I hate both, there's no other way to look at that, I like my phone as it is, but well scratches will come with time, that's a fact too, so I was wondering which to get. I mean if I go for a Tempered Screen Protector, could that save the display from shattering in case of an accidental drop? Or shall I be using a Protective Case? I know that the corners of a phone are the most important parts, that's where protection should be present, so am I wrong to guess that a tempered glass protector can't protect the corners? I am thinking from a phone drop point of view, not normal scratches, for normal scratches I think I don't need a tempered glass screen protector, a normal one shall do.
So what shall I aim for, a case or the other?
If it's a case then which one? I love the UAG cases for the protection it provides, but hate them for their industrial design, but I won't buy something which won't have a good amount of lip around the screen to protect it from drops and kinds. I need something simple and neat looking, low profile and lightweight and the material should be half rugged so that it won't slip out from my palms.
Thanks in advance.
Tempered glass will NOT save the screen from every drop. If it's face impact then yes most likely will save but if impact is on back of phone and no case or very slim case will Crack LCD it self. Wife's note had a super slim tpu case and LCD shattered but both glass were fine.
i always go with glass screen protector and thin tpu jelly type case. doesn't protect if like an otterbox but will be able to handle any of the minor mishaps i might have. i am very careful and treat my phones like gold so it hasn't failed me so far.
i realize there are plenty of things that setup will not protect your phone for but i can not stand to add bulk to any phone no matter how thin it starts out
1slow4G said:
Tempered glass will NOT save the screen from every drop. If it's face impact then yes most likely will save but if impact is on back of phone and no case or very slim case will Crack LCD it self. Wife's note had a super slim tpu case and LCD shattered but both glass were fine.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep, you are right.
I have decided to get a Nillkin 9H tempered protector and a Spigen Neo Hybrid, I guess these will do more than fine for protection.
devilsdouble said:
Yep, you are right.
7
I have decided to get a Nillkin 9H tempered protector and a Spigen Neo Hybrid, I guess these will do more than fine for protection.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't like because the nilkin one gets fingerprints too easy.
Gonna look into others and change this one
Best one I've used so far is the xtremeguard spartan. Not as bad as others as far as smudge and prints. All though, they changed the design lately, and sold them, was hoping for them to send me the previous design.
Related
I picked up the realook protector, and love it. it covers the screen perfectly (really) and looks and feels like the original glass. problem is the verizon high gloss tpu case i bought for the phone last weekend causes the edges of the protector to lift up when the case is squeezed even slightly.
is anyone using the amzer case with a protector? does this work better?
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00691RJ80/ref=oh_o04_s00_i01_details
tspderek said:
I picked up the realook protector, and love it. it covers the screen perfectly (really) and looks and feels like the original glass. problem is the verizon high gloss tpu case i bought for the phone last weekend causes the edges of the protector to lift up when the case is squeezed even slightly.
is anyone using the amzer case with a protector? does this work better?
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00691RJ80/ref=oh_o04_s00_i01_details
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This made me lol. This is one of the only reasons I don't use a tpu case on my phones. I know the cheaper ones usually don't wrap as tightly and don't go over the bezel as much, making it so they don't touch the edges of the screen protector. I've never tried that one but from what I remember the Diztronic ones don't mess the protector up.
First I'd like to introduce myself, I'm InfamousChicken, or you can call me Tim if you prefer. I can't wait to divulge myself into this community and talk with people and make some friends, now onto my question.
I am buying the Galaxy S4 next week, and I wasn't sure what I should get case wise. I was thinking of getting the Otterbox Commuter, along with getting Glass.tR Is this a wise choice and will it keep my phone and screen safe?
I'd post links if I was allowed to, but with 4 million users I understand they may not want that!
Thanks guys!
Hi Tim, welcome to XDA! You may want to check out the Accessories forum: http://forum.xda-developers.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2317
There are a ton of case-specific threads/posts with very helpful reviews and pictures. Personally, I use a red Spigen Neo Hybrid and I love it. There's a ton of photos/reviews in that forum, so check them out.
ttupa said:
Hi Tim, welcome to XDA! You may want to check out the Accessories forum: http://forum.xda-developers.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2317
There are a ton of case-specific threads/posts with very helpful reviews and pictures. Personally, I use a red Spigen Neo Hybrid and I love it. There's a ton of photos/reviews in that forum, so check them out.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks, I was looking through that. How do you feel like that is for protection, and how do you feel that is protection for your screen incase you drop it face first?
