Hello,
Earlier today I got an OTA upgrade of my Samsung Galaxy S4 to Jellybean 4.3.
Everything is working great except for some reason my external SD card (A 64 GB SanDisk MicroSD) is read only. The only thing I can do with it is to format it. Otherwise all write operations to it fail.
I have tried two different cards and several different apps (Terminal, Astro File Manager for instance) and none of them can write to the device.
Is anybody else experiencing this issue or does anybody have any tip for how to solve it?
I am almost thinking it is a matter of a missing new permission but I can't find anything in the SDK docs about it (If this is the case that is fine because my main use of the card is a home made music player that I've written).
I have the same issue after updating to 4.3 yesterday - external SD card is mounted as Read Only after the update.
I have not seen it mentioned before, but It is quite possible that it is just part of the new "Google Experience" - Google has for a long time advocated having a single SD card and several of the tablet devices already had their external SD card mounted as read only in the past.
You can still write to it using MTP from a PC, but it is mounted as ReadOnly for the accounts that Android apps run on the device.
Of course it is possible that it is just a strange side effect (bug) in the upgrade process that is affecting only some devices.
pirin said:
I have the same issue after updating to 4.3 yesterday - external SD card is mounted as Read Only after the update.
I have not seen it mentioned before, but It is quite possible that it is just part of the new "Google Experience" - Google has for a long time advocated having a single SD card and several of the tablet devices already had their external SD card mounted as read only in the past.
You can still write to it using MTP from a PC, but it is mounted as ReadOnly for the accounts that Android apps run on the device.
Of course it is possible that it is just a strange side effect (bug) in the upgrade process that is affecting only some devices.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, in some way I'm comforted that I am not going insane here.
I will be calling customer support but in a perfect storm for some reason yesterday my Google Wallet account was "suspended pending validation" and it supposedly takes 2-3 days for Google to verify it and you can't get to the support number for Nexus and Google Experience devices without access to your wallet account .
If I learn something I will be letting you know.
same thing happened to me when I updated my s4 to 4.3 made the external SD card into read only cannot modify it using android only if I connect it with my PC. I called Google today they told me that they have not heard of this issue before but they forward the info to there technical people and they will respond back eventually for an email and hopefully a fix. but I am glad to see I am not the only one dealing with this. hopefully Google will get this issue fixed.
ES File Explorer works, so its not impossible for other apps to get updated to work.
I've been looking into this, trying to work around the issue in my own apps. Regrettably don't have a GS4 GPE, but working with users and searching have so far discovered the following:
The underlying problem is that in Android 4.3 (at least on the GS4 G.P. Edition), an application's UNIX user id needs to be part of the group "media_rw" in order to write to the removable "external" SD card.
The "WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE" permission that almost every app out there uses is inadequate. That will get your app uid added to the group "sdcard_rw", which in the case of Android 4.3+GS4 G.P.E. is only good enough to write to the built-in storage.
The "WRITE_MEDIA_STORAGE" permission is required in order to have your app uid added to the group "media_rw". The problem is that this is a system protected permission. You can put this permission in your manifest, but you won't actually be granted it unless you're a system app. (Even tested this modification to FX File Explorer to make sure, and it still fails).
There does appear to be one solution available if you have root: modify the /system/etc/permissions/platform.xml file and grant the WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE permission access to the group "media_rw". Source of this is here: http://forums.androidcentral.com/samsung-galaxy-s4-google-edition/303764-4-3-sd-write-access.html I have not personally tried this.
Issues with external SD
tliebeck said:
There does appear to be one solution available if you have root: modify the /system/etc/permissions/platform.xml file and grant the WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE permission access to the group "media_rw". Source of this is here: http://forums.androidcentral.com/samsung-galaxy-s4-google-edition/303764-4-3-sd-write-access.html I have not personally tried this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi!
I have the very same problem: some apps can access the external SD, some others do not.
I tried mount/unmount and root access in ES Explorer... but no way.
The freshly downloaded "Root Explorer" does have WRITE access to the ExtSD, but TBackup doesn't...
I am running Jamal 4.3 AOSP Rom on a EU i9505.
Any help is welcome!
Help! Got the same problem here
64gb samsung micro sd card. Always write protected and no other way to re-format it.
ivanslh said:
Help! Got the same problem here
64gb samsung micro sd card. Always write protected and no other way to re-format it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This solution here helped me: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=48702336&postcount=13
"I was having the very same problem. I finally went into the computer management, and was about to throw phone across room....when I tried to format one last time. This time I unchecked the quick format. It is taking longer, but seems to be working...I am keeping fingers crossed.
