I am not associated with any product in this thread.
I contacted Whitestone Dome and was told they have no plans to create a protector for the OnePlus so I started searching for a LOCA kit and so far could not find one. I had already purchased a 2 pack protector from amazon and I love it. So I had the idea to take the extra LOCA from my Note 9 Whitestone Dome Kit and the extra protector and experiment.
Surprisingly other than a little extra glue, it worked perfect. I had the phone on a paper towel when doing the install to help soak up the extra so it would not get into the ports.
This is a true 100% coverage of your front glass. If you use a case with a lid such as the Poetic this will pop off if you hit the sides, this works completely with the cases that are sold by One Plus and do not have aggressive side or "lip" coverage over the edge or for those who run raw without any case:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07L1GKV26/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o01__o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
If you have an aggressive case such as the Poetic or the Spigen Tough Armor the following screen protector will work. When used with these two cases it covers 100% of whats visibly left with the case installed, without the case it covers approx 99% of the screen (roughly .5mm gap around each edge):
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01G5AMA7E/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00__o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
My house is dusty so I cant seem to get a good pic without some settling but all the dust you see in the photo is on top of the screen, response is perfect and the finger print sensor works flawlessly.
The photo on the wood desk is with the 100% coverage protector for running case less or using the stock One Plus Cases.
The second photo is the 99% coverage with the Spigen Tough Armor.
i tried to use loca glue with my s9+ and a cheaper than whitestone dome tempered glass. it was a huge mess and got in all the buttons.
how did you apply it cleanly without making a huge mess?
Related
Hey there I figured this might be of some use to anybody wanting the ultimate "ruggedized" protection for their Note 3.
It is well-known that the added thickness of some tempered glass screen protectors will prevent some of the most rugged cases from being used (as is the case with Otterboxes apparently). So, should you be stuck with a cheap TPU case while having the best protection for your screen??! No!
The usual rule of thumb dictates that any case with hard plastic parts that snap together (front and back) will not work, alas if it covers too much of the phone's face. It cannot flex so it cannot clip closed. Futhermore, if it DOES close, it might put a lot of pressure on the phone or protector, as well as potentially make your protector lift. We don't want that.
There are, however, 2 rugged cases that you can use with glass protectors. I did the tests with a MIME USA Ghost glass (0.32mm thickness) so any protector of equal or inferior thickness will work.
1: Ballistic SG MAXX
2: Trident Case Kraken AMS
With Ballistic's case I'm pretty sure one would be able to fit one of the thicker protectors such as the regular Spigen (0.4mm), as you only have rubber corners going over the screen.
Hope this can help.
Sent from my SM900W8 Note 3 using xda-devs app. And my fingers.
Does a ruggedized case really give you that much extra protection or is it placebo effect? I've dropped my phone a bunch of times onto either my tile floor or garage asphalt/sidewalk and never had problems with screen or body damage- all without a "ballistic" type of case. In fact all I do is put a tempered glass protector on it and a bumper around the edges- because when you drop your device, it's usually those areas that are the vulnerable points.
Other than protecting the edges and front glass, why make a device thicker than it needs to be with a $50 case if the back cover itself is $5-$10 to replace?
Anyone know a reliable cheap tempered glass screen protector brand on ebay? My first time using tempered glass and I want to get the right one for my new baby
icarez is about $10 and seems to have a good rating on amazon. Pretty sure you can find it eBay too
You're going to want rounded beveled edges, 8H-9H hardness, and oleophobic covering.
Make sure the protector is thin enough, I've heard from people that .4mm and above screen protectors can be not sensitive enough to touch.
I've also heard that you want the cut out for the speaker to be a hole rather than a whole chunk missing as that leaves a large part of the screen (including the edge) vulnerable and attracts dust.
Hope that helped!
