Related
For some reason my WhatsApp can't automatic hibernate. It's always in the 'Not hibernating automatically'. Whenever I manually make it hibernate, I don't receive any notifications or messages unless I open the app. I have the donation version, GCM is checked, keep notifications is checked, I have greenify enabled in both Accessibility and DeviceAdmin.
I do receive further notification and messages after I opened WhatsApp manually. Anyone else has experienced this and/or has a solution to fix this?
Slmii92 said:
For some reason my WhatsApp can't automatic hibernate. It's always in the 'Not hibernating automatically'. Whenever I manually make it hibernate, I don't receive any notifications or messages unless I open the app. I have the donation version, GCM is checked, keep notifications is checked, I have greenify enabled in both Accessibility and DeviceAdmin.
I do receive further notification and messages after I opened WhatsApp manually. Anyone else has experienced this and/or has a solution to fix this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Quite weird as I don't face this! I would suggest for you to uninstall whatsapp, and then install it again. Backup its data beforehand with Titanium Backup if you intend to save the messages.
TechnoSparks said:
Quite weird as I don't face this! I would suggest for you to uninstall whatsapp, and then install it again. Backup its data beforehand with Titanium Backup if you intend to save the messages.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Didn't work. I still only get the messages when I open WhatsApp. Automatic hibernation is working now tho, for WhatsApp.
Slmii92 said:
Didn't work. I still only get the messages when I open WhatsApp. Automatic hibernation is working now tho, for WhatsApp.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There's no actual fix for this, but I would try to reinstall Greenify, reset its device administrator and then clear the dalvik cache. It is quite of an isolated problem.. I sometime do have to admit Clash of Clans, Facebook and some 2 other I don't remember, stay without automatic hibernation but I can now cope with it. Thanks to swipe gestures of Nova Launcher lol.
And since it is a problem only related to certain apps, I don't think greenify should be blamed for this.
TechnoSparks said:
There's no actual fix for this, but I would try to reinstall Greenify, reset its device administrator and then clear the dalvik cache. It is quite of an isolated problem.. I sometime do have to admit Clash of Clans, Facebook and some 2 other I don't remember, stay without automatic hibernation but I can now cope with it. Thanks to swipe gestures of Nova Launcher lol.
And since it is a problem only related to certain apps, I don't think greenify should be blamed for this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Funny thing is...if you un-greenify them and then choose to greenify them again and then hibernated them. The next time those apps will auto hibernated.
But upon reboot, the whole process starts all over again...weird.
Sent from my GT-I9506 using Tapatalk
TechnoSparks said:
There's no actual fix for this, but I would try to reinstall Greenify, reset its device administrator and then clear the dalvik cache. It is quite of an isolated problem.. I sometime do have to admit Clash of Clans, Facebook and some 2 other I don't remember, stay without automatic hibernation but I can now cope with it. Thanks to swipe gestures of Nova Launcher lol.
And since it is a problem only related to certain apps, I don't think greenify should be blamed for this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did a Factory Reset yesterday, because I had some issues. Thought it would work after the reset, but it didn't. How do you use the gestures to hibernate, coz I have also Nova Launcher?
Slmii92 said:
I did a Factory Reset yesterday, because I had some issues. Thought it would work after the reset, but it didn't. How do you use the gestures to hibernate, coz I have also Nova Launcher?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You'll need to purchase Nova Prime in order for the feature to work. Assuming you have Nova and its premium features, go to Nova settings, and then tap on "Gestures and Buttons". Afterwards, choose your desired gesture, and then when choosing the action for a gesture, tap on "Shortcuts" tab, and choose Greenify's "Hibernate now" shortcut.
I personally choose the swipe up gesture. So when I am at the home screen, and I do also want my apps to be greenified forcibly, I will just have to swipe the screen up, and then the magic happens
kotaxor said:
Funny thing is...if you un-greenify them and then choose to greenify them again and then hibernated them. The next time those apps will auto hibernated.
But upon reboot, the whole process starts all over again...weird.
Sent from my GT-I9506 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In my case, this only happens to some apps. Others are perfectly hibernated. I agree it does feel weird, but I don't really concern about it.
Yes it only happen on some apps for me too..but if you un-greenify one of them and greenify it again and hibernated all of them, the next time all the apps will behave.
Sent from my GT-I9506 using Tapatalk
kotaxor said:
Funny thing is...if you un-greenify them and then choose to greenify them again and then hibernated them. The next time those apps will auto hibernated.
But upon reboot, the whole process starts all over again...weird.
Sent from my GT-I9506 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You're right, I just tested this and it actually work. Only tested this with WhatsApp tho. Thanks! But the problem I'm still having is, whenever WhatsApp is hibernated, I'm not getting any notifications and messages, even tho I have GCM enabled. I read that other people do receive them, so I find this really weird why it's not working.