Full Format has finished and card is saved! Hope this helps anyone in the future."
tliebeck said:
There does appear to be one solution available if you have root: modify the /system/etc/permissions/platform.xml file and grant the WRITE_EXTERNAL_STORAGE permission access to the group "media_rw". Source of this is here: http://forums.androidcentral.com/samsung-galaxy-s4-google-edition/303764-4-3-sd-write-access.html I have not personally tried this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know this is almost 1 year old but... I was struggling with this issue for some days until I tried this and: :laugh:This is the solution!
[HOW-TO] Installing AOSP Android 7.0 "Nougat" Internally on the 16 GB Nook Tablet
Edit 2-5-23: I recently revisited my installation and found it had become sluggish to the point of being more or less useless. Google Play service updates had taken their toll. So I decided to start over and use microG instead. I also found that the original rooting method no longer worked for some unknown reason, so I resorted to Magisk. Seems like a good time for an update to the instructions!
[shamelessly adapted from peerless instructions for other NT installs by @digixmax, and information from @mikeataol that is scattered through the CM 13.0 thread.]
Disclaimer: Neither I nor any other user mentioned here, real or imaginary, is responsible if you brick your device following these instructions. The only stupid question is the one you didn't ask right before you ruined your tablet.
By following these instructions you can install an AOSP Android 7.0 ROM from @amaces internally (into emmc) on a 16 GB Nook Tablet running either stock, CM 10.x, CM 11.x, CM 12.x, or CM 13.x, assuming you have done no special repartitioning (it may also work if you have done special repartitioning, but I do not know). If you have previously installed CM 14.x and have repartitioned, you can return to those installation instructions where there may be a description of how to revert to the regular partitioning. This ROM does not require any special partitioning.
The AOSP ROM is a bare-bones, very responsive build. It runs rings around my former CM 12.1 install without any freezes or shutdowns. Using microG to spoof Google Services Framework signature frees you from the relentless pressure of GApps as Play Services are always updating and always expanding. I originally used a pico GApps package on my first install. At the time the package was 77 MB. The current package as of this editing is 184 MB--too much for the device. You can start with my original package but it won't stay that size. Still, some people will want to try so I have provided instructions for both microG and GApps.
If you have a bootable SD card made for installing CM 10.x-13.x, you can skip to step 2b.
1. Using a disk partition tool (such as MiniTool Partition Wizard Home Edition) create on the SD card a Primary FAT32 partition, set the partition ID type for the partition to 0x0C FAT32 LBA, and set its Active flag. Once this is done, the partition should appear as a (read/write accessible) drive under Windows
2. Obtain and copy to the SD card the following files:
a. first MLO, then next u-boot.bin, and finally flashing_boot.img in succulent_boot.zip obtained from https://www.mediafire.com/folder/xjwc1a482a6ll/Nook_Tablet
b. TWRP (TeamWin Recovery Project) version 2.8.6.0, e.g. twrp-2.8.6.0-acclaim-sdcard.img from https://dl.twrp.me/acclaim/twrp-2.8.6.0-acclaim-sdcard.img.html, rename it to recovery.img before copying to SD card. Be sure to use the sdcard.img file and not the one for internal emmc
c. the flashable_TWRP_3.0.2-0.zip zip file from https://www.mediafire.com/folder/xjwc1a482a6ll/Nook_Tablet
d. the zip file of the AOSP Android 7.0 ROM by @amaces, i.e., aosp_acclaim-ota-NBD90Z.161020.zip from https://www.mediafire.com/?5vcw8l603d3r5sc or https://mega.nz/#!nQwiEILS!dm7i-4AOUzYW5yP0LaqcZ5EAUsxeh-Qr8DULB4BGYZ8 [this ROM is no longer in the repository maintained by @amaces] (alternate link provided by @mikeataol)
e. Magisk for the Nook Tablet: https://forum.xda-developers.com/attachments/magisk-v16-0_patched2-zip.4427362/ (credits to member @fddm)
OPTIONAL:
f. the zip file of the GApps package (corresponding to Android 7.0): https://www.mediafire.com/file/po12x99lg47p4oj/open_gapps-arm-7.0-pico-20170310.zip/file
3. Put the SD card into the NT and boot from its power off by inserting a powered USB cable. Press and hold the "n" button as soon as CyanoBoot comes up to get the boot menu to display.
a. Select SDC Recovery.
b. [Optional step but highly recommended] Select Backup to backup your NT current ROM config (/boot, /recovery, /system, and /data).
c. Return to TWRP opening screen and select Install. From the external SD card install flashable_TWRP_3.0.2-0.zip
(my experience with TWRP is that it is very cranky, at least on my tablet; if you have trouble with it not recognizing the external SD card, try rebooting into recovery again....or again....)
