Related
So I've read that a few people on this forum have removed their Factory ASF, though I haven't read much feedback on how this affected the device:
- was the sensitivity of the screen altered?
- did the screen quality change?
- is there sticky residue left after removal?
- if so, does the residue come off after a few weeks of removal?
I've watched several videos where the ASF is removed off of the Xperia Z, but I have yet to come across videos for the Xperia TABLET Z.
(Just Search "Xperia Z anti shatter film removal" on Youtube)
So far, the feedback is good for removing the ASK off the Xperia Z, but is it really safe for the Xperia Tablet Z?
Should I :
a) Remove the ASF and leave it as so
b) Remove the ASF and purchase a screen protector.
c) Leave the ASF on and purchase a screen protector
I have no scratches on my device yet, but I am afraid of having some in the future due to the fragility of the ASF.
Thanks!
I recklessly went ahead and removed the ASF with a box cutter and peeled of the film and I am satisfied with the results!
Youtube link : youtube.com/watch?v=xuwHzRYnzQY (sorry, new user -> cant post links)
The SONY logo is still on, but after washing the surface with a cloth and water, most of the adhesive is gone and it has a much better feel to it than the default film!
With that said, I plan on purchasing a Screen Protector anyways and have just bought the Poetic Slimline Case.
So far, I like the change because there is:
>Less Friction (After washing the tablet)
>Bettter Responsiveness
>Scratch resistance that eclipses the ASF
>A more premium feel to the screen
This DOES void your warranty so be wary of that, but in my opinion this was a worthwhile change!
I have been thinking about doing this since the day I got my xtz and an hour later seeing a small scratch. Does the true screen really seem more scratch proof?
Sent from my SGP311 using Tapatalk HD
jmikeb92 said:
I have been thinking about doing this since the day I got my xtz and an hour later seeing a small scratch. Does the true screen really seem more scratch proof?
Sent from my SGP311 using Tapatalk HD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It actually is resistant to scratches, I have absolutely no idea why Sony decided to apply a scratchable film on top of their scratch resistant screen, it really seems like nonsense. Plus, the glass surface seems smother after washing it, so I definitely recommend doing it, I doubt it affects shatter resistance, if you drop your tablets from 1 meter/3ft, it's screen is likely to break either way.
I ordered the Poetic Slimline Case, so that'll add protection to the tablet too; it theoretically renders the ASF's "purpose" useless since it offers shock redistribution. The screen remains a fingerprint magnet, though, but it's not as bad as having the film on.
My Questions: Answered
Q - was the sensitivity of the screen altered?
A: Yes, The screen feels more responsive. An overall improvement. +1
Q - did the screen quality change?
A: The screen is definitely clearer and fingerprints are less prominent An overall improvement. +1
Q - is there sticky residue left after removal?
A: Yes, but a cloth and water or a screen washing solution removes it after a bit of rubbing, not much effort is needed.
Q - if so, does the residue come off after a few weeks of removal?
A: Refer to above answer.
padooka said:
So I've read that a few people on this forum have removed their Factory ASF, though I haven't read much feedback on how this affected the device:
- was the sensitivity of the screen altered?
- did the screen quality change?
- is there sticky residue left after removal?
- if so, does the residue come off after a few weeks of removal?
I've watched several videos where the ASF is removed off of the Xperia Z, but I have yet to come across videos for the Xperia TABLET Z.
(Just Search "Xperia Z anti shatter film removal" on Youtube)
So far, the feedback is good for removing the ASK off the Xperia Z, but is it really safe for the Xperia Tablet Z?
Should I :
a) Remove the ASF and leave it as so
b) Remove the ASF and purchase a screen protector.
c) Leave the ASF on and purchase a screen protector
I have no scratches on my device yet, but I am afraid of having some in the future due to the fragility of the ASF.
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I removed the shatterproof film on mine within a week of getting the tablet. I hate the feel of screen protectors and like to leave all my devices unprotected!
Anyway, I'd highly recommend anyone thinking of it to go ahead and remove it. YES, it does improve touch sensitivity and its so much better to touch real glass than a plastic film. I didn't notice much change in the display quality and would love to see a kernel which will let me change some of the gamma settings (way too warm for me now and blacks aren't dark enough).
Removing the film is not that easy and there will be some residue left behind but it comes off with a days use.
I also removed the film.
