Related
I know questions have been asked. And I realize all have their favorite cases. I am suggesting this thread as a "clearing house" of cases that definitely work with the car dock. If users could post links (and maybe photos) of these cases, I'm sure myself and many others would appreciate it.
I'm about to ramble a bit, sorry if I get a little off topic here and there...
I generally stick with skins, because with my EVO thats all that would work the car dock. With this new dock, the Photon can have a smallish case and still work with the dock if the insert is removed. I like that forward thinking from Moto regarding this, and the design of the dock is way better than the HTC one for the EVO. I also like how the skin will protect from a lot of things but add no bulk.
I just got in a number of skins from Phantom Skinz, and applied one to my Photon today. Overall, I like the product. It does make it a tad hard to get out of the dock with the insert in, because the skin material has a slight give to it (a soft plastic vs rigid). I wish that they included a little spray bottle, like ones I got from Body Guardz. They say to get a cup of warm water, add a touch of soap to it and dunk the skins into it. its hard to get just right, i ended up having a bit too much soap i think and theres some bubbles underneath that I dont think will go away. The fit of these skins is great. I've used some that are just a hair too big, and they end up snagging on things because they overhang. the corners where the skin wraps around the unit did have to be tweaked a bit: i had to ttrim a little off and make wider v cuts to make sure it didnt bunch up. There is a skin section for every side of the Photon, including the camera section. it doesnt cover the lens, and the fact that they had a piece for it impressed me. I would recommend this to anyone who likes the skin style protectors, but only if you're quite patient.
http://phantomskinz.com/motorolaphoton4g.aspx
This thread is a good idea. I can tell you that the case and holster that is sold by sprint does not fit, but only slightly contacts the material around the connector. I may trim it to see if I can get it to fit easily.
I can confirm that the OtterBox Commuter does not work. Also, even the little cheapo hard shell snap together cases do not work.
Incipio Feather Hard Case for Motorola Photon 4G
Hi all,
I recently purchased an Incipio Feather Slim hard case for my Photon 4G and so far it does seem to work with the car dock, though I had to add a little foamy tape on the right side of the dock so the phone would sit straight when it is in the dock, incidentally I am not using the insert that came with the dock, the website is myincipio dot com.
Problem is, I cannot find a classy leather horizontal case that will accommodate the phone with the Feather case on; everything I have been able to find so far looks cheap and flimsy not to mention too small. I guess one real advantage to sticking with an iPhone is that the after market accessory options available are so vast that if one just keeps looking for what they want they will most likely find it. Anyway, my 2 cents.
TPU cases don't work
I picked up a "TPU" case via eBay (pic attached). It's similar to the silicone skins except the material is a little stiffer and has a glossy finish (which I prefer).
Without the insert, the phone does fit physically in the dock, but the contact with the dock connector is poor. I may need to do what h8zgray wrote and that is to put some kind of pad on the right side of the dock to help hold up the phone. I think I have some left over weatherstripping I could use...
For the time being, I'm using an Arkon Mega Grip mount in my car.
I found it ironic that the dock doesn't work with some of the "official" Sprint cases, like the gray plastic two-piece case.
I hope someone can find a good case that will fit.
Update: Another member posted a comment in another thread that enlarging the notch surrounding the USB/microHDMI port could help make cases fit the car dock. There's a raised area in the dock surrounding the USB connector. I took a second TPU case and enlarged the opening for the USB/microHDMI ports and that made the case work in the dock. The connection is a little loose but I think adding a thin strip of padding to the right side of the dock might help keep the phone and case stable. So the stock TPU case won't work without this modification.
Purchased the SiKai MicroFiber case for the Lenovo IdeaPad K1 Tablet. Delivery was within the UK and didn't take too long, about 5 days including the weekend.
I paid £15.19 delivered from Ebay UK Item number: 200647561882
The case is made from a strange type of plastic material, it's quite soft and flexible. Am kind of glad rather than faux leather. It is very thin and light, but seems sturdy enough to protect the tablet around the house. I have a 10" netbook bag that I keep it in when travelling to add extra protection.
I like it since it makes it easy to carry around with you and doesn't add bulk to it. I would say the case is lighter than my official HP Touchpad case and similar in strength, although a different material. I can only compare it to the ROOCASE Multi-Angle Leather Case and can say it is much thinner and lighter than that.
There is only one angle that the case allows for, but since it is an Android tablet you can flip the whole thing round and get a lower angle. Its fine for watching at night when streaming video so its not an issue for me.