d. Reboot. Press and hold the "n" button as soon as CyanoBoot comes up to get the boot menu to display. Select Internal (emmc) Recovery (note that from here on all installation is done using the internal TWRP 3.0.2-0)
e. Select Wipe (data & factory reset) OR, using Advanced Wipe, wipe system, data, cache, dalvik.
f. [Optional] Select Advanced Wipe, Repair or Change file system; select "data" (only) and change file system from ext4s to f2fs (supposedly a faster format--if you decide to undo all this, you should probably reformat "data" to ext4s)
g. Reboot to internal (emmc) recovery as in 3d. (ignore warnings about "no system" if you see any)
h. Select Install. From the external SD card install aosp_acclaim-ota-NBD90Z.161020.zip (ignore E: unknown command errors)
i. Reboot to internal (emmc) recovery as in 3d.
j. Select Install. From the external SD card install magisk-v16-0_patched2-zip
OPTIONAL:
k. Reboot to internal (emmc) recovery as in 3d.
l. Select Install. From the external SD card install appropriate opengapps zip
Continue here from either step j or step l
m. Remove SD card and select reboot.
For GApps
n. Wait for first boot to complete and sign in.
After first boot and the usual stuff, check Magisk Manager to see if root is enabled. You will be asked to update Magisk Manager. You can say "yes" ONCE. It will ask every time you open the app, but don't say "yes" again. The next update will render it inoperable., you'll lose root, curse me, etc. You've been warned.
Done!
[Don't you want to make a baseline backup right now?]
microG (for those skipping GApps)
Spoiler
You've skipped GApps if you're looking at this. There are all kinds of packages available for Magisk to do all the microG stuff in one fell swoop. But there's a lot of contradictory information out there and many of the packages include other stuff you may not want. Also, this old version of Magisk may not work with some of the packages. In the end I decided to try setting up microG the way I learned to do it: manually. It's not that difficult and you get only what you want.
To work, microG requires that signature spoofing be enabled on the ROM. On this ROM you need to use Xposed for that. So let's get started!
4.
a. Download the Xposed installer zip for Magisk and SDK 24 (Android 7.0): https://www.mediafire.com/file/v6zkpj4n3rbi11t/xposed-sdk24-topjohnwu.zip/file. Copy the file to the bootable SD card you used for the ROM installation.
OPTIONAL
b. Download the flashable maps zip file and copy it to the SD card (you only want this if you wish to use Location services or might want to run Tasker): https://www.mediafire.com/file/7y8cmr4obydo35d/mapsv1.flashable.zip/file
c. You'll need some kind of root file manager for this process (you could use adb, but it's cumbersome). I've attached an old version of ES File Explorer that I like. You'll have to adb install that since the meager sort of "file manager" in the ROM doesn't work with the package installer.
d. You'll also need the Xposed installer app and the Fake GApps module which enables signature spoofing. I've attached both below.
e. Finally, you need the microG component apps. You can get them here: https://microg.org/download.html. You want Services Core, Services Framework Proxy, and Store. If you want to use Location services, you will also need the UnifiedNLP app.
The tools are now assembled!
f. Shut down your tablet and place the bootable SD card in the slot. Power up.
g. Press and hold the "n" button as soon as CyanoBoot comes up to get the boot menu to display. Select Internal (emmc) Recovery
h. Select Install. From the external SD card install xposed-sdk24-topjohnwu.zip
OPTIONAL
i. If you want to use Location services, also install mapsv1.flashable.zip
j. Remove the SD card and reboot. The process may take a little longer due to the new Xposed framework (first time only).
k. Transfer the apps you collected in steps d and e above to the internal Download folder. Use the root file manager you installed to install the Xposed installer app and the Fake GApps app. Open the installer app and check anything that needs checking then reboot. Check the installer app once more to see that the Fake GApps app has been installed and enabled.
l. Using the root file manager create the folder /system/priv-app/Phonesky. Set folder permissions to rwx-rx-rx. Use the root file manager to move fake "Store" app (com.android.vending-16.apk) into /system/priv-app/Phonesky and set apk file permissions to rw-r-r.
m. Move microG component apks into /system/priv-app; set apk file permissions to rw-r-r (you need a minimum of Services Core and Services Framework Proxy for this step). Reboot.
n. Check microG Settings to be sure spoofing is enabled and other permissions are granted. You don't need to enable any of the other Google stuff at this point unless you want to.
OPTIONAL
o. If you want Location services install the UnifiedNLP app then return to microG settings to configure (check regular settings for "Location" also--you'll see that the microG settings have been inserted into the general Settings app)
OK, you now have microG running at its lowest service level. Without doing anything else it should provide signature spoofing for apps that are looking for Google Services Framework. If you want higher levels of service (say, an actual Google account) you can make those selections in the settings. Generally, apps that require a Google account will call up microG to initiate a Google login (slow, but it works).
It is theoretically possible to run the PlayStore with the right configuration, but I would not recommend it. The Aurora Store (F-droid) runs really well on the device and can provide you with PlayStore access without GApps (or more demanding levels of microG service). You can use the anonymous login.
Calendar and Contacts will not sync with Google using microG. There's a lot of old stuff online about this working and how to set it up, but it does not work any more, so don't waste your time. If you MUST have synced contacts and calendar, you can use DavX (F-droid) (configuration--start with Calendar!) . Otherwise you can export a vcard file (*.vcf) of your contacts and load them in as a local set on the tablet. For a contacts app I extracted the Contacts.apk from a CM 13 ROM and placed it in /system/app/Contacts (permissions rw-r-r). Likewise the Calendar.apk in /system/app/Calendar. I've attached these apps below.
For email I tried using the AOSP client from a CM 13 ROM. The system recognized it but crashed on opening. Eventually I settled on an older version of K-9 mail (6.20). I had problems with Google 2-factor verification with the more current versions.
I've attached a screenshot of my system below. More discussion on individual apps and issues in the following post.
My thanks to @digixmax for his many, many excellent how-to's and for the help he has given me in the past. He is also responsible for providing the flashable TWRP that avoids the need for fastboot in this install. I'm grateful to @mikeataol for his patient responses to my probably lame questions in the CM 13.0 thread concerning this ROM and, of course, really thankful that @amaces turned out this excellent version of AOSP Android 7.0 for our devices.
See post immediately below for a discussion of known issues and app options.
Updated 2-16-23
Issues and Apps
Every custom (and stock) ROM has some issues. This one seems to have very few and they are easily addressed.
1. The stock browser is "broken", at least to the extent that it cannot save bookmarks.
Here's a fix for the bookmark issue. Use a root file manager to navigate to /system/app/BookmarkProvider. In that folder you will find an apk file of the same name. Tap to install (actually update, I guess). Then reboot.
A good alternative browser that works well with this ROM is Via.
2. The stock launcher is pretty basic. After a lot of fooling around with display and font size in Settings I found no combination that significantly affected the rather large (for my taste) icon size without otherwise distorting the display in some way.
I ended up restoring the display to defaults and installing Nova Launcher.
3. There's no Gallery?! Yep. For awhile I was using a Gallery from my old CM 10.2.1 install, but it didn't work very well. Then I discovered that @theportal2 had worked up a Lineage Gallery app with the necessary libraries for install on other ROMs. It works great and includes a ton of features, even photo editing. You can get it here: https://forum.xda-developers.com/an...lineage-os-gallery-apk-photo-editing-t3664460
4. The MTP file transfer setting in Settings>Developer options>Networking>Select USB Configuration is not effective and selecting it in Settings seems to encourage the MTP host to whine with system messages occasionally.
Leave setting on "charging" (default) and when you connect via USB, use the pull-down notification to select MTP transfer for that session.
Better yet, you can disable the MTP Host app with no apparent repercussions. Just go into Settings>Apps (show system) and disable it. I was sort of surprised that this had no effect on file transfer protocol.
5. The swipe-to-unlock screen is tenacious and its use may result in repetitive motion injury.
OK, so maybe this is a "feature?". If you touch anywhere on the swipe-to-unlock screen the little "Swipe to unlock" bounces up from the bottom. With that visible, the screen swipes effortlessly. Who knew?
6. The system throws up two notifications when you connect to USB (if you have debugging enabled). Just a minor annoyance. If you don't like seeing those two "N"s either, you can see just one (for the connection type: charge, transfer, etc.) with a simple addition to /system/build.prop:
Code:
persist.adb.notify=0
7. Some apps can't write to the SD card (as portable storage). Kodi is an example, I'm sorry to say. I've tried many "solutions" to this problem but the only one that worked for me is to edit /data/system/packages.xml, adding the permission for each specific app you want. This is a long file and I recommend off-loading a copy and editing with something like Notepad++. After locating the app you want in the xml file, add this line anywhere between the <perms> and </perms> tags:
Code:
<item name="android.permission.WRITE_MEDIA_STORAGE" granted="true" flags="0" />
Replace the file on the device with the edited version and reboot. This change will be overwritten if the app updates, so you might want to keep that in mind.
8. I am partial to the version of ES File Explorer which is attached to the first post. It's not too bloated and works well with the device, the package installer, etc.
9. Generally speaking I would gravitate toward older versions of apps which may be easier on the system. As an example, I'm using version 1.8.6 of MX Player, long before all the streaming nonsense took over. TuneIn Radio and Pandora are so old they will run on Android 2.1! Sometimes enough is just right.
