AOSP, Modified Stock or just Stock? - Verizon Samsung Galaxy Note II

Curiosity poll. Also to help me choose my next ROM, since official 4.3 is near.
For all y'all fun people using a Note II-- have you gotten the best mileage out of an AOSP ROM (CM, AOKP, AOSPA etc.), a modified Stock ROM (Jelly'Beans', etc.) or just plain old Samsung 4.1.2? I put AOSPA on my Note II as soon as I got it and have stuck with it mostly, but the prevalence of stock-based ROMs means there must be a point. Does TouchWiz actually bring anything to the table?
Interested to see what anyone says. Thanks!

Dude, these threads are not allowed and this is going to be shut down soon. There is no answer to your question.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 4

^^ This ^^ the answer depends on what each individual users wants and how they use their phone.
Trial and error is the answer, thread closed.

Related

[Q] New ROM Requirements

Greetings,
I don't have the Galaxy Note (yet), but before I pick one up, I've got a few questions about the available ROMS.
1. Which ROM floating around out there is closest to Stock ICS? (I'd be coming from a Galaxy Nexus.)
2. Are there any ROMS that get rid of all the Samsung Custom Apps? Not just TouchWiz, I'll get rid of that with ADWLauncher, but all the customizations that Samsung has done to Messenger, Calendar, etc.
I'm eager to get the Note, but I want to make sure it's easily "De-Samsung-ified" first.
Thanks!
Take a look at:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1640162
[ROM/MOD]The Collective - The Unofficial v2.0 Beta 4 - 5/13/2012
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using xda premium
briand.mooreg said:
Take a look at:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1640162
[ROM/MOD]The Collective - The Unofficial v2.0 Beta 4 - 5/13/2012
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, That does look good, but I'm a bit apprehensive when I see Beta in the title. Is this what you're using? Can you post screenshots of the Messenging and Calendar apps? The Samsung customizations of those really bother me. I know it's nitpicking, I'm a bit anal with my devices...
It comes shipped with the Samsung apps, there is an aosp app ad on within the roms ota feature.
There isn't a true aosp ROM for the note... Yet.
Thanks @studacris @briand.mooreg for the suggestion. Are there any others, I'm looking for a stable, non-beta ROM to use at first, but once I get confortable with the device, I'll play around with it more.
It's only a beta by name alone. because we, the collective, have much more in store for it.
It's stable as a table.
Once we get official ICS, devs are gonna go ALL out on the ROMs. :thumbup:
-Once you go NOTE, you'd say 4 inches a Joke
I think until we get source for ICS, any ROM you see available will claim to be an Alpha or a Beta (at developer's decision).
The reality of the situation is that all of the i717 ICS ROMS are based on a leaked ICS build, not something official.
jpg71 said:
I think until we get source for ICS, any ROM you see available will claim to be an Alpha or a Beta (at developer's decision).
The reality of the situation is that all of the i717 ICS ROMS are based on a leaked ICS build, not something official.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When the source comes out, will it be posted online like Google posts the images for the Nexus devices? I ask because I'm just looking for as Pure an ICS experience as I can get.
I don't even have the Note yet, but I flashed my Galaxy Nexus to AOSP ICS tonight and I'm a bit eager to dive into Android experimenting and maybe eventually cooking up a ROM myself.
Thanks.
try out dagr8s rom its pretty awesome def with the tablet mod
Dude thuer all beta or alpha we have no source codes to make a rc ics rom yet but its coming don't worry and most ics roms out right now are very stable and very nice don't be afraid lol go buy a note and Ice it out
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using Xparent ICS Blue Tapatalk 2