TechnoSparks said:
You'll need to purchase Nova Prime in order for the feature to work. Assuming you have Nova and its premium features, go to Nova settings, and then tap on "Gestures and Buttons". Afterwards, choose your desired gesture, and then when choosing the action for a gesture, tap on "Shortcuts" tab, and choose Greenify's "Hibernate now" shortcut.
I personally choose the swipe up gesture. So when I am at the home screen, and I do also want my apps to be greenified forcibly, I will just have to swipe the screen up, and then the magic happens
In my case, this only happens to some apps. Others are perfectly hibernated. I agree it does feel weird, but I don't really concern about it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm using Hibernate + Lock for double tap atm, and it's hibernating WhatsApp with the method above. I tested it with Google Play Services as well, but that didn't work. So my only problem now is not receiving anything while hibernated. Still can't figure this out. -_-'
Slmii92 said:
I'm using Hibernate + Lock for double tap atm, and it's hibernating WhatsApp with the method above. I tested it with Google Play Services as well, but that didn't work. So my only problem now is not receiving anything while hibernated. Still can't figure this out. -_-'
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You should not mess with Play Services! You should know that GCM apps use play services to deliver push notifications!
About whatsapp, most people sorted the problem out by enabling Device Admin. In the OP, you've mentioned that you did that. I suggest degreenify play services, and re-activate device admin.
kotaxor said:
Yes it only happen on some apps for me too..but if you un-greenify one of them and greenify it again and hibernated all of them, the next time all the apps will behave.
Sent from my GT-I9506 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
TechnoSparks said:
You should not mess with Play Services! You should know that GCM apps use play services to deliver push notifications!
About whatsapp, most people sorted the problem out by enabling Device Admin. In the OP, you've mentioned that you did that. I suggest degreenify play services, and re-activate device admin.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Funny thing is, after I ungreenify WhatsApp and then greenify it, it will be hibernated and then I do receive the messages. Whenever I open WhatsAspp, it's going back to the 'Not automatically hibernating' list. Really werid. It says 'Service in use by Android-system Push'. The only way of hibernating it, would be forcibly, but then again, I wont receive anything and it will go back to the same list.
I removed Google Play Services from the list and did re-activated greenify in device admin, didnt work.
I had try greenifying Whatsapp before, sometimes it works real good, sometimes I encounter the same issue as you. As such, I did not greenify it again.
I don't greenify Play Services.
Sent from my GT-I9506 using Tapatalk
Maybe I'll give it up as well. But on the other hand, I really want it to work, because the main reason I bought it was for WhatsApp.
Install greenify then clean master.. It works. And saves battery
Sent from my HTC Desire 616 dual sim using XDA Free mobile app
Slmii92 said:
Maybe I'll give it up as well. But on the other hand, I really want it to work, because the main reason I bought it was for WhatsApp.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I understand. I also wanted this to be sorted out too.
ImmaN00B said:
Install greenify then clean master.. It works. And saves battery
Sent from my HTC Desire 616 dual sim using XDA Free mobile app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
TechnoSparks said:
Yes, I understand. I also wanted this to be sorted out too.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok, I think I found the solution. I had this app, called Wakelock Terminator. Within the app, I checked 'Prevent Wakelock' for Google Play Services. I unchecked it and deleted everything in the 'Filter' field and after that I deleted the app as well, because the reason I had this app was for Google Play Services.
Now WhatsApp is working while hibernated. I'm getting the notifications and messages. Maybe this would be your problem as well?
Slmii92 said:
Ok, I think I found the solution. I had this app, called Wakelock Terminator. Within the app, I checked 'Prevent Wakelock' for Google Play Services. I unchecked it and deleted everything in the 'Filter' field and after that I deleted the app as well, because the reason I had this app was for Google Play Services.
Now WhatsApp is working while hibernated. I'm getting the notifications and messages. Maybe this would be your problem as well?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nah WhatsApp is not the problem. It is okay for me. The only problem I have is the other apps that people don't report it here. But I don't really mind about it. And I don't kill any wakelock or some sort, so the problem lies on those rogue apps instead. Anyway glad you finally worked it out. Told ya it doesn't have to do with Greenify
TechnoSparks said:
Nah WhatsApp is not the problem. It is okay for me. The only problem I have is the other apps that people don't report it here. But I don't really mind about it. And I don't kill any wakelock or some sort, so the problem lies on those rogue apps instead. Anyway glad you finally worked it out. Told ya it doesn't have to do with Greenify
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yup, same here, did not hibernated Whatsapp too..no battery issues, I'm still getting 0.2% per hour during deep sleep regardless of whether Whatsapp is hibernated or not.
Did tried to hibernate it before tho and get occasionally delayed message..Lol
Sent from my GT-I9506 using Tapatalk
kotaxor said:
Yup, same here, did not hibernated Whatsapp too..no battery issues, I'm still getting 0.2% per hour during deep sleep regardless of whether Whatsapp is hibernated or not.