Price wise the only options available to me at the time were the faux leather ones for about £9.99 or the official case from the Lenovo website coming in at a hefty £34.99 once you add the crazy £10 delivery charge! Not many options in the UK unfortunately but am glad I did some research and found this case.
Other things that you might notice in the photos (sorry poor camera phone ones) there is a place to put a pen, all cut outs seem correct and I love the fact that I can charge it without having the case open, also the hdmi port is free.
Not sure how long it will last but considering the few days usage of it, the minor things like the tablet can slide a tiny bit inside the case so would have preferred a tighter fit (although will try and adjust the velcro again that closes once you slip the tablet inside), the cut out by the front facing button could be a bit lower, and the magnetic clasps to be quite weak I will give this case an 8/10 and can recommend it.
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/SiKai-MicroFiber-case-Lenovo-IdeaPad-Tablet-K1-case-/200647561882
great case! I bought this sikai case too and actually prefer it more than the original lenovo K1 case.
This covers all ports, and also has a great microfiber texture that is slightly grippy, while remaining smooth to the touch. does not attract dust at all and keeps the K1 snug (if it feels loose, readjust the velcro tighter).
recommended!
Yeh have tightened it a bit more, doesn't move as much.... Glad I chose this over the cheaper cases and the official one which was more than double the cost here in the UK.
Can't believe how dead this forum is for this tablet, going to see if there are anymore forums with more support....
Just got this tab last week and love it so far. Looking for a good case but hate the leather, faux leather look.
Please let me know if you find more forums as I have looked and am surprised how little I've found....
I know of one other decent one, google "lenovo community K1"
viggs74 said:
Just got this tab last week and love it so far. Looking for a good case but hate the leather, faux leather look.
Please let me know if you find more forums as I have looked and am surprised how little I've found....
I know of one other decent one, google "lenovo community K1"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cool will do.
This case is pretty good if you want something thin and light, there are stronger/more protective cases out there but they add bulk and I don't want that since I use this round the house...... Still glad I bought this case and find it better in that respect to the Roocase.....
Thanks, will google what you said.....
Got the SiKai for my TPT. Everyting else looks bulky in comparison. It is extremely thin (I''ve tried a lot of gadget cases over the years), and although it's screamingly vinyl, it doesn't look really cheap since it fits so well. Leather like this might come off as over-the-top (not that I wouldn't probably sucker into that if I could find it). It's got the seam around the edge where it cushions a drop, and the magnetic closure on the flap is a great touch, not too powerful, but it stays closed well enough.
My gripes are with the screen cover flap: it leaves two stripes on my matte screen protector where the fold places rub off the grease I thought I cleaned off last night, it doesn't hold the tablet vertical enough to really use, and it's busy looking on the front. If I had a choice in the design, I would leave off the "stand" capabilities and leave it flat. If it's open, it's really floppy; it would be easier to manage if it were entirely rigid. I might add a hide-able tether & a knob/button so you could stand it up on its other edge more vertically instead.
All in all, for the price I paid (US$26-ish), I'm very happy with it. If Piel Frama comes up with something, though, I might check that out, if only to drool. I still love my old Wizard case, and my Advantage case from them, too. Very lovely, solid product, and they've been keeping customers happy for a long time.
Addendum: After a couple of months with it, mine is holding together just fine. I had to trim a bit of vinyl fringe, butvall vinyl does that ( it frays a bit after it's freshly cut, but after you trim it once, unless it's cut really crooked, you're done). I have noticed that after a bit of stretching from the daily+ in & out I do to use the dock, it's loose enough to partially obscure the rear camera, not to mention trying to take pics with the flap cover is a huge PITA. If I used this camera a lot, I'd be totally fed up with this case. I may also be melting a bigger hole for the speaker (whch is hard-core disappointing to begin with). All in all, though, that's it for my complaints, which is pretty rare for me.I plan on cloud storage sync and a great cam on my next phone to use the tab for pviewing,
To be fair the official HP Touchpad case does the same thing to my Touchpad so it's one of those things.
I use the same case for my Thinkpad Tablet, and it's the best I've encountered so far, albeit with some flaws of it's own: Some of the stitching on the inside of the cover is already beginning to fall apart after ~1 Month of usage :-/
Stitching has been fine on mine, maybe tell the reseller to exchange it?
Wow cool.... but its little bit expensive
I took my device out of my Caseen case in order to do my downgrade/root...yes I know I didn't need to take it out, but I did.