Now I find the color reproduction better, picture seems brighter, touch sensitivity unchanged.
And indeed the feeling of touching glass is better!
Only thing is, now the rim is a bit higher than the screen glass (just the amount that equals the thickness of the Sony screen protector which is surprisingly thick), which doesn't feel as smooth to the fingers when holding the device.
You can adjust the white balance by rooting the tablet and installing the white balance from the Xperia ZL. There is a thread somewhere (Xperia ZL white balance ported to Xperia Z or so) with instructions how to install. Works flawlessly here. For removing the yellowish/greenish tint, you have to increase the saturation of blue/violet tones (complementary color).
I can't seem to get the peeling started any pointers?
Sent from my SGP311 using Tapatalk HD
You have to cautiously lift one corner of the film with a very thin blade, for instance a carpet knife. Then you can grab the film and peel it off.
I am using Poetic Slim Case. It perfectly fits with luxury look and feel.
I bought Sony case and returned within an hour after walked out of the store. Ridiculous expensive but feel cheapo.
padooka said:
I ordered the Poetic Slimline Case, so that'll add protection to the tablet too; it theoretically renders the ASF's "purpose" useless since it offers shock redistribution. The screen remains a fingerprint magnet, though, but it's not as bad as having the film on.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Zb134 said:
I removed the shatterproof film on mine within a week of getting the tablet. I hate the feel of screen protectors and like to leave all my devices unprotected!
Anyway, I'd highly recommend anyone thinking of it to go ahead and remove it. YES, it does improve touch sensitivity and its so much better to touch real glass than a plastic film. I didn't notice much change in the display quality and would love to see a kernel which will let me change some of the gamma settings (way too warm for me now and blacks aren't dark enough).
Removing the film is not that easy and there will be some residue left behind but it comes off with a days use.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Love the feeling without sticky oil and fingerprint!!! But i gonna get another screen protector for anti-glare purpose. Thanks for experiences
Ryu_1806 said:
Love the feeling without sticky oil and fingerprint!!! But i gonna get another screen protector for anti-glare purpose. Thanks for experiences
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am still rocking the shipping plastic screen which goes over the ASF. lol.
I'd just like to point out the "purpose" of the shatterproof screen protector is to prevent shattering (key word being shatter meaning shards of glass coming Off the screen the screen) which the protector does its job and keeps the shards on the device thus making it shatterproof. It does not make it crack proof. And replacing with another screen protector Will retain the original shatterproof ability. I am happy to have stumbled across this thread as I was unaware there was a protector and was mad that it scratched so easily. Now I have a way to remove those scratches.
I have to be entirely honest here, i got my XTZ 4 months ago and i just now realised it even has an antishatter film
i was directed here by another kind member, after noticing my EasyAcc case was causing scratches on the screen.
I am glad that the screen itself has not been scratched, but instead the ASF. Was effing annoyed when I saw the scratches!
Now that I know it is just the ASF I am going to keep it on and allow it to take more punishment before I take it off! Then i'll decide whether to buy another protector or leave the screen naked.
Was considering getting the Official Sony case, but feedback from people here is not good, so I guess the seach continues for an alternative case.
I'd recommend against buying the Sony case. It's too expensive for the design and quality. My first one was damaged within 2 months of normal use.... Luckily they replaced it.
Sent from my SGP311 using XDA Premium HD app
removing ASF from my tablet Z is the best thing I have done..... sharper and more responsive with my stylus.... and more ....
the best is the fingers print ... without the film minimum print.....
don't tell Sony lol
I just removed mine almost two years after I bought the tablet. Brilliant. You can imagine the level of scratching on the tablet by now!!!! Now, let's get lollipop and it'll feel like that I got a brand new tablet for nothing!
Removed mine after many years with this tablet and sadly regret:
- Glass is uncoated so feels worse to touch, has higher friction, and picks up oily marks. Refraction from fingerprints is now visible when the display is on; oleophobic coating normally prevents this
- Screen appearance is identical, no change in colours/contrast/etc. I'm a nerd when it comes to monitor calibration so I don't say this lightly!
- Most importantly: touch input is degraded. I have verified with the developer tools that swipes misbehave - either registering as a tap, or as a swipe that jumps to the corner of the screen. Scrolling feels broken now - often fails to continue momentum scrolling after removing finger due to the corner jump
Overall would not recommend, the digitiser is calibrated for the ASF to be present. The only positive is fewer scratches.