Did tried to hibernate it before tho and get occasionally delayed message..Lol
Sent from my GT-I9506 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I actually hibernate whatsapp but still have push messages come in. I have to agree it does comes a bit late but sometimes it appears instantly when I connect to a wifi. I may consider ungreenifying it though, but not now.
I am going to post a separate thread because I think I am having a different problem than what the other user is trying to accomplish. I am NOT getting push notifications even when whatsapp is not greenified.
In my first install of greenify, all experimental options are ticked and I tried greenifying whatsapp, wechat, and qq but I was not getting any notifications from these. So, I de-greenified them but I still was not getting the push notifications unless I was actively in the app.
I have since then tried uninstalling and reinstalling (without having greenify touch those 3 applications) but I still do not get push notifications UNLESS I enter the application. The only way I can get push notifications back is if I uninstall greenify completely. What is preventing greenify from letting me access my push notifications?
Twmade said:
I am going to post a separate thread because I think I am having a different problem than what the other user is trying to accomplish. I am NOT getting push notifications even when whatsapp is not greenified.
In my first install of greenify, all experimental options are ticked and I tried greenifying whatsapp, wechat, and qq but I was not getting any notifications from these. So, I de-greenified them but I still was not getting the push notifications unless I was actively in the app.
I have since then tried uninstalling and reinstalling (without having greenify touch those 3 applications) but I still do not get push notifications UNLESS I enter the application. The only way I can get push notifications back is if I uninstall greenify completely. What is preventing greenify from letting me access my push notifications?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I had the same problem ! You should buy donation package (if you use KK and you're rooted).
Nevermind go to settings>accessibility>service : unselect greenify.
Untick Greenify in Settings>Security>Device Administrators.
And also in settings> Sound & Notification> in notification panel >access to notification : unselect greenify.
No just have to reboot and it will work.
Regards,
Likesatan
likesatan said:
I had the same problem ! You should buy donation package (if you use KK and you're rooted).
Nevermind go to settings>accessibility>service : unselect greenify.
Untick Greenify in Settings>Security>Device Administrators.
And also in settings> Sound & Notification> in notification panel >access to notification : unselect greenify.
No just have to reboot and it will work.
Regards,
Likesatan
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do have the paid version of Greenify.
Tried what you said .... Still same problem. I deleted Greenify and I'm trying it right now and so far all messages are getting through. This is sad and I don't know what to do - without getting push messages I can't use this app:crying::crying:
Go into settings>applications search for com.whatsapp
See if the box show notification if ticked !
If don't tick it test if it works !
If it's still not working we're going to the rude way :
1) Go into settings>applications search for com.whatsapp erase data and cache then force quit and uninstall app.
2) Check in root explorer for example that in /data/app the file com.whatsapp is not there, if you find it erase it (need root).
3) Check /extsdcard/Android the file com.whatsapp is not there if you find it erase it.
4) Go into settings>applications search for com.oasisfeng.greenify erase data and cache DO NOT UNINSTALL.
5) Go into settings>application search for com.oasisfeng.greenify.pro erase data cache force quit and uninstall.
6) redo step 2 and 3 for com.oasisfend.greenify.pro DO NOT ERASE com.oasisfeng.greenify !!
7) In Greenify app, in about tap uninstall.
8) Go in Xposed installer > Framework > Install/update update framework and reboot.
9) Go in Xposed installer > Modules : check that there is no Greenify package if one is present uninstall and reboot.
10) Go in Google Play install Greenify and donation package, activate boost mode, activate all options you need but you have to tick keep notification. (I tick all options personnally).
11) Go in Xposed > Modules > Greenify > activate module check that it's the last update if dont update and reboot.
12) Go Google Play install Whatsapp.
13) Activate on Greenify all the apps you want to hibernate even Whatsapp it will work now.
Tell us if it's working but now it should.
Next time each time you update Greenify go in Xposed : update Framework and Greenify module to nevers again have that issue.
Regards,
Likesatan
Twmade said:
I do have the paid version of Greenify.
Tried what you said .... Still same problem. I deleted Greenify and I'm trying it right now and so far all messages are getting through. This is sad and I don't know what to do - without getting push messages I can't use this app:crying::crying:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did it work ?
likesatan said:
Did it work ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This sadly, did not work
likesatan said:
Go into settings>applications search for com.whatsapp
See if the box show notification if ticked !
If don't tick it test if it works !
If it's still not working we're going to the rude way :
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Applications there was no com.whatsapp, only whatsapp.
I am, however going to try to test the RUDE way right now! Thanks for taking the time to write this up!! <3. I'll report back if its working or not
likesatan said:
Go into settings>applications search for com.whatsapp
See if the box show notification if ticked !