I forgot how light and nice it is to have such a thin device. It got me thinking that I might not want to use a case that often. What do you think?
I'm a kind of a no case guy, but since it is my favorite expensive toy I'm going to try to keep it in the case as much as possible. The good thing about cases like the one you have, is that it is wonderful to use when you are on a flat surface, no need to hold the tablet or break your neck looking straight down.
I think the answer is both. For home use, I prefer not to have it in a case, enjoy the tablet for what it is. If you plan on taking it on a trip or to work, then put it in a case for that extra protection.
I plan on getting one of the ones posted in another thread where it holds both tablet and dock but other than that, no. I would but it would be annoying having it on and off to use the dock
The best case is the keyboard dock
Sent from my SGH-T989 using XDA
I just got the 300 and I'm loving it. I agree that the best case is the dock but it worries me that some people have posted about the screen getting cracked when docked. I wonder if this happens when you put the tab with the keyboard in a bag and pressure is applied to the screen. If you read the tf201 forums some users have attached rubber or silicone bumpers to the dock to spread the pressure along more points. As for me I'm going to add the silicone bumpers and leave it docked. My ideal case would be a snap on hard plastic case for the back of the tab and leave it docked so that the back is protected by the case and the screen by the dock. I have yet to see a snap on case for the 300
I'm thinking of buying the Roocase or the Poetic case and cutting off the case in half so I can then use the part that covers the back only and leave the tab docked. Not sure how it will look but its the only way I can think of getting what I want.
I don't like cases. I got a good bag to carry it around in. When it's in my hands I want it as light as possible. Ruins the comfort and functionality of having a tablet if you increase the weight with a case, IMO.
^^^^^yup
Il just get a carrying bag
Sent from my SGH-T989 using XDA
No.. no case! This light, thin tablet placed in ugly thick case..
Agree with Raul69.atl, best case is dock and just take care of device)
The main reason I get the case is to use it as a kickstand for watching movies or if i using at a table or desk. but i got one thats fairly easy to take out, so if I'm carrying it around the house, I take it out.
I ended up just encasing mine with Armorsuit gear and carrying it around like that. I much prefer it without the case. I would like a stand though. Any suggestions for a stand?
churraman said:
I just got the 300 and I'm loving it. I agree that the best case is the dock but it worries me that some people have posted about the screen getting cracked when docked. I wonder if this happens when you put the tab with the keyboard in a bag and pressure is applied to the screen. If you read the tf201 forums some users have attached rubber or silicone bumpers to the dock to spread the pressure along more points. As for me I'm going to add the silicone bumpers and leave it docked. My ideal case would be a snap on hard plastic case for the back of the tab and leave it docked so that the back is protected by the case and the screen by the dock. I have yet to see a snap on case for the 300
I'm thinking of buying the Roocase or the Poetic case and cutting off the case in half so I can then use the part that covers the back only and leave the tab docked. Not sure how it will look but its the only way I can think of getting what I want.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, there were some screen cracking issues with the Prime but that was a fault of a bad weight and pressure distribution when docked. If you compare the two docks side-by-side, you can tell that ASUS redesigned the TF300's so as not to have that problem. and as for a case I love sleeves. exactly like those laptop sleeves that lots of people get, but in 10" size. thats what I recommend.
Sent from my ASUS Transformer Pad TF300T
Case = Piece of mind for me since I am so clumsy. I also agree that it is good to use as a stand for movies and surfing.
I went back and fourth myself over this issue. What I ended up doing with my 7” HTC Evo View 4G tablet was to get a case that's just the plastic part of the 360° style case, without the big hole in the middle to rotate of course. It's lightweight yet protects the corners and back. I'm hoping that type of case will be available by the time my red TF gets here.
Sent from my Sprint Evo View 4G (PG41200) using Xparent Purple Tapatalk 2
With case! It's a €400,- device and would hate to get it broke or lots of scratches on it. But depends which kind of case because you got really thick ones which I think dont hold as good. The thin ones I think are better.
A advantage of a case (not all of them) is that you can use it as a stand for the tablet.
If you want to use it without a case but want to store it safely, why not use a 10" sleeve.
