Hey all, i thought i would start a thread about an issue that many canadians seem to have with the GS2, it seems to have been beat to death but there is no actual solution.
Im currently using the GS2 with Telus, its a wcdma/3G/H/H+ carrier using the frequency 1900 mostly and 850 at times on the cdma network, i used so far KG3-KG6 i placed them in that order because KG6 is the latest i tried and has proven to give me better coverage but its still really bad..
I can connect to data but only outdoors or only when the reception is full bars, if i start to lose any bars there goes my data connection and i can no longuer use any services data/sms/mms/calls i literaly cant do anything..
This is a big issue as i know for a fact that you dont need a data connection to send sms. but it seems the galaxy s2 under the current modem firmware im using KG6 wont allow me to unless im on full data coverage...
My question is this, what is the best modem firmware to use according to the frequencies that i meantioned earlier 1900/850 WCDMA i dont mind using another country's modem as long as they are oriented towards the same frequencies that i need
My phone came from Korea and i know they use 2100/900 could that be the issue? Is my hardware oriented towards that? At this point anything could help and please feel free to post thanks
SL.
What is the model # of your phone?
Sent from my GT-I9100M using XDA App
GT-I9100 thats my model
im using
PDA: I9100XXKG6
PHONE: I9100XXKG6
CSC: I91000XAKG6
Hmm, I'm a SGS2 owner on TELUS as well and haven't had any problems so far, besides the GPS Lock Time which most people seem to complain about. It takes about 1 minute for the GPS to lock for me, but my data is fine. No dropped calls or sms problems here. My download speed as I checked last was at 8.31 Mbps down and about 2 Mbps up.
But again, having horrible GPS issues. Wish I could figure that one out
Sobai can u post your results to *#1234#
so i can compare my settings to yours.
I'm using KG6 on Rogers network and don't have fantastic reception either. For most situations it holds calls -- but buildings with lots of concrete I lose the signal completely. It's as if I'm not truly on the 850 band ... my G1 had the same problem until I flashed a Bell-specific modem, that solved the problem. I guess we'll have to wait until Bell launches the G2 here, we'll be able to swipe the modem again.
i have an imported gs2 that i am using on rogers and it doesnt drop calls, but i have had times in the past when it would show 3g but not download any data. once i turned airplane mode on and off data would work fine again. the best radio for me has been the kf2 modem in terms of not having the data stalling issue. i find that even if i show no bars of strength i can still download data with no issue.
if you are on telus i would make sure so set the wireless settings to 3g only so the phone doesnt try to look for a 2g signal.
KG2 on a Bell SGS2 on Rogers/Fido network in Vancouver.
GPS locks in seconds. no dropped calls. H+ all the time, never once saw a 3G symbol. no data dropouts.
over 7Mbps down on this network with the SGS2, when i had 1/3rd the speeds an HTC Desire. great reception in my office downtown, my apartment, everywhere i've been so far.
KG2 (not the stock canadian though), in Montreal on the Virgin/Bell network. So far no complaints on the data. Since I started messing w/ the firmware however, the connection is on 3G when idle and only switches to H+ when actually in use. From what i've been reading many people have been noticing this when flashing over the stock Canadian firmware.
On the other hand however, the GPS has been having a hard time establishing a lock (whereas it used to be quite speedy and precise before I flashed). Won`t be able to test whether this is a firmware problem untill the stock Canadian is released by Samsung.