Apps that don't work
1. The NPR News app currently in the PlayStore at this writing crashes repeatedly just after starting.
Version 2.6.1 works fine. Interestingly, when the PlayStore version installs, the icon background color is black. On another Nook Tablet (HD) running CM 11, the same version installs with a white icon background and runs fine. Version 2.6.1 also installs on this AOSP ROM with a white icon background. Hmm.
Xposed
Oh yes, even I eventually missed a feature or two from my last CM install The good news is that the Nougat version of Xposed runs well on this ROM, at least to the extent of using Gravity Box (I just had to have the extended power menu back.....)
Alternative apps for microG
I've included some of the more common ones (Contacts, Calendar, Email) in the previous post. If you've set up Location service you might want Maps. I've not had much luck with newer versions of Maps on my various devices. Too greedy for system resources. But I have found an older version of the app which still runs, includes Places, and allows you to cache map areas which do not expire.
YouTube is another real resource hog. I'm not a big YouTube fan, but there are times when I want something and a browser like Via or the stock one is so-so (it works, but you have to be patient). I looked around and decided NewPipe would meet most of my needs. It's not perfect. The full-screen player crashes on all the custom ROMs I've tried. However, you can set it to use an external player (like MX Player) and that works fine with full screen. I really like the ability to download videos (or just the audio) in a recognizable format--and even to the SD card!
And don't forget the Aurora Store (F-Droid) for PlayStore access.
nmyshkin said:
[shamelessly adapted from peerless instructions for other NT installs by @digixmax, and information from @mikeataol that is scattered through the CM 13.0 thread.]
Disclaimer: Neither I nor any other user mentioned here, real or imaginary, is responsible if you brick your device following these instructions. The only stupid question is the one you didn't ask right before you ruined your tablet.
By following these instructions you can install an AOSP Android 7.0 ROM from @amaces internally (into emmc) on a 16 GB Nook Tablet running either stock, CM 10.x, CM 11.x, CM 12.x, or CM 13.x, assuming you have done no special repartitioning (it may also work if you have done special repartitioning, but I do not know). If you have previously installed CM 14.x and have repartitioned, you can return to those installation instructions where there may be a description of how to revert to the regular partitioning. This ROM does not require any special partitioning.
The AOSP ROM is a bare-bones, very responsive build. It runs rings around my former CM 12.1 install without any freezes or shutdowns. Adding a pico Google Apps package keeps the ROM mean and lean while giving you PlayStore access to add just what you want.
If you have a bootable SD card made for installing CM 10.x-12.x, you can skip to step 2b.
1. Using a disk partition tool (such as MiniTool Partition Wizard Home Edition) create on the SD card a Primary FAT32 partition, set the partition ID type for the partition to 0x0C FAT32 LBA, and set its Active flag. Once this is done, the partition should appear as a (read/write accessible) drive under Windows
2. Obtain and copy to the SD card the following files:
a. first MLO, then next u-boot.bin, and finally flashing_boot.img in succulent_boot.zip obtained from https://www.mediafire.com/folder/xjwc1a482a6ll/Nook_Tablet
b. TWRP (TeamWin Recovery Project) version 2.8.6.0, e.g. twrp-2.8.6.0-acclaim-sdcard.img from https://dl.twrp.me/acclaim/twrp-2.8.6.0-acclaim-sdcard.img.html, rename it to recovery.img before copying to SD card. Be sure to use the sdcard.img file and not the one for internal emmc
c. the flashable_TWRP_3.0.2-0.zip zip file from https://www.mediafire.com/folder/xjwc1a482a6ll/Nook_Tablet
d. the zip file of the AOSP Android 7.0 ROM by @amaces, i.e., aosp_acclaim-ota-NBD90Z.161020.zip from my Dropbox: https://www.dropbox.com/s/b7zc8d56z2gl69m/aosp_acclaim-ota-NBD90Z.161020.zip?dl=0 (alternative link provided by @mikeataol: https://mega.nz/#!nQwiEILS!dm7i-4AOUzYW5yP0LaqcZ5EAUsxeh-Qr8DULB4BGYZ8) [this ROM is no longer in the repository maintained by @amaces]
e. the zip file of the Gapps package (corresponding to Android 7.0) from http://opengapps.org/
3. Put the SD card into the NT and boot from its power off by inserting a powered USB cable. Press and hold the "n" button as soon as CyanoBoot comes up to get the boot menu to display.
a. Select SDC Recovery.
b. [Optional step but highly recommended] Select Backup to backup your NT current ROM config (/boot, /recovery, /system, and /data).
c. Return to TWRP opening screen and select Install. From the external SD card install flashable_TWRP_3.0.2-0.zip
(my experience with TWRP is that it is very cranky, at least on my tablet; if you have trouble with it not recognizing the external SD card, try rebooting into recovery again....or again....)
