Related
Got the EVO 3D yesterday, and the phone being naked is irking my life!!!
Is the Defender too bulky?
I never had a screen protector on my EVO 4G, you think I should have one on the EVO 3D?
The Commuter seems like a smaller, sleeker fit. But I have read of some people saying it isnt tight on the phone from the top or something.
What do you guys recommend?
Or should I not even go with Otterbox?
issafram said:
Got the EVO 3D yesterday, and the phone being naked is irking my life!!!
Is the Defender too bulky?
I never had a screen protector on my EVO 4G, you think I should have one on the EVO 3D?
The Commuter seems like a smaller, sleeker fit. But I have read of some people saying it isnt tight on the phone from the top or something.
What do you guys recommend?
Or should I not even go with Otterbox?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All of this really depends on what you do during your daily routine, what your job is etc. Personally for me the Defender was a bit bulky and it also made it hard to hit the side keys on the keyboard when texting.
A screen protector is your choice. The Evo 3D DOES NOT have Gorilla Glass like some have stated so just do as you see fit. The commuter comes with a screen protector that is actually half decent.
Yes, the Commuter is a little loose at the top but Otterbox will send you a replacement at no charge( the silicone part). Hopefully enough people contact them so they actually remanufacture the case.
All in all, if you work in a place where your likely to drop your phone or you don't really baby your phone like some get the Defender. If you are always careful with your phone I would say just go with the defender.
I have the defender and I agree, the side buttons are hard to hit while it's in portrait. I looked at the commuter, I had the defender and commuter for my OG EVO and the commuter was my primary case. The problem I have with the commuter for the 3D is the way they did the camera pod. There is no protection for the cameras, I have an issue with that. I don't own the commuter for the 3D and all I've seen is the pictures so it might not be as bad as I think. Just something to think about.
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
ausch30 said:
I have the defender and I agree, the side buttons are hard to hit while it's in portrait. I looked at the commuter, I had the defender and commuter for my OG EVO and the commuter was my primary case. The problem I have with the commuter for the 3D is the way they did the camera pod. There is no protection for the cameras, I have an issue with that. I don't own the commuter for the 3D and all I've seen is the pictures so it might not be as bad as I think. Just something to think about.
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The rubber and hard shell of the Commuter extends out past the camera lens, so there is that bit of protection. It does not cover the lens but if you lay your phone down on a table there is no way you can scratch them.
I agree with the previous posts, it depends on what you need the case for. If you work in a high risk environment for your phone, I'd go with Defender (I'm talking construction, workshops, garage, other manual labor). If you just want some added day to day protection, the Commuter will suit you fine. I have this case and it still keeps the phone slim while protecting every aspect of the case. I have read that this case does not protect as well against drops as the Defender, so if you are clumsy maybe the Defender is a better choice.
As for the looseness of the case, there is a slight gap near the top. Like Winning said, we are all complaining to Otterbox so hopefully they will do a revised model soon once they get enough complaints. Hope this helps.
Check out other threads on the commuter. I bought it and what people are saying is true, there is a noticeable gap at the top, almost like the case was made a little big. You can also see the gap through the headphone jack. I returned it and kept my previous case, the platinum series from BestBuy. I got the blue one. I LOVE this case. It feels good in the hand, and more importantly it fits snug on the phone. I like that it fits snug because there is way less chance of dirt, dust, and debris to make its way in between the case and the phone.
Otterbox Commuter was awesome on my original EVO, however, so I do have experience with Otterbox cases.
Only thing I don't like about defender is the large sides. Makes selecting pain in arse. Other than that it's light and doesn't pull my gym shorts down.
I wanted good protection so I picked up the defender. A thing about that I really like is that it covers up the camera and the lenses. It really isn't that bulky imo and it feels great in the hand.
#Winning# said:
Yes, the Commuter is a little loose at the top but Otterbox will send you a replacement at no charge( the silicone part). Hopefully enough people contact them so they actually remanufacture the case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wait what? Just go through their contact us page? I would love a new one. the gap is driving me nuts.
Go Defender!
Go Defender, reguardless of what people say, Size does matter..... when it comes to protecting your phone
I have the outter defender because its great and I also get drunk and tend to drop my phone a lot.
Sent from my Ebt Funded Htc Evo 3d
aFoodStampBaby said:
I have the outter defender because its great and I also get drunk and tend to drop my phone a lot.
Sent from my Ebt Funded Htc Evo 3d
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
HA! AWESOME!!!! Nothing is ever as funny as brutal honesty I love it!
Impact.
Impact is the best case Otter makes, and its also the cheapest.
Defender is like carrying 4 cell phones instead of 1.
Commuter is OK, but has no shock absorption or grip.