New AT&T User

Hey guys!
I just received my Galaxy Note from AT&T (previously a T-Mobile G2 user), and am wondering about custom ROMs.
I used a MIUI ROM on my G2 with T-Mobile, but am more interested in ICS and the international capabilities of the Note (Premium suite, apps, etc). Do we not get those apps?
Are there any custom ROMs you guys would recommend for a new user?
Thanks!
yesshh said:
Are there any custom ROMs you guys would recommend for a new user?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Start Here:
Get CWM installed - http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1586223
This is the most stock ICS (an a good solid ROM to start with):
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1664980
This is the best (IMHO) of the ICS ROMs. It's due for an update very shortly - but it's the only one to really take advantage of the capability of ICS to handle tablet mode:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1581065
yesshh said:
Hey guys!
I just received my Galaxy Note from AT&T (previously a T-Mobile G2 user), and am wondering about custom ROMs.
I used a MIUI ROM on my G2 with T-Mobile, but am more interested in ICS and the international capabilities of the Note (Premium suite, apps, etc). Do we not get those apps?
Are there any custom ROMs you guys would recommend for a new user?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Team perfections ics is the best ics rom ive tried fjs is ok but scrolling is a mess..if u want to stay on gb saurom 7.1 or emily is the way to go
sent from team perfections ics rom
Deleted due to the fact that I shouldn't have gotten involved. My apologies.
Sent from Galaxy Note
froidroid said:
There's no reason to say anything bad about anyone's rom. If you like apps rom, then say just that. Theres no reason to point out what you think is horrible scrolling. They're both excellent roms and both are very smooth. Go to the threads and read up. Or better yet, try them and see what fits your needs the best.
Sent from Galaxy Note
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's an opinion and we are entitled to it.
Deleted for the same reasons as my 1st post. Again....my apologies. Of course now that both of my posts have been quoted, I guess your stuck with my opinion.:banghead:
Sent from Galaxy Note
froidroid said:
Deleted for the same reasons as my 1st post. Again....my apologies. Of course now that both of my posts have been quoted, I guess your stuck with my opinion.:banghead:
Sent from Galaxy Note
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I understand. I'm not new to ROMs, but I find it easier to ask for opinions than to try flashing endless ROMs. I'm having a hard time believing rooting and all is even worth it. But I'm hoping some of you veteran Note users' will provide me with a little more incentive to flash or keep stock.
I'm sure he meant no disrespect to the developers, and hopefully they take no offense.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using XDA
If you're a fan of baredone then try cm9 or aokp. They are amazingly fast and surprisingly stable.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using xda premium
Check out ONLYONE rom.... includes s-voice and s-note... Its amazingly fast and smooth...
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using xda premium
yesshh said:
I understand. I'm not new to ROMs, but I find it easier to ask for opinions than to try flashing endless ROMs. I'm having a hard time believing rooting and all is even worth it. But I'm hoping some of you veteran Note users' will provide me with a little more incentive to flash or keep stock.
I'm sure he meant no disrespect to the developers, and hopefully they take no offense.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your choice but my opinion is as follows. You have a great device with capabilities far beyond those which it was sold with(GB), so you could stay with your awesome device and never know its "full" potential. Adversely, you could unleash the beast with a little research and gumption... Think portable wireless hotspots and ease of use modifications and custom works allowing you to customize your device. With stock gb it generally takes 2 to 4 more steps to achieve the same goal in custom GB. Same with ICS... These are my opinions and individual experience may vary... Ultimately its up to you how excited about your device you get, and how much research you do to ensure a great experience.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using XDA
tyler79durdan said:
Your choice but my opinion is as follows. You have a great device with capabilities far beyond those which it was sold with(GB), so you could stay with your awesome device and never know its "full" potential. Adversely, you could unleash the beast with a little research and gumption... Think portable wireless hotspots and ease of use modifications and custom works allowing you to customize your device. With stock gb it generally takes 2 to 4 more steps to achieve the same goal in custom GB. Same with ICS... These are my opinions and individual experience may vary... Ultimately its up to you how excited about your device you get, and how much research you do to ensure a great experience.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using XDA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I ended up trying a few, and nothing seemed stable enough. We won't have to wait too much longer for ICS and premium suite I am sure!
I say if you're fine with GB go with unofficial rom. Best laid out in my opinion and with holokernel incredibly fast and smooth. For ics I say forget about your s pen and try cm9. I missed notes at the beginning but with how fluid everything is and problem free of a build this is I try not to think of that plastic pen jammed into my phone and just enjoy ics for what it is and what it should be on any android phone without all the little touches manufacturers throw in trying to make their phone a special snowflake in an industry of special individual snowflakes. Just my two cents anyhow
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using XDA

Verizon Galaxy Note II Development...