PDA: I9100XXKG6
PHONE: I9100XXKG2
CSC: I9100OXAKG6
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA App
Wow guys I appreciate the feedback I thought I was the only one with this issue! I will definitely give kf2 a try right now and I'll also download the 3G only data app and give it a try and I'll get back to u guys with some feedback. Thanks again
Btw I'm using, touch x 3.2 rom that has kg5 on and I did notice a little improvement in the reception but the data connectivity is still very spotty so I'll give kf2 a try but so far kg5 modem is definitely the best one I seen so far to use on telus. Btw anyone trying to use the galaxy s2 on fido, I was never able to get 3G at all to work I was stuck on edge.
hondaguy said:
i have an imported gs2 that i am using on rogers and it doesnt drop calls, but i have had times in the past when it would show 3g but not download any data. once i turned airplane mode on and off data would work fine again. the best radio for me has been the kf2 modem in terms of not having the data stalling issue. i find that even if i show no bars of strength i can still download data with no issue.
if you are on telus i would make sure so set the wireless settings to 3g only so the phone doesnt try to look for a 2g signal.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you know how I would be able to set it up so that it stays locked on 3G? I tried the *#301279# trick and disabling hsdpa and hsupa with revision 99 but to no avail. Even if it shows full bars and 3G I still get no data connection and also I can't send or receive texts unless there is a data connection for some reason, have you guys had this issue??
sashpimp said:
Do you know how I would be able to set it up so that it stays locked on 3G? I tried the *#301279# trick and disabling hsdpa and hsupa with revision 99 but to no avail. Even if it shows full bars and 3G I still get no data connection and also I can't send or receive texts unless there is a data connection for some reason, have you guys had this issue??
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i have never needed to mess around with that menu. you should be able to go to
settings
wireless network
mobile networks
network mode
select wcdma only
that will lock it to 3 only. if you keep having issues you might get a new sim card from telus as that might be causing you some issues
Do you have your apn configured properly for your provider? If it isnt your data definitely work. Other then that I havent had these issues in edmonton on kg6 or maybe I just dont know what to expect reception wise. I do notice it hops from 3G to hspa to hspa+ a lot so i switched to only 3g. If anyone finds anything that improves that or reception though I would be interested
Sobai said:
Hmm, I'm a SGS2 owner on TELUS as well and haven't had any problems so far, besides the GPS Lock Time which most people seem to complain about. It takes about 1 minute for the GPS to lock for me, but my data is fine. No dropped calls or sms problems here. My download speed as I checked last was at 8.31 Mbps down and about 2 Mbps up.
But again, having horrible GPS issues. Wish I could figure that one out
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can u post what Rom u are currently using and modem ?
sashpimp said:
Can u post what Rom u are currently using and modem ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This information would be great because I am also experiencing spotty data connectivity (browser loads data, stalls, resumes centuries later) which results in severe crappy data speeds of 0.8mbps down and 0.07mbps up (done on in-browser speakeasy test and speedtest.net app.
Running VillianRom 2.4.2 on Bell's I9100M over Telus Network
PDA: I9100XXKG6
PHONE: I9100XXKG3
CSC: I9100OXAKG6
nk_blu said:
This information would be great because I am also experiencing spotty data connectivity (browser loads data, stalls, resumes centuries later) which results in severe crappy data speeds of 0.8mbps down and 0.07mbps up (done on in-browser speakeasy test and speedtest.net app.
Running VillianRom 2.4.2 on Bell's I9100M over Telus Network
PDA: I9100XXKG6
PHONE: I9100XXKG3
CSC: I9100OXAKG6
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wish there was a way to extract the modem.bin file from the bell sgs2 this way we could simply distibute it around. Someone should root their phone, install cwm4 and make a backup and we could simply pass the backup around so we could all have the modem
Bell modem has already been posted to the forum.
sashpimp said:
I wish there was a way to extract the modem.bin file from the bell sgs2 this way we could simply distibute it around. Someone should root their phone, install cwm4 and make a backup and we could simply pass the backup around so we could all have the modem
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA Premium App
Or flash KG6, KH1, whichever modem you please.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA Premium App
Hi i have vs 2.3.5 offical kies android with root access and i have baseband version xxKI4 is there a newer modem version for this one because my current modem is realy not stable. Bad reception where i didn't have that with 2.3.3
I have a Beglian phone but willing to try more then one recent good modem
What is your carrier. Maybe try match the modem to the same recommended by the carrier?