Are there any protectors with the same cut out as the spigen, but thinner than 0.4 and not $30
BayRyder said:
icarez is about $10 and seems to have a good rating on amazon. Pretty sure you can find it eBay too
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the icarez glass on my G3 and think it's great for the price. It covers the entire screen just about. There is enough space from the edges to use a case with no issues. Install was a breeze and they packaged it nicely with a wet wipe, micro cloth, squeegee, and lint stickers. The edges are rounded as well.
eRod v1.0 said:
I have the icarez glass on my G3 and think it's great for the price. It covers the entire screen just about. There is enough space from the edges to use a case with no issues. Install was a breeze and they packaged it nicely with a wet wipe, micro cloth, squeegee, and lint stickers. The edges are rounded as well.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed - got my .33mm version yesterday - installed easily and it works with my Spigen case with no problems.
This is the one I use:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00JV93WC4/ref=oh_details_o00_s00_i00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Had it on since the first day, absolutely no bubbles, dust, etc. Has a perfect fit and works very well with my Diztronic case (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00KN7UQ6I/ref=oh_details_o00_s00_i01?ie=UTF8&psc=1).
I highly recommend this combination.
xtremeguard.. go to there facebook page and there is a code for 85% off all glass protectors.. ends up being like 6 bucks a piece.. has the the speaker cut out. its a little thicker than some but touch functions work just fine. i have it on my verizon g3 right now
we know the tempered glasses of this phone is complete and utter thrash. I've had 3 of them in about 3 months now.
So here's some logic I'm questioning based of a basic understanding of physics:
I buy, or used to buy tempered glass in theory that it absorbs the force that breaks or cracks the LCD of the phone. now with these "new??" protectors they are no longer full adhesive therefore not absorbing force because its not adequately "attached" to the screen to give it added strength. so basically these tempered glass are only to protect from scratches and dings and what-have-you which i can get with non-glass ones that are at least full adhesive, thinner, without the dot matrix or rainbow bull**** or cutting off millimeters of my screen with the boarder they have or the dust that can get underneath after two weeks.
the reason im bringing anything into question is that last night my phone flew out of my jacket pocket hitting concrete stairs and upon impact the glass protector flew completely off the phone. like seriously........im sick of this bull**** regarding TGSP with this phone.......why hasnt this been an issue with phones in the past? any reason why they cant be full adhesive? or have to have the black boarder? and still be full coverage?
There are a number of tgsp full coverage, full adhesive screens with variable prices. The major problem is that with curved (a.k.a 2.5D) displays there is a lip on these protectors. The lip for the most part are NOT case friendly. The most popular cases when flexed (buttons pressed), tend to lift that lip eventually raising/popping off the protector. If you want a tgsp you must marry it with a compatible case which will never press the tgsp's lip.
Initially I had a cheap transparent case and a Orzly tgsp which seemed perfectly fine for three weeks before dust appeared around the power and volume buttons. Subsequently I purchased a bumper case with rubber liner which does not flex when the buttons are pressed so does not press against the tgsp lip.
I replaced the first Orzly with the second one from a two pack and am now over four weeks (Oct 7th-Nov 13th and counting) with no dust or tgsp lift of any kind. When ever I feel I need a replacement tgsp I will likely buy one of the following full coverage, full adhesive tgsps. I use a bumper case as they best show off my dBrand skin which gets hidden even with clear cases.
Another approach is one I heard while watching a series of dropped tests of screen protectors. The video was nothing special but the reviewer said he just bought bulk cheap tgsp protectors from china (ebay) and changed them every month. With my Orly experience matched to a low flex case this actually may be a better choice than looking for that ultimate protector, especially when no matter what tgsp the Oleophobic Coating will eventually wear off.
Some Full adhesive, Full coverage protectors:
OMYFILM OnePlus 5 Protector [Tempered Glass+Carbon Fiber], On Amazon.
SUPTMAX OnePlus 5 Tempered Glass Screen Protector, Seems identical to the OMYFILM but slightly cheaper.
Good luck
i removed my tgsp,
i tried like 10 different versions
100% of them are bad, even the full adhesive rounded edges bla bla
now i use it just with a case, no screen protector at all
the money i spend on TGSP i could buy a new screen for...
3DSammy said:
There are a number of tgsp full coverage, full adhesive screens with variable prices. The major problem is that with curved (a.k.a 2.5D) displays there is a lip on these protectors. The lip for the most part are NOT case friendly. The most popular cases when flexed (buttons pressed), tend to lift that lip eventually raising/popping off the protector. If you want a tgsp you must marry it with a compatible case which will never press the tgsp's lip.
Initially I had a cheap transparent case and a Orzly tgsp which seemed perfectly fine for three weeks before dust appeared around the power and volume buttons. Subsequently I purchased a bumper case with rubber liner which does not flex when the buttons are pressed so does not press against the tgsp lip.
I replaced the first Orzly with the second one from a two pack and am now over four weeks (Oct 7th-Nov 13th and counting) with no dust or tgsp lift of any kind. When ever I feel I need a replacement tgsp I will likely buy one of the following full coverage, full adhesive tgsps. I use a bumper case as they best show off my dBrand skin which gets hidden even with clear cases.
Another approach is one I heard while watching a series of dropped tests of screen protectors. The video was nothing special but the reviewer said he just bought bulk cheap tgsp protectors from china (ebay) and changed them every month. With my Orly experience matched to a low flex case this actually may be a better choice than looking for that ultimate protector, especially when no matter what tgsp the Oleophobic Coating will eventually wear off.
Some Full adhesive, Full coverage protectors:
OMYFILM OnePlus 5 Protector [Tempered Glass+Carbon Fiber], On Amazon.
SUPTMAX OnePlus 5 Tempered Glass Screen Protector, Seems identical to the OMYFILM but slightly cheaper.
Good luck
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
since i wrote this thread i have put in a few hours in research into tgsp for this phone and i landed on the same screen protector.........the OMYFILM carbon fiber. although i went a different route and bought the Spigen NeoFlex, its not a glass, figured ill give them a try since its been years since my last film type protector.
me myself and i said:
since i wrote this thread i have put in a few hours in research into tgsp for this phone and i landed on the same screen protector.........the OMYFILM carbon fiber. although i went a different route and bought the Spigen NeoFlex, its not a glass, figured ill give them a try since its been years since my last film type protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The Orzly was my first tempered glass protector on either a tablet or phone as I used film protection previously. I fell for that slippery glide feel due to the Oleophobic Coating which I've read wears off after a number on months. I'll likely stick with a tpsg only due to that coating. With that being said I've never really minded the film type protectors. So far I've not had a major accident involving a device and the screen so I'm mainly looking for limited display shock resistance and significant scratch protection without compromising the display's feel.
Is the included clear case tempered glass screen protector friendly, or does it lift it up from corners? Any recommendations for screen protector? And if that included one is no good, also recommendation for clear case is appreciated.
im using the MOFI full screen tempered glass screen protector with the factory case without issue.... just too bad the MOFi looks like a oild slick in the middle of the screen otherwise it would be perfect
I bought a Spigen case which is, as usual, nice and protective.
For the tempered glass, i bought a Force Glass ($$$) which is really nice to touch without fingers trails, but finally it's ****. Like all the S8/S9 (not dome glass) it's only glued with the edges and not very well, so it'll become dirty fast . And if you look at it under a bright sun you don't see anything.
I don't recommend to buy this "way too expansive" Force glass! I regret it! 2$ glass will do a better job.
Am I not right in thinking this phone comes with a screen protector already on it.? Mine looks like it does, obv don't want to try and take it off in case it is one lol... Came with a clear case too
Cheap tempered glass + clear case (Huawei case)
I used the clear case which came with the phone as for tempered glass I used a cheap (£1.99) from eBay.
The tempered glass covers the screen almost perfect. It isn't edge to edge, but it is wide as the screen.
The glass hasn't got a good oleophobic coating, but is better than the plastic one and has adhesive on entire surface. (i would add a photo but I've got no clue how?