Hi everybody.
I have been testing a couple of screen protectors in the past and wanted to share my experince with you.
The best one in my opionen is from SAMSUNG itself. It simply has the best quality. If you buy it on amazon its only $11. (http://amzn.to/2xGpWWs) I think for 2 screen protectors thats a good value for the money.
I even made a video review about it to tell what I like about it. If you are interested in it you can watch it here:
https://youtu.be/S2ixW_dvx8s
What are your experiences with screen protectors? I am curious. Share your opinions here
Though mine isn't really a screen protector, I am using the lifeproof case for my S8. Have been very happy with it. The screen protector built into the case is already curved so it fits easily. People have complained about issues with the curved part of the touchscreen and responsiveness. I have not experienced this issue at all. I have always had good luck with the Zagg Glass Protector with other phones, not sure how that is with the S8. Something to potentially look at for people.
chris674 said:
Though mine isn't really a screen protector, I am using the lifeproof case for my S8. Have been very happy with it. The screen protector built into the case is already curved so it fits easily. People have complained about issues with the curved part of the touchscreen and responsiveness. I have not experienced this issue at all. I have always had good luck with the Zagg Glass Protector with other phones, not sure how that is with the S8. Something to potentially look at for people.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see. THe big problem with most of the screen protectors for me was that most of them could not hold to the edges and came off pretty early. So that's a big criteria for a good screen protector. THe one by samsung still covers my whole front after months which is one of the many reasons I like it so much.
Glass protectors are to thick and make the phone too thick in my opionion. But maybe I should give it another shot..
yes but glass protectors are designed to protect your screen in an accident, the normal film ones you have will not protect your screen from accidental damage, i presently have a htc phone with a glass screen protector on it and it has saved my phone many times as the glass screen protector cracked but the screen underneath was unmarked. I know have a samsung s8, i bought two glass screen protectors from amazon uk, the reviews were made by 72 viewers and almost 100%. i fitted the screen protector perfectly and it didnt stick to the curve edges and was very unresponsive to touch , i sent them back for full refund which i got. most importantly most of the reviews are fake reviews, amazon should stop this. ive left my feedback on amazon.
These flimsy plastic screen protectors make no sense to me. Your phone glass is already harder than anything you'll throw into your pocket. The metal on your keys and **** can't scratch your screen anyway and all these would do is protect from scratches by getting scratched themselves.
People want screen protectors to protect from cracking and shattering the phone not to protect from scratches. The screen is already mostly scratch proof unless you're rubbing it up against a pointy edge of some harder glass which I seriously don't think you'd be doing.
Anyone try Nano Fix it?
Shofar1
best Screen Protector for the S8
I almost feel bad that I underestimated the installation part as I almost wanted to throw the first screen protector I used. If done correctly and patiently, you will have a premium looking phone. Don’t rush it if you don’t want to regret it. So for you guys who are afraid of the “wet installation”, give it a try. It was a bit difficult for me, but I’ll do it again if it means maintaining the high quality of my Samsung Galaxy S8. And besides, the S8.
https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/aw/d/B07DF82TJ3/ref=sspa_mw_detail_5?ie=UTF8&psc=1
I bought this one, though I will give it a try. It works perfect and holds very strong as well. I bought same brand for s7 edge and it is the same quality.
Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk
IDK for you but I'm satisfied with this goo.gl/8brXA2 straight from Amazon and reasonable price also I think they have for s8 plus goo.gl/gMg9Wb
https://www.ebay.com/itm/153275884028?var=&ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1555.l2649
i tested this one works perfectly
the guard actually sticks to the device via glue with UV just like whitestone one but is lot cheaper
I don't use any screen protector, I realized that touching and stroking the screen was very sensational.
I can totally agree with you. In the past, I've always used multiple screen protectors.
I have my S8+ device a bit over a year now and I can see only a micro-scratches, which are invisible in the daily usage.
Besides, what's the point of buying screen protectors for, let's say 50$ and replace them every year? I'd rather save this money and buy sooner the new, fresh model.
Hi. I would like to know what you all end up using on your screen. I just bought me an S8+ and are desperately looking for a good screen protector that i can use with a case.
Please enlighten me
First of all, I want to say this device is awesome, unbeatable at this price range. I don't care about screen bleeding, notch etc.
