM to make unlock, root...also S-OFF if needed to flash any ROM, but it was the first time i was flashing EVO3D so it was whole day I sit at the computer watchin&reading tutorials and this forum before I could do anything...finally i partially succed, I made unlock by HTCdev method, flashed recovery via fastboot...flashed ROM from recovery, but I wanted to install CM9 ROM by agrabren and surely it wasnt working, because the phone is no HBOOT 1.53.0007...
So for the instance, the phone:
Is HTC EVO3D GSM
was on stock ICS 4.0.3 OTA rom
HBOOT 1.53.0007 S-ON
UNLOCKED S-ON by htcdev method
followed this thread to root http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?p=28106291 and flash ROM
Then it's working on ICS NonSense® 4.0
but i want to try CM9/10/AOKP ROMs so i realized i need to downgrade HBOOT to 1.49.0007 and get revolutionary S-OFF so i tried to follow this http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1471246
The first method copying mmcblk0p31.img to sdcard and here im stuck....I dont understand why, but the command "adb shell dd....." copies mmcblk0p31 file of 16kB size and total empty content, so I cant change any version to 1.20.720.1 and cant downgrade....
So how to solve this problem? Is it cause that first I need to get hboot 1.53 S-OFF?
Thanks for the reply...
//Im sorry my post is also located here http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1833367 where is I think better place for it and I didnt find how to delete it from here...
I bought 3d evo a year ago and I tempered with it at first to root. I could not root it but it was s-off. Anyways , this whole time I thought I was getting updates and such because I was receiving update notifications and downloading them, and phone was restarting afterwards , so I thought everything was ok. Then, recently I checked software versions in settings and I was shocked. My phone was exactly the same as the first day. Then I tried to do a hard factory reset from settings. It did not work. Tried again from the bootloader menu, it did not reset again. There was a method by relocking it at first and using RUU's to make it back to original state. I relocked it but RUU file did not work , i think it was incompatible and gave an error.
Here are the version numbers in settings:
Android version - 2.3.4
HTC Sense - 3.0
Software - 1.20.468.6
This is the bootloader screen:
*****Relocked*****
****Security Warning*****
S- On
Hboot 1.49.0018 Emm-boot Oct 3-2011
I have a phone which can not revert to original state and can not apply any updates. Hboot version is an issue I always see guides about 1.50.
Do I have to start over and S-off first ? I have tried everything, putting pc86img.zip file to sd card , it reads during bootloader but does not ask to update. I tried sprint ruu file from windows but it did not work either. Need directions because I am really pissed off. Please help. Thanks.
bro i'm pretty sure that thats a gsm phone. please dont try to flash any cdma(sprint) stuff on it.
Normally I would have directed you to a thread containing gsm RUU's but apparently the new hosting site is down. Keep checking here though
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2094402
A word of warning: If you update using the RUU you will have the new hboot 1.53 and it is only possible to achieve s-off on that hboot with the wire trick. Whereas your current hboot can make use of flashmaniac's tool to downgrade and s-offf using revolutionary
EM|NEM said:
bro i'm pretty sure that thats a gsm phone. please dont try to flash any cdma(sprint) stuff on it.
Normally I would have directed you to a thread containing gsm RUU's but apparently the new hosting site is down. Keep checking here though
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2094402
A word of warning: If you update using the RUU you will have the new hboot 1.53 and it is only possible to achieve s-off on that hboot with the wire trick. Whereas your current hboot can make use of flashmaniac's tool to downgrade and s-offf using revolutionary
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks man, I looked around and found stock a rom suitable for my region.And it worked. Now I'm updating to android 4
Ok, so it July 15 2014. I've come to terms that this phone is old, but i recently picked one up for cheap in the hopes to replace my broken M7. unknowingly, my phone updated it's firmware to 3.17.651.5 and the Hboot is already at 2.09. I have dug through guides, upon guides in hopes of getting this damn thing S-off but i see Barely the Slightest mention of 3.17 anywhere. So as of today, does anyone know what my best option is for S-off? I am at a lost..I am close to just using an RUU i found that apparently is android 4.3 and Sense 5 and not bothering to s-off.