Hi all, is there any spigen neo hybrid alternative for Huawei P20 Pro?
Hi, any issues getting the tempered glass on with the Spigen case? Thanks
RubyRP62 said:
I bought a Spigen case which is, as usual, nice and protective.
For the tempered glass, i bought a Force Glass ($$$) which is really nice to touch without fingers trails, but finally it's ****. Like all the S8/S9 (not dome glass) it's only glued with the edges and not very well, so it'll become dirty fast . And if you look at it under a bright sun you don't see anything.
I don't recommend to buy this "way too expansive" Force glass! I regret it! 2$ glass will do a better job.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've applied Zabra tempered glass (Amazon purchase) without any bubbles but after applying the Huawei clear case, edges came out, disabling my screen touch features.
Highly not recommended to buy this "Zabra full glue 9H tempered glass screen protector"
On of the best tempered glass for P20 PRO is Nillkin the hall series..
I have try Nillkin amazing H (3mm cover real screen leave 2mm at the edges case friendly) Nillkin amazing H+ (2,6mm cover real screen leave 2mm at the edges case friendly best clarity) & Nillkin CP-MAX 3D (3mm Full Cover edge to edge full adhesive full glue)
They are all fit perfect with excellent fit & clarity
No bubbles, no rainbow effect, no halo effect, no dot matrix, no fingerprints
I prefer CP-MAX 3D for full protection with original clear silicone case or ipaky case
I have bought the Spigen tempered glass screen protector and Spigen Ultra Hybrid Crystal Clear case recently
those side adhesive screen protectors suck!!!
whitestone is loca based and because of that full adhesive and it will be released in a week or so on amazon. great feel to the proctector, just like the original screen, no 3d dot matrix, no problems with touch sensitivity, almost no fingerprints and if they are gone with one wipe and so on.
i will get it asap since it's doing fantastic on my note 8 for over 9 months now.
i got the spigen rugged armour and i love it. Feels great in your hands. its like velvety soft. Using this with the stock screen protector, which i feel is sufficient for me
i just wish spigen released the ultra hybrid clear case with a built in kickstand for this phone.
I've never used a protector on my previous phones but opted for the Spigen and think it's great. Had it in five days now, doesn't get too messy from fingerprints and only issue with haloing was my fault, had to take it off a couple times as I want happy with how I put it on. Used it in direct sunlight and was amazed, after one Samsung and two Sony's I can actually read my phone outside"
TheRedIndian said:
I have bought the Spigen tempered glass screen protector and Spigen Ultra Hybrid Crystal Clear case recently
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I bought the Spigen Slim Armor case ( £15 ) and Spigen Tempered Glass ( about £8 ) and am very happy with both. I moved from Otterbox a few years ago when I couldn't see a decent case that I liked. I've had 4 Spigen cases for various phones so far and have never been let down to date
ESR products for me fits perfectly
It looks like there are not much good options for this phone (compared to my last one), I have ordered the spigen ultra hybrid (transparent) & tempered glass combo.
I'll post photos with the result
Do some regions not get an included case? I just bought this device yesterday in Canada and there was no case with it.
Spigen crystal clear case and Nillkin Amazing H+ for tempered screen. Trust me, this glass protector is the only one I have found to not retain fingerprints and to stick perfectly and evenly on the 20 pro. If you correctly align it with the edges of the screen, there will be no air pocket whatsoever. It's impressive.
Anybody know the brand of this screen protector and where I can get one? I'm most interested because, well, it's full screen and not just adhesive around the edge. But also the guy mentioned it works with the case I'm going to be using ( UAG ) .
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FymSOb_3vOs
[Review] alinsea tempered glass / taobao tempered glass & soft film / lens protectors
Alinsea LOCA tempered glass from Amazon Canada (case friendly)
https://www.amazon.ca/Alinsea-Prote...teway&sprefix=alinsea,aps,147&sr=8-6-fkmrnull
Just like everyone else have mentioned, application with LOCA liquid is difficult, messy, and takes a lot of patience. I watched a number of youtube videos before doing this and my success rate is 2 out of 3 applications. Ruined the first one, and rest went ok. This one from amazon was my third run.
