WHICH is the best OC governer for P500 out of these all and WHY...
- interactiveX
- interactive
- smartass
- SavazedZen
- ondemand
rjtchn15 said:
WHICH is the best OC governer for P500 out of these all and WHY...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1133098 just a few posts below, plus tons of others. Additionally, the question does not make much sense without specifying your usage case (performance vs. battery or whatever)
Hi,
Since we can add the smartass module developped for the X8, I wonder what are the pros/cons of smartass vs. ondemand, as regards energy consumption and performance.
If there's already information about that, feel free to point me to the source. But don't hesitate to give me your opinnion based on your experience.
SebbyNC
sebbync said:
Hi,
Since we can add the smartass module developped for the X8, I wonder what are the pros/cons of smartass vs. ondemand, as regards energy consumption and performance.
If there's already information about that, feel free to point me to the source. But don't hesitate to give me your opinnion based on your experience.
SebbyNC
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Rudimentary comparisons:
Generally:
Performance: Smartass < Ondemand
Battery life: Smartass > Ondemand
Cheers
SpyderX
Remember to set correct settings for smartass.
Thanks SpyderX, in your comparison is there any way to have an idea about how much one is better than the other (5% or 25% advantage or disadvantage....) ?
sebbync said:
Thanks SpyderX, in your comparison is there any way to have an idea about how much one is better than the other (5% or 25% advantage or disadvantage....) ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. But battery life can last a whole day more using smartass and moderate use. As for performance smartass governor will cause minor lag on opening apps etc.
Hi, i have just flashed the new HyperDroid v5.2.21 (Full wipe) and i wanted to know if i can overclock my SGS2 from 1.2ghz to 1.5ghz, if so how do i go about it?
Do i need to change the current kernel (XWL1)?
P.S ive heard its stable, but does it drain the battery?
Thanks XDA Community
Hello there. Yep you can overclock but you need a kernel that supports it. [url="http://gokhanmoral.com]SiyahKernel[/url] is a good choice. With that, use the Voltage Control app from the market.
However I know nothing about battery draining or stability... dualcore 1.2GHz mobile processor is more than enough for me, and the phone can get pretty hot under maximum load, same with the MALI GPU which can be overclocked to 400MHz (but since it has 4 cores and the phone has no active heatsinks it could get risky...)
AJ.Rockwell said:
Hello there. Yep you can overclock but you need a kernel that supports it. [url="http://gokhanmoral.com]SiyahKernel[/url] is a good choice. With that, use the Voltage Control app from the market.
However I know nothing about battery draining or stability... dualcore 1.2GHz mobile processor is more than enough for me, and the phone can get pretty hot under maximum load, same with the MALI GPU which can be overclocked to 400MHz (but since it has 4 cores and the phone has no active heatsinks it could get risky...)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think AndroidMeda kernel already supports OverClocking...using this ROM for a quite long time...
Harvinder09 said:
Hi, i have just flashed the new HyperDroid v5.2.21 (Full wipe) and i wanted to know if i can overclock my SGS2 from 1.2ghz to 1.5ghz, if so how do i go about it?
Do i need to change the current kernel (XWL1)?
P.S ive heard its stable, but does it drain the battery?
Thanks XDA Community
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes you can overclock and you can stick with the kernel that comes with Hyperdroid. I am currently Overclocking 1.6ghz max and 200 min. Not touching voltages though. Use No-Frills app to set it up. My advice though to you no point in overclocking as 1.2ghz is good enough as it is..And the kernel you are on is good enough...It is stable depending what voltage frequencies you use..I say leave it as they are. And like i said download No-Frills from the market..Set your clock speeds and that should be it..Choose a governor and off you go
Neo3000 said:
Yes you can overclock and you can stick with the kernel that comes with Hyperdroid. I am currently Overclocking 1.6ghz max and 200 min. Not touching voltages though. Use No-Frills app to set it up. My advice though to you no point in overclocking as 1.2ghz is good enough as it is..And the kernel you are on is good enough...It is stable depending what voltage frequencies you use..I say leave it as they are. And like i said download No-Frills from the market..Set your clock speeds and that should be it..Choose a governor and off you go
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No-Frills ? AndroidMeda Developers recommend Voltage Control (and I personally like it much more than No-Frills, too) with their kernel.
