Related
Hi guys..
Introduction to this thread and why we actually needed it.
Since we have a great dev working for us non stop on kernels I actually noticed that it was difficult for yank himself to run across both the thread.
I felt that we can have a common thread for QnA’s & troubleshooting and of course describing the aroma settings and all other features of our Yank555.lu kernels ?
So this is how it goes here are the links to
Yank’s respective threads :
Yanks JB Samsung Awesomeness here
Yanks Cm/AOSP/AOKP Awesomness
The Aroma Settings are explained:
A.S.E. for Samsung ROMsA.S.E. for AOSP, CM, AOKP ROMs
The changelogs to respective kernels :
Changelogs for Samsung ROMs
Changelogs for AOSP, CM, AOKP ROMs
PS-I have taken permission from Yank555.lu and he knows wat i am doing
Directions
What to do & How to do it ... And what kind of help is to be expected here.
This is how we would like you to report your problem
Please indicate :
1---the Rom you are using
2---the configuration you have chosen in aroma
3---simplest and as to the point explanation possible of the problem you are facing !
And now comes the point of sharing !
Since we all will be using kernels with different settings and most of us will be satisfied some would not be some would be unsatisfied to a very large extent (I wish no one feels this way )
So share with us :
1---the settings that u have done or chosen in aroma
2---your results (free ram, battery life, etc.)
But yes please keep in mind we wont believe anything until we have seen it, so Screenshots should be added whenever possible !!!
Re: [Help][QnA][Troubleshooting][Sharing][OneStop JB/AOSP]Yank555.lu Kernels
Thanks for this, hopefully this will unclutter the dev threads!
slaphead20 said:
Thanks for this, hopefully this will unclutter the dev threads!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I Hope for the same mate
This is the only reason i sent an inbox to Yank and asked for his permission..and he will be monitoring the thread and ofcrs we will have all the users here too
Nobody seems intrested..! Still Sharing
This is my limited usage on my s3..
Sotmax v15.. Yanks 3.2
yanksusQ.. 1.5ghz low..!!
the thread is dead.!
Just a heads up that the bold lines in post 2 show as black on black on Tapatalk with a dark background. Presumably it will be the same with the xda app.
Sent from my SGS3 using Tapatalk
ROM Sotmax Ultimate V15
Kernel Yank555.lu-V3.2
Nice thread buddy ) I will post my screenshots soon. I'm on crdroid now with yank's latest kernel
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
saywhatt said:
Nice thread buddy ) I will post my screenshots soon. I'm on crdroid now with yank's latest kernel
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks
i kinda wanted to lessen traffic on yank's thread.. But it seems to be a failed attempt..!
geekynoob said:
Thanks
i kinda wanted to lessen traffic on yank's thread.. But it seems to be a failed attempt..!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe with a little time it may change...
JP.
PS: I wanted to hit the thanks button, but I saw you have 555 thanx, that was too nice a figure for me to change it
Yank555 said:
Maybe with a little time it may change...
JP.
PS: I wanted to hit the thanks button, but I saw you have 555 thanx, that was too nice a figure for me to change it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no worries made
i made urs 5050 looks awwsome..! it wont stay 5050 fr more 2 mins m sure
why did his threads get closed? where to get his kernel now? i found his forum where i have to register to download, but apparently i have to be manually approved by an admin...
crnkoj said:
why did his threads get closed? where to get his kernel now? i found his forum where i have to register to download, but apparently i have to be manually approved by an admin...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dev decided to close his own thread .
jje
Your link in OP seems to be problematic, at least with XDA apps, it goes to dead end link while I click it
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium
crnkoj said:
why did his threads get closed? where to get his kernel now? i found his forum where i have to register to download, but apparently i have to be manually approved by an admin...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have been
---------- Post added at 05:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:11 PM ----------
JJEgan said:
Dev decided to close his own thread .
jje
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In fact, he actually decided to move them to a place better controlled than xda (really no trolling allowed).
My threads now are in my very own forum
JP.
Yank555 said:
You have been
---------- Post added at 05:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:11 PM ----------
In fact, he actually decided to move them to a place better controlled than xda (really no trolling allowed).