The good:
- Case friendly! The company actually delivered as advertised. It covers a lot of the screen, but left just enough room to accommodate cases. Compatible with both my clear TPU case from Taobao / tmall and my Tech 21 Evo Check case.
- Fingerprint sensor works, although at times require slightly higher pressure but it works
- It is glass, so yes it feels smooth to touch
- Comes with pre cut stickers that covers up all the holes (usb plug, mic, ear piece etc) from the LOCA liquid during installation
- Company was VERY quick in providing a replacement (see below for reason why replacement was requested)
The bad:
- It is not resistant to smudges from finger prints
- 2 weeks into it and top left corner started to detach (see attached photo). I do not know if this is due to the quality of the LOCA liquid or if there was simply insufficient liquid at that particular corner. I am confident in my application technique as I waited to make sure the entire protector has LOCA liquid spread underneath it before starting the UV bake. I also UV baked all 4 edges extensively (longer than recommended time) prior to baking the main part of the screen.
- Expensive, $20 canadian dollars for 1 tempered glass. I think the company should at least provide an extra tube of LOCA liquid in case the first attempt goes wrong
See photos attached.
Taobao / tmall LOCA tempered glass (not case friendly)
https://detail.tmall.com/item.htm?id=579991819869&spm=a1z09.2.0.0.fbf72e8dE31OoJ&_u=m34gi5s2f0b6
Same as above with one major difference. This is quite close to FULL coverage, meaning not enough room along the edges to accommodate for cases. Unfortunately, I didn’t take any pictures of it because 2 days into using it, the case started to lift it, I got frustrated and ripped it off. Mind you I waited 1 full day for the protector to settle before putting on the case. I do not recommend this if you plan to use a case.
Taobao / tmall soft full coverage screen protector (not case friendly)
https://detail.tmall.com/item.htm?s...6684d62bdf7e2&abbucket=20&skuId=4032341339706
The good:
- Extremely easy to install; dry installation with application device included.
- Very good clarity (minimal orange peel effect)
- Feels smooth to touch
- Full coverage
The bad:
- Full coverage which means incompatible with case. Just like the Tabao glass above, started to lift after 2 days using it.
I also did not take pictures of this one, I apologize. At the time I didn’t think I would write these reviews. But bottom line is, I wouldn’t recommend if you plan to use a case.
eBay plastic film lens protector
https://www.ebay.ca/itm/6x-Displays...e=STRK:MEBIDX:IT&_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2649
Not much to say. Plastic film will protect against scratches, most importantly, it does not interfere with the flash unlike the one below. Came in a pack of 6. Good value and does its job. Fast shipping from seller.
Taobao / tmall tempered glass lens protector
https://detail.tmall.com/item.htm?id=579257689665&spm=a1z09.2.0.0.fbf72e8dE31OoJ&_u=m34gi5s2b3ae
Came in a pack of 2. It is glass so obviously more protective than the film above. However, they made a cut out for the flash and it is a COMPLETE fail.ure You’d think they would actually test it before selling it to people. The cut out appears to be big enough, but the strong flash still catches it and causes a blue glare in photos and videos. Although flash photography is not preferred, sometimes it is still needed. If you plan to use your flash at all for photos or videos, do not buy this type of lens protector.
update:
since the top left corner started to lift, it got a little worse over time. last week, i had 2 minor drops, 'soft' impact in my opinion, but was enough to cause further lifting of the rest of the screen protector. i forgot to take photos of the screen before removing it and i already applied the replacement which alinsea sent me weeks ago.
so now i am on alinsea glass #2 and will update this thread as time goes on.
Thanks for posting this, I'm looking for a screen protector.. I would usually buy skinomi, but they do not have the Mate 20 Pro available...
thanks