Why is everyone ignoring the terrible audio capture? - Galaxy S III Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

Why do people keep on ignoring the terrible audio capture? Every video I have seen and heard from the GS3 has terrible audio. It is actually worse than the HTC X in many instances, and that phone has rather subpar audio capture as well. There are many many phones that capture much better audio, from the Xperia S, Motorola Razr, Nokia Lumia, iPhone, Rim Blackberry Bold, and even most of Samsung's own previous and lower tier phones and of course this phone's predecessor, the S2. About the only thing worse is probably most HTC phones, but not by much. Samsung's audio capture quality has dropped big time, into the gutter actually, and every review I've read has ignored this fact. There are occasional mentions of it by other posters, but ultimately the screaming fanboys usually overwhelm the conversation by saying how awesome everything is and to STFU GTFO about it.
I don't think there's anything wrong with my hearing. There's just something wrong with this phone. So why is this issue falling on deaf ears? Pun intended.

---

What do you mean exactly? Call quality, audio recordings, videos?
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium

---

It's not something that I'm particularly bothered about because I don't think I've ever used my phone to video anything so a bit of a moot point for me I'm sure it probably is annoying if it is indeed as bad as you say
Sent from my CM9 TouchPad

---

It sounds more like there is no filter on the microphone.

---

Honestly, I got my Galaxy III yesterday and due to bad audio in my recorded videos (I do record a lot) i'm seriously thinking to return it.
Compared to my current SE Xperia Pro which has a nice sound in all videos the quality of the sound in my videos made with S3 is really bad

---

Wait for Voodoo Sound!!!
Sent from my GT-I9100 using xda premium

---

I am very much bothered with that awful thin sound.
I don't think it has ANYTHING to do with Voodoo sound.
It has to do with some ****ty Band Pass Filter if you ask me.
It sound like there is no bass, middle, and no high.
Only some mid/high is left. can easily be checked actually.

---

if you want better audio on recordings, just use the included headset and plug it in before starting the recording.

---

katamari201 said:
Why do people keep on ignoring the terrible audio capture? Every video I have seen and heard from the GS3 has terrible audio. It is actually worse than the HTC X in many instances, and that phone has rather subpar audio capture as well. There are many many phones that capture much better audio, from the Xperia S, Motorola Razr, Nokia Lumia, iPhone, Rim Blackberry Bold, and even most of Samsung's own previous and lower tier phones and of course this phone's predecessor, the S2. About the only thing worse is probably most HTC phones, but not by much. Samsung's audio capture quality has dropped big time, into the gutter actually, and every review I've read has ignored this fact. There are occasional mentions of it by other posters, but ultimately the screaming fanboys usually overwhelm the conversation by saying how awesome everything is and to STFU GTFO about it.
I don't think there's anything wrong with my hearing. There's just something wrong with this phone. So why is this issue falling on deaf ears? Pun intended.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well has nothing to do with fan boys I guess. In my case for instance, I actually never use my phone to record audio/ video, so I really do not care about that feature at all. If I need to record video, or take superb pics, I use my Canon D600, and I do not mind the weight.
I do reckon that in the reviews there has been more emphasis on the image quality, rather then the audio quality... However that is something you'll have to confront the actual reviewers with rather then the users that do not use certain features that much or at all.

---

nobody is bothered by it because soon it will be fixed by developers.

---

hefonthefjords said:
nobody is bothered by it because soon it will be fixed by developers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wild guesses and speculations are not welcome.
Maybe the mic physically has a frequency response that leads to that tinny sound?
Will that be fixed by developers?

---

eitama said:
Wild guesses and speculations are not welcome.
Maybe the mic physically has a frequency response that leads to that tinny sound?
Will that be fixed by developers?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wth :| the videos ive seen were amazing, you could even hear a guy walking some some twigs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJ0VbqfWUC4&feature=g-all-u

---

LeviathanPT said:
Wth :| the videos ive seen were amazing, you could even hear a guy walking some some twigs
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJ0VbqfWUC4&feature=g-all-u
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The issue is most prominent when recording someone speak, or some music being played, or some sounds which fill the entire audio spectrum not just some walking noises.
Listen to people speaking in videos, you will see (hear) the sound is awful.
Iv'e had an SGS, SGS2, Note and soon SGS3
I know how it should sound, and from many samples I know this sounds very bad.
The video is absolutely amazing, the audio, not so much.