My threads now are in my very own forum
JP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i see, thanks for adding me. one can hardly find your forum actually, i only managed to find it through this german forum http://www.android-hilfe.de/kernel-...7-yank555-jb-sammy-3-4-cm10-cm10-1-1-6-a.html over google (i was searching for "aosp yank555 i9305").
just wanted to ask a few more things as i didnt seem to find it in the features/changelog: will you be supporting abb, like its in the perseus kernel, as well as the rgb calibration? thanks for your work
crnkoj said:
i see, thanks for adding me. one can hardly find your forum actually, i only managed to find it through this german forum http://www.android-hilfe.de/kernel-...7-yank555-jb-sammy-3-4-cm10-cm10-1-1-6-a.html over google (i was searching for "aosp yank555 i9305").
just wanted to ask a few more things as i didnt seem to find it in the features/changelog: will you be supporting abb, like its in the perseus kernel, as well as the rgb calibration? thanks for your work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope and nope, because :
UV / ABB
I am convinced that UV brings close to nothing in battery life (for having tested this deeply on my Sensation and no difference measurable at -100mV which is quite more than many devices can take), hence I don't have it in my kernels and do not plan to add it as all it really will bring is people complaining about the kernel being unstable because they just overdid themselves with too much UV.
As for ABB, all I really believe this is good for is to allow for slightly more stability at high OC, that's nothing that I have in my kernels (1.6GHz is max) and I do not plan to go any higher anyway. Also, same applies for ABB, people don't really understand what it is and how it works, and ramdomly will play with it and then complain about the kernel being unstable.
So for my time's sake, I really don't need a thread filled with such posts, and since the threads are in my forum, I don't care either to have my thread look popular by that many kinds of posts either (just being sarcastic here)
Also, my highest goal is stability, and with decend battery, and I can't say my phone is unstable in any way, and I intend to keep it this way, and battery is pretty fine as well, and it's pretty snappy as well, so in fact I'm pretty happy with it as it is for now.
mdnie
I have no need for it, and I do not intend to include it. mdnie scenarios available in ROMs are good enough for me, AMOLED screens are anyway not good enough colorwise to be really well calibrated and I do not intend to do any kind of desktop publishing on my S3 either.
The good thing is, though, there are a few kernels to choose from the offer both by now
JP.
Yank555 said:
Nope and nope, because :
UV / ABB
I am convinced that UV brings close to nothing in battery life (for having tested this deeply on my Sensation and no difference measurable at -100mV which is quite more than many devices can take), hence I don't have it in my kernels and do not plan to add it as all it really will bring is people complaining about the kernel being unstable because they just overdid themselves with too much UV.
As for ABB, all I really believe this is good for is to allow for slightly more stability at high OC, that's nothing that I have in my kernels (1.6GHz is max) and I do not plan to go any higher anyway. Also, same applies for ABB, people don't really understand what it is and how it works, and ramdomly will play with it and then complain about the kernel being unstable.
So for my time's sake, I really don't need a thread filled with such posts, and since the threads are in my forum, I don't care either to have my thread look popular by that many kinds of posts either (just being sarcastic here)
Also, my highest goal is stability, and with decend battery, and I can't say my phone is unstable in any way, and I intend to keep it this way, and battery is pretty fine as well, and it's pretty snappy as well, so in fact I'm pretty happy with it as it is for now.
mdnie
I have no need for it, and I do not intend to include it. mdnie scenarios available in ROMs are good enough for me, AMOLED screens are anyway not good enough colorwise to be really well calibrated and I do not intend to do any kind of desktop publishing on my S3 either.
The good thing is, though, there are a few kernels to choose from the offer both by now
JP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the extensive explanation, ill try your kernel out and see what it brings. About other kernels that support it, its so that im a bit limited by it as i have an i9305 and not an i9300 (had one before, but came to changing it for the i9305), so there are practically no non-cm/replacement kernels for aosp roms (apart from yours) and what it takes for samsung based roms, all of those custom ones for the i9305 are still "bloated" (thers none like anonorom for the i9300), so i prefer not to use them =/
again, thanks for your time and work.
Yank555 said:
You have been
---------- Post added at 05:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:11 PM ----------
In fact, he actually decided to move them to a place better controlled than xda (really no trolling allowed).
My threads now are in my very own forum
JP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As many devs decide so to do in the interests of sanity .
jje
Just in case some don't know where to look, new kernel drops today in my forum (registration required), the various versions (MIUI, CM10.1, Sammy) will be available as I finish them.
PS: @ Mods, before hitting any moderation function, read this.
Which rom is recomended to be daily driver with everything working
Tested some of the aosp roms and found them not to be stable yet for every day use .
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
For me Unlocked Potential was very stable, basically all or most ICS ROMs work with zero to little problems. I've had quite a few with CM10.
Sent from my Rooted HTCEVOV4G running CM10.1 WFTN.
If anyone who sees this has no real interest in flashing and testing different roms, and simply want a "microwave" solution, then disregard my block of text below. This is not a shot against anyone, just simple advice being shared.
My response whenever people ask this question is this: you can try one at a time, so why not try as many as you can?
How would you know if any Rom is the best without knowing what makes it better than the other Roms in the first place? Not to mention that every user has their personal preferences, likes, and dislikes. Some like simple roms while others prefer the bells and whistles. You must see what you lime for yourself.
Please understand, Rom testing IS time consuming when testing the options and checking for speed, smoothness, stability, functionality, etc., but it is well worth it. You build your knowledge base, too. Asking for someone to tell you the best rom is taking the easy way out, guided by a biased opinion that is likely to change between most responses that you receive. Unless, of course, as I said before, you have no interest in this kind of thing, and you just want a rom that works. If so...then do whatever rocks your boat.
______________________________
HTC Evo 4G LTE
---------- Post added at 10:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:31 AM ----------
A good website for roms is
http://galaxys2root.com/tag/sgh-t989-roms/
There are videos posted for most roms reviewing the features, speed, stability, visuals, and overall feel of each rom.
And FYI, GB roms tend to be more stable than ICS, and DEFINITELY JB, but you gain more functionality and lose stability with each step up. Keep that in mind.
______________________________
HTC Evo 4G LTE
smartguy10 said:
Which rom is recomended to be daily driver with everything working
Tested some of the aosp roms and found them not to be stable yet for every day use .
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Questions such as these are not allowed. As the user above me mentioned, just download and try for yourself.
Mods close this.
My favorite rom is... the one that gets these threads to stop. :beer:
sent from MY BAD A$$ ET4G
There is nothing wrong with asking these questions. Plus the people who replied here.
Did you guys tested every single rom out here , if thats the case thats great .
smartguy10 said:
There is nothing wrong with asking these questions. Plus the people who replied here.
Did you guys tested every single rom out here , if thats the case thats great .
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's wrong is that the Evo 3D forums do not allow favorite ROM threads. You can try posting your requirements in this thread per the instructions in the OP and someone will probably provide feedback.
ramjet73
My favorites are cyanogen based roms, but there are some bugs in cm 10.1 (bluetooth etc)
As stated above best Rom threads are frowned upon to many variables to say one Rom is hands down the best Rom.
Closed
Almost forgot
XDA Moderator
This may be borderline the wrong place to post this, but it does concern custom ROM's, so technically it would be considered development I do believe. If not I'm truly sorry and move it to the correct section please. Anyway, my question is just like the title states. I've dug around a lot and haven't really found the answer. I promise I wasn't lazy and just made a new thread without researching :angel:. I want to know if anyone knows of anything like a CM10, CM11, any CM based ROM, or basically anything other than the 4.1.2 stock based ROM's with working HDMI. It is a must for me. You can go to the CM site and others, but it doesn't really say anything about it, being that most ROM's aren't all out device specific anymore, and many devices do not offer HDMI because of hardware anyway. If anyone can help it would be greatly appreciated.
NO WAY ！This is only available on stock ROMs because the related stuffs are close-sourced.