Also what is your model; 9100, 9100T, 9100G, ......
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
I9100 and Proximus
Try some of these modems flashable through CWM Recovery. They are generic European XX.
[MODEM] Main modem XX versions flashable through CWM
I haven't found anything newer, but these only take a moment to flash and try.
Before you flash, observe current; signal strength and quality (-dbm asu) and connection type E, UMTS, H etc....... in phone menu / settings / about phone / status , and then compare after you flash each modem. Be aware of any increase in battery drain.
Edit: Also Check DL & UL speeds with speed tests app
Hope this helps
good tips thx
they all act around 91-95 and one 101 dbm what is best, as low as possible?
Usually as low as possible will give better and more stable reception, and also less switching between 2g (Edge) & 3g (UMTS, HSDPA, HSPA).
Your figures for signal strength are extremely poor.
Maybe nan-backup your current ROM, and re-flash a 2.3.3 backup if you still have it and compare, ensuring you then re-flash the modem used with your 2.3.3 ROM after.
Were your figures for 3g connection or 2g? 2g will nearly always give better signal.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
I'm on ics vk rom. Currently on ki4 modem, have used lps modem previously. Which is the best (in terms of internet speed and battery performance) modem on tmobile? Which is the best on O2? I have read that nelp2 or bokg1 should be considered.
Forgot to mention wi-fi reception is also imperative.
LosKhan said:
Forgot to mention wi-fi reception is also imperative.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can't answer your first question, but I don't think modem/baseband will affect WiFi reception.
My question is for all users from Romania, or other people that might have some usefull info.
I'm trying diffrent modems at the moment but I can't seem to get better signal than -89 dbm and 12 asu.
Could it be a carrier problem or a phone problem. I have installed Ressurection Remix v2.0 and my curent modem is KI4.
Before this i was on RR1.9 with LPS modem....and the signal strength was a bit lower.
If anyone from the region has better signal numbers please post them alongside with the modem you are using.
Cosmin.
Sent from my GT-I9100 using XDA
hi Cosmin,
i'm using xxlpw modem with the same rom as you, and before the xxlpw i was using the bvlpb modem, and i have the same results as you -89 and 12 ASU.
I belive this are the best results we can get in our country.
Well I'm a bit disappointed by the quality of the signal. Perhaps someone with better signal quality will come along and tell us what we are doing wrong
I've recently moved to Hampshire, UK and got myself a Vodafone simcard. This problem probably existed already prior moving to UK but wasn't as noticeable as phone networks were a lot better in Finland and Czech Republic where I lived before. I often notice my signal being non existent or very low when other people with Vodafone but different phones have ok to good signal. I often also notice that according to the phone it has a HSDPA connection but no data is being transmitted, but immediately if it jumps to HSDPA+, data is being transmitted flawlessly again. I'm running the latest stable CM 10 on my phone. Additionally there seems to be similar issues with WIFI, other phones show good signal but mine doesn't.
Any ideas what could be the cause? Is the reception in S3 just worse than in my old Nokia E71 or Iphone5? What really puzzles me is the not working data connection with HSDPA, sometimes moving few meters might make it jump to HSDPA+ and data again transmits normally.
First go back to full stock rom, latest uk generic firmware and modem to test.
It's more likely to be due to your rom than hardware.
I've tried few different stock roms but the same problem seems to be present, still shows that I'm connected with HSDPA but no data is being transmitted. Any other ideas?
Check APN settings correct modem and CSC .
Would any of these affect the wifi aswell?
LtnKowalski said:
Would any of these affect the wifi aswell?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No the wifi is kernel .
JJEgan said:
No the wifi is kernel .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Modem, CSC and APN were all correct. My problems are with both wifi and phone network, could the problem be physical? Doesn't kernel come with the firmware, or should I try with another kernel?
You can flash a kernel or modem separately or as part of a whole firmware.
If you've tried going back to stock then hardware is the most probable cause.
Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk