Related
Can anybody confirm, that wifi (wlan) roaming, between different access points on the same SSID network and different channels, is working?
I have at home 2 access point (one is on channel 1 and another is on channel 6) and my SGS2 wouldn't switch from one AP to another when I walk in the house. My son has SGS1 and wifi roaming works for him. Before I had Nokia N95 and I had no problems with wifi roaming. The same thing, when I'm at work. We have 3 AP's (all three Cisco) in the house and switching between them doesn't work. In order to switch between AP's I toggle WiFi off then back on again.
I went from KE2 to KE7, now I'm on Litening ROM 1.5, but it's all the same.
I tried everything, I can think off (set AP/router to b/g/n, only b, only g, only n, set different channels, set different security,...tried also flashing different modems on the phone...) but for me wifi roaming is not working...
Any ideas?
Anybody?
Nobody? Realy?
That's realy strange...
Nobody?
I really can't believe.... almost 90 views and no answer...
I'm I the only one with this problem?
While you are moving round your house do you lose connection, i think that your phone will be connected to the strongest signal.
mine loses signal when i leave home and auto picks up an usecured signal down the road.
I don't quite understand, what you mean...
When I walk in my house from basement to the top floor, my SGS2 is always connected to the router in the basement. When I come to the 2nd floor, where I have another Access point, it should switch to that AP, but it wouldn't. Instead, it's still connected to the router in the basement, which (in the Wifi Analyzer) shows -90 db (and the AP on the 2nd floor shows -30). When I switch off Wifi on my SGS2 and then back on, then it will connect to the AP in the 2nd floor. But then, when I walk back, down to the basement, it stays connected to the AP on the 2nd floor, even when I stand next to the router in the basement and Wifi Analyzer shows -28 db on the router.
I can confirm that wifi roaming is not working (at least for me). The phone stays connected to the same old AP all the time even with really poor signal quality.
Unless it loses the connection it doesn't connect to the best AP available.
Tried it on several ROMs (multiple stock roms and now I am on Cognition 1.20), same behaviour every time.
Exactly the same with my SGS2.
I also tried several ROM's, from original KE7 to latest KG3, now I'm on Lite'ning 3.2, and it doesn't work...
That's really strange...
Exact same issue here. Tried three different stock ROMs and a couple of modified ROMs and no change.
I'm even running Cyanogenmod now and the problem persists! How does that work? Does Cyanogen use the Samsung source-code for the Wifi driver?
It's really pissing me off. I basically cant use Wifi on the end of the house I use it most in without cycling the Wifi on/off switch as I pass a different AP on my way into the house to get there!
The most strangest thing is, that nothing can be found on the web about this issue (only one on code.google.com)...
And also here, on XDA, millions of posts, but nothing about wifi roaming...
Are people not using more then one AP/router?
zxcslo said:
The most strangest thing is, that nothing can be found on the web about this issue (only one on code.google.com)...
And also here, on XDA, millions of posts, but nothing about wifi roaming...
Are people not using more then one AP/router?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I am sure most people use one AP/router - that is why you are not seeing too many responses. The source code is from the samsung source drop, the drivers were written by broadcom. We at teamhacksung have not modified them for CM7, so the behavior would be the same across all ROMs that are using the drivers unmodified.
So, that means, we are stuck with this, until Samsung fix it?
I still can't believe, that the best phone on the world (at the moment... ) has such a flaw...
What about trying driver for Wifi from SGS1? On SGS1 wifi roaming works beautiful (my son has one and he is laughing at me all the time ).
Is there much difference between SGS1 and SGS2 in the wifi handling?
Wow - this is an annoying issue to have. Yup, i have 2 routers too, and it really sux to be in an 'overlapping' zone and see the SGS2 connect to the router that is further away.
Is there nothing that can be done about this?
MorRoquen said:
Wow - this is an annoying issue to have. Yup, i have 2 routers too, and it really sux to be in an 'overlapping' zone and see the SGS2 connect to the router that is further away.
Is there nothing that can be done about this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm very pis..... angry, when I'm in my room/office, and see, that my phone is connected to the AP, which is in my son's room, two floors above me... and I'm sitting 1m away from router...
Yesterday I tried in my office with 3 AP's with my friend's SGS2 with original stock ROM KE2 (he didn't change nothing on the phone).
Result:....... the same as with my SGS2.... wifi roaming not working....
Any news about wifi roaming?
How annoying!
I'm having similar problems at work.
At home connectivity's fine with just 1 AP. Here at work there are about 10 Cisco APs. Every now and then I have to turn WiFi off and on again and I use the original stock rom.
I have exactly the same problem, it always connects to the same AP, not the one with the better signal... very annoying! How difficult is it to fix that?
Morghus85 said:
I have exactly the same problem, it always connects to the same AP, not the one with the better signal... very annoying! How difficult is it to fix that?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which channel does this AP have?
Last night I was looking for a video on youtube on my photon, and my wife was searching on our old laptop. Both were connected to our WiFi router, and we were sitting right next to each other. The laptop was MUCH faster than the photon, and the photon kept hanging in the middle of videos.
I'm pretty sure it was a wireless issue. I turned off WiFi and ran it on 3G, and it ran faster with no signal drops! I went back to WiFi and the performance dropped significantly.
Any suggestions for how to improve the WiFi performance? Would a newer router help? The 2300 is tried & true, and I've always like it. Does WiFi channel matter? Other ideas?
I'm not rooted, if that matters for any response.
Jeffrey_L said:
Last night I was looking for a video on youtube on my photon, and my wife was searching on our old laptop. Both were connected to our WiFi router, and we were sitting right next to each other. The laptop was MUCH faster than the photon, and the photon kept hanging in the middle of videos.
I'm pretty sure it was a wireless issue. I turned off WiFi and ran it on 3G, and it ran faster with no signal drops! I went back to WiFi and the performance dropped significantly.
Any suggestions for how to improve the WiFi performance? Would a newer router help? The 2300 is tried & true, and I've always like it. Does WiFi channel matter? Other ideas?
I'm not rooted, if that matters for any response.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What build version are you currently on? Have you flashed any of the updates or is the phone stock from Sprint?
I don't think a new router would help. My wifes nexus s 4g always has better signal strength than my photon when on wifi, I compared it to a friends Htc sensation connected to the same router and he had the better signal strength, and places where my evo 4g use to get a very weak signal but was still able to connect the photon won't connect at all.
Just some info to add to the OP....
I have a good router at home and a good one at work (different brands) and my WiFi is fast and smooth while at work but sometimes at home it is slow and chunky. Very sporadic at home for some reason and it never seemed to happen until after one of the updates.
CCallahan said:
Just some info to add to the OP....
I have a good router at home and a good one at work (different brands) and my WiFi is fast and smooth while at work but sometimes at home it is slow and chunky. Very sporadic at home for some reason and it never seemed to happen until after one of the updates.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the same issue after the last "update". It seems to lose the wi-fi connection and keeps any network from connecting. I have to turn the wifi off and wait for the 3G to connect or I won't get any mail. I can't figure out what changed, but it used to work perfectly. I'm contemplating rolling back to the first update.
pzztgotbagz said:
What build version are you currently on? Have you flashed any of the updates or is the phone stock from Sprint?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have installed all OTA updates to date.
Build No. 4.5.1A-1_SUN-154_6
Ok, I bit the bullet and used RSD to roll back to the earliest version of the code (I didn't lose any data or even the location of the widgets on my screen) and it totally fixed the WiFi issues I've been having. Plus the battery seems to last quite a bit longer. I thought that the latest update was a loser, this just proves it.
I came to the conclusion on my own that the photon doesn't like any mixed wifi signals; i had my 2.4ghz router running with mixed b/g/n for wireless and it didnt play nice. Once i changed it to n only it worked way better.......
Nextelian said:
Ok, I bit the bullet and used RSD to roll back to the earliest version of the code (I didn't lose any data or even the location of the widgets on my screen) and it totally fixed the WiFi issues I've been having. Plus the battery seems to last quite a bit longer. I thought that the latest update was a loser, this just proves it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am experiencing the same wifi issues after updating to 198_6. Which version did you roll back to?