Regards,
Likesatan
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just want to add - I just saw a notification from WECHAT pop up, and it got HIGHJACKED by greenify and then disappeared - the only reason I even saw it was because the notification got pushed through to my pushbullet on Chrome. WTF man? Does that mean I have to repeat the procedure for wechat, qq, and line?
Further testing shows that pushbullet (which I ONLY greenified the first time I installed it), does not get push notifications sometimes when pushing from chrome to phone - same thing. Only get the update when I open the application manually.
EDIT:
after testing ... I still missed Whatsapp notification which only appeared after I opened the app. For reference the message was sent to me 15 minutes before I opened and recieved it based on timestamp. At a loss .
EDIT2: Testing a tasker task where if screen off i FORCE whatsapp to wake up ... that's the only solution I can think of short of just completely factory reset my phone. Will report back
EDIT3: Even with this configuration, I'm still getting delayed push messages from whatsapp?!?!?!?
Twmade said:
This sadly, did not work
Applications there was no com.whatsapp, only whatsapp.
I am, however going to try to test the RUDE way right now! Thanks for taking the time to write this up!! <3. I'll report back if its working or not
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes,
com.whatsapp = whatsapp
com.oasisfeng.greenify = greenify
com.oasisfeng.greenify.pro = greenify donation package !
---------- Post added at 08:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:40 AM ----------
Twmade said:
I just want to add - I just saw a notification from WECHAT pop up, and it got HIGHJACKED by greenify and then disappeared - the only reason I even saw it was because the notification got pushed through to my pushbullet on Chrome. WTF man? Does that mean I have to repeat the procedure for wechat, qq, and line?
Further testing shows that pushbullet (which I ONLY greenified the first time I installed it), does not get push notifications sometimes when pushing from chrome to phone - same thing. Only get the update when I open the application manually.
EDIT:
after testing ... I still missed Whatsapp notification which only appeared after I opened the app. For reference the message was sent to me 15 minutes before I opened and recieved it based on timestamp. At a loss .
EDIT2: Testing a tasker task where if screen off i FORCE whatsapp to wake up ... that's the only solution I can think of short of just completely factory reset my phone. Will report back
EDIT3: Even with this configuration, I'm still getting delayed push messages from whatsapp?!?!?!?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You did the "rude way" but it didn't work at all ?
It's weird, wich ROM do you use ?
Wich Apps do you use ? I see Tasker did you make a "program" or running one to clear RAM, manage data, wifi and so on to avoid battery drain ?
For Edit 1 : hum It's making me mad
For Edit 2 : Ingenious but not optimum your going to drain a lot of battery
For Edit 3 : Yes I think your algorithm under is to wake whatsapp every 2 minutes ; even with that you will have delayed message (around 2-3 minutes)
At this time yes, I think you should do a factory reset restart everything from the beginning
likesatan said:
Yes,
com.whatsapp = whatsapp
com.oasisfeng.greenify = greenify
com.oasisfeng.greenify.pro = greenify donation package !
---------- Post added at 08:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:40 AM ----------
You did the "rude way" but it didn't work at all ?
It's weird, wich ROM do you use ?
Wich Apps do you use ? I see Tasker did you make a "program" or running one to clear RAM, manage data, wifi and so on to avoid battery drain ?
For Edit 1 : hum It's making me mad
For Edit 2 : Ingenious but not optimum your going to drain a lot of battery
For Edit 3 : Yes I think your algorithm under is to wake whatsapp every 2 minutes ; even with that you will have delayed message (around 2-3 minutes)
At this time yes, I think you should do a factory reset restart everything from the beginning
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Stock Rom, only rooted. I will probably factory reset this weekend when I have more time ....
I do not use anything else - I use to use amplify but in lieu of whats happening I uninstalled it also. Tasker is running nothing but turning on and off sync to try to save more battery. Nothing else that affects how applications react. Thanks for your help... I will try to do factory reset - but now I think I probably shouldn't even restore from backup because of all of this :S
Even with this tasker task, I think the delay is longer than 5 minutes. I'll continue to monitor for now, tonight. Out of ideas of what to do.
Twmade said:
Stock Rom, only rooted. I will probably factory reset this weekend when I have more time ....
I do not use anything else - I use to use amplify but in lieu of whats happening I uninstalled it also. Tasker is running nothing but turning on and off sync to try to save more battery. Nothing else that affects how applications react. Thanks for your help... I will try to do factory reset - but now I think I probably shouldn't even restore from backup because of all of this :S
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, seems to be a good idea to factory reset !
Restoring a backup is crap in my opinion for saving some time you better use ZIPme app, save your apps but no data
Regards,
Likesatan
Don't do factory reset
Seems like it's a problem in 2.5.x version of Greenify !
http://forum.xda-developers.com/apps/greenify/greenified-fb-messenger-notifications-t2872840
likesatan said:
Well, seems to be a good idea to factory reset !