Yes I also have the neo hybrid case and glasstr by spigen lovly combo. Im sure its good w/a commuter case as well
Sent from my galaxy s4 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
InfamousChicken said:
Thanks, I was looking through that. How do you feel like that is for protection, and how do you feel that is protection for your screen incase you drop it face first?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It has a very minimal lip surrounding the screen, so if it were to fall completely flat, I don't think there would be much for protection. However, most drops land on corners or edges. In that case, I think the Neo Hybrid provides very adequate protection - at least for me. I typically use phones without a case, as I think cases cover up the beauty of the phone and add bulk. This case feels and looks amazing, better than the pictures IMO. The only downside I can think of is the slim cutout of the headphone port.
What about the Spigen Slim Armor case, would it be as equally good or better than the commuter?
The slim armor is on sale if you bundle it with the glass screen protector, 40 dollars for both. That's what I would do.
sent from my galaxy s4
Hi Tim, Welcome!
I decided on the MIME Ghost Glass for my GS4 for 3 main reasons instead of the Spigen glass protector. To note, I have the Spigen Neo Hybrid case.
1st reason: Spigen glass has a hardness rating of 8H-9H and the MIME was a solid 9H rating (Gorilla Glass 3 i think is a 7H-8H). That means it takes something harder to scratch it.
2nd reason: Spigen has a thickness of .40mm and MIME was .32mm. This i noticed after I installed the glass... The MIME Ghost Glass STILL sits lower then the rubber edge of the Neo Hybrid case so setting it face down, the glass still doesn't touch the table, and it BARELY sits below the case edge leaving me to believe the Spigen glass would be even with or sitting past/above the edge of the case.
3rd reason: I don't think that Spigen has a lifetime warranty with their glass protector. MIME Ghost Glass does. It's lifetime but its not replacement its 60% off your next glass it the first one you bought gets scratched/cracked.
I hope this helps your decision.
Eric
this may be a dumb question, but what is the advantage of a glass screen cover as opposed to flexible plastic one. i just ordered 6 matte/anti-glare covers on ebay for like $5 and they're great. fingerprints are a thing of the past, not that it was that big of a problem with the bare screen. but what is so much better about the glass? i've never covered a phone with a glass screen cover, but i'm definitely interested in why i should be.
it is glass... simply put. It feels just like the gorilla glass so it feels and looks like you have nothing on your phone!
Plus it protect ur screen much better than a plastic protector. I think u get around 3-4 hardness when then spigen glass ones get 8-9 hardness. If u drop ur phone on the screen the glass screen will crack before ur phone screen. Yea its alil pricey for 1 but its worth it
Sent from my galaxy s4 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
Eric214 said:
Hi Tim, Welcome!
I decided on the MIME Ghost Glass for my GS4 for 3 main reasons instead of the Spigen glass protector. To note, I have the Spigen Neo Hybrid case.
1st reason: Spigen glass has a hardness rating of 8H-9H and the MIME was a solid 9H rating (Gorilla Glass 3 i think is a 7H-8H). That means it takes something harder to scratch it.
2nd reason: Spigen has a thickness of .40mm and MIME was .32mm. This i noticed after I installed the glass... The MIME Ghost Glass STILL sits lower then the rubber edge of the Neo Hybrid case so setting it face down, the glass still doesn't touch the table, and it BARELY sits below the case edge leaving me to believe the Spigen glass would be even with or sitting past/above the edge of the case.
3rd reason: I don't think that Spigen has a lifetime warranty with their glass protector. MIME Ghost Glass does. It's lifetime but its not replacement its 60% off your next glass it the first one you bought gets scratched/cracked.
I hope this helps your decision.
Eric
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sold on mime glass, my only question now is, what should I get with it to make a solid combo that will keep my phone safe. I guess it is true that in a drop, people are more worried about shattering their screen.
But It's either Spigen Neo Hybrid case.