+ Here is a small guide : http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1036020 how to test your OC Settings, I use it when I am testing new voltages.
Thanks for the replies i will try out the no-frills app and see what happens. What would you say is the best governor to use? and wouldnt you recommend going over 200min?
DomButcher said:
No-Frills ? AndroidMeda Developers recommend Voltage Control (and I personally like it much more than No-Frills, too) with their kernel.
+ Here is small guide : http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1036020 how to test your OC Settings, I use it when I am testing new voltages.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Pongster uses No-Frills. The rest of the team uses Voltage Control. And to avoid any freezes or random reboots leave the voltage settings as they are till you get to grips with the overclocking. Hence why i suggested No-Frills as currently Voltage Control for me kept on reverting back to stock frequencies..And yes there is a way round it but it is to much of an effort
Harvinder09 said:
Thanks for the replies i will try out the no-frills app and see what happens. What would you say is the best governor to use? and wouldnt you recommend going over 200min?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am currently using ondemand and Sio as scheduler. You can not go wrong with that. Like i said..choose a governor choose a scheduler and let them do the work...I also do recommend Voltage control but No-frills is simple and does the job for you. And no i would recommend either go to 100min or stick with 200...I am currently on 1.6max and 200 min
Harvinder09 said:
Thanks for the replies i will try out the no-frills app and see what happens. What would you say is the best governor to use? and wouldnt you recommend going over 200min?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I personally use Sleepy governor and noop scheduler, but everyone uses different governors and schedulers...
I think 200 min is OK...100 MHz is too low and 500 is too high...
Neo3000 said:
Pongster uses No-Frills. The rest of the team uses Voltage Control. And to avoid any freezes or random reboots leave the voltage settings as they are till you get to grips with the overclocking. Hence why i suggested No-Frills as currently Voltage Control for me kept on reverting back to stock frequencies..And yes there is a way round it but it is to much of an effort
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have -75mV (previously had -50mV) and I haven't ever had any freeze or random reboot...
DomButcher said:
I personally use Sleepy governor and noop scheduler, but everyone uses different governors and schedulers...
I think 200 min is OK...100 MHz is too low and 500 is too high...
I have -75mV (previously had -50mV) and I haven't ever had any freeze or random reboot...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dude..he is just learning...let him take baby steps first before he jumps right up and wants to walk.... Let him follow what i suggested and then he can come back and ask for more help once he tries his new settings out...I remember you use to ask a lot of questions before..And i said the same thing..baby steps first before you start walking
Neo3000 said:
Dude..he is just learning...let him take baby steps first before he jumps right up and wants to walk.... Let him follow what i suggested and then he can come back and ask for more help once he tries his new settings out...I remember you use to ask a lot of questions before..And i said the same thing..baby steps first before you start walking
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh...he has just 6 posts...I didn't notice it...sorry. Then I will suggest No-Frills, too.
DomButcher said:
Oh...he has just 6 posts...I didn't notice it...sorry. Then I will suggest No-Frills, too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good..Now thanks wont hurt
Thanks for the support guys, and yeah i am new to this whole android/rooting scene so no-frills looks like a nice simple and easy option for now until i get to grips with things. i will try out the differen governors and schedulers and see whats best for me.
P.S Neo is yours running stable at the maximum 1.6ghz?
Harvinder09 said:
Thanks for the support guys, and yeah i am new to this whole android/rooting scene so no-frills looks like a nice simple and easy option for now until i get to grips with things. i will try out the differen governors and schedulers and see whats best for me.
P.S Neo is yours running stable at the maximum 1.6ghz?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes my friend pretty stable. Listen go here http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1369817 and read regarding governors and schedulers..Pretty straight forward and good explanations...And i am running the latest hyperdroid version but i am using Siyah kernel with thunderbolt tweaks...For you i would use the kernel that comes with the rom and use the default governor that comes with the rom...When i was on previous kernel version i always use to use Kenobi...Not sure if they have it there or if Pongs removed it but either that or solo...
Neo3000 said:
Yes my friend pretty stable. Listen go here http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1369817 and read regarding governors and schedulers..Pretty straight forward and good explanations...And i am running the latest hyperdroid version but i am using Siyah kernel with thunderbolt tweaks...For you i would use the kernel that comes with the rom and use the default governor that comes with the rom...When i was on previous kernel version i always use to use Kenobi...Not sure if they have it there or if Pongs removed it but either that or solo...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Kenobi was removed and solo was renamed to sleepy.
which governer is best with overclocking 1.6ghz
mzeshanhakeem said:
which governer is best with overclocking 1.6ghz
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i am using ondemand
Neo3000 said:
i am using ondemand
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Neo when i overclock to 1.6ghz with 200min using the lulzactive governer and SIO scheduler my phone freezes i have to reboot it?
whats the best setup to run 1.6ghz so its stable for everyday use?
P.S anyone know if it drains the battery by overclocking?
Harvinder09 said:
Neo when i overclock to 1.6ghz with 200min using the lulzactive governer and SIO scheduler my phone freezes i have to reboot it?
whats the best setup to run 1.6ghz so its stable for everyday use?
P.S anyone know if it drains the battery by overclocking?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
change to ondemand governor when overclocking
Neo3000 said:
change to ondemand governor when overclocking
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
And what scheduler?
Thanks
Harvinder09 said:
And what scheduler?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
stick with SIO
Hi all, now i'm using vr- lulzactive with 100-1200 and stock voltages can somowone teach me what is the best governor and i/o for this rom?
cfq/ondemand are usually paired with siyah kernel
AleDB said:
Hi all, now i'm using vr- lulzactive with 100-1200 and stock voltages can somowone teach me what is the best governor and i/o for this rom?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is difficult to say, as it depends on your hardware, apps, settings, region, carrier and usage ... and what is "best" for you (best performance or best battery life).
So, you may have to check out the available governors and schedulers yourself.
Here is a very good thread about io schedulers and governors => http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1369817
If you don't read it already and want to know more.
The whole time that i have had the rezound i have had problems with the cpu settings sticking, and i read somewhere that using a script to set it works best. would this work? http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1584508. and also since I have not really had luck with them sticking i would like to know what you guys think is the best governor, i was probably going to use smartassv2, wheatley, or pegesusq, but im not sure if they are the best for performance and all the explanations of them dont really tell if they perform in real life. Im looking for mostly performance, but i dont want something that will destroy my battery
edit: that link doesnt work, the download is missing, so what is a different way?
Why would you want a CPU governer if it wasn't to help with your battery life?
GrayTheWolf said:
Why would you want a CPU governer if it wasn't to help with your battery life?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
to overclock it to get better performance
xxtsxx said:
to overclock it to get better performance
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You need an overclocked kernel to do that.
GrayTheWolf said:
You need an overclocked kernel to do that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
well yeah i have that, im running cubed ics kernel 2.3.5, and i just want a better way to make my overclock stick and which governor will give the best performance without completely using up the battery, kind of a happy medium but leaning a little more towards performance. I guess I didnt explain that good enough
xxtsxx said:
well yeah i have that, im running cubed ics kernel 2.3.5, and i just want a better way to make my overclock stick and which governor will give the best performance without completely using up the battery, kind of a happy medium but leaning a little more towards performance. I guess I didnt explain that good enough
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
These are a bit dated and from another phone, but can provide a bit of insight into kernel governors and their behavior. Keep in mind a few technical points are different for our phone (different min/max clock speeds) but much is the same in general.
tl;dr Smartassv2 should meet your needs as a top performer while still gaining some battery savings. Try with noop or sio I/O scheduler. A modest undervolt, but avoid pushing it.
Kernel Features and Benchmarks
Battery Saving Governor Benchmarks
Battery Drain Benchmarks
PhantasmRezound said:
These are a bit dated and from another phone, but can provide a bit of insight into kernel governors and their behavior. Keep in mind a few technical points are different for our phone (different min/max clock speeds) but much is the same in general.
tl;dr Smartassv2 should meet your needs as a top performer while still gaining some battery savings. Try with noop or sio I/O scheduler. A modest undervolt, but avoid pushing it.
Kernel Features and Benchmarks
Battery Saving Governor Benchmarks
Battery Drain Benchmarks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hey thanks for all that info
I have no problems keeping my Governor (Wheatly) set with System Tuner using the set CPU preference to remember after boot complete.