HunterKiotori said:
Ok, so it July 15 2014. I've come to terms that this phone is old, but i recently picked one up for cheap in the hopes to replace my broken M7. unknowingly, my phone updated it's firmware to 3.17.651.5 and the Hboot is already at 2.09. I have dug through guides, upon guides in hopes of getting this damn thing S-off but i see Barely the Slightest mention of 3.17 anywhere. So as of today, does anyone know what my best option is for S-off? I am at a lost..I am close to just using an RUU i found that apparently is android 4.3 and Sense 5 and not bothering to s-off.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try rumrunner or firewater. If neither work, relock your bootloader, run the ruu then use firewater again.
Sent from my EVO using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
My Hboot guide specifically mentions both Rumrunner & Firewater for Hboot 2.09/software version 3.17 One of those exploits should work just fine:thumbup:
Sent from my HTC M8
Here's what I did just 2 days ago to successfully get the EVO 4G LTE 3.17.651.5 bootloader unlocked (rooted), S-Off, and firmware upgraded.
1) Used HTCDev.com to unlock the bootloader.
2) Installed TWRP 2.7.0.1b Recovery and SuperSU
2) Used Rumrunner to gain S-Off (make sure you have SuperSU installed and grant permission to Rumrunner as it asks or it will fail. This can be a little tricky and was a frustrating problem until I came across this thread to get S-Off --> http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=49567833&postcount=73
This helped also. I read every page. --> http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=50112361&postcount=1
Good Luck!
The recovery ending with the letter B is for the new partition layout. If they're on the old layout they can't use that version of TWRP. I know you updated to the new layout so that version is correct for you.
Sent from my HTC M8
Magnum_Enforcer said:
The recovery ending with the letter B is for the new partition layout. If they're on the old layout they can't use that version of TWRP. I know you updated to the new layout so that version is correct for you.
Sent from my HTC M8
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks Magnum_Enforcer,
I actually loaded and used that version (2.7.0.1b) of TWRP just after I picked up the phone from Sprint last week and it worked fine on the old partition layout. After you helped me get the RUU flashed I reflashed it and seems to work just the same on the new partition scheme. I may be wrong (I've read so many pages on the forum lately) but I believe that 2.7.0.1b was created/modified by Captain_Throwback to work with the new memory partitioning while keeping compatibility with old memory partitions.
airdog99 said:
Here's what I did just 2 days ago to successfully get the EVO 4G LTE 3.17.651.5 bootloader unlocked (rooted), S-Off, and firmware upgraded.
1) Used HTCDev.com to unlock the bootloader.
2) Installed TWRP 2.7.0.1b Recovery and SuperSU
2) Used Rumrunner to gain S-Off (make sure you have SuperSU installed and grant permission to Rumrunner as it asks or it will fail. This can be a little tricky and was a frustrating problem until I came across this thread to get S-Off --> http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=49567833&postcount=73
This helped also. I read every page. --> http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=50112361&postcount=1
Good Luck!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So i tried this method and was unable to get root at all. one i tried to get root with TWRP my phone just went into boot loops. I'm gping to try the sense 5 ruu. I can't use any other one
OK, so i got the newest RUU and am now on the Sense 5 platform, i have used the Modded TWRP and achieved SU. from there i noticed that my Hboot is now 2.10. Knowing this, which is the best option for S-off or am i stuck?
Hboot: 2.10
Software: 4.13.651.4
Recovery: TWRP 2.7.1.0b
Super user: Yes
Bootloader HTC Dev Unlocked
Try Rumrunner or Firewater. Both are known to work on Hboot 2.10. Links to both exploits can be found in the top link in my sig.
Sent from my HTC M8
I've rumrunner and it fave a fatal message at the end of the process and to download latest package, which I was using. I'll try the other one next
Alright, I am happy to report that firewater has worked for me. thank you very much guys for the support. I hope to try out some new roms
HunterKiotori said:
I've rumrunner and it fave a fatal message at the end of the process and to download latest package, which I was using. I'll try the other one next
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I found this post and was finally able to achieve S-Off using Rumrunner with the instructions provided by Strat911 (post #803) http://androidforums.com/evo-4g-lte...ng-dummies-complete-guide-17.html#post6554970
I was getting the same error as Strat911 (scroll up in the thread to post #801) until he figured it out. I found that opening SuperSU and going to Settings and changing Default access from Prompt to Grant fixed the problem as Rumrunner was being denied superuser permission during the process. Just read the thread I linked (start at post #801) and if that's the issue you are having change that setting in SuperSU and you should get S-Off.
Good Luck!
EDIT: Looks like you got it fixed with Firewater while I was typing up my reply. Congrats on getting S-OFF !!!