I just use a sleeve. Its easiest, and unless I get an otterbox like case this thing is gonna break if I drop it anyways. I just use sleeves and padding for when its in my bag
I love how sleek my TF300 is and I tried a couple of different cases but did not like the bulk they added. I agree that the keyboard dock is the best solution for docking and I bought one of those sleeves from Amazon and use it when i have to carry it around.
i just purchased a moko case and let me tell you. when i was on a plane flying back home from NTC, i wish i had done so sooner. lol
I actually went a few days without a case when i first got my Pad....i usually dont use a case for any devices as i am usually VERY careful with them. however, the Pad almost seemed to thin and light without a case and i was always very scared of dropping it. day 1, walking from my work to my car, i had a death grip on the thing...lol
needless to say, i got a case (moko slim multi-angle one off amazon for $15...well worth the $$ IMO) and it has been great. Gives that extra protection when i want it, a great multi-angle stand for watching videos or normal use (placed it on my lap and browsed with it last night) and it is actually fairly thin and light still. even without it on the "stand" it is easier to hold due to the grooves on the back.
it's so nice i may never take it out of the case again....especially since i have Tile floors throughout my entire house....lol
Sure glad I had a case on mine when my 2 year old threw it straight down onto the hard wood floor the other day! It's a Moko case.
So my Poetic cases arrives today, bought 2 of them. Looking at them, they are really nice. Putting the Tablet in the case looked nice and all the holes lines up perfect, I was able to charge the tablet while in the case with no issues. This is "almost" the perfect case with one major flaw, the hand strap inside is too thick and when you snap the case closed, and open it after a minute, it leaves a really bad impression in your screen from the hand strap. Lucky I have a screen guard on so I am pretty sure it did not damage the actual screen. Also, due to the hand strap the case will not lay flush when closed. My wife and I are really disappointed, it was almost the perfect case. When already contacted the seller and are going to try and send them back.
Shame you have to send it back, but anything that messes with a tablet's screen is definitely a no go!
Just a quick update, we bought them through Amazon, but it was a reseller we actually bough them from. Returning them sounded like a pain, so we decided it was not worth our time. What we did was used a sewing stitch remover and removed the sticking around from the hand strap and removed the hand strap. The case actually works pretty well now. If I have time tonight, I will take picture of before and after (we have only modified one case so far, but plan to do the other).
jericko said:
Just a quick update, we bought them through Amazon, but it was a reseller we actually bough them from. Returning them sounded like a pain, so we decided it was not worth our time. What we did was used a sewing stitch remover and removed the sticking around from the hand strap and removed the hand strap. The case actually works pretty well now. If I have time tonight, I will take picture of before and after (we have only modified one case so far, but plan to do the other).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Id def like to see pics if you get a chance please. Thinking about ordering and removing the hand strap as well. Was going to order the Moko one which is the same minus the strap but the in stock date keeps getting pushed back
I have the same case, and the same issue. I wrote a review here about the case and the strap. I also dont like the strap, as a matter of fact I have the same case for my Galaxy tab also, and the strap left an indention into the screen protector so I stopped using it. There are a few cases exactly like it that dont have the strap. Moko, Blurex, and a Minisuit, but the Minisuit one is not available until June 13th, but I highly recommend the Minisuit, after the issue with the poetic case on my galaxy Tab I bought the Minisuit without the strap and its the only case I use now. Im going to order one of the one listed here because I now have the exact same screen protector on my 300 and I dont want to handstrap the damage it.
Moko Case
I have the moko case from amazon. It works great. Fairly lightweight, yet feels very solid. Kickstand works great. The onlyslight problem is if you want to charge it while it is standing up, you have to put it in upside down, and the camera is blocked. But this is mainly ASUS's fault and it works perfect otherwise.
I ended up pitching these cases in the trash. I though removing the handstrap would make this a great case, but I took it out last night and noticed where one of the hooks are the screen and plastic is marred. Funny I bough a case to keep my tablet in pristine shape and this cases is what has caused my Damage.
Gam3r 4 Life said:
I have the same case, and the same issue. I wrote a review here about the case and the strap. I also dont like the strap, as a matter of fact I have the same case for my Galaxy tab also, and the strap left an indention into the screen protector so I stopped using it. There are a few cases exactly like it that dont have the strap. Moko, Blurex, and a Minisuit, but the Minisuit one is not available until June 13th, but I highly recommend the Minisuit, after the issue with the poetic case on my galaxy Tab I bought the Minisuit without the strap and its the only case I use now. Im going to order one of the one listed here because I now have the exact same screen protector on my 300 and I dont want to handstrap the damage it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
oh the MoKo one looks lovely.
i'll perhaps hang on for that Minisuit
which moko case will fit the tf300T?
r3skyline said:
which moko case will fit the tf300T?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can't post links, but if you go to amazon and type 'tf300t moko' you get a few results
dang....shipping isnt fast enough. oh well. looks like i gotta wait a month, lol
I just got this case this morning and Im impressed to be honest.. but I dont know how the hand strap was making marks on your screen due to the fact on mine it is snug when closed but the strap isnt touching the screen
T_VASS said:
I just got this case this morning and Im impressed to be honest.. but I dont know how the hand strap was making marks on your screen due to the fact on mine it is snug when closed but the strap isnt touching the screen
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wow. I cant see how it doesnt touch on yours. It so tight on mine it bulges out where the strap is. I ended up removing the strap, didnt like it so I ordered this blurex one here that is the same kind minus the strap.
Gam3r 4 Life said:
Wow. I cant see how it doesnt touch on yours. It so tight on mine it bulges out where the strap is. I ended up removing the strap, didnt like it so I ordered this blurex one here that is the same kind minus the strap.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Same issue, the case would bulge where the hand strap was, and when it was closed for a hour or more, when I opened the case, I could literally see indentations of where the stitching was and the line of the hand strap on my screen guard.
jericko said:
Same issue, the case would bulge where the hand strap was, and when it was closed for a hour or more, when I opened the case, I could literally see indentations of where the stitching was and the line of the hand strap on my screen guard.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That is exactly what happened on my Galaxy Tab 7.7, thankfully the marks went away. But the bulge was always there, and caused a lot more pressure on the screen. My Blurex is out for delivery today. Ill update with pics later.
I havent even closed it with the case on for Id say no more than 30 mins as its either on the dock or I have it propped open with the case. When its making marks on your screen are these naked screens or do you have a screen protector on them?
I have a screen guard, one of invisible shield types where you apply them wet.
T_VASS said:
I havent even closed it with the case on for Id say no more than 30 mins as its either on the dock or I have it propped open with the case. When its making marks on your screen are these naked screens or do you have a screen protector on them?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On mine it was with a XtremeGuard screen protector. Which is basically a cheaper Zagg.
Got my Blurex case today. Its nice, but Im thinking I might return it. I know things are usually tight when you first get them, but this is too tight. I had to push VERY hard to get the snap to close, and when it did it separated the trim from the case. The hook is just way too tight and should have been angled a little different so its not so hard to close. Take a look at the pic and youll see the snap hook Im talking about. And it wasnt just the closing hook, but all the others were very tight, without a lot of insulation/ padding which makes me think in time it will start scuffing the paint on the outer trim. The poetic case that I just got is the exact same style but has the hand strap, but it wasnt even close to as hard to snap in as this Blurex.
I really love these type of cases, but Im thinking I might have to go with a different style on my 300. I hate the look, but maybe one like this. Or Ill give this type one more try with the Minisuit case coming out on the 13th. I have a Minisuit just like it on my Galaxy Tab 7.7 and love it..
UPDATE: I was able to bend most of the tabs so that they arent so tight, but before I bent them I took a pic (pic#2)to show the difference in the hook from the Blurex case (top), and the Poetic case (bottom). If you look you can see that the poetic case is more round, and the Blurex has a sharper angle. This is why it was causing the bezel to pop off. But using my thumbs I was able to bend it enough that it doesnt pop it off, and closes ok now. I dont know if this was just mine, or if all the blurex cases do this. Added a few more pics as well.
Gam3r, I too like the "snap in" type cases. There doesn't seem to be a huge difference in quality from what I can see. Do you have any insight you'd like to share from the ones you have?
Got myself an Xperia tablet z yesterday and love it, however I'm not a fan of the usb charging flap, so I have just decided to splash out £30 and buy a sgp-ds5 so I can simply slide my tablet in over night and charge without messing about
I'm looking for a case that can remain on, but still allow me to use the dock, I have a few simple needs from the case.
Protection is low down on my list, my tablet will never leave the house, the case is actually more of a stand, I am looking for a case that works as a great stand when I sit down and have the tablet on my lap.I never use the tablet at a table,I just use it when sitting on the couch or when laying in bed, I am looking for a stand that holds the tablet at a nice angel whilst on my lap?
The other thing is price I want one at a reasonable price, I like the official case, but it's silly money for me.
I see a lot about the poetic case, does it fit in the dock? Also the way it works as a stand, doesn't look like it would work well on a lap, looks like it works fine on a table, but as I said I never sit at a table.
Thanks
dougie175 said:
Got myself an Xperia tablet z yesterday and love it, however I'm not a fan of the usb charging flap, so I have just decided to splash out £30 and buy a sgp-ds5 so I can simply slide my tablet in over night and charge without messing about I'm looking for a case that can remain on, but still allow me to use the dock, I have a few simple needs from the case. Protection is low down on my list, my tablet will never leave the house, the case is actually more of a stand, I am looking for a case that works as a great stand when I sit down and have the tablet on my lap.I never use the tablet at a table,I just use it when sitting on the couch or when laying in bed, I am looking for a stand that holds the tablet at a nice angel whilst on my lap? The other thing is price I want one at a reasonable price, I like the official case, but it's silly money for me. I see a lot about the poetic case, does it fit in the dock? Also the way it works as a stand, doesn't look like it would work well on a lap, looks like it works fine on a table, but as I said I never sit at a table. Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The only case I know of that can remain on the XTZ when sitting it in the charging cradle is Sony's XTZ case. I own the XTZ case and I found that even though the XTZ fit in the cradle with the case on, it was not really practical. I also own three other cases (currently using a Poetic case) which require the case to be removed before placing the XTZ in the cradle. But that is not a problem for me. It only takes a few seconds to remove the XTZ from its case or to put it back into its case. I also feel charging the XTZ with its case removed allows the XTZ to better dissipate the heat caused by the charging, which is a good thing.
Cat McGowan said:
The only case I know of that can remain on the XTZ when sitting it in the charging cradle is Sony's XTZ case. I own the XTZ case and I found that even though the XTZ fit in the cradle with the case on, it was not really practical. I also own three other cases (currently using a Poetic case) which require the case to be removed before placing the XTZ in the cradle. But that is not a problem for me. It only takes a few seconds to remove the XTZ from its case or to put it back into its case. I also feel charging the XTZ with its case removed allows the XTZ to better dissipate the heat caused by the charging, which is a good thing.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the reply, when you say the genuine xtz case fit the charger but was not practical can you please explain that a little for me? Do you just mean not practical in the great dissipation sense? Or for another reason?
I would agree keeping any electrical device cooler rather than letting it get warm is always a good thing, but Sony seem to recommend using both accessories together and have designed the 2 to work together, so you would hope the tablet would still be well within its safe heat tolerances when using the case and dock?
The xtz case seems almost perfect for myself, it looks very sturdy to use to prop the tablet on my lap, it fits the charger, it is the lightest and thinnest case I believe?
Just the price really puts me off, £55 is a lot of money compared to most cases
If I went for the nice budget poetic case, and just removed it to charge, would the poetic case hold the tablet at a decent angle on my lap and be nice and steady without me having to hold the tablet firm? Or am I asking too much of any case to so that? Seems like most are just designed to sit on a table and play a movie, but I am trying to help get my tablet sat at the correct viewing angle for surfing whilst on my lap without the need for me to touch it, much like a laptop would.
Thanks
dougie175 said:
Thanks for the reply, when you say the genuine xtz case fit the charger but was not practical can you please explain that a little for me? Do you just mean not practical in the great dissipation sense? Or for another reason?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
For another reason. When the XTZ is placed in the cradle with the Sony case on it, the case's front cover must be fully opened and folded towards the rear of the tablet and the case's rear cover must be pulled slightly away from the lower part of the XTZ so it will slide into the cradle. The part about the case's rear cover is not a problem, but the case's front cover wants to lie flat on my desk's top, which means a lot of clear area is needed behind the cradle and on my desk's crowded top, that is a not practical. So, it is better for me to slide the XTZ out of the case when I want to place it in the cradle. Again, the XTZ quickly and easily slides into and out of the case, so that is not a problem for me.
dougie175 said:
I would agree keeping any electrical device cooler rather than letting it get warm is always a good thing, but Sony seem to recommend using both accessories together and have designed the 2 to work together, so you would hope the tablet would still be well within its safe heat tolerances when using the case and dock?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree; however, having worked with electronic devices for more than 40 years and knowing heat is their enemy, an enemy that will shorten their life, I tend to give concern to heat dissipation. It is a choice from experience to keep my XTZ as cool as possible.
dougie175 said:
The xtz case seems almost perfect for myself, it looks very sturdy to use to prop the tablet on my lap, it fits the charger, it is the lightest and thinnest case I believe? Just the price really puts me off, £55 is a lot of money compared to most cases
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Sony case is a nice looking, sturdy case. The problem I had with it was the ugly elastic band that holds the case closed. The case will not remain closed without the band because the case does not have a magnet in its front cover like the Poetic and other cases do. The band also caused a notch to be formed on the long edge of the case which subtracted from the case's nice look, and the band would occasionally snag on something when I would pull the XTZ from my messenger bag.
dougie175 said:
If I went for the nice budget poetic case, and just removed it to charge, would the poetic case hold the tablet at a decent angle on my lap and be nice and steady without me having to hold the tablet firm? Or am I asking too much of any case to so that? Seems like most are just designed to sit on a table and play a movie, but I am trying to help get my tablet sat at the correct viewing angle for surfing whilst on my lap without the need for me to touch it, much like a laptop would. Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I like the Poetic case even though it only provides three choices of angles for placing the XTZ; (1) right side up (Sony logo at top of XTZ) at 60º (0º being flat on a desk top), (2) up side down (Sony logo at bottom of XTZ) at 30º, and (3) nearly flat on a desk top. I say "nearly flat" because when the case's front cover is folded towards the rear of the XTZ, the front cover will not allow the XTZ to lie perfectly flat. For me, the choice of angles are enough. I mostly used my XTZ at the 60º angle and the case keeps my XTZ fairly firm in place, and I have no problem browsing web sites or watching videos. When I am doing a lot of typing, I use my XTZ at the 30º angle and again the case keeps my XTZ fairly firm in place. The case's front cover has a strong magnet that holds the case securely closed. The magnet is so strong that it also holds the case's front cover against the rear cover when the case is fully folded open. One thing I do not like is the USB port access hole cut into the fold of the case. Not only does the hole subtract from the case's nice look, it also makes folding the case open a little awkward. I wish I had bought the Poetic case before its manufacturer started cutting the hole in the case. The original Poetic cases did not have the hole.
Cat McGowan said:
For another reason. When the XTZ is placed in the cradle with the Sony case on it, the case's front cover must be fully opened and folded towards the rear of the tablet and the case's rear cover must be pulled slightly away from the lower part of the XTZ so it will slide into the cradle. The part about the case's rear cover is not a problem, but the case's front cover wants to lie flat on my desk's top, which means a lot of clear area is needed behind the cradle and on my desk's crowded top, that is a not practical. So, it is better for me to slide the XTZ out of the case when I want to place it in the cradle. Again, the XTZ quickly and easily slides into and out of the case, so that is not a problem for me.
I agree; however, having worked with electronic devices for more than 40 years and knowing heat is their enemy, an enemy that will shorten their life, I tend to give concern to heat dissipation. It is a choice from experience to keep my XTZ as cool as possible.
The Sony case is a nice looking, sturdy case. The problem I had with it was the ugly elastic band that holds the case closed. The case will not remain closed without the band because the case does not have a magnet in its front cover like the Poetic and other cases do. The band also caused a notch to be formed on the long edge of the case which subtracted from the case's nice look, and the band would occasionally snag on something when I would pull the XTZ from my messenger bag.
I like the Poetic case even though it only provides three choices of angles for placing the XTZ; (1) right side up (Sony logo at top of XTZ) at 60º (0º being flat on a desk top), (2) up side down (Sony logo at bottom of XTZ) at 30º, and (3) nearly flat on a desk top. I say "nearly flat" because when the case's front cover is folded towards the rear of the XTZ, the front cover will not allow the XTZ to lie perfectly flat. For me, the choice of angles are enough. I mostly used my XTZ at the 60º angle and the case keeps my XTZ fairly firm in place, and I have no problem browsing web sites or watching videos. When I am doing a lot of typing, I use my XTZ at the 30º angle and again the case keeps my XTZ fairly firm in place. The case's front cover has a strong magnet that holds the case securely closed. The magnet is so strong that it also holds the case's front cover against the rear cover when the case is fully folded open. One thing I do not like is the USB port access hole cut into the fold of the case. Not only does the hole subtract from the case's nice look, it also makes folding the case open a little awkward. I wish I had bought the Poetic case before its manufacturer started cutting the hole in the case. The original Poetic cases did not have the hole.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for taking your time write such an in depth reply, the fact that the Sony case requires so much room has totally out me off that one. Thanks for pointing that out to me. So a case that it's easily removed would be the next best option for me I guess, which you have confirmed the poetic it's simple to click in and out.
Thanks again for explaining the angle functions of the case, can you just confirm the case works well when using it as a stand on your lap? It is a major concern to me and the only thing stopping me buying the poetic really. Thanks
dougie175 said:
Thanks again for explaining the angle functions of the case, can you just confirm the case works well when using it as a stand on your lap? It is a major concern to me and the only thing stopping me buying the poetic really. Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I cannot honestly comment on how well the case will work standing on your lap because I rarely place my XTZ on my lap, but when I do, I have the case fully folded open with the XTZ lying flat.
Cat McGowan said:
I cannot honestly comment on how well the case will work standing on your lap because I rarely place my XTZ on my lap, but when I do, I have the case fully folded open with the XTZ lying flat.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok no worries, thanks for all the help. Guess I'll just have to buy one and see if it's fits my needs, at least they are reasonable money even if it isn't right.
Try too look on amazon you will see a lot of different cases. I have the cradle and the sony case I have no problem using both togethrre at all.
Sent from my SGP312 using xda app-developers app
mrlokoo said:
Try too look on amazon you will see a lot of different cases. I have the cradle and the sony case I have no problem using both togethrre at all.
Sent from my SGP312 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks I've spent hours on Amazon and eBay looking at cases I've gone for a roxfit Sony one with the 3m double sided tape, to try first, seems like the lightest simple solution for me, that I think will go in the dock with the case tucked behind it!
Yeah so have I. They really didn't make as much covers for it. I dont how that 3m sticky cover looks. I have the slide in cover from Sony. If not go on YouTube and try to see what people have chosen out.
Sent from my LT30at using xda app-developers app
Use the roxfit case, not sure the exact name but its really low profile and the flap is magnetic
almo40192 said:
Use the roxfit case, not sure the exact name but its really low profile and the flap is magnetic
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Roxfit Book Case Ultra for Sony Xperia Z Tablet at Amazon.com for $38.78 USD plus shipping cost. I'm not liking the idea of having to use double-sided adhesive tape to attach a case to a $600 USD tablet.
Cat McGowan said:
Roxfit Book Case Ultra for Sony Xperia Z Tablet at Amazon.com for $38.78 USD plus shipping cost. I'm not liking the idea of having to use double-sided adhesive tape to attach a case to a $600 USD tablet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Op said protection wasn't a concern. Besides, the adhesive is surprisingly good. There is no way the two come apart without extreme force. Mine stays on the dock or in the bedroom so protection wasn't a concern for me either, plus its the slimmest case I've found.
So just buy the sony case, the slide in one or the adhesives type. cause you are looking for the slimmest one. At the same time it looks good having the same namebrand together.
Sent from my SGP312 using xda app-developers app
My dock and roxfit arrived today, after much research I felt the roxfit would be the best for me so ordered one on Sunday.
Works a treat, I have no fear of the adhesive doing any damage. Fits perfectly into the dock very tidy with the cover pinned behind with the magnet.
It is almost the prefect case for me, its only fault is that it tends to slide down if you try and get to much angle on the screen which is a shame, however if you keep it quite upright it works perfect and it's very strong.
Really impressed with how light and tidy this case is, may just look at modifying it to help hold the screen at a lower angle in future if I feel I require it.
Thanks for the help and advice
I've got the same issue, I want to buy the dock but it would mean having to remove the tablet from the case every time, its a tight fit so its quite annoying.
Was hoping there would be a case that would work with the dock (apart from the official one)
http://www.incipio.com/cases/tablet...her-ultra-thin-sony-xperia-tablet-z-case.html
That one looks quite thin, anyone think it'll work with the dock ?
Edit: nvm that one just seems to protect the sides and bottom.
any more successes with finding a case that fits the cradle?
anyone?
Roxfit Case
I have the Roxfit case, and can confirm that it does work with the dock.
Like other users I do find that it can slip down, if trying to use it as a stand, but not a great problem.
My main criticism is that because the front of the case is one rigid piece, when it is folded back, it covers up the camera!
The only way I have found to use it, is to hold it like an open book.
If it were divided into two or three flexible parts,(like an iPad case) it would be possible the fold it back on itself, and so allow the camera to be used.
Has anyone else noticed this problem, or have a solution?
The official Sony 'Natural Rubber' case (SGPCV5) will allow you to dock the tablet but it's pretty messy ... you can hinge the case away from the Xperia and have it folded back and splayed behind the dock.
Not at all ideal but possible if you really want to dock it without taking it out of the case. Personally, I'd only use the case if travelling somewhere with the tablet. At home it doesn't need a case (especially considering that cases add bulk) and since that's where the dock stays, it's never an issue that I want to dock the tablet in the case.