Impact has shock absorption and grip and looks nice.
I have the defender like others the sides of the screen are a little tough to reach and I wish it was water proof but as far as total phone protection and protection from dust and dirt it's the way to go. I looked at the commuter and the sprint store even let me try it on my phone I did like how slim it was but that was it. But as others have said it's all in personal preference and life style I can't afford to have anything but the best protection because of my job as a firefighter just wish it came waterproof to.
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
reply from htc to me re: cases
so i emailed htc about the use of cases with their phones, any physical testing before release, etc., specifically with the evo 3d. here's the reply:
Dear Dave,
I'll be glad to help you out with this information. We certainly do test our phones in a number of manners before they are released, including a number of tests that ensure the durability of the phone. As for recommendation about using cases or not, I don't think we have a stance one way or the other. The phones stand up just fine on their own, but extra protection is always a good thing if you don't mind the bulk. We think of it as more of a personal choice that each person can make. From all reports that I've heard from customers and from my experience with the EVO 3D, it just feels right in the hand without a case; just well balanced and designed. I've also never been much of a case person myself as I just like the way phones feel naturally (at least the ones I buy), so it could be a matter of my opinion. If you feel like you might need a case for your usage of the phone, by all means go ahead and get one; when I do use cases I use Otterbox cases and I'm pretty sure they've already got them available for the EVO 3D. Again, just my opinion, and those do add plenty of bulk, but they're good cases. There are plenty of cases out there, so if you think you need one I'm sure you'll be able to find something you like. However, I think you can rest assured that your device will be safe without one as well.
To send a reply to this message or let me know I have successfully answered your question log in to our ContactUs site using your email address and your ticket number (greyed out).
Sincerely,
Philip
HTC
Want to see what others are saying? Have a question to ask other HTC fans?
Become a fan of HTC facebook.com/htc
Follow us on Twitter twitter.com/htc
Subscribe to our YouTube Channel youtube.com/htc
Explore our development resources developer.htc.com
We are unable to receive replies to this email account. Please visit us at htc.com if you have any questions or need further assistance.
sweet huh? nice honest response. this company could teach lessons on how to get right to it's customers lately
I had the defender... Loved it, got used to the heftiness. BUT since the front edges were so proud and at a steep angle, I couldn't type properly. All the peripheral letters (p l q a # etc) were difficult to press. I had to retype so many times that I returned the case.
Switched to Commuter and seems fine, albeit about half the heft that I liked. Seems to provide decent protection at a low profile. Otterbox is sending me a new Commuter BC I called and said the rubber seems a bit too large. IDK if it is or if I believed it from overanalyzing it from reading forums.
Anyway, I might report back after I chuck this phone against a wall to see how the Commuter really does. Haha
...adjusting to life without the trackball
Ok here's an FYI for all of us. When i was in the Sprint store getting my 3vo and debating what case I wanted and the rep was showing me the commuter I said that after a little while it stretches out and won't fit right ,she told me to bring it back and exchange it , its got a waranty . It might be a pain having to take it back but I don't mind I'm getting a new case. So just a heads up guys.
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
I got the impact at radio shack for 10 dollars. Does what it needs to. The only thing I don't like about silicone cases is the dust that attracts to them easily.
I have both. Like others have said, the commuter seems to fit a bit loose on top of the screen. Its also weird when I grab it as the rubber moves around too much for my liking.
Defender on the other hand, fits perfect. I agree that the area around the screen is a bit high buy I've gotten used to it and have no problem typing. I need a holster setup so that's another plus for the defender. It's not bulky either in my opinion, considering all that's going into the case.
I also have the Seidio Surface with holster. It's ok but offers little protection.
In my opinion, the defender offers the most value for the price. It's also the best looking case in my opinion. Its a very good case all the way around.
My commuter fits awesome better than the two I had for the OG evo
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
I'm quite happy with the Commuter as an interim case.
It has good shock protection and good grip and a thin profile.
It's a great case for me during weekdays in the pocket of my dress shirt.
I'll likely go with Seidio later since I like to use a holster on weekends with jeans or shorts. Not sure why Otterbox ignores that market, but they do .........
Ok, I finally got my Otterbox Defender today. First impression is that it isn't exactly the way I thought it would be. I am not sure exactly what I was expecting but I know it wasn't quite what I got.
Pro: plastic shell feels pretty solid around phone and I really like the way the solid clear protector covers the whole screen it makes me feel a lot less worried about messing up my phone. The silicon/rubber outer sleeve holds the two halves of the hard shell together and gives a good grip. There is no way for it to fall out of the holster.