Restoring a backup is crap in my opinion for saving some time you better use ZIPme app, save your apps but no data
Regards,
Likesatan
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I did a factory reset yesterday and after a little bit of testing it seem like the problem went away. After a couple hours, I installed greenify again and everything seemed like it was going well I did not greenify any of Google play Service apps and did not even touch whatsapp, but now it seems like I am getting delayed messages again. Granted, I did not test whataspp notifications for very long before installing greenify again, but messages were rolling through like normal. With greenify installed, I have to click into whatsapp to see any updated messages which - is it possible that greenify screws up my google push notification systems?
Twmade said:
I did a factory reset yesterday and after a little bit of testing it seem like the problem went away. After a couple hours, I installed greenify again and everything seemed like it was going well I did not greenify any of Google play Service apps and did not even touch whatsapp, but now it seems like I am getting delayed messages again. Granted, I did not test whataspp notifications for very long before installing greenify again, but messages were rolling through like normal. With greenify installed, I have to click into whatsapp to see any updated messages which - is it possible that greenify screws up my google push notification systems?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Looking at what happen to you, it seems like your google push notification system is screwed up !
likesatan said:
Looking at what happen to you, it seems like your google push notification system is screwed up !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is this something that can't be fixed with a factory reset? What's the alternative? Flash a new rom? Currently its stock rom argh.
Twmade said:
Is this something that can't be fixed with a factory reset? What's the alternative? Flash a new rom? Currently its stock rom argh.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wich is weird ; I'm not on 4.4.X anymore. I'm using Art system's lollipop AND I DON'T HAVE ANY PROBLEM (well I don't greenify Whatsapp and push apps) !
My ROM is CM12 ported by Arter97 ! A ****ing awesomely stable rom !
Look at CM page a lot of devices are officialy supported by CM12 check if your is too.
If don't try Unofficial ones !
Regards,
Likesatan
likesatan said:
Wich is weird ; I'm not on 4.4.X anymore. I'm using Art system's lollipop AND I DON'T HAVE ANY PROBLEM (well I don't greenify Whatsapp and push apps) !
My ROM is CM12 ported by Arter97 ! A ****ing awesomely stable rom !
Look at CM page a lot of devices are officialy supported by CM12 check if your is too.
If don't try Unofficial ones !
Regards,
Likesatan
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is xposed and stuff still working on loli?
Twmade said:
Is xposed and stuff still working on loli?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not yet dude !
likesatan said:
Not yet dude !
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So an interesting development of event happened today:
I rebooted my phone and I got this message from Pushbullet
{
"lightbox_close": "Close",
"lightbox_next": "Next",
"lightbox_previous": "Previous",
"lightbox_error": "The requested content cannot be loaded. Please try again later.",
"lightbox_start_slideshow": "Start slideshow",
"lightbox_stop_slideshow": "Stop slideshow",
"lightbox_full_screen": "Full screen",
"lightbox_thumbnails": "Thumbnails",
"lightbox_download": "Download",
"lightbox_share": "Share",
"lightbox_zoom": "Zoom",
"lightbox_new_window": "New window",
"lightbox_toggle_sidebar": "Toggle sidebar"
}
I'm glad that Pushbullet at least notifies me that it's not being able to function properly in the background unlike most of the other applications. Now it seems GCM is getting blocked somehow. Now I have two hypothesis for this
1) Greenify screwed up Google play services somehow and it's making all of my GCM either delayed or unable to get through
2) I live in China, so if GCM requires any sort of connection through google's servers, that might cause problems/delays.
I'm more leaning towards number 1, as these problems started happening only after I installed and played around with greenify. However, at the same time, the message disappeared after I hopped on VPN so it's uncertain and driving me crazy.
Twmade said:
So an interesting development of event happened today:
I rebooted my phone and I got this message from Pushbullet
I'm glad that Pushbullet at least notifies me that it's not being able to function properly in the background unlike most of the other applications. Now it seems GCM is getting blocked somehow. Now I have two hypothesis for this
1) Greenify screwed up Google play services somehow and it's making all of my GCM either delayed or unable to get through
2) I live in China, so if GCM requires any sort of connection through google's servers, that might cause problems/delays.
I'm more leaning towards number 1, as these problems started happening only after I installed and played around with greenify. However, at the same time, the message disappeared after I hopped on VPN so it's uncertain and driving me crazy.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Try to use VPN or proxy server. But I do think that it's Greenify who's screwing up.
likesatan said:
Try to use VPN or proxy server. But I do think that it's Greenify who's screwing up.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Okay, so I left my phone on with VPN all night, and in the morning I had no messages from what'sapp until I entered the application, so that theory is out the window. I sent the DEV a PM I hope he reads it.