However It has one weakest link- QUALITY OF SCREEN.
I bought this device because it has one advantage over other flagships i.e. plastic back. These days companies are making all glass phones because they know consumers, sooner or later, will break their glass phones and pay hefty sum of money to fix them. Poco F1 has plastic back and I love it but it's screen is fragile AF. I don't know what screen they have used because gorilla glass is not so delicate. I have moto g as secondary device and it's GG3 screen is intact after several drops. Now, people over youtube, twitter and xda forums are telling their stories how their screen got shattered even when very small pressure was applied or dropped from very small height. I know cost cutting is done but to this extent? Very Fragile screen with weird touch responses.
There could be following reason for this.
Xiaomi has deliberately used very cheap screen. Device is just 300 dollars, people will root it and debloat it or use custom Roms. So how to make money when there are no miui ads shown? Simple, every customer will break their screen and pay 100 dollars or 6-7k rupees.
But personally I don't think any brand would do this to their first phone when their is so much hype. But it is what it is. Our screen is not safe even after applying unofficial tempered glasses available. This is a big mess.
Best Solution-
Screen protectors are available online and offline for this device but they do not fit well and people are still breaking their screen after applying them. So, Xiaomi should provide official edge to edge screen protectors. So I would request their head Mr. @jaimani to do something about it.
We don't need hard cases because plastic back is enough.
We don't need skins because plastic back is enough.
But We need official screen protectors.
I have used another brand adhesive based screen protector on my expensive Samsung, curved screen phones (Note 8, S10+, now S20+) a few times, each time with limited success. This one seems to have the best qualities without much of the headaches. The difference seems to be two fold - 1) the glass does not curve to fit the screen. On my S20+, it is a flat glass, which covers the screen perfectly, given the small bezel of the S20+ and 2) the weight provided, to be placed on the fingerprint reader during installation.
The Samsung curved Gorilla Glass, while attractive and smooth, does not like screen protectors when used with a case. The fact that this is a flat screen works well with my case (a generic silicon case).
The fingerprint recognition worked immediately, without having to re-register my fingerprint.
The screen is slick - almost slippery - but is just as sensitive to the touch as the naked glass. An added benefit seems to be it's oleophobic (no fingerprints) ability. It doesn't pick up any fingerprints.
Installation is easy, if you take your time and follow directions. Use the level. Clean the screen. Open the adhesive from the proper end. wait for the adhesive to cover the entire screen, and then, wait some more. Use the UV light for the proscribed time. I read some negative reviews here and it is apparent that directions are not being followed. FOLLOW THE DIRECTIONS! This isn't rocket science, people.
Botoom line - this is better in many ways to the alternative adhesive screen protector that is on Amazon, and I paid about $10 less. I would do it again, and will for my wife's phone.
I purchased this screen protector and am not being paid to write this review.
whartonsprinter said:
I have used another brand adhesive based screen protector on my expensive Samsung, curved screen phones (Note 8, S10+, now S20+) a few times, each time with limited success. This one seems to have the best qualities without much of the headaches. The difference seems to be two fold - 1) the glass does not curve to fit the screen. On my S20+, it is a flat glass, which covers the screen perfectly, given the small bezel of the S20+ and 2) the weight provided, to be placed on the fingerprint reader during installation.
The Samsung curved Gorilla Glass, while attractive and smooth, does not like screen protectors when used with a case. The fact that this is a flat screen works well with my case (a generic silicon case).
The fingerprint recognition worked immediately, without having to re-register my fingerprint.
The screen is slick - almost slippery - but is just as sensitive to the touch as the naked glass. An added benefit seems to be it's oleophobic (no fingerprints) ability. It doesn't pick up any fingerprints.
Installation is easy, if you take your time and follow directions. Use the level. Clean the screen. Open the adhesive from the proper end. wait for the adhesive to cover the entire screen, and then, wait some more. Use the UV light for the proscribed time. I read some negative reviews here and it is apparent that directions are not being followed. FOLLOW THE DIRECTIONS! This isn't rocket science, people.
Botoom line - this is better in many ways to the alternative adhesive screen protector that is on Amazon, and I paid about $10 less. I would do it again, and will for my wife's phone.