---

eitama said:
The issue is most prominent when recording someone speak, or some music being played, or some sounds which fill the entire audio spectrum not just some walking noises.
Listen to people speaking in videos, you will see (hear) the sound is awful.
Iv'e had an SGS, SGS2, Note and soon SGS3
I know how it should sound, and from many samples I know this sounds very bad.
The video is absolutely amazing, the audio, not so much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ive listened to the video from Eldar Murtazin for mobile-review where hes speaking on the street with someone and it sounds good tbh.
http://mobile-review.com/review/image/samsung/galaxy-s3-fl/photo/video.mp4
Maybe my requirement levels are lower than yours ? :|

---

LeviathanPT said:
Ive listened to the video from Eldar Murtazin for mobile-review where hes speaking on the street with someone and it sounds good tbh.
http://mobile-review.com/review/image/samsung/galaxy-s3-fl/photo/video.mp4
Maybe my requirement levels are lower than yours ? :|
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I downloaded the video you linked and listened to it.
No bass, no high treble, just high mids.
You can hear voice, but it's just dead.
There is no doubt you can hear people and the bitrate is ok, but the EQ is bad.
Really bad.

---

eitama said:
I downloaded the video you linked and listened to it.
No bass, no high treble, just high mids.
You can hear voice, but it's just dead.
There is no doubt you can hear people and the bitrate is ok, but the EQ is bad.
Really bad.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ahh so thats what this is all about, for me it seems like the noise cancelation could be reason if it, its too sensitive you can notice on the beginning of the video.. could supercurio voodoo tool be able to fix or improve this ?

---

LeviathanPT said:
Ahh so thats what this is all about, for me it seems like the noise cancelation could be reason if it, its too sensitive you can notice on the beginning of the video.. could supercurio voodoo tool be able to fix or improve this ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't know if noise cancellation is active during video recording, but let me just remember you the size of the SGS III microphone, that is only a few milimeters (and the hole is less than a milimeter wide). Don't expect anything spectacular with such a small piece, it's far from being as large as this : http://www.guitariste.com/share/achat/marchands/woodbrass/neumann-u-87-i-116930.jpg
EQ'ing might help a bit, but remember this is a phone.

---

XpLoDWilD said:
I don't know if noise cancellation is active during video recording, but let me just remember you the size of the SGS III microphone, that is only a few milimeters (and the hole is less than a milimeter wide). Don't expect anything spectacular with such a small piece, it's far from being as large as this : http://www.guitariste.com/share/achat/marchands/woodbrass/neumann-u-87-i-116930.jpg
EQ'ing might help a bit, but remember this is a phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh well. I just made a vid with my note and spoke with my deepest bass voice into the mics, and indeed it is pretty thin here as well, but I don't remember having this problem with SGS2/1, I'll have one of them to try later today.
Not that this issue will prevent me from getting an S3 and enjoying every moment!
---------- Post added at 03:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:35 PM ----------
Actually - I just recorded myself with High Q MP3 Rec (Lite) and there is plenty of bass. So this problem should be resolvable by changing the way audio is recorded or captured. Here is me speaking into the mic : http://dl.dropbox.com/u/15924481/recording-20120606-174117.mp3
In my opinion there is so much more bass there. The audio quality obtained when recording video has a great deal of margin to improve.

---

he meant the audios in videos that are record by sgs3.
as some have noticed it sounds muffled and thin.
---------- Post added at 03:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:01 PM ----------
eitama said:
The issue is most prominent when recording someone speak, or some music being played, or some sounds which fill the entire audio spectrum not just some walking noises.
Listen to people speaking in videos, you will see (hear) the sound is awful.
Iv'e had an SGS, SGS2, Note and soon SGS3
I know how it should sound, and from many samples I know this sounds very bad.
The video is absolutely amazing, the audio, not so much.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the vids they are talking about is the one from gsmarena the on where they compare sgs3 and hox vids of cars on street.
and another vid it was an early hands-on it was also taken on the street where you see a man riding a bicycle then pans to the left to show the road under.
i'm sure some of you have already seen that vid.
the sound from those vids does sound muffled and thin.
---------- Post added at 03:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:05 PM ----------
LeviathanPT said:
Ahh so thats what this is all about, for me it seems like the noise cancelation could be reason if it, its too sensitive you can notice on the beginning of the video.. could supercurio voodoo tool be able to fix or improve this ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes that was what i thought ever since those gsmarena vids,
that the noise cancellation is set a bit aggressive when recording vids.

---

Noise cancellation should be disabled when recording video IMHO.
It is good when talking on the phone you want only your voice to go through and clear, but when recording audio as audio, i think there is no need.
Top mic should be left, bottom should be right, and thats it