Another thing I tried from a reddit thread is cleared the cache of all Google related services. So far that doesn't work either
Edit 2: and upon further investigation, with VPN ON and, while inside the whatsapp app, and having the screen off(it dims) will lead me to get delayed/no messages until the screen turns back on. This leads me to believe that it must be greenified? I'm not running any other app controlling apps
Well, i have observed it with Facebook Messenger and Viber, should be the same issue with other greenified applications
The GCM push works fine, but the problem is, that the notification won't be visible till i actually open or unlock my screen
That said, i can see that the application has been woken by a push( seconds or minutes before i get the notification) but you can't see it till you actually open the phone so the application opens in foreground.
I am almost definitely sure this used to work at KitKat normally
I have tested this using Greenify beta(the latest) with the xposed-alpha 14-05 on OnePlus One
Reptant said:
Well, i have observed it with Facebook Messenger and Viber, should be the same issue with other greenified applications
The GCM push works fine, but the problem is, that the notification won't be visible till i actually open or unlock my screen
That said, i can see that the application has been woken by a push( seconds or minutes before i get the notification) but you can't see it till you actually open the phone so the application opens in foreground.
I am almost definitely sure this used to work at KitKat normally
I have tested this using Greenify beta(the latest) with the xposed-alpha 14-05 on OnePlus One
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can confirm this too! @oasisfeng you should definitely look into this issue.I've tried it on my two devices running 5.0.2 and 5.1.1 respectively.The notification doesn't come through until I wakeup the screen.The app is waken up but the notification doesn't arrive until I turn on the screen.
Removing the app from greenified list fixes the issue.
Tapped from my furious dogo
vaisakh7 said:
I can confirm this too! @oasisfeng you should definitely look into this issue.I've tried it on my two devices running 5.0.2 and 5.1.1 respectively.The notification doesn't come through until I wakeup the screen.The app is waken up but the notification doesn't arrive until I turn on the screen.
Removing the app from greenified list fixes the issue.
Tapped from my furious dogo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well sometimes, after a random amount of time it may appear.. But the randomness is what troubles me as well..
@oasisfeng Can confirm this. Unless I turn on the screen manually, I don't hear the notification chime. And yes, it did work fine in KitKat.
Have same issue, no notification with Facebook and Messenger.
I get the when screen turns on, but not instantly...after a while.
Any fix?
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S5 SM-G906K using TapaTalk
Same here, but also without greenify. I switched to a new ROM and phone. So perhaps it is ROM related.
bongster said:
Same here, but also without greenify. I switched to a new ROM and phone. So perhaps it is ROM related.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi again, I have managed to get it work again. I degreenified all apps, deselected everything under experimentally features. After a reboot I ticked off my normal feature set. And voila I'm getting gcm messages again! I guess I messed something up by using titanium...
BTW I'm using cm 12.1 optimized on a S4
bongster said:
Hi again, I have managed to get it work again. I degreenified all apps, deselected everything under experimentally features. After a reboot I ticked off my normal feature set. And voila I'm getting gcm messages again! I guess I messed something up by using titanium...
BTW I'm using cm 12.1 optimized on a S4
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you be more precise in what you've done?
For now I've made an app with Tasker that closes Facebook and Messenger and then Greenify all my app list and then locks system, so to not put Facebook and Messenger on Greenify and have push messages, but don't constantly have them on Active Apps last if used.
If you want I can share it.
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S5 SM-G906K using TapaTalk
PIRATA! said:
Can you be more precise in what you've done?
For now I've made an app with Tasker that closes Facebook and Messenger and then Greenify all my app list and then locks system, so to not put Facebook and Messenger on Greenify and have push messages, but don't constantly have them on Active Apps last if used.
If you want I can share it.
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S5 SM-G906K using TapaTalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
OK. I'll try to explain a bit more precisely.
My issue was, that e.g. whatsapp does not receive messages while greenified. I had to start it manually to see if I got new messages.
This started a few days ago with my new phone. Before the new phone I had no problems with greenify in combination with cm12.1.
Here my steps:
1. Remove all Apps from greenify
2. Remove all options from experimental features
3. Restart the phone
4. Select all apps that I want to greenify
5. Reselect my normal options under experimental options.
That's it
Regards
Unfortunately this didn't work for me. But I tried something else that might be helpful. I use Amplify and decided to disable it temporarily to see if I received the GCM push and the notifications, and yes, it did work flawlessly. I might have stopped a wakelock or a service being of google that might be helpful in this.
same issues, then went to settings security device administrators checked greenify now i get push notifications when screens off
stesteste said:
same issues, then went to settings security device administrators checked greenify now i get push notifications when screens off
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You mean you turned on the administrator setting?
ottomanrage said:
You mean you turned on the administrator setting?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes just for greenify
blisspop 6.3 .arter97 kernel xposed
Same here :/ It's enabled in security settings
stesteste said:
yes just for greenify
blisspop 6.3 .arter97 kernel xposed
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, it didn't help much. I tried flashing all the ROMs available for S3 and it works, partially, in the latest BlissPop. The thing is that GCM push gets received instantaneously but the notification doesn't get posted. It does though, like after 30 mins or so. But never soon enough.
any news why GCM doesnt work proberly anymore with some apps like WhatsApp ? It used to work so i wonder if this a ROM, App, Xposed or Greenify problem.