Sent from my XT875 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
ludeawakening said:
This may be borderline the wrong place to post this, but it does concern custom ROM's, so technically it would be considered development I do believe. If not I'm truly sorry and move it to the correct section please. Anyway, my question is just like the title states. I've dug around a lot and haven't really found the answer. I promise I wasn't lazy and just made a new thread without researching :angel:. I want to know if anyone knows of anything like a CM10, CM11, any CM based ROM, or basically anything other than the 4.1.2 stock based ROM's with working HDMI. It is a must for me. You can go to the CM site and others, but it doesn't really say anything about it, being that most ROM's aren't all out device specific anymore, and many devices do not offer HDMI because of hardware anyway. If anyone can help it would be greatly appreciated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hes absolutely right. roms that are "Stock based", Jellybean 4.1.2 will possibly have the hdmi functionality. Artmod is one
Thanks for the replies. That's exactly what I've come to learn. I decided to give up and I'm in the process of cooking up my own ROM. It will have every feature that I use and a lot of other goodies baked in.
ludeawakening said:
Thanks for the replies. That's exactly what I've come to learn. I decided to give up and I'm in the process of cooking up my own ROM. It will have every feature that I use and a lot of other goodies baked in.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you want a stable option you can overclock to 1365 easily check out this one http://www.droidrzr.com/index.php/t...6-bloodrage-v26-update-310-optional-stock-ui/
Its my wife's favorite no freezes or laging fully functional.
jluva420 said:
If you want a stable option you can overclock to 1365 easily check out this one http://www.droidrzr.com/index.php/t...6-bloodrage-v26-update-310-optional-stock-ui/
Its my wife's favorite no freezes or laging fully functional.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've run this ROM and it's okay. I've pretty much run everything imaginable on six different devices. I was just hoping that someone knew of something like a pure AOSP based or Cyanogen based ROM with working HDMI. I've looked everywhere and tried to add it to ROM's and it just won't work. It has something to do with the stock 4.1.2 firmware and the drivers. So we'll probably never see that function in anything like a 4.4+ ROM unless we get an official update (WHICH WILL NEVER HAPPEN) I decided to give up and I'll just swap to stock in Safestrap when I need HDMI capability. Right now I'm in the process of cooking up a nice little custom 4.4.2 pure AOSP based ROM. It will feature NOVA Launcher and the most dynamic launcher made (it's a secret) as home options. I'm mainly focusing on smoothness, responsiveness, and battery life.
MFsicKness v1.0 will be coming to a Forum near you soon!
Lucize got a working kexec kernel with hdmi feature tested. But it's still a little buggy. However, I'm also in now for some new development and we'll see how it goes
Tapped from my RAZR BLADE
dtrail1 said:
Lucize got a working kexec kernel with hdmi feature tested. But it's still a little buggy. However, I'm also in now for some new development and we'll see how it goes
Tapped from my RAZR BLADE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome.. I can see the day when the RAZR and atrix 2 will have ROMs fully stable.. Thanks dtrail
Sent from my MB865 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
nikhJ said:
Awesome.. I can see the day when the RAZR and atrix 2 will have ROMs fully stable.. Thanks dtrail
Sent from my MB865 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I fixed yesterday problems, this last zip should be good for every omap4 and work on any rom, haven't you tried ?
Regards
---------- Post added at 01:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:59 PM ----------
qqzwc said:
NO WAY ！This is only available on stock ROMs because the related stuffs are close-sourced.
Sent from my XT875 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
way !
please try my kernel and report back
Regards
---------- Post added at 01:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:01 PM ----------
ludeawakening said:
I've run this ROM and it's okay. I've pretty much run everything imaginable on six different devices. I was just hoping that someone knew of something like a pure AOSP based or Cyanogen based ROM with working HDMI. I've looked everywhere and tried to add it to ROM's and it just won't work. It has something to do with the stock 4.1.2 firmware and the drivers. So we'll probably never see that function in anything like a 4.4+ ROM unless we get an official update (WHICH WILL NEVER HAPPEN) I decided to give up and I'll just swap to stock in Safestrap when I need HDMI capability. Right now I'm in the process of cooking up a nice little custom 4.4.2 pure AOSP based ROM. It will feature NOVA Launcher and the most dynamic launcher made (it's a secret) as home options. I'm mainly focusing on smoothness, responsiveness, and battery life.