I purchased this screen protector and am not being paid to write this review.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Does the fingerprint sensor work?
xela19115 said:
Does the fingerprint sensor work?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it does
You need to re scan your fingerprints post install though
I've had it on my S20 ultra for a few months now and no issues, no lifting at the edges either
I recently bought a tempered glass on amazon for my Samsung S20 Plus and got it delivered a month ago. Was eager to try it on and upon trying I realized that it won't stick well around the curved edges. Sadly I wasted 800rs on that. Then my cousin refered me a screen protector from GadgetShieldz, he had been using the same for his Samsung S20 which had a curved screen as well. At first while purchasing I was afraid because I had to apply the product to the phone. But after reffering to their "How to?" videos, I got it perfect the first time. If you too are confused like I was, feel free to follow the below link and check out their collection. They have body protectors too if you want transparent protection for body!
Screen Guards & Mobile Phone Full Body Screen Protectors
Screen Guards for Smartphones & Mobile Phone Full Body Screen Protector, Scratch Guard for Apple iPhone, Samsung, OnePlus, Redmi, Xiaomi, Moto, Huawei Honor, Vivo, Oppo, Nokia, Realme & more. Ships Worldwide. Buy Online | Gadgetshieldz Screen Protector In
www.gadgetshieldz.com
I had S20 for about 6 months and today I've been unlucky enough to somehow get dust under the protector and I had to peel it off.
I've been happy with it but I sadly found out that Samsung doesn't sell (or apply) the exact same screen protector in their stores so I'm looking for a replacement that will provide the most similar experience to the one that was originally applied on the screen.
Note: I do NOT want a glass screen protector. If there's a foil that will work as good or better than the pre-applied one, that's fine but a glass screen protector is something I'm not interested in.
Yep, I agree with you, their included protector is just great! I read that they do it in their stores, but that was while ago.... I'd be interested in similar protector as well since mine has some scratches and bubbles
I got some of these. Easy to apply (they give you all the tools) and is basically the same as the OEM one in terms of performance and aesthetics. Just read the installation booklet before you dive in as it's like a two part thing with a squeegee tool.
apiker [4 Pack] Compatible for Samsung Galaxy S20 Plus/S20+ Screen Protector, Soft TPU S20 Plus Screen Protector Film [Support Fingerprint Sensor] [Case Friendly] [Maximum Coverage][Bubble free]: Amazon.co.uk: Electronics & Photo
Free delivery and returns on eligible orders. Buy apiker [4 Pack] Compatible for Samsung Galaxy S20 Plus/S20+ Screen Protector, Soft TPU S20 Plus Screen Protector Film [Support Fingerprint Sensor] [Case Friendly] [Maximum Coverage][Bubble free] at Amazon UK.
www.amazon.co.uk
So I did but the one you suggested and I'm generally happy, the application I've done wasn't perfect (I applied the foil slightly to the left but other than that, it is aligned) but I do agree that it was quite easy to apply.
So onto differences from the OEM one.
There is no hole for the camera which I'm not sure is bad since I don't really use front camera and can't say if it affects the quality. For me it's probably a benefit because it would drive me mad if the hole were misaligned because of my imperfect application
Sadly, the foil is "softer" - if I grab the phone in wrong way and my fingernails put too much force towards the screen, it does leave marks (scratches, I guess). They don't seem to actually stay there for long but I don't feel as comfortable knowing that I can scratch it that easily. Even though I don't expect to change this foil to anything else, the OEM was definitely better on that front.
I don't really have much else to say here, for the price (I bought 3-pack for an equivalent of 13-14$) it's great but if I would be looking for the best foil out there (and had money to waste on all the different foils ), I would definitely keep looking for a better one.
Ibywind. Best of the best.
jack1142 said:
I had S20 for about 6 months and today I've been unlucky enough to somehow get dust under the protector and I had to peel it off.
I've been happy with it but I sadly found out that Samsung doesn't sell (or apply) the exact same screen protector in their stores so I'm looking for a replacement that will provide the most similar experience to the one that was originally applied on the screen.
Note: I do NOT want a glass screen protector. If there's a foil that will work as good or better than the pre-applied one, that's fine but a glass screen protector is something I'm not interested in.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the same problem with my S20; I tried different tempers but nothing worked, then I tried gadgetshieldz screen skins, which were recommended by a colleague. I've been using it for three months and am pleased with it.
In my perception, you may like that because the display skin is ultra-thin.
Am leaving the link which I ordered on: Samsung s20