Con: my biggest complaint would be the silicone/rubber outer sleeve feels a bit sloppy. I would have expected it to be tighter, more exactly form fitting. The outer sleeve also picks up every piece of lint that comes it's way and because it is a black case white pocket lint shows very well. It is very difficult/awkward to remove from the holster, that may get better over time as out gets worn in a bit.
Conclusion: pretty good case that should do it's job but over priced at this time, at $10 it would be a deal, at $15 it would still be a good value, at $20 it's something I would consider and at the $30 I paid after shipping and handling well I feel like I over paid but I don't feel like I was robbed. I will be keeping it.....for a while at least.
***EDIT***
Ok after playing with it, the fact that the soft outer case is not super tight is not as annoying as the lint sticking to the outside of it.
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
I have one and have to say the biggest issue is the bulk.
It pops into and out of the holster so simply it's disgusting....dunno why you had problems there ?
If you spend a few moments and make ABSOLUTELY CERTAIN that the soft rubber/silicone outer shell is on properly it is not loose in the slightest. It is in fact quite snug. It's a bit trying to get it on perfect, but it's time well spent..
My complaint about it is when you use the holster as a vertical stand and have the phone facing outwards with the charger cable plugged in...the little flap that covers the charge port is not quite in the correct spot (you'd have to try it and see it for yourself, very difficult to explain).
The holster snap/clasp thing is in the way of that formentioned flap.
Not a deal breaker....I will be keeping the otterpop.
editater>
BTW, it's a holster made to go on your belt or the waist of your trousers....why are you concerned with lint sticking to it when it should never see any lint if used in the fashion it's intended for ?
Well after a little time I figured out why it WAS loose and had went on WAY too easy.......you see I live in a desert.....and it's summer AND my case had gotten stuffed in my mail box for oh at least a few hours before I got home and went to put it on. Now after both it and I have cooled off and had a kick a$$ nap, it fits quite well. Since it's little baking in the desert episode it may never be as tight as it would have been but it is very snug over all and no longer has any gaps or bulges.
As for the holster.....maybe it is because I am left handed or maybe mine it's just extra tight in the holster, but it is a chore to get outso I put it in my pocket.I may try to work with the holster some but together with case and holster it's pretty dang big. I will use the holster on a limited basis more then likely.
***EDIT***
Since I don't really care for the holster I still feel I over paid, but since the soft cover fits better now I don't feel I over paid quite as much.
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
Personally speaking, I wouldn't use the Defender for day-to-day protection. There are many other options available which offer less bulk and less lint-grabbing.
The Defender is perfect for rough users such as construction workers, farmers, soldiers, truck drivers, etc. The Defender has protected my MoPho twice already while on duty. Both were scenarios where I feel a 'lesser' case may have allowed damage to the device.
$30 is nearly a third of the cost of replacement under insurance. It is a tad on the expensive side. However, I think this is the very best level of personal device protection short of encasing it in a brick of silicon gel.
Compared to the defender I had on my evo the photon defender is perfectly tight. I went straight to radio shack and bought the defender after I bought my photon at sprint 3 days ago and I've only taken it off once to install my new sd card yesterday. As far as it sitting in the holster just make sure you push the rubber in all around the mounting clips on the sides. If they stick up a little it won't secure correctly. I've used defender cases before so I knew what I was getting but I must say this one is very well built.
The only thing that I don't like about the defender cases is that the screen protector just seems to take away from the beauty of device screens. I had my evo in a defender case for a week. I took it out one day and once I saw the screen again I was floored to how much I was missing by having the defender plastic over it!
And boom goes the Shooter
I've had the defender for 3 weeks now and I love it but it isn't for everyone. If you want a somewhat rugged smartphone that can take a few drops there are plenty of cases for you to choose from. If you want a case that protect your phone from falling out of a speeding vehicle then you want the defender, I should know i accidentally left my phone on top of my vehicle when driving away one late night.
It is bulky but that is fine, I don't want a sleek phone that breaks. This thing is like a brick. If you are playing around with the software and usually bork your phone you may want an easier to remove case. I hate doing battery pulls because it takes too long to remove this case and you end up with too many parts in your hands. This case is my insurance policy. Its a great case for people who play hard with their phones. The commuter case is a great case too but you have to match the case to your lifestyle. For me, I wont buy a phone that doesn't have a defender case.
In my experience the phone does not move around inside this case. It stays locked tight in its plastic shell. The rubber can be stretched easily but it is form fitting to the plastic shell and has just enough play to make it comfortable to remove. You have to tuck the rubber in all around the phone, as well as on the sides and on the back near the kickstand. Failure to do so will cause it to shift around but if you properly put this case together it shouldn't move at all. If it does then you may want to call Otterbox.