MFsicKness v1.0 will be coming to a Forum near you soon!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
please report back if is working for you, I'we developed it on droid 4 but should be good for razr.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2654233
Regards
lucize said:
I fixed yesterday problems, this last zip should be good for every omap4 and work on any rom, haven't you tried ?
Regards
---------- Post added at 01:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:59 PM ----------
way !
please try my kernel and report back
Regards
---------- Post added at 01:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:01 PM ----------
please report back if is working for you, I'we developed it on droid 4 but should be good for razr.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2654233
Regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Will the zip work for my
atrix 2
Sent from my MB865 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
The best way to find out is to try it I don't own one, if it has the omap4-common sources it should work but have a backup to restore from
Sent from my XT894 using xda app-developers app
dtrail1 said:
Lucize got a working kexec kernel with hdmi feature tested. But it's still a little buggy. However, I'm also in now for some new development and we'll see how it goes
Tapped from my RAZR BLADE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lucize said:
I fixed yesterday problems, this last zip should be good for every omap4 and work on any rom, haven't you tried ?
Regards
---------- Post added at 01:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:59 PM ----------
way !
please try my kernel and report back
Regards
---------- Post added at 01:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:01 PM ----------
Regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OOOH MY MY Lol! I'm very intrigued on this. I will definitely load the kernel up on a 4.4 build and see how it works out. If it works I will either put it in my build or link it to my OP when I post my ROM. Regardless lucize and dtrail1 will have full recognition and credit for the kernel and working HDMI. Man, if this works my RAZR will be a beast. I got really lucky and scored a MAXX on ebay for $51 with only the screen broken. It took a total of about 20 minutes to convert mine to the MAXX last night. As far as I can tell I'm saving around 11 to 13 percent more battery per hour with fairly heavy use. I have a couple of questions. Do you guys like the Xperia's Album (photo gallery) and Walkman music player with ACID Audio? All features work in the builds I have. And which gapps do you prefer? I'm trying to figure out which ones to recommend. I pretty much always go with Slim. Okay enough rambling. It's time to test.
lucize said:
please report back if is working for you, I'we developed it on droid 4 but should be good for razr.
http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=2654233
Regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will definitely report back and give detailed info on what I find. Thank you for your hard work on this.
ludeawakening said:
OOOH MY MY Lol! I'm very intrigued on this. I will definitely load the kernel up on a 4.4 build and see how it works out. If it works I will either put it in my build or link it to my OP when I post my ROM. Regardless lucize and dtrail1 will have full recognition and credit for the kernel and working HDMI. Man, if this works my RAZR will be a beast. I got really lucky and scored a MAXX on ebay for $51 with only the screen broken. It took a total of about 20 minutes to convert mine to the MAXX last night. As far as I can tell I'm saving around 11 to 13 percent more battery per hour with fairly heavy use. I have a couple of questions. Do you guys like the Xperia's Album (photo gallery) and Walkman music player with ACID Audio? All features work in the builds I have. And which gapps do you prefer? I'm trying to figure out which ones to recommend. I pretty much always go with Slim. Okay enough rambling. It's time to test.
I will definitely report back and give detailed info on what I find. Thank you for your hard work on this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
for hdmi you should thank stargo and me , because my device behaved and stargo's didn't and he fixed for him too and now should work for every device, I was lucky that my device was different and I could find out the way to make it work.
regards
lucize said:
for hdmi you should thank stargo and me , because my device behaved and stargo's didn't and he fixed for him too and now should work for every device, I was lucky that my device was different and I could find out the way to make it work.
regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright, I will definitely give thanks to all where thanks is due. If this works out then our little RAZR's will at least be able to contend with any device when it comes to performance and the all out coolness factor. Fully functioning HDMI is pretty much all it was missing
ludeawakening said:
OOOH MY MY Lol! I'm very intrigued on this. I will definitely load the kernel up on a 4.4 build and see how it works out. If it works I will either put it in my build or link it to my OP when I post my ROM. Regardless lucize and dtrail1 will have full recognition and credit for the kernel and working HDMI. Man, if this works my RAZR will be a beast. I got really lucky and scored a MAXX on ebay for $51 with only the screen broken. It took a total of about 20 minutes to convert mine to the MAXX last night. As far as I can tell I'm saving around 11 to 13 percent more battery per hour with fairly heavy use. I have a couple of questions. Do you guys like the Xperia's Album (photo gallery) and Walkman music player with ACID Audio? All features work in the builds I have. And which gapps do you prefer? I'm trying to figure out which ones to recommend. I pretty much always go with Slim. Okay enough rambling. It's time to test.