I’ve been curious as to why development and rom builds have been so slow to come to the Verizon Galaxy Note II? I look at other carriers and see that they have a more extensive collection of ROMS available and was wondering why?
The reason for thisi is our devs have currently been working out keeping unlocked bootloaders on the latest update for some unfortunate people, And we are just getting started with the roms. FOr the best roms, let the devs work on their own pace.
Ill take quality over quantity any day
Sent from my SCH-I605 using xda app-developers app
richii0207 said:
Ill take quality over quantity any day
Sent from my SCH-I605 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would have to agree. I've been using Clean ROM because I love the 5x6 Launcher. Thanks for the heads up though. I have been tied to the fourms every day just browsing waiting for new ROM releases.
smOBudda said:
I would have to agree. I've been using Clean ROM because I love the 5x6 Launcher. Thanks for the heads up though. I have been tied to the fourms every day just browsing waiting for new ROM releases.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From past experience, I've had a phone with many roms but most of them had their share of bugs which drove me away. I have used Scott's roms before the note 2 and his attention to detail and simplicity is unsurpassed, we are very fortunate to have him. We also are lucky to have CM builds pumping out as my former device waited over a year for just the beta.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using xda app-developers app
Really most OTA ROMS are not all that different.. Sure some have more options etc.. The real fun comes when AOSP is stable..
We just got official CM nightly's as of yesterday.. While there are a few things to work out with kinks here and there, the real fun has just begun...
Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2
It will only improve. Verizon was late to the party with their variant and locked out the bootloader. Nobody is going to develop much on a device with locked bootloader. Also, it is true that devs have been busy helping us noobs.
I didn't think development would even be this fast. This is the best phone on the best carrier, so I assume development will continue. I am sure many people have a GS3 already, so won't be moving to this platform.
Speed up development by donating to a dev.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2
Didn't someone just release a mod that a allows cross carrier roms?! Not to mention aosp is finally getting solid. Patience is a virtue, things are taking off.
I personally think the development on this device has been great. Better than I expected really, given the way Verizon tried to chase away users from this device with stupid things like the branding on the home button. At the end of the day I'm just happy with what we have. Could have been a lot worse without Adam.
If your that bored flash some N7105 base roms. Just don't derp and flash the radios for the other carriers. I am running SkyNote right now.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using xda premium
Can someone point me to the thread where both radio files are? I downloaded VRALL4 but I want to flash the older one. Thanks.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using Tapatalk 2
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2108510
Sent From My Galaxy Note 2
smOBudda said:
I’ve been curious as to why development and rom builds have been so slow to come to the Verizon Galaxy Note II? I look at other carriers and see that they have a more extensive collection of ROMS available and was wondering why?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think one of the reason why is lack of stock functionality. The varieties of AOKP, Baked, CM, AOSP, Miui roms have been extremely popular and successful on other Google devices(varieties of these roms account for more than 50% of entire roms), but apparently not many people demand those roms on Galaxy Note2 because of lack of stock functionality...such as SPen, page buddy, other good motion functions, and etc, etc. I used to be a huge fan of AOKP roms while I was owning Galaxy Nexus, but after switching to GNote2, I never looked back. I wanted more of Samsung experience rather than Google.
dcdgoth said:
I think one of the reason why is lack of stock functionality. The varieties of AOKP, Baked, CM, AOSP roms have been extremely popular and successful on other Google devices(varieties of these roms account for more than 50% of entire roms), but apparently not many people demand those roms on Galaxy Note2 because of lack of stock functionality...such as SPen, page buddy, other good motion functions, and etc, etc. I used to be a huge fan of AOKP roms while I was owning Galaxy Nexus, but after switching to GNote2, I never looked back. I wanted more of Samsung experience rather than Google.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I agree with this. I want to keep most of the stock functionality with the ability to mod. Hence why I love beans rom.

[Q] Any mods similar to FlappJaxxx UCLF6?