Now the defender series comes with the adjustable holster. If you do not use a holster then you may want a commuter series case. This thing isn't too easy to get in and out of your pocket since the rubber does grip well to cotton pockets. I use the holster about half the time and keep this thing in my pocket the other half. I'm okay with this but if you wear really tight skinny jeans you'll probably hate this case. So if you don't use holsters or you wear skin tight pants then you should get something else.
The screen protector causes glare and degrades the visual quality of the screen. The camera lens also has a protector over it which I find does degrade the camera quality if it is not properly cleaned. I don't find this to be a deal breaker because I could easily remove that piece of protective plastic. If anything I wish it was removable and replaceable out of the box.
Its a great case that can take a ton of abuse and leave your phone looking brand new.
sub2k1 said:
This thing is a brick.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I cringe at your use of this term!
Car Dock & case.
Is the Defender series compatible with the Car dock? If not how easy is it to remove.
I never tested it on the car dock but I can guarantee you it does not work with the HD Dock. While it is not too difficult, you don't want to disassemble this case on the regular. Reassembly is a *****.
droidevo1 said:
Is the Defender series compatible with the Car dock? If not how easy is it to remove.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, I can tell you it's not compatible....I have the Commuter and it doesn't even work in the Car Dock.
I was hoping that by taking off the outer rubber shell of the defender series, that maybe the hard cover would still fit in the car dock. I'll let you know in a few weeks when everything finally arrives in the mail.
Yeah, let us know.....I even bought a cheapo $5 case (the thin plastic ones) just to try it.....nope!! Wouldn't work.
Yeah this case is still a lint magnet even without putting in my pocket and now I have some dust between protective screen and the actual screen.....of course some compressed air took care of it but I had to open it for that. I also worry a bit about heat while tethering. Not that it gets anywhere near as hot as my htc hero did (could fry an egg on it) but if it got warm enough to feel trough hard case AND the soft rubber it must have been pretty warm inside (does it get hotter doing wifi tether as opposed to usb & which uses more battery).
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
Does anyone know what the difference is between the $50 Defender (Revision A) and the first revision that other sites (other than otterbox.com) sell? The difference in the model # is the letter A at the end.
Can someone post pictures of this case on their phone? I have always bought otterbox defenders but im debating if i should buy another after a bad experience with the one for the Evo 4g.
Sent from my MB855 using Tapatalk
I don't think a picture will do it any justice. It is one of those things you are really going to want to see and touch in person to decide if you like it or not. I like mine, lint magnet and all because it makes me feel my Photon its safe and for that I am willing to live with the trade off of some lint and a little extra bulk. Of course every time I take off the case to clean it I remember just how sexy a naked Photon is and I consider slapping on an invisashield screen protector and going naked.
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
I just received my otter box defender in the mail today. I bought mine at amazon for $27 + $5 S&H. The case appears to be genuinely an otter box. The box it came in was damaged and opened, but the case itself is fine. My guess is that the amazon ones are cheaper because they are in damaged boxes.
As far as I'm concerned though I'll take the damaged packaging for the $20 savings.
Bought the Defender last month and was enamored by the fact that i can throw, kick, slam the phone anywhere and it wouldn't get damaged. The only problem was (and this was a big one) that the case is so f***ing huge for regular use! I got fed up of that and exchanged the case for the commuter. SOOO much better for everyday, common hazards.
IUH1991 said:
Bought the Defender last month and was enamored by the fact that i can throw, kick, slam the phone anywhere and it wouldn't get damaged. The only problem was (and this was a big one) that the case is so f***ing huge for regular use! I got fed up of that and exchanged the case for the commuter. SOOO much better for everyday, common hazards.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bugger, just ordered the Defender, does it really add so much bulk?
Sent from my MB855 using xda premium
Man this phone is so nice and sleek, I'm not sure if I want to put a case on it or not.
Love this phone compared to my evo 4g. Blows it out of the water. Decent battery life as well.
What are your thoughts on cases?
I had started a seidio active vs otterbox commuter thread but didn't get much love. Maybe people are using other cases I haven't thought of. All I am using is a leather pouch.
ideas, thoughts?
I'm using a Commuter that I modified slightly for the car dock. I always second-guess the expensive Otterbox cases but last week the Photon took a trip to the floor and nearly bounced back into my hand. That settled that one.
One from the mall. Black rubberized and i'm happy. I believe its cellairis or something like that
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
One thing I don't like so far is it is a little difficult to push power button. I find myself missing it from time to time. I think the otterbox would help with that but I'm not sure if I wanna give up the lightweight and sleek feel of it.
Yeah, sleek and Otterbox don't go together. I prefer caseless but I know it only takes one drop to all but stop my life. I'm finding myself waaaay too reliant on this little device.
Amazon had/has the Commuter for $22, which I think is worth it.