Otterbox Commuter
Spigen Neo Galaxy S4 Case Slim Armor
or the WorkMate by cygnett
Which is sturdier of the 3? Which spigen neo is sturdier?
Saw another post with link to it, but here's a review of the case. It's not super bulky. But add enough protection for most
Leave questions and comments
Just got one of these. My question is to pop the included screen protector off and just go with the one that came with the Nexus or peel that one off and go with the Supcase protector. I've read reviews of people suggesting both.
This is a durable feeling and looking case. I've always had UAG cases in the past but this one seemed to offer a little more protection.
Bgbird68 said:
Just got one of these. My question is to pop the included screen protector off and just go with the one that came with the Nexus or peel that one off and go with the Supcase protector. I've read reviews of people suggesting both.
This is a durable feeling and looking case. I've always had UAG cases in the past but this one seemed to offer a little more protection.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I find a tempered glass screen protector under the plastic built-in one to be the best. It sits really flush this way and you can't see the halo in the glass screen protector because of the case.
Bgbird68 said:
Just got one of these. My question is to pop the included screen protector off and just go with the one that came with the Nexus or peel that one off and go with the Supcase protector. I've read reviews of people suggesting both.
This is a durable feeling and looking case. I've always had UAG cases in the past but this one seemed to offer a little more protection.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you do this, make sure you after you pop the built in screen protector off you scrape off the black adhesive that held it on or it will fuse to your screen protector and rip it off if you take off your case. Any small metal tool can be used but be careful not to scratch the case. After its removed you can use some qtips and a little bit of rubbing alcohol to clean any residual adhesive.
I didn't do this originally and my case was stuck to my screen protector for 2 months till I finally decided to try and force it off and it ruined my screen protector.
I'm going to keep my supplied screen protector on along with the case screen protector.
Bgbird68 said:
I'm going to keep my supplied screen protector on along with the case screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Good luck, sensitivity sucks!
No problems with sensitivity so far. I like the case. Little bulky but the phone feels safe.
Bgbird68 said:
No problems with sensitivity so far. I like the case. Little bulky but the phone feels safe.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The edges of the screen sometimes take a few tries to respond!
I have this case. Its fantastic for work. Its awfully bulky though! But, with that bulk you get great protection.
Its great if you need the protection. I typically remove the phone from the case when I'm home.
GreenXSniper said:
If you do this, make sure you after you pop the built in screen protector off you scrape off the black adhesive that held it on or it will fuse to your screen protector and rip it off if you take off your case. Any small metal tool can be used but be careful not to scratch the case. After its removed you can use some qtips and a little bit of rubbing alcohol to clean any residual adhesive.
I didn't do this originally and my case was stuck to my screen protector for 2 months till I finally decided to try and force it off and it ruined my screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is what I described doing in a different topic - used an X-Acto knife and it took about 10 minutes to get all the plastic protector's adhesive off, which I felt might stick or lift up the lip of their case on the actual screen protector I'm using.
However, I also found that the Supcase didn't sit perfectly flush on the Nexus 6 with my own screen protector after removing their plastic one - one longer side has a gap between the frame and my protected phone surface.
So, I am keeping this case as a backup, only.
- ooofest
Just got this case from EBay .I must say Dam good quality cases an holster love it..actually kind of like its design an fit better then Otterbox...feels more solid..
Had the case for a while its pretty good. Not a daily case for me as I switch when doing different jobs. It's actually kind of hard to get off that's a good thing for some people.
I've just had to return mine after using it for a few days. When taking pictures with the rear camera flash on, the flash and case don't work well together and the pictures are spoilt (first pic is with case, second without. You can see the tint that having the white case on causes). Disappointing as I have already had the screen break on me (first time ever!) and was happy of the extra protection that this case affords
For the most part I go naked with my N6. I am ordering one of these cases for when I go golfing and maybe some other activities where I want to have the best protection. I am keeping the supplied protector cause it will keep dust and water from getting on my phone. Which is, by the way, the reason I am going with this brand because most of the other "tough" cases don't have that.
How does this case fit around the speakers? Is it open letting dust in under the screen protector or are the speakers sealed?