** meant to say ROMs and not mods in the title
Hello,
I am one of the few that actually like touchwiz but i also like being able to change roms so i was not really into a bunch of the roms i was trying out until i flashed the flappjaxxx UCLF6 rom. but i wanted to update and it looks like he has stopped working on that project. the rom in am on is IMM76D.UCLF6+FJMod-Build_12
The key parts to why i like this rom are the month view calendar shows text instead of just colored blocks like AOSP month view. and I do like a lot of the contact functionality like long press to send contact info via SMS (instead of a conatact book file) and contact book group messaging. I am assuming this is TouchWiz functionality.
anyway wanted to see if anyone had made a rom similar to the flappjaxxx one that wasn't just a themed or graphics wrapped version of the same rom.
thanks,
nate
Indeed, those are TouchWiz features.
Bigfau has black star
Nunhugger has novena
Both are TouchWiz based ics Roms.
Both offer added features while maintaining the features of TouchWiz.
both of those developers along with myself are on of the development team that flappjaxx is a part of as well.
Flapp is taking some time off developing to pursue his professional career.
And now you're in luck, AT&T just released a jellybean update of TouchWiz, Bigfau and nunhugger will be working to update black star to this new firmware.
Thanks! What rom do you endorse personally?
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using Tapatalk 2
I personally like novena, but I was running aosp builds of another of our team members Rom "gubment cheeze" then hopped onto novena to help out and test.
Black star was being developed at the same time as cheeze and at that time I wasn't wanting TouchWiz so I kinda passed that one by,
but as I said in my previous, that's being updated to the jelly bean TouchWiz firmware that was dropped Thursday. So that's what I'd be keeping my eyes on.
You rule, this is the exact information I was looking for
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using Tapatalk 2
Yes. This is the information I was looking for.. Do you think that any of these roms thas comming out will have pieces of sg4 on it like the ultimate rom for n7000
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using xda app-developers app

[Q] Developers and Android 4.3.0

Hello.
1. Are there some devs here that that already have JB roms like 4.1.2 and 4.2.2 and are now working on building a 4.3.0 rom?
I do know that CM 10.2 it out in early stage.
Don´t know if dews want to keep unreleased work a secret, but it would be nice to know if some recognized devs are at least planning on a rom based on 4.3.0 for our SGS2
2. What advantages and features/new things can we expect with 4.3.0?
Thanks for answers
Tesla said:
Hello.
1. Are there some devs here that that already have JB roms like 4.1.2 and 4.2.2 and are now working on building a 4.3.0 rom?
I do know that CM 10.2 it out in early stage.
Don´t know if dews want to keep unreleased work a secret, but it would be nice to know if some recognized devs are at least planning on a rom based on 4.3.0 for our SGS2
2. What advantages and futures/new things can we expect with 4.3.0?
Thanks for answers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
features such as restricted user profiles (only on tablets), Bluetooth Low Energy profile, virtual surround sound, autocomplete for dialpad, improved keyboard, OpenGL ES 3.0 support and a handful of other things
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1529173
Think about it this way...You're a developer; the SGS2 was released >2 yrs ago & has been superceded twice (and will likely be superceded again within 12 mths), why would you bother putting yourself through the kind of grief you go through (as a result of Samsung's stupidity with sources) everytime a new Android version is released yet again for a phone 3x superceded ?
Answer - very few devs would bother. If I were one, I would have moved on from the SGS2 12 mths ago.
Moderator please close this thread
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
stopro said:
Moderator please close this thread
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why close it? At least give me a reason thank you.
@MistahBungle
I get your point.
But the other roms live on. It´s still has a large amount of users in the world.
Why not do it just for fun? That it can be done? The dev still use a SGS2?
I can think of many reasons to do a rom based on 4.3.0.
Custom 4.3 ? Yes there's a few sorting this as we speak. Some are in testing now. Read threads mate.
andrewwright said:
Custom 4.3 ? Yes there's a few sorting this as we speak. Some are in testing now. Read threads mate.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sweet. Will do.
Anny thread you can recommend?
I was hoping some devs would read this thread and say something about what they are doing.
Rootbox pacman pa all doing final builds on 4.2.2 and moving on to 4.3. Its all a wAiting game. No real info but there doing it and that's the main thing right? Either way i9100 is gonna be getting custom 4.3 soon. :thumbup:
andrewwright said:
Rootbox pacman pa all doing final builds on 4.2.2 and moving on to 4.3. Its all a writing game. No real info but there doing it and that's the main thing right? Either way i9100 is gonna be getting custom 4.3 soon. :thumbup:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thats awesome news m8. Thank you :good:

Categories

Resources