How much bulk does it add?
Kevets said:
Yeah, sleek and Otterbox don't go together. I prefer caseless but I know it only takes one drop to all but stop my life. I'm finding myself waaaay too reliant on this little device.
Amazon had/has the Commuter for $22, which I think is worth it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The commuter is roughly 5/8" thick by 2 3/4" wide by 5 1/4" tall.
The phone is roughly 1/2" by 2 5/8" by 5" respectively.
The case is actually a good hand-grip size.
Using the Seidio Active. So far I am liking it. Fits good and nice balance for me between function and protection.
Thanks for that.
Kevets said:
The commuter is roughly 5/8" thick by 2 3/4" wide by 5 1/4" tall.
The phone is roughly 1/2" by 2 5/8" by 5" respectively.
The case is actually a good hand-grip size.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've dropped my phone so many times with my Otter-box Commuter Case and stopped gasping after the third drop I'm clumsy but it's defiantly a great case!
Im using the otter box commuter case and its been great so far, I drop my phone alot and I know that the otter box works great, I dropped a friends evo 3d and the screen shattered,, no bueno especially when your trying to date her
---------- Post added at 12:20 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:20 AM ----------
Kevets said:
Yeah, sleek and Otterbox don't go together. I prefer caseless but I know it only takes one drop to all but stop my life. I'm finding myself waaaay too reliant on this little device.
Amazon had/has the Commuter for $22, which I think is worth it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got mine at the sprint store for 20
I first bought my wife this case for her Evo and liked it so much that I got one for my mopho! Its thin, feels like it part of the phone and yet it can take some drops.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B005F9ZQB4?is=300&qid=1318310572&sr=8-2&in=3
I currently have 2 otterbox cases. 1 defender series and 1 commuter series. Both have their uses. I mainly use the defender for work so I can easily clip my phone into the holster and not leave it laying around in a rush to go do something. It's also amazing for those unfortunate occasions where the phone leaves your hand and makes a 3 or 4 ft dive to the ground. Access to every button and port is also amazing with this case. power/wake button is very easy to press, no problems at all. same with volume rocker and camera buttons. I love the port covers on this case b/c they are extremely durable and long lasting. However, my favoite benefit of the defender case is how easily it can be removed... I know you're thinking "wtf, this guy is an idiot!" Well the reason I say that is b/c i actually sell cellphones for a living and offering otterbox cases is second nature. having installed and removed just about every case they make, many of the other defenders are difficult to remove with the little clips on the internal plastic part of the case which is snug on the phone. The photon defender is almost effortless if you like to trade out ur cases on occassion it is a major benefit
I use the commuter series when not at work b/c I don't typically liek to wear my phone on my hip if I have an available pocket... just my personal preference. Commuter is definetly much less bulk but I also don't like the way that it's designed as far as installing/removing from the phone. It's a bit of a pain. Also, unfortunatly the part of the case that makes it grip in your hand makes it difficult to insert/remove from a normal pocket.
I have decided that I'm going to try out one of the tpu cases from amazon.com for a non work alternative and we'll see how that goes.
Let me know if you wanna sell the commuter.
rickyhfc02 said:
I currently have 2 otterbox cases. 1 defender series and 1 commuter series. Both have their uses. I mainly use the defender for work so I can easily clip my phone into the holster and not leave it laying around in a rush to go do something. It's also amazing for those unfortunate occasions where the phone leaves your hand and makes a 3 or 4 ft dive to the ground. Access to every button and port is also amazing with this case. power/wake button is very easy to press, no problems at all. same with volume rocker and camera buttons. I love the port covers on this case b/c they are extremely durable and long lasting. However, my favoite benefit of the defender case is how easily it can be removed... I know you're thinking "wtf, this guy is an idiot!" Well the reason I say that is b/c i actually sell cellphones for a living and offering otterbox cases is second nature. having installed and removed just about every case they make, many of the other defenders are difficult to remove with the little clips on the internal plastic part of the case which is snug on the phone. The photon defender is almost effortless if you like to trade out ur cases on occassion it is a major benefit
I use the commuter series when not at work b/c I don't typically liek to wear my phone on my hip if I have an available pocket... just my personal preference. Commuter is definetly much less bulk but I also don't like the way that it's designed as far as installing/removing from the phone. It's a bit of a pain. Also, unfortunatly the part of the case that makes it grip in your hand makes it difficult to insert/remove from a normal pocket.