They are open, dust can accumulate
I've been using mine for months now with no problems. only complaint is the camera port is long. Dust an small debris gets under screen protector, its slightly bulky but worth the protection. Both factory screen protector an case built-in on an notice a little touch sensitivity loss, but worth the protection! Add the fact that the N6 is water resistant an its damn near perfect!
I find that the (plastic) screen guard that's provided with this phone is a major smudge magnet. I'm thinking of removing it. I'd like any feedback from anyone who has already taken it off.
Cheers.
UPDATE: I went ahead and got 9H Glass cover. 2-pack for $8 on Amazon. Immensely better than the plastic this phone ships with. I highly recommend doing this, even if you don't personally see a problem with the plastic cover. I promise once you see the difference you'll agree it was worth it.
So happy I posted this question.
Thank you all for your responses!
There doesn't seem to be an oleophobic coating on the display because they expect you to keep the screen protector on. So taking it off might result in even more smudges. Personally, I didn't find the screen protector that came pre-installed to be a smudge magnet. I actually found that it reduced them. I'm not saying the protector necessarily has an oleophobic coating, but that I didn't have a problem with smudges on it. The only reason why I took mine off was because there was some black dust underneath the screen protector and I couldn't get it back on without more dust appearing under it. So I just removed it completely. You might have to buy another screen protector of your choice that will better repel smudges to your satisfaction.
I've taken mine off because I scratched mine with a paper towel (like wtf?) but now I wish I haven't, because things stick to the screen easier. So unless you have an alternate screen protector ready, I'd recommend not.
NexusHeat said:
There doesn't seem to be an oleophobic coating on the display because they expect you to keep the screen protector on.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks. This is information I didn't have. I have a couple of other devices with no plastic cover; I don't have the smudge issue with them. But if there's no coating on the h5, then it's probably best to keep it on.
Buy a tempered glass protection, that's cheap and protect very well the screen (ebay, amazon, aliexpress bangood, etc....) keywords : phone name + "tempered glass" or "9h"
mooms said:
Buy a tempered glass protection, that's cheap and protect very well the screen (ebay, amazon, aliexpress bangood, etc....) keywords : phone name + "tempered glass" or "9h"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Had various of those. All broke either in my pocket or by a slightdrop (dropping it on the table from like 4cms high. It doesnt protect against smudges very well. Got a plastic matt screenprotector. Tempered glass is a waste of you money in my opinnion.
Demian3112 said:
Had various of those. All broke either in my pocket or by a slightdrop (dropping it on the table from like 4cms high. It doesnt protect against smudges very well. Got a plastic matt screenprotector. Tempered glass is a waste of you money in my opinnion.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have various myself, only broken one, on a tablet.
Plastic is not the same feel as glass on the fingers (don't know how to explain it better in english), and it scratch must faster.
mooms said:
Have various myself, only broken one, on a tablet.
Plastic is not the same feel as glass on the fingers (don't know how to explain it better in english), and it scratch must faster.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which one did you have? I had the one from nillkin 9h. Scratched in my pocket and cracks began with the slightest drop. But yeah plastic is diffrent then glass..
Demian3112 said:
Which one did you have? I had the one from nillkin 9h. Scratched in my pocket and cracks began with the slightest drop. But yeah plastic is diffrent then glass..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bought a generic 9H on eBay for 1€
I also have a transparent silicone case for the same price
I also bought the Nillkin 9H, but the other is still good so....
I took my plastic screen protector off the moment I got my tempered glass screen protector. Couldn't really remember how the original one felt since I only had for a very short period of time. That said, I recommend taking screen protector off for something better.
The stock screen protector is trash, all it does is act as a fingerprint magnet.
I did go to a Nillkin 9H. Wow - 90% reduction in smudges, and it is more sensitive than the stock plastic. Dropped the phone a few times, no issues. I do have an iPacky thin case, and it shows the abuse of daily use, but survives fine. It is also very thin. The thick cases defeat the whole purpose of our slim beauty.
I found that replacing the factory plastic screen protector with a high quality glass screen protector makes it a little better in terms of less fingerprint smudges and protection.
Oscar_david said:
I find that the (plastic) screen guard that's provided with this phone is a major smudge magnet. I'm thinking of removing it. I'd like any feedback from anyone who has already taken it off.