I would be interested in knowing what version also,, I'm sure if I did some research I can find out on my own in the meantime,,,,
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
Sorry to be so late responding. I've been away from the forum for awhile (been out slumming with the iPhone crowd trying to see what the panic was about).
1FF-sunfire-user-2.3.4-4.5.1A-1_SUN-154_5-CM-release-keys-signed-Sprint-US.sbf
is the one I used. I just accidentally applied the OTA update and the WIFI issues returned. Back to the drawing board. I guess I need to do the "no OTA update" hack.
EXACTLY! This has been happening to me now on TWO Phones! I can't say that it's been just my home router though. I took my phone into the sprint store, hooked up to their wifi and same problem... Right off the bat it didn't connect to the market.
This happens at home and is super frustrating. I will get to browse a couple pages/apps/zedge then nothing. I've even had it go retarded enough to pop up the 3G icon as well as the wifi signal indicator...? No up/down arrows showed in the 3G to indicate data transfer but I was just like WTF?
So now when I leave my house, out of range of wifi, my phone blows up with e-mails, apps I've had in queue, etc.
I've noticed these problems more with the most recent update but I didn't spend too much time browsing without it though. Maybe I'll get a new one from Sprint and just never apply the update.
**EDIT: Both times I've received one of these phones the only update I've done is the most recent one. I haven't bothered checking the software version they are coming with. Is it possible they're no longer putting out the first update and these aren't cumulative? Just a shot in the dark but maybe I needed that first update before the second to make things jive. It's unlikely they would put out updates in this manner but I'm grasping for straws here.
kennypow3rs said:
I came to the conclusion on my own that the photon doesn't like any mixed wifi signals; i had my 2.4ghz router running with mixed b/g/n for wireless and it didnt play nice. Once i changed it to n only it worked way better.......
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My experience is different. The phone connects and works great at the office but not so great at home. Both routers are set on mixed. Not sure what the difference is (besides the brand of router). I do know the one at home is handing out IPs but the one at work is not. The server handles that.
Not sure what else could make a difference.
Just got my third Photon from the sprint store and same issue. This one already had the 42.5.7 update installed on it but wifi has been flakey. I'm convinced that it's something in the software combined with the wifi we are using. The ridiculous thing is I have a motorola SBG 900 that I use for wireless at home so you would think they would be compatible. I really like the phone otherwise so I hope a new update is right around the corner.
Just went and bought a $160 modem/router combo and my phone has no issues at all with wireless now...
Three Photons in a week and a good chunk of cash later and I can use wifi at home. And now that I've finally had time to play with it I find out wifi tether only does ad hoc natively.
I wouldn't mind having my Evo Shift back.
I'm having the same problem. I updated to 198_6 as part of the testing group and at first had no problems with Wifi. Now when I am connected to wifi (both at work and at home) I can't send or receive text messages, download from the market, nada. As soon as I connect back to 4G everything works perfectly. I'm gonna roll back tonight to the previous update. BTW, I also updated my PRL to 51082 and that didn't seem to help.
Is the problem basically where wifi is connected to the router then stops going past that? Like you still have an ip but no data?
If so try turning off notifications for gmail or turning off the "notify once option". This seemed to help me lose my connection to where i had flip on/off the wifi radio.
Let me know how you fare with this.
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
Are you running any "turbo or super G" like modes set on the router? I remember reading on the motorola forums that these sometimes may cause issues - other things, router firmware update if applicable... do you have an airave device? If so, make sure the distance between that and the router are more than 5ft apart in distance.
Still, in your situation - streaming over the wifi shouldn't be an issue with bandwidth to keep in consideration, but realistically speaking - that should be better than 3g speeds for video playback.
These were some of the thing I had picked up from while troubleshooting an ongoing issue I am still having with my old d-link di-624 and photon getting stuck at "obtaining an IP address" on the official Motorola photon forums. In the latter situation, mine will connect if I reboot the router... my other tablets and laptops connect flawlessly on this.
Anyone know why WiFi would work some places and not others? For example it won't work at my house. Just keeps saying scanning, connecting, disconnecting. I have gotten it to work in one bldg I work in. Not any other place. Is there a way to clear it out and start fresh? I have been able to.connect in the past with this phone and my wireless router at home. This all started 3 days ago. Im running complete stock. I have rebooted computer, router and phone, to no avail.
Sent from my Rezound
No clue. Mine unfortunately seems to work everywhere but my house. I have to keep wifi switched off when I get home because it causes the internet to stop working for every device in the house. Pretty inconvenient. Anyway I decided to buy a new router to see if that fixes it. Should be here tomorrow.
Well the new router fixed my wifi problem. I bought this Medialink - Wireless N Router ( amazon.com/gp/product/B0044YU60M/ref=ox_sc_act_title_2?ie=UTF8&m=A1DCPNQKKEISZB ) Sorry, forum wont let me post links yet. Set it up in a few minutes and instantly had wifi on my rezound.
OK, I've seen a lot of posts in various forums about this issue, but have yet to find a single thread that captures all the details about what I've experienced. Let me know if I should move this conversation into a different thread.
On my home wifi network, I am able to connect, but constantly receive the error "internet connection is unstable", and I cannot pull any data over wifi. I noticed this issue on my home network after returning from a business trip this week. I'd previously seen the issue occasionally in hotels, etc, and had already disabled the "Passpoint" and "Auto network switch settings". That seemed to work on the road, but now that I'm at home, I'm unable to pull any data over wifi.
My home router is a TP-Link Archer C7, running the latest firmware.
Per Verizon and Samsung's advice, I cleared the cache partition, "forgot" and reconnected to the network, tried using safe mode, and tried a factory reset of the phone. I also restarted the router and changed the router's broadcast channels.
Last night, I rooted the phone via Kingo and installed the Jelly 'Beans' rom using SafeStrap, since I wasn't getting satisfactory answers from support. To my surprise, the issue also occurred on the new rom. I'm not an Android expert, but it seems like this means its either:
1) a hardware issue, or
2) a lower-level software issue (radio firmware? not sure how that works)
I removed root and safestrap, to continue support options with Verizon, but I wanted to ping the community here for suggestions. The timing is confusing to me. I'm pretty sure, though not certain, that I've used my home network successfully since the 12/17 OTA update. However, since so many others are seeing issues, it seems unlikely that this is a hardware issue.
Could others describe their issues and router, so we can look for patterns? Let me know if I should move this into a different thread.
Thanks!
Mine does the same thing from time to time but only on certain roms
Sent from my SM-N900V using XDA Premium HD app
yeah, I'd seen intermittent issues previously, but all of a sudden it stopped working at home entirely. Still connects to some other networks, although not all.
After seeing a bunch of posts on the Verizon forums (and just the general timing and behavior of the issue) it seemed like a software problem.
Verizon is actually cooperating, so I may just end up replacing this phone. Wondering if anyone else has seen wifi completely break like this.
This is the only thing I can not stand about my note
I have a Zyxel WAP3205 WIFI access point (Wireless G) that I use at both work and at home.
At home, I have Comcast Business Cable internet, and have absolutely no issues connecting to it. The WAP is connected to a Belkin N600 router, which is then connected to my cable modem (not sure of the model, shouldn't matter TBQH).
At work on the other hand, I have constant connection issues. Albeit, I don't get the 'connection is unstable' notification, but I get constant connect/disconnect problems. I also have almost no (most of the time I can't even send/receive text messages at my desk.....) phone signal (ie not even 1X). I'm not sure if that plays into it at all either. The company I work for uses Windstream for their ISP, and it's complete crap to be perfectly honest. Needless to say, it doesn't change the fact that I'm connecting to the internet through the same device (well, same model/firmware/etc...), and I'm having issues at 1 place and not at the other.
I might also add that my tablet (Nexus 7 2013 running CM11) doesn't seem to have these issues at all and works just fine via the WIFI.
That's about the only information that I can provide. I know my internet where I work is complete crap. I sometimes remote desktop back to my home server to browse the web and download files via that because it's actually faster. I'm not even kidding.
I have 2 routers at home and have experienced the same issue as well and none of my other devices have this problem
Sent from Rooted Note 3 (stock rom) Xposed framework
Verizon is shipping a replacement phone to me tomorrow, so I'll test this out and see if it makes a difference. I'm on the road until Thursday, so it'll be a few days before I can check on my home router.
The behavior on this issue just seems strange. It began intermittently, but then completely stopped working at my house (but still sometimes works elsewhere). Lots of people report intermittent issues, but a few seem completely broken. Not sure what to make of it, I'm just glad I was able to get a different device out of Verizon. We'll see if that actually fixes the problem.
I haven't had this notification until I got the Note3. Is it possible that its android 4.3? Or this tw 4.3? Anybody know if other folks get this with other devices?
Harleydroid said:
I haven't had this notification until I got the Note3. Is it possible that its android 4.3? Or this tw 4.3? Anybody know if other folks get this with other devices?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I only have this problem if I connect to the wifi at work, which is odd because I'm about 7 unobstructed feet away from the AP. I don't get this anywhere else.
I had a Note2 on stock rom up to 4.3 and never had the issue. I have a 2012 Nexus 7 latest version, again, no problem. It's only on my Note3 with stock rom that this happens.
exactor_mortis said:
I only have this problem if I connect to the wifi at work, which is odd because I'm about 7 unobstructed feet away from the AP. I don't get this anywhere else.
I had a Note2 on stock rom up to 4.3 and never had the issue. I have a 2012 Nexus 7 latest version, again, no problem. It's only on my Note3 with stock rom that this happens.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It happens on custom roms too.
I've asked a couple devs if they could remove it and they said it been like that in android for along time.But I never experienced it until my Note 3
exactor_mortis said:
I only have this problem if I connect to the wifi at work, which is odd because I'm about 7 unobstructed feet away from the AP. I don't get this anywhere else.
I had a Note2 on stock rom up to 4.3 and never had the issue. I have a 2012 Nexus 7 latest version, again, no problem. It's only on my Note3 with stock rom that this happens.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same here. Never happened on my Note2 but happens all the time on my Note3. I have two Linksys Routers at home for full house coverage and I can be in the next room and get that message. Just got it earlier. Same routers as I had with the N2 a few months ago. My Tablet, nor the Spouses HTC One Max have that issue and are connecting just fine, and stay connected.
I get this all the time. Got it on stock as well. Only really happens with my ghetto satellite Internet though lol
Sent from my SM-N900V using xda app-developers app
Has anyone with this issue installed AdBlock and/or an ad-blocking HOSTS file? I didn't start seeing this problem until I did both.
Whenever I see this message I can go into the speedtest.net app and pull a continuous 60mbits down, pretty much maxing my connection, and I never see any actual stability issues.
I think the system may have some connectivity test that's being interfered with but I haven't had time to go digging through the logs yet, so I wanted to see if anyone else had done what I did to trigger it first.
Seems to be two different issues being discussed here without really differentiating the two... the OP states that he is always getting the notification and "can't pull any data over wifi" ... others are saying they are getting the notification without really stating if it is affecting their overall wifi performance at all.
I'm on AT&T DSL... I was getting the notification ALL THE TIME while using the supplied (4 year old) AT&T 2Wire router and it would fail and freeze and disconnect and it was DRIVING ME NUTS... so i went out and got a brand new Netgear N300 router and problem is solved ... mostly
I'm still using the AT&T 2Wire as a modem... disabled it's internal wifi... ethernet cable to the Netgear. .. and BINGO!!! All my connection problems and data problems have gone away... i still get the unstable notification maybe once or twice a week but i figure that's a DSL thing... any little glitches in Internet availability will be detected by the device and displayed so that doesn't bother me at all.
It's almost like this phone does ping tests all the time and if one doesn't come back properly it throws the notification...
i was at a friends house the other day and was getting the notification constantly but was still able to watch YouTube videos and Netflix without much problem... so i did some speed tests on his wifi and his ping and upload were all over the place... His download speed was solid between 20 and 28 but his upload was never even close to normal and failed several times... and his ping was good on some and took forever on others... i also noticed Web pages would sometimes take forever to start loading ... Once they started loading they did so quickly but the start was painfully slow a lot of the time... This would indicate to me that the ping or upload connection has issues or maybe over congested on his iSP.
Anyway... hope this helps others iron things out
b00mb00mchuck said:
Seems to be two different issues being discussed here without really differentiating the two... the OP states that he is always getting the notification and "can't pull any data over wifi" ... others are saying they are getting the notification without really stating if it is affecting their overall wifi performance at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When I get the notification, it refuses to use the wifi at all.
I haven't noticed any problems with my WiFi. I host 6 wireless networks, and play with WiFi a lot, War driving, and wireless network setup is a hobby of mine.
One thing I noticed at several throttled Hot Spots My VZW note 3 would test the WiFi speed, if it was slower than 4G it would display a popup, something to the effect "Wireless too slow, using mobile Data" I can't remember the exact popup text. It might be a VZW thing.
I use the OOKLA speedtest, free from the play store. (After you run your OOKLA test, for fun drag the speedometer down to reveal some cool messages about Ookla!
A few wireless router settings I use:
Set 2.4 to N 20 Megs max. N 40 or AC mostly just creates problems with connections, and the neighborhood.
Channels 1, 6, or 11 in USA Use a WiFi analyzer app and pick a less cluttered WiFi channel.
Place wireless router up high away from electronics, construction, and stuffs. Mine is on a pedestal in a window.
SM-N900V DE Running JellyBeans V6
radionerd said:
One thing I noticed at several throttled Hot Spots My VZW note 3 would test the WiFi speed, if it was slower than 4G it would display a popup, something to the effect "Wireless too slow, using mobile Data" I can't remember the exact popup text. It might be a VZW thing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Go to WiFi settings/advanced/auto network switch... and turn that off so it won't jump off slow WiFi networks
b00mb00mchuck said:
Go to WiFi settings/advanced/auto network switch... and turn that off so it won't jump off slow WiFi networks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks,
I just tested "auto network switch" on and then off. It let me connect to one of my throttled networks, without; "Checking quality of internet connection".
I noticed that it only showed; "network disabled because internet connection is slow" on the congested 2.4 GHz band, not with same router on 5.8 GHz.
Radio interference, location, and router settings, can cause many problems on wireless networks.
b00mb00mchuck said:
Seems to be two different issues being discussed here without really differentiating the two... the OP states that he is always getting the notification and "can't pull any data over wifi" ... others are saying they are getting the notification without really stating if it is affecting their overall wifi performance at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're right, I noticed in my research that multiple issues seem to be getting lumped together. I think you're correct in that it's related to the router as well, somehow. I see the notification occasionally on slow hotel connections, but it's intermittent, my problem at home seems permanent. I can use some other wifi networks without problems, though.
That said, I used this phone on my home router for a couple months before ever seeing this problem. I'm guessing it's a combination of the 12/17 OTA update, and particular router models.
Verizon sent me a replacement phone, and it's running the previous build (MJ7 instead of MJE). I'll check things out tonight, and will report back.
Alright, the issue seems resolved on the new phone. This seems to suggest that it is related to the MJE build. So far this phone hasn't asked for an update, but I'm hoping Verizon doesn't break this again for me
I've had the International HTC one Max for about 4 days so far.I've noticed extreamly bad Wi-Fi reception. In places where my old Razr had 2-3 signal bars, I can't even connect to my wifi. While standing right next to the router I have about 3 bars, and I have more when I turn the phone around the other way. I've turned of WiFi optimization, factory reset my router and phone, even got a new router. I need some help with getting the WiFi to work. Any tips will be helpful. I'm running stock, unrooted sense 6 with android 4.4.2. Any easy way to fix this?
Excudent said:
I've had the International HTC one Max for about 4 days so far.I've noticed extreamly bad Wi-Fi reception. In places where my old Razr had 2-3 signal bars, I can't even connect to my wifi. While standing right next to the router I have about 3 bars, and I have more when I turn the phone around the other way. I've turned of WiFi optimization, factory reset my router and phone, even got a new router. I need some help with getting the WiFi to work. Any tips will be helpful. I'm running stock, unrooted sense 6 with android 4.4.2. Any easy way to fix this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The fact that you reset the router, bought a new router, and reset the phone, leads me to believe its a hardware issue with the wireless card in the phone. To test this, can you connect to other wireless routers say at a coffee shop or friends house?
After playing around with my phone for a while, im pretty sure its fixed. Not sure if it was s-off that helped, or taking the phone apart.