I have decided that I'm going to try out one of the tpu cases from amazon.com for a non work alternative and we'll see how that goes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
TPU! my sis is rockin one too and ive liked them. fit firm, slid easy into my pocket, good feel in the hand, and they are like 6-7 bucks
might have to step up and get me a TPU case, that thing is sexay!
has anyone found a carbon look case yet? i'd be much much more interested in form than function if one is found!
rickyhfc02 said:
I currently have 2 otterbox cases. 1 defender series and 1 commuter series. Both have their uses. I mainly use the defender for work so I can easily clip my phone into the holster and not leave it laying around in a rush to go do something. It's also amazing for those unfortunate occasions where the phone leaves your hand and makes a 3 or 4 ft dive to the ground. Access to every button and port is also amazing with this case. power/wake button is very easy to press, no problems at all. same with volume rocker and camera buttons. I love the port covers on this case b/c they are extremely durable and long lasting. However, my favoite benefit of the defender case is how easily it can be removed... I know you're thinking "wtf, this guy is an idiot!" Well the reason I say that is b/c i actually sell cellphones for a living and offering otterbox cases is second nature. having installed and removed just about every case they make, many of the other defenders are difficult to remove with the little clips on the internal plastic part of the case which is snug on the phone. The photon defender is almost effortless if you like to trade out ur cases on occassion it is a major benefit
I use the commuter series when not at work b/c I don't typically liek to wear my phone on my hip if I have an available pocket... just my personal preference. Commuter is definetly much less bulk but I also don't like the way that it's designed as far as installing/removing from the phone. It's a bit of a pain. Also, unfortunatly the part of the case that makes it grip in your hand makes it difficult to insert/remove from a normal pocket.
I have decided that I'm going to try out one of the tpu cases from amazon.com for a non work alternative and we'll see how that goes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The otterbox is a lil bulky, and the commuter is good too.
---------- Post added at 07:50 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:31 PM ----------
wagonattack said:
might have to step up and get me a TPU case, that thing is sexay!
has anyone found a carbon look case yet? i'd be much much more interested in form than function if one is found!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check Amazon for a carbon case.
Check this Carbon Fiber Case Out, CLICK HERE (http://www.amazon.com/Sprint-Motoro...SU12/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1318549681&sr=8-3)
I like the look of that case but the power button is a little tough to press so if I do get one I think I want one with something that goes over the power button.
I currently have Ghost Armour, It's more of a scratch resistance film, not a protective cover. I do not like anything that adds bulk personally. With that said, in the last 5 years, I have owned a AT&T Tilt, AT&T Fuze, Sprint Evo 4G, and now Photon. I dropped the Fuze once. I treat my phones like a 2 month old baby!. I have special mouse pads at work, living room, bed room, ect. To be honest, I have sold ALL of my phones for more that I paid for them in the first place! David
Seidio Active + holster. loving it!
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
ive been looking around on amazon and ebay for a holster perferably a horizontal one. and i was just wondering does any one have one? and if so what kind? and would you recommend it? im not sure why but ever sence ive had blackberrys (that came with the holster) ive always liked carrying my phone in a holster. any good ones out? they all seem kind of universal now, so i want one with a tight fit.
thanks for any help guys =)
The otterbox defender series is nice but it depends on what you want.
Pros
Nice cover with built in screen protector
Rubberize skin helps with slipping out of hand and protects from damage from dropping.
Holster has 360 degree swivle
Good customer service
best protecting case on the market
company covers phone deductible on damages
Cons,
Adds bulk (once used to it this becomes no big deal)
Rubberized outer shell may snag coming in and out of pockets. (may cause missed calls but your phone shouldnt fall out accidently)
I have broken the holster broke the thumb off ( I was drunk dont ask how. The customer service sent me out 2 replacement holsters after calling them)
The holster is nice but can have a propensity to catch things when walking in tight proximities.. (doesnt help I am a large guy)
Recap,
If you work construction then getting an otterbox will help keep your device longer in harsh environments.
ScottieRotten said:
The otterbox defender series is nice but it depends on what you want.
Pros
Nice cover with built in screen protector
Rubberize skin helps with slipping out of hand and protects from damage from dropping.
Holster has 360 degree swivle
Good customer service
best protecting case on the market
company covers phone deductible on damages
Cons,
Adds bulk (once used to it this becomes no big deal)
Rubberized outer shell may snag coming in and out of pockets. (may cause missed calls but your phone shouldnt fall out accidently)
I have broken the holster broke the thumb off ( I was drunk dont ask how. The customer service sent me out 2 replacement holsters after calling them)
The holster is nice but can have a propensity to catch things when walking in tight proximities.. (doesnt help I am a large guy)
Recap,
If you work construction then getting an otterbox will help keep your device longer in harsh environments.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ill look into it. the only issue i have with that is that it is huge. i was hopping that i could get one with no case. like a leather one or something?
thanks for the help man i appreciate it
Before I got the defender, I bought one from the sprint store kind of a bare bones cover, the holster did have a swivel. THe cover itself didnt offer much in protection and same time didnt have any bulk..