Cheers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i took it off and you get some scratches but not allot. if you look at the jerryrigs video he tested it and its as strong as gorilla glas. So you can take it off. i took mine off because there was a huge scratch in my screen protector and i could not live with that.
Cheers:good:
Oscar_david said:
I find that the (plastic) screen guard that's provided with this phone is a major smudge magnet. I'm thinking of removing it. I'd like any feedback from anyone who has already taken it off.
Cheers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I would wait to get a tempered glass, just to prevent any scratches on the LCD
** *** **
I have literally never used any screen protector and have never had issues. However, YMMV. I immediately took off the screen protector that came with it. I did buy a nice cheap protective case from Amazon prime. It has enough lip to protect the screen and I always make sure not to put my phone in the same pocket as my keys or sharp items.
using honor 5x without screen protector since months, no scratch at all.
bt the back side got a couple of scratches from my bike keys
UPDATE: I went ahead and got 9H Glass cover. 2-pack for $8 on Amazon. Immensely better than the plastic this phone ships with. I highly recommend doing this, even if you don't personally see a problem with the plastic cover. I promise once you see the difference you'll agree it was worth it.
So happy I posted this question.
Thank you all for your responses!
Oscar_david said:
UPDATE: I went ahead and got 9H Glass cover. 2-pack for $8 on Amazon. Immensely better than the plastic this phone ships with. I highly recommend doing this, even if you don't personally see a problem with the plastic cover. I promise once you see the difference you'll agree it was worth it.
So happy I posted this question.
Thank you all for your responses!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Great.
I removed mine last night, can't believe how much better the display looks without it.
Hi all,
I have a spigen neoflex TPU protection on my s23 ultra, with a plastic spigen case.
I've bought an official Samsung leather case, and it seems really nice.
But, the neoflex is a bit to short on the sides, so that my finger feels the border of the screen protection every time I swipe left or right.
So, I would like to replace the neoflex with a tempered glass protection.
Do you know one who will fit well?
I have had a really bad experience with an Oppo find X5 pro : I've tested 5 tempered glass brands and every time my beautiful official Kevlar case unglued the tempered glass in the corners...
Thank you for your help
Whitestone dome or Spigen have been the best in my experience.
Avoid amfilm at all costs.
I have domeglass with leather samsung cover. In my opinion everything is fine. Of course glass not cover full screen and is about 1,5 mm smaller than all screen - safe "bumper" for covers.
I have too spigen optic armor and with domeglass is perfect fit, no one gap between case and glass but I seldom use this spigen.
Since S23 Ultra has a curved screen, I dont really think you should get a tempered cause either they dont cover the curved area or if they do, I dont really trust the protection they offer. For Curved Screen, I suggest getting a Screen Protector Film just to be safe. There is a Full-Body Screen Protector from Gadgetshieldz that covers the screen and other parts of the device like the sides, back and camera. Cases dont necessarily help with the scratches cause Ive seen multiple devices getting permanent marks inspite of the cases mostly due to the dust and things. So best to keep everything protected with either a Skin or a Full-Body protector. They also provide Skins if thats what you prefer.
Prakash_Raj said:
Cases dont necessarily help with the scratches cause Ive seen multiple devices getting permanent marks inspite of the cases mostly due to the dust and things
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly, I saw too. Refers to people who don't pull off case for months to clean
_GRIZZLY_ said:
Exactly, I saw too. Refers to people who don't pull off case for months to clean
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yaa I swear. All my previous devices had this issue. Ive used the best of the best cases and they still have these tiny scuffs which are permanent. This reduced the resale value of my devices and thats when I opted for this Full-Body Coverage cause I really dont mind spending a bit more to avoid these permanent damages. Im thinking of getting it wrapped with Skins next time.
So I am happy with still good stick fabric foil around frame .
Sometimes better use only minimalistic covers, not too bulky and happy with device than see scratches or crack after more time with angry tell "what was it for all this protections"
_GRIZZLY_ said:
So I am happy with still good stick fabric foil around frame .
Sometimes better use only minimalistic covers, not too bulky and happy with device than see scratches or crack after more time with angry tell "what was it for all this protections"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Both screen protectors and skins they provide barely adds any bulk. they are literally as thick as a sheet of paper and I dont think you can go any thinner