d. Reboot. Press and hold the "n" button as soon as CyanoBoot comes up to get the boot menu to display. Select Internal (emmc) Recovery (note that from here on all installation is done using the internal TWRP 3.0.2-0)
e. Select Wipe (data & factory reset) OR, using Advanced Wipe, wipe system, data, cache, dalvik.
f. [Optional] Select Advanced Wipe, Repair or Change file system; select "data" (only) and change file system from ext4s to f2fs (supposedly a faster format--if you decide to undo all this, you should probably reformat "data" to ext4s)
g. Reboot to internal (emmc) recovery as in 3d. (ignore warnings about "no system" if you see any)
h. Select Install. From the external SD card install aosp_acclaim-ota-NBD90Z.161020.zip (ignore E: unknown command errors)
i. Reboot to internal (emmc) recovery as in 3d.
j. Select Install. From the external SD card install appropriate opengapps zip
k. Remove SD card and select reboot.
Wait for first boot to complete and sign in. To fully enable root access for ADB and apps you must install the opensource version of the SU interface from the PlayStore: https://play.google.com/store/search?q=phh superuser&c=apps. Search for "phh superuser".
Done!
[Don't you want to make a baseline backup right now?]
My thanks to @digixmax for his many, many excellent how-to's and for the help he has given me in the past. He is also responsible for providing the flashable TWRP that avoids the need for fastboot in this install. I'm grateful to @mikeataol for his patient responses to my probably lame questions in the CM 13.0 thread concerning this ROM and, of course, really thankful that @amaces turned out this excellent version of AOSP Android 7.0 for our devices.
See post immediately below for a discussion of known issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have cm 11 installed with 12 gb system and 1 gb media partition . and twrp 2.8.6... Installed . can i flash rom and g apps straight away ? Without foolowing other instructions
ehtisham ali said:
I have cm 11 installed with 12 gb system and 1 gb media partition . and twrp 2.8.6... Installed . can i flash rom and g apps straight away ? Without foolowing other instructions
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can try, but I think you'll need to update the internal TWRP at least.
Is anyone able to install any of the recent AOSP/LNOS builds of Amaces on a 16G NT that still uses the original partition format PLUS any recent opengapps TOGETHER successfully???
For me any builds from Amaces since 2017 can install successfully ... BUT ran out of /system space after that and cannot install OpenGapps. I use/tried PICO opengapps only always.
When I open file manager from TWRP 3100 there is nothing inside /system .... so was not able to clean up anything inside ....
Amaces: If you see this can you please help?? I know your focus is on the Ovation (I use it too) but I really want to try your LNOS for the NT on my original partitioned one.
Just FYI on the 16G NT that has the newer CM14.1 repartitioned format -> None of Amaces' ROM for Acclaim can install. Can only use dmarble's new LNOS builds or the old remaining CM14.1 builds on those.
If anyone has a good and easy solution to get around the /system out of space issue to install Gapps please share. I want to keep one acclaim on the original partition format. My other acclaim is running dmarble's ROM happily.
nsfgp said:
Is anyone able to install any of the recent AOSP/LNOS builds of Amaces on a 16G NT that still uses the original partition format PLUS any recent opengapps TOGETHER successfully???
For me any builds from Amaces since 2017 can install successfully ... BUT ran out of /system space after that and cannot install OpenGapps. I use/tried PICO opengapps only always.
When I open file manager from TWRP 3100 there is nothing inside /system .... so was not able to clean up anything inside ....
Amaces: If you see this can you please help?? I know your focus is on the Ovation (I use it too) but I really want to try your LNOS for the NT on my original partitioned one.
Just FYI on the 16G NT that has the newer CM14.1 repartitioned format -> None of Amaces' ROM for Acclaim can install. Can only use dmarble's new LNOS builds or the old remaining CM14.1 builds on those.
If anyone has a good and easy solution to get around the /system out of space issue to install Gapps please share. I want to keep one acclaim on the original partition format. My other acclaim is running dmarble's ROM happily.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, have done many times.
make sure you have mounted /system in TWRP
Try a reboot after ROM install, and before gapps install.
The latest LNOS in experimental (lnos_acclaim-ota-N2G47E.170416) installs a fresh pico gapps of about 80MB with no manipulation.
in the past if I have had to make room, I copy and delete /system/media to /emmc before gapps install, and copy it back after
mikeataol said:
Yes, have done many times.
make sure you have mounted /system in TWRP
Try a reboot after ROM install, and before gapps install.
The latest LNOS in experimental (lnos_acclaim-ota-N2G47E.170416) installs a fresh pico gapps of about 80MB with no manipulation.
in the past if I have had to make room, I copy and delete /system/media to /emmc before gapps install, and copy it back after
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you Mike!!! It is the /system mounting .... I never thought it would have to be mounted .... since it complaint not enough space instead of not found/mounted. But anyway .... I mounted /system in TWRP after ROM install+reboot into recovery. Now I can see stuff inside /system.