The only downside with the holster was you needed to fully slide the phone out to retrieve and answer any calls. Unlike the holster for the otterbox it is a quick snap out.
I will see about a link for that case for you. Chances are good you can go to a sprint store and they would have one on hand you can checkout before buying..
http://shop2.sprint.com/NASApp/onli...ryID=CHM4701R&topPageNumber=0&subPageNumber=0
Here is a link to the cover I used before the otterbox..
Also have this through sprint, no case but simply a holster.
http://shop2.sprint.com/NASApp/onli...ID=CCU2588Q_C&topPageNumber=0&subPageNumber=0
THis one looks pretty good too but I cannot speak for it since I havent used one personally.
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B005IGF1E6...e=asn&creative=395093&creativeASIN=B005IGF1E6
ok sounds good man, thanks. if you find the link ill sure look at it =)
edit: oh i see you have posted them now =) looking at them right now.
edit 2: ok after looking at them i think i like the leather one the most. i may go look at them soon, i cant today because i have 7 inches of snow and a icey driveway, uphill. haha also i may find simular ones on amazon, as sprint is always so expensive! this one doesnt look to bad but im not sure what ill get just yet.http://www.amazon.com/Horizontal-Re..._32?s=wireless&ie=UTF8&qid=1326927546&sr=1-32
Best holster ever is my left pocket. Keys and stuff go in right pocket.
Sent from my MB855 using Tapatalk
cornelious2 said:
Best holster ever is my left pocket. Keys and stuff go in right pocket.
Sent from my MB855 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
really? myns the opposite. well actually i have my keys on a karabeaner so other than the keys part.
naked the phone seems to do just fine and fits fine in my slacks pockets with out any bulging. unless your doing something really active, id vote to just go for the pocket, if you have seen the videos the screen is really hard to scratch.
cornelious2 said:
naked the phone seems to do just fine and fits fine in my slacks pockets with out any bulging. unless your doing something really active, id vote to just go for the pocket, if you have seen the videos the screen is really hard to scratch.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
weird. myn has little ones all over on it, i keep it alone in my pocket always.
The otterbox defender and commuter are both excellent cases IMHO. They're a bit on the pricey side but well worth getting if you want to protect your screen/camera (and basically everything else)
Looks like Otterbox just needs a phone to put in their just posted case.
Can't wait!
Saw one at Radio Shack 2 days ago and bought it. Waiting for the phone to go along with it. Me thinks it will be very soon, brand new Rezounds retail are down $100.00 on Ebay from just a couple of days ago.
cman6453 said:
Looks like Otterbox just needs a phone to put in their just posted case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know anything about otterbox and haven't heard of it before. Is it a hard shell case that does something special? Seems a little pricy.
Senryo said:
I don't know anything about otterbox and haven't heard of it before. Is it a hard shell case that does something special? Seems a little pricy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a hard case with a rubber skin around it. It's super durable. Highly recommended.
Sent from my vivow using Tapatalk 2
I picked up the Commuter with it today and its awesome! Fits perfect and doesn't add much bulk.
Sent from my ADR6410LVW using Tapatalk 2
Do you guys find it to big? I've been looking at this or the Ballistic case but they both seem to make the phone in to a brick.
The Commuter seems like the perfect size to me. I'll take some picture in a bit so you can see.
Sent from my ADR6410LVW using Tapatalk 2
Here are some pictures of it, and ones comparing it to my mom's Razr with a Case-mate case on it in my previous post.
I've commented on the otterbox defender series case before. I've got one on my Dinc. Yes the defender series will bulk it up, with the outer hardshell and clip but guess it depends on your lifestyle. I'm a mechanic so I need something that can withstand getting dropped or inadvertantly laid on, etc.
The defender is like a brick **** house, it just doesn't get any better protection wise. The nice thing about it, is if I take the phone all the way out to just it's core size without all the protection, and wipe it down, you wouldn't know this phone was not brand new, it's mint condition, thanks to the otterbox, and it has been dropped on the otterbox at least 5 times.
The commuter series would be a lot smaller profile if that's what you are looking for....
I'm glad to see OB has their act together on this and released a case for it, it actually took them a while to release one for the og Dinc..
ohredwood said:
I've commented on the otterbox defender series case before. I've got one on my Dinc. Yes the defender series will bulk it up, with the outer hardshell and clip but guess it depends on your lifestyle. I'm a mechanic so I need something that can withstand getting dropped or inadvertantly laid on, etc.
The defender is like a brick **** house, it just doesn't get any better protection wise. The nice thing about it, is if I take the phone all the way out to just it's core size without all the protection, and wipe it down, you wouldn't know this phone was not brand new, it's mint condition, thanks to the otterbox, and it has been dropped on the otterbox at least 5 times.