I will definitely report back and give detailed info on what I find. Thank you for your hard work on this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Indeed, HDMI is something that even the newest flagships don't have..
As for Xperia Album and Walkman, not a big fan of Albums, but Walkman, Hell Yeah.!!! I've been trying to make it work for Razr since the day I bought it. Would love it on the device.
neo.ank said:
Indeed, HDMI is something that even the newest flagships don't have..
As for Xperia Album and Walkman, not a big fan of Albums, but Walkman, Hell Yeah.!!! I've been trying to make it work for Razr since the day I bought it. Would love it on the device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The problem with making it work on the RAZR is the drivers. Even if you get a hold of a flashable Walkman .zip, most of the time it will not work correctly, no matter which version you get. It will usually also break any other music player you have installed. When you play a song you only get a split second of sound. The song will continue to play but with no sound. But never fear, it functions 100% in my build. Everyone can thank Nx Biotic for telling me where to look for the fix to this issue. Unfortunately I'm delayed on finishing the ROM for a short time. My little girl decided my screen and LCD looks better completely shattered Lol. At least I have the trusty "absolutely sucks compared to the RAZR" Droid Charge. It does have HDMI though. Parts are on the way for the RAZR and I will continue testing shortly. Keep an eye out.
So, did anyone get HDMI working with a custom ROM? AFAIK only the "official" ROM's work, but as they are so old, not so much fun. Shame we can't get the best of both worlds. Anyone know someone from Moto who can find the source code for this "secret" HDMI stuff, or has anyone the knowledge to decompile it from an official ROM?
I just found this rom last night called Tipsy 1.0 for the vs985. I don't know why they haven't made a thread for it on xda, or maybe I just haven't seen it yet.. But I gave it a whirl and I also flashed 777R11 kernel with it.. So far I think it is the best rom I have flashed in a while.
Here is the link if anyone else wants to give it a go.. I am sorry if I missed the thread somewhere.. If so please delete this post.. Thank you.
https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=24052804347768942
-Tipsy-1.0/777R11-
Nope. They don't have a thread currently here. Also, 404 link dead.
https://www.androidfilehost.com/?w=files&flid=34817
Any other opinions? Might give it a shot. How's battery life
---------- Post added at 12:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:05 PM ----------
And I'm assuming an LP GAPPS is fine?
I actually used it for a couple days. It's very fast and PLENTY of customization. I was pretty impressed with its performance. The only reason I came back is because I prefer the audio and camera stock LG (I use Xcam)
New builds for Tipsy are now found here:
http://forum.xda-developers.com/verizon-lg-g3/development/rom-tipsyos-official-builds-t3195201
It's really absurd to see people happy with the arrive of GSI roms that doesn't feature Moto mod support. I've tried some roms and the obvious result is that non of it let you use any mod so, ¿Is there any chance that developers build a ron or a module that let Moto mods work in GSI?
I agree, it's very annoying, there is even a super detailed guide on how to implement it on XDA somewhere. It has been accomplished already for all main mods, including JBL. (Maybe version 2)?
I tried bringing this guide to the attention of devs and got in **** for posting it in the development section so devs could see it lol
At least the battery mod will still charge the phone in recovery mode our little secret lol.
Well, at least we have Pie ROMs. And I don't know how compatible the Mods framework is with GSI. @MusicAlleyInc and you where already told that most devs wont do that since that can break too much stuff on the way and none are willing to go through the hassels just to satisfy a hand full of people actually using modules
Artim_96 said:
Well, at least we have Pie ROMs. And I don't know how compatible the Mods framework is with GSI. @MusicAlleyInc and you where already told that most devs wont do that since that can break too much stuff on the way and none are willing to go through the hassels just to satisfy a hand full of people actually using modules
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Many people use Turbopower, and JBL.
Those are referenced over and over.
Most times, Turbopower works but efficiency mode does not.
JBL often works without volume control.
These Roms are all using the same basic foundation.
Artim_96 said:
Well, at least we have Pie ROMs. And I don't know how compatible the Mods framework is with GSI. @MusicAlleyInc and you where already told that most devs wont do that since that can break too much stuff on the way and none are willing to go through the hassels just to satisfy a hand full of people actually using modules
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As I said: there is a tutorial which describes how to do this PROPERLY, without breaking anything, maybe a few things in the mods not working yet, but not breaking other things.
> https://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=72601804&postcount=2 <
It has been done, can be done, and obviously can be done if Motorola can do it in the first place.
And as noted, many people do use mods. That is why any intelligent person would have bought this phone. It's not to satisfy a handful of people, it's to have our phones work as they are meant to work.
MusicAlleyInc said:
As I said: there is a tutorial which I posted in this very forum which describes how to do this PROPERLY, without breaking anything.
It has been done, can be done, and obviously can be done if Motorola can do it in the first place.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, there is quite a big difference between being Motorola, getting paid for it and having access to all necessary source code and being a dev doing that in your free time a having only limited access to necessary source codes
Artim_96 said:
Well, there is quite a big difference between being Motorola, getting paid for it and having access to all necessary source code and being a dev doing that in your free time a having only limited access to necessary source codes
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There is also a difference between competence and incompetence. The main mods used >already< work without issues except for the JBL mod, which is only an issue because of some proprietary code or driver or something.
But who the hell cares, that is what Bluetooth speakers are for.
All most people really care about is the battery mod and projector. Exclusive features like that without any simple/efficient alternatives.
These mods have worked stable in many custom ROMS when a little extra effort was made to make something competent. The only reason they are not working in Pie ROMS is because GSI's are universal and don't have them implemented in their base as they have been in past custom ROMS which were made FOR THIS PHONE...
MusicAlleyInc said:
There is also a difference between competence and incompetence.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
While you call every ROM developer incompetent, when you know oh so much about that and how it had to be done, why haven't you just made your own ROM supporting every Moto mod?
MusicAlleyInc said:
The only reason they are not working in Pie ROMS is because GSI's are universal and don't have them implemented as they have been in past custom ROMS...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
...And what was this thread about?
Artim_96 said:
MusicAlleyInc said:
There is also a difference between competence and incompetence. [\quote]
While you call every ROM developer incompetent, when you know oh so much about that and how it had to be done, why haven't you just made your own ROM supporting every Moto mod?
...And what was this thread about?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What's your problem? I didn't call every ROM developer incompetent, I was actually highlighting the competence of ones who achieved mod compatibility.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MusicAlleyInc said:
Artim_96 said:
What's your problem? I didn't call every ROM developer incompetent, I was actually highlighting the competence of ones who achieved mod compatibility.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You complain most ROMs do not (fully) support mods, that means in your words those ROM developers are all incompetent
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MusicAlleyInc said:
Artim_96 said:
What's your problem? I didn't call every ROM developer incompetent, I was actually highlighting the competence of ones who achieved mod compatibility.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Neither did I claim to know so much, I simply shared what I found.. an observation, do you gather?
It's not cool twisting peoples words to try to make them look bad.
Why would I build a ROM that supports most mods: when it has been done, that makes no sense...
Neither does the attitude I have received while trying to relay this information to devs for the benefit of the entire Moto Z2 play community.
I am not a DEV, perhaps that is another reason why I don't build my own ROM.
---------- Post added at 10:23 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:19 AM ----------
Artim_96 said:
MusicAlleyInc said:
You complain most ROMs do not (fully) support mods, that means in your words those ROM developers are all incompetent
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
By the very definition of competence, building something that doesn't fully work is technically incompetence IN REGARDS TO THIS SUBJECT MATTER.
Especially when it has been already achieved to some degree. I am not complaining, nor did i say "fully" either. I am highlighting this fact and this fact only, do you have an issue with facts, or just a problem with pretense?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MusicAlleyInc said:
I am not a DEV, perhaps that is another reason why I don't build my own.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Then, just maybe, you should leave those topics to people who actually are instead of whining in several threads about devs deciding not to support it. You simply have no right to complain.
Artim_96 said:
Then, just maybe, you should leave those topics to people who actually are instead of whining in several threads about devs deciding not to support it. You simply have no right to complain.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe you need to understand the concept of progress and a constructive attitude.
Calling it whining is literally just making things personal, and totally unnecessary.
You insist on trying to dictate my intention as negative, your problem, not mine.
The thing is that GSI roms are generic, I know. But I have not seen any developments in Android P working around the mod support, ¿There's no possible way to build a module that let the users use turbo power mod in GSI? We have a great phone with a great power mod and we can't use it. For me is absurd to use GSI if I cannot get the most out of it
"Then, just maybe, you should leave those topics to people who actually ARE implementing this the same way the guy in the link I posted did....?"
But yet everyone is so fast to tell me nobody is and that nobody IS or has much interested in replicating his work, hmmm.
MusicAlleyInc said:
Maybe you need to understand the concept of progress and a constructive attitude.
Calling it whining is literally just making things personal, and totally unnecessary.
You insist on trying to dictate my intention as negative, your problem, not mine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Then just read the thread you opened on that topic. That's basically the definition of whining. And you are surprised that it wasn't taken very well when you don't stick to the forum rules about what belongs in which section and write it with such an attitude basically telling anyone that reads it that you think most ROM devs are just lazy and don't care about their users interests
santip32 said:
The thing is that GSI roms are generic, I know. But I have not seen any developments in Android P working around the mod support, ¿There's no possible way to build a module that let the users use turbo power mod in GSI? We have a great phone with a great power mod and we can't use it. For me is absurd to use GSI if I cannot get the most out of it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Be happy that at least you can get something out of it for now using recovery mode.
I say just be patient, Stock Pie shouldn't be that far off. And if you want CUSTOM PIE and mod support, well chances look good that it can be done when dev's have access to stock pie firmware?
---------- Post added at 10:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:43 AM ----------
Artim_96 said:
Then just read the thread you opened on that topic. That's basically the definition of whining. And you are surprised that it wasn't taken very well when you don't stick to the forum rules about what belongs in which section and write it with such an attitude basically telling anyone that reads it that you think most ROM devs are just lazy and don't care about their users interests
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dude, please cease and desist and stop twisting things out of context. You are pretentiously whining about me sharing important information and expecting ROMS made for this phone to make use of something that allows mods to work for this phone. Give it a rest.
And that post was totally soiled by someone with an attitude similar to your own, the reason I broke forum rules was for citing blatent ignorance as ignorance. Yeah, ask me how bad I feel about that.
MusicAlleyInc said:
Artim_96 said:
What's your problem? I didn't call every ROM developer incompetent, I was actually highlighting the competence of ones who achieved mod compatibility.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That very developer removed mods support to improve the stability and performance of the Rom. And don't try to teach the developers how to create a ROM , we have only one left.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nikhil5143 said:
MusicAlleyInc said:
That very developer removed mods support to improve the stability and performance of the Rom. And don't try to teach the developers how to create a ROM , we have only one left.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So the same guy who claims he got these mods working stable and was promoting other people used what he learned, removes his work from his ROM because it makes it perform worse?
How does it impact performance? I have run at least 3 or 4 ROM with projector and turbo pack support that were absolutely fine and stable.
Also: it's fairly obvious this dude was the one trying to teach developers how to integrate mod support into their ROM, not me.
---------- Post added at 05:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:34 PM ----------
A post of his from that thread:
"Rom discontinued
hey guys thanks for using this rom
sorry if i couldn't bring up ALL mods without bug (key word being ALL)
but i can't keep this rom updated anymore
so unfortunately i have to say Rom discontinued
this is mod apps update flashable zip to make new mods work https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=889964283620776495
all sources is online and ready for interested dev continue developing it"
---------- Post added at 05:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:43 PM ----------
Sorry, but can you produce evidence of your claim?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
guys ! would you please stop bickering?
the OP of this thread wanted some insight about his problem and you use it to flame each-other ... this is not cool, huh?
I urge you to stop here, help the guy if possible and to keep it civil, I have trust in your cooperation, please don`t disappoint me...
thank you!