But it still complaint about not enough /system space and cannot install Gapps. I just copied off /system/media and deleted it. And now the Gapps installed ok. I am rebooting into LNOS now.
Do I really need those stuff in /system/media and have to copy it back?? If no use I want to keep it lean.
Thanks again!!! (I am using the exact LNOS ROM in A's experimental folder as you mentioned)
Just a heads-up that I don't actually have the hardware, so everything that I upload for acclaim is not really tested, but I try to not to break things.
nsfgp said:
But it still complaint about not enough /system space and cannot install Gapps. I just copied off /system/media and deleted it. And now the Gapps installed ok. I am rebooting into LNOS now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'll put something like this on the list, so a larger /system (upstream Lineage, or via REPIT) is usable with these builds (Lineage/AOSP would still need manual resize).
So far this build (7.0) works much better than 6.0. Thanks!
Hi, thank you very much for the tutorial, I have followed the guide step by step but I can't get the tablet to boot the cyanoboot, I turned off and plug the power cable from the adapter and it boots normally, my tablet model is BNTV250 16 GB version, runing stock OS and it has not been rooted before or anything, I have tried flash the sd with older methods in order to root it and haven't had any success, that's how I ended up here, I'm using an 8GB trascend sd card, the Tablet detect the sd card since I can see the files in the tablet browser but I can't get it to boot the cyanoboot or anything else, can someone assist me? thank you very much in anticipation.
killerkalmah said:
Hi, I'm using an 8GB trascend sd card, the Tablet detect the sd card since I can see the files in the tablet browser but I can't get it to boot the cyanoboot or anything else, can someone assist me? thank you very much in anticipation.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
there is a certain percentage of Nook tablets that wont boot from a card unless you power down, insert the card, then power up by inserting the USB cable, not by pressing the on/off switch. (about 15% of nooks I've seen are like this)
if even that doesn't work, you should make another card . Class 4 is best, faster isn't better in this case.
killerkalmah said:
Hi, thank you very much for the tutorial, I have followed the guide step by step but I can't get the tablet to boot the cyanoboot, I turned off and plug the power cable from the adapter and it boots normally, my tablet model is BNTV250 16 GB version, runing stock OS and it has not been rooted before or anything, I have tried flash the sd with older methods in order to root it and haven't had any success, that's how I ended up here, I'm using an 8GB trascend sd card, the Tablet detect the sd card since I can see the files in the tablet browser but I can't get it to boot the cyanoboot or anything else, can someone assist me? thank you very much in anticipation.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If the tablet won't boot from the SD card it's likely that there is either something wrong with the boot files, i.e., those files first placed on the card in step 2a, or with the formatting of the card (step 1). You might want to download a fresh set of files and try making the card again. Corrupt files will make this task impossible.
It's also possible that your particular SD card just won't do it. It's been known to happen.
mikeataol said:
there is a certain percentage of Nook tablets that wont boot from a card unless you power down, insert the card, then power up by inserting the USB cable, not by pressing the on/off switch. (about 15% of nooks I've seen are like this)
if even that doesn't work, you should make another card . Class 4 is best, faster isn't better in this case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's they way I've tried, inserting the USB cable, the sd is class 4 indeed, so I don't know what it could be.
nmyshkin said:
If the tablet won't boot from the SD card it's likely that there is either something wrong with the boot files, i.e., those files first placed on the card in step 2a, or with the formatting of the card (step 1). You might want to download a fresh set of files and try making the card again. Corrupt files will make this task impossible.
It's also possible that your particular SD card just won't do it. It's been known to happen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is it possible that the SD card can be read it, explorer and formated from the tablet and unable to do the boot? cuz the tablet appear to recognize evrything on the SD
killerkalmah said:
Is it possible that the SD card can be read it, explorer and formated from the tablet and unable to do the boot? cuz the tablet appear to recognize evrything on the SD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Unfortunately, yes. I'm not saying your card is defective but this whole business of booting from the card contains a minor but distinct element of voodoo
So....download those files from step 2a again, reformat the card (again....), and prepare it as before (again....). If it still does not work, I'd look for a different card to try this process. Don't be discouraged. I did a lot of "again..." when I first did anything like this. It will work for you.
nmyshkin said:
Unfortunately, yes. I'm not saying your card is defective but this whole business of booting from the card contains a minor but distinct element of voodoo
So....download those files from step 2a again, reformat the card (again....), and prepare it as before (again....). If it still does not work, I'd look for a different card to try this process. Don't be discouraged. I did a lot of "again..." when I first did anything like this. It will work for you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I downloaded those files again, re-do the sd card and prepare it again, it still don't boot lol
This is the link I'm following for the TWRP image; https://dl.twrp.me/acclaim/twrp-2.8.6.0-acclaim-sdcard.img, i don't know if I have to use that or the one that comes in the suculent boot folder?