The commuter series would be a lot smaller profile if that's what you are looking for....
I'm glad to see OB has their act together on this and released a case for it, it actually took them a while to release one for the og Dinc..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I fele ya ottebox is the best.
.. u dropped ur inc4g 5 times already
I bought the Commuter, and the fit was horrible. The hard plastic outer shell didn't securely clamp to the soft rubber inner cover, and that inner cover did not fit the phone securely. The port covers didn't lay flat either. I bought an incipio silicrylic case and it fits much better.
Wow, I really like that Incipio case, holy cow. You have anything that can take pictures of it on the phone? Would really like to see some real world pics. How soft is the inside layer? Would it be ok sliding in and out of a pocket or would it "grab" or rip over time?
It doesn't look any different than from the website. Slides into and out of pockets just fine, and I don't think it will wear over time. The included screen protector is way better than the one OtterBox packages with their case, it covers the entire front glass panel.
A62335 said:
I bought the Commuter, and the fit was horrible. The hard plastic outer shell didn't securely clamp to the soft rubber inner cover, and that inner cover did not fit the phone securely. The port covers didn't lay flat either. I bought an incipio silicrylic case and it fits much better.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree! I just got my Otterbox case in on Saturday and the fit is really bad. I have a hard time pushing the power and volume button, the rubber over top of the front camera does not lay flat, the bottom end below the soft keys does not hug the phone(kind of protrudes out), the screen protector does not cover the whole screen, and the headphones port cover does fit very well into the hard shell.
I'm very disappointed in this case and will try and return it.
I'm not a big fan of otterbox because it's too big for me. :silly: But, if I don't find that many cases, I might have to buy this one. haha
i just got me an otter box defender, and its awesome, fits perfect, it makes the phone.has it's own screen cover too.
---------- Post added at 08:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:54 PM ----------
hieu2ueih said:
I agree! I just got my Otterbox case in on Saturday and the fit is really bad. I have a hard time pushing the power and volume button, the rubber over top of the front camera does not lay flat, the bottom end below the soft keys does not hug the phone(kind of protrudes out), the screen protector does not cover the whole screen, and the headphones port cover does fit very well into the hard shell.
I'm very disappointed in this case and will try and return it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
boy they must have given you the wrong one, mine is nothing like you discribe
I haven't used an otterbox on the Inc4, but we've got a fleet of iPhones for our salesmen at work. Every single one is in an otterbox Defender series, and trust me when i say our salesmen are extremely hard on phones. These cases have probably saved us hundreds of dollars no question.
The point of my post however is if you get one that doesn't fit quite right though i would ask for a replacement. When i was setting up all the phones and putting them into there cases i did run into a few that just didn't sit right. Looked like a manufacturing defect to me, but i was able to get replacements. That might be the issue your running into.
Void4ever
Edit: The Defender series WILL absolutely bulk up the phone though, but if you need the protection you'll find none better. I have no exp with the Commuters personally, but from the pics the size looks good.
andybones said:
I fele ya ottebox is the best.
.. u dropped ur inc4g 5 times already
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Naaa bud, I don't have the Inc4g yet, I've got my original Dinc sealed up in the defender series.
To the latest posters, as I mentioned in my post earlier as well, I have no experience with the commuter series OB but I did have two defender series OB's that cracked a small portion of the clip/case. I think it's a weak link in the design of the case and the snapping/unsnapping of the phone in/out of the case over time that caused this. But OB themselves, have been absolutely stellar to deal with, they looked up my purchase date, no questions, shipped out new cases to me each time.
I'd call em up tell em, and maybe they sent the wrong case, maybe you got a design flaw on yours, who knows but if some of the folks using the commuter case have posted awesome fit and look, that just don't jibe with what your reaction is to your case...
I went to radio shack to try out the otterbox commuter and the defender.
The commuter was unimpressive. The fit was loose even after much working of the acrylic over the silicone to have it get into the right place. The top part that hangs over the front facing camera is kind of flappy and I can see a lot of dust getting in there. The screen protector doesn't cover up under the loose area either. The bottom part of the case barely hangs on to the bottom of the phone, not tight at all.
The defender was completely opposite, the defender was a great fit. It felt sturdy, durable and overall just comfortable (if you like the additional bulk added). The screen protector was flush with the screen and responsive. Not nearly as nice feeling as a skinomi, but still nice.
I know this is an older post but........ I just got the defender series and it really doesn't bulk up the phone that much - frankly it is pretty small in you hand without a case. Even with this case on it still fits into the side pocket of a pair of carhartts. It is worth the money.