About 6-8 weeks ago i had this working with CM12.1 on a GT-I9505 (Galaxy S4) with at that time actual apps, modules and ROM.
Hi guys, I have serious issue with my Mate 10 Pro. I started to notice, that my phone is not notificating me about new e-mails (gmail and outlook apps), new messages (hangouts) or reminders (to-do app). I Googled everything about this but nothing helped. I set background apps to "manage manually" and turned on "Ignore battery optimisation". I have also locked the apps in multitasking and added widgets to home screen. Nothing helped.
Also I have noticed that during the night all apps are gone from multitasking. What is going on? I never had such issue with any Android phone or tablet before.
Can anybody help me please?
yurij666 said:
Hi guys, I have serious issue with my Mate 10 Pro. I started to notice, that my phone is not notificating me about new e-mails (gmail and outlook apps), new messages (hangouts) or reminders (to-do app). I Googled everything about this but nothing helped. I set background apps to "manage manually" and turned on "Ignore battery optimisation". I have also locked the apps in multitasking and added widgets to home screen. Nothing helped.
Also I have noticed that during the night all apps are gone from multitasking. What is going on? I never had such issue with any Android phone or tablet before.
Can anybody help me please?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Which firmware do you have
I had same issues with some apps but now, it works fine, at least with apps I'm using
sonydesouza said:
Which firmware do you have
I had same issues with some apps but now, it works fine, at least with apps I'm using
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
8.0.0. 125 (C432), no update avaliable
yurij666 said:
8.0.0. 125 (C432), no update avaliable
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have 127-C432 o'er update from 115-C432.
Never had 125 ?
sonydesouza said:
I have 127-C432 o'er update from 115-C432.
Never had 125 ?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have single SIM version, from Orange with data plan. I would try factory reset but I consider it as a last resort
yurij666 said:
I have single SIM version, from Orange with data plan. I would try factory reset but I consider it as a last resort
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ahh.
Ok.
Bloody hell orange ?
Your problem is very likely being caused by Huawei's by-default aggressive battery optimisations.
There are two sections of settings to look at in fixing this;
1. To stop critical (to you) apps being forcibly closed, go to SETTINGS -> BATTERY -> LAUNCH, change your selected apps from "automatic" to "manual" and make sure "Run in Background" is enabled for them.
2. To allow critical (to you) apps to continue running with the screen off, go to SETTINGS -> APPS & NOTIFICATIONS -> APPS -> SETTINGS -> SPECIAL ACCESS -> BATTERY OPTIMISATION, change "Not Optimised" to "All" at the top of the screen, then set your critical apps to "Not Optimised."
It's a true pain that it's a two-fold process in different sections of the settings and that they're so tedious to get to, but once you've discovered where they are, it (sort of) makes sense.
Cephalus said:
Your problem is very likely being caused by Huawei's by-default aggressive battery optimisations.
There are two sections of settings to look at in fixing this;
1. To stop critical (to you) apps being forcibly closed, go to SETTINGS -> BATTERY -> LAUNCH, change your selected apps from "automatic" to "manual" and make sure "Run in Background" is enabled for them.
2. To allow critical (to you) apps to continue running with the screen off, go to SETTINGS -> APPS & NOTIFICATIONS -> APPS -> SETTINGS -> SPECIAL ACCESS -> BATTERY OPTIMISATION, change "Not Optimised" to "All" at the top of the screen, then set your critical apps to "Not Optimised."
It's a true pain that it's a two-fold process in different sections of the settings and that they're so tedious to get to, but once you've discovered where they are, it (sort of) makes sense.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have already done these two steps. Didn't work. For example this morning I checked my phone, no notification. I opened gmail app, suddenly there is big 7 next do my new e-mails. Even then there was no notification in status bar.
yurij666 said:
I have already done these two steps. Didn't work. For example this morning I checked my phone, no notification. I opened gmail app, suddenly there is big 7 next do my new e-mails. Even then there was no notification in status bar.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you checked that the app has notification permissions? SETTINGS -> APPS & NOTIFICATIONS -> NOTIFICATIONS MANAGEMENT
This is admittedly a far stretch as by default all apps should have notification permissions, but it's worth a try - and unfortunately is the only remaining idea I have.
Cephalus said:
Have you checked that the app has notification permissions? SETTINGS -> APPS & NOTIFICATIONS -> NOTIFICATIONS MANAGEMENT
This is admittedly a far stretch as by default all apps should have notification permissions, but it's worth a try - and unfortunately is the only remaining idea I have.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, did that too. Even set those apps to priority. I guess I will really have to try that factory reset. What also bothers me is, that sometimes I want to unlock the phone (fingerprint or button) I hear the unlock sound, but the phone lights up like 5 seconds later.
yurij666 said:
Yes, did that too. Even set those apps to priority. I guess I will really have to try that factory reset. What also bothers me is, that sometimes I want to unlock the phone (fingerprint or button) I hear the unlock sound, but the phone lights up like 5 seconds later.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I doubt that the factory reset will help you. Well, at least with the to-do app reminders part. As I've described in my post (https://forum.xda-developers.com/mate-10/help/local-notifications-t3737241), almost any to-do app fails to show the reminders (all possible optimization turned off, all permissions given), and it either has smth to do with our firmware, or with the apps not being adopted for the Oreo (some noticeable changes in notification API).
But if his phone takes 5 seconds to wake up, something is seriously wrong. I would highly recommend a factory reset if for nothing else than fixing the 5 second wake up time.
i have the same issue with almost all apps that i am using
did everything in google and still no luck
not sure is it app issue , huawei , android .... me ?
common i dont want to open and check all apps all the day to see if there is update or not just push it to me as soon as it get .
Same here, I have BLA-L09 8.0.0.128 (C432). I've tried all battery and notifications settings and I've also factory reset my phone. Google now does not update news, Gmail does not notify new emails, 3rd party widgets do not refresh, and the app for my car does not sync via Bluetooth (I have to remove the the BT profile and create it again to sync 1 time then stops)
I had the same problem with my previous phone (samsung note 3). It turned out to be due to IPv6 being enabled. Have you tried disabling it?
Cephalus said:
Your problem is very likely being caused by Huawei's by-default aggressive battery optimisations.
There are two sections of settings to look at in fixing this;
1. To stop critical (to you) apps being forcibly closed, go to SETTINGS -> BATTERY -> LAUNCH, change your selected apps from "automatic" to "manual" and make sure "Run in Background" is enabled for them.
2. To allow critical (to you) apps to continue running with the screen off, go to SETTINGS -> APPS & NOTIFICATIONS -> APPS -> SETTINGS -> SPECIAL ACCESS -> BATTERY OPTIMISATION, change "Not Optimised" to "All" at the top of the screen, then set your critical apps to "Not Optimised."
It's a true pain that it's a two-fold process in different sections of the settings and that they're so tedious to get to, but once you've discovered where they are, it (sort of) makes sense.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for this! I had already done #1, but #2 I had no clue about. It seems to have fixed the delay in notifications from the Outlook app.
Novi84 said:
Thanks for this! I had already done #1, but #2 I had no clue about. It seems to have fixed the delay in notifications from the Outlook app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wonder why Gmail is not listed as an app that can bypass the battery optimization?
jaseman said:
I wonder why Gmail is not listed as an app that can bypass the battery optimization?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because its preinstalled app. Anyway both settings doesn't works. I'm selling this peace of **** phone because it has no use anymore. Worst phone ever.
Can't get notifications from most of apps. So why do I need a smartphone like this...
And even battery, doesn't lasts full day from the time I wake up, till I go to sleep. so Huawei is the last phone I ever bought.
so is there any chance to have this issue fixed ?
by update perhaps , can we contact them or complain so they notice ?
i really search about phones before i buy it and choosed this one from the e specs and reviews
but i didnt expect there is a (SMART)PHONE would have a problem like this at all it is unbelievable
and i dont want to sell it .. just want this issue to be fixed
Just a thought...I read here and elsewhere that putting widgets on your home screen helps notifications comes through due to the fact that the widget keeps the apps open. I did this with my Honor Note 8 and, along with the other bits of advice above, got most of my notifications to work.
I know this is a topic existing over internet, I've googled it extensively, but up to now I haven't found a solution.
I've got a non-pro Mate 10, the Chinese version AL-00, rebranded to International/Global ALP L-29.
Approximately two to three weeks ago I got an update from 9 to EMUI 9.1, and maybe a week later, another update as a security patch. The current version of the software is 9.1.0301 (C636E2R1P12).
After the system update, I normally updated all the apps that needed updating and cleaned the phone's cache from bootloader. And although now I once again receive notifications from Google play when an app needs updating (I stopped receiving those a while back for an unknown reason), I stopped receiving notifications for virtually any messaging service or social network, including Gmail app.
To be more specific, when using Gmail, Facebook Messenger, Viber, Whatsapp LinkedIn or some other, I do not get notified of new messages/posts/emails whatever, UNLESS I am using the phone at that particular moment, or unless I am using that specific app at that moment. That also applies for my bank's custom app which should normally notify me instantly as soon as some expense occurs on my card. A few times it even happened that I would receive and reply to a FB message, close the app and like an hour later would receive a notification that that specific person messaged me.
This only started happening after that last update.
I tried turning off battery optimization for each and every single of those apps, I tried switching App launch to