Another thing is that I've been using an SD card adapter and have tried trough the nook too, and also downloaded the mini gaaps file for android 7 ARM, but I'm pretty sure that has nothing to do with the boot stuff, so I'm gonna fallow your suggestion and try with an old 1 gb or 2 gb card, and see what happens, everything related on formating the SD via partition tool mini has done correctly, my Internet security blocks a menace while I attemp to download the files from media fire, you think that could be corrupting the files? I get the download and the menace blocked by Iinternet Security so I'm not sure, if you have any other suggestion I will be glad to read, meanwhile I will search for those damn cards, and I can't thank you enough for you time helping a noob here! thanks!!
killerkalmah said:
I downloaded those files again, re-do the sd card and prepare it again, it still don't boot lol
This is the link I'm following for the TWRP image; https://dl.twrp.me/acclaim/twrp-2.8.6.0-acclaim-sdcard.img, i don't know if I have to use that or the one that comes in the suculent boot folder?
Another thing is that I've been using an SD card adapter and have tried trough the nook too, and also downloaded the mini gaaps file for android 7 ARM, but I'm pretty sure that has nothing to do with the boot stuff, so I'm gonna fallow your suggestion and try with an old 1 gb or 2 gb card, and see what happens, everything related on formating the SD via partition tool mini has done correctly, my Internet security blocks a menace while I attemp to download the files from media fire, you think that could be corrupting the files? I get the download and the menace blocked by Iinternet Security so I'm not sure, if you have any other suggestion I will be glad to read, meanwhile I will search for those damn cards, and I can't thank you enough for you time helping a noob here! thanks!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You are downloading the correct TWRP. The other one is too old. I don't know about any warnings from MediaFire. I just downloaded the succulent_boot.zip myself and saw no warnings, but that may be browser/configuration dependent. I'm using Firefox with a double layer of ad-blocking.
Generally speaking you want to download the files on your PC, then insert the SD card into the adapter, into the SDHC slot, and do all the work on the PC before inserting the card into the tablet.
If you have a way to verify the MD5 checksums of your boot files (winmd5free), this is what I get:
MLO: 979fa71c9ee33ca9690df809c71e1991
u-boot.bin: 1070cd90b3d57a47cdc8c22b00243ff7
flashing_boot.img: 3a626c102ef4324a163d54751ef680f1
I think you might run into size issues with the mini GApps.
nmyshkin said:
You are downloading the correct TWRP. The other one is too old. I don't know about any warnings from MediaFire. I just downloaded the succulent_boot.zip myself and saw no warnings, but that may be browser/configuration dependent. I'm using Firefox with a double layer of ad-blocking.
Generally speaking you want to download the files on your PC, then insert the SD card into the adapter, into the SDHC slot, and do all the work on the PC before inserting the card into the tablet.
If you have a way to verify the MD5 checksums of your boot files (winmd5free), this is what I get:
MLO: 979fa71c9ee33ca9690df809c71e1991
u-boot.bin: 1070cd90b3d57a47cdc8c22b00243ff7
flashing_boot.img: 3a626c102ef4324a163d54751ef680f1
I think you might run into size issues with the mini GApps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Alright! I found 3 sd cards each of them with a 2gb capacity, that should the incompatibilty, each three are different brands, and I found a better SD adapter, I will re-do all the steps in building the SD and if that does not work will download the files again with jdownloader to avoid menace pop outs, and if that doesn't do I will check the MD5 :fingers-crossed: I will update here, and thank you again!.
Update: it was the SD, I manage to do all the steps except for the gapps file, I couldn't install it, which you will recomend to download, I download the ARM android 7.0 mini, and more importantly my tablet loops on the "android" screen, with or without the SD inside, am I missing something? I did not installed supersu even though I got asked a few times during tutorial, any suggestion?
Have you tried clearing the cache? That worked for me the first time I did this.
Also, which OS image are you using? When I tried to reinstall a newer version mine would not boot after copying gapps over, presumably due to space.
nosborm said:
Have you tried clearing the cache? That worked for me the first time I did this.
Also, which OS image are you using? When I tried to reinstall a newer version mine would not boot after copying gapps over, presumably due to space.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm a little bit lose regarding memory space on this tablet, I reinstall the OS that was in this tutorial and finally booted to menu, but I can't connect to wifi, I don't know why, I might install another OS, which gapps file you reccomend to download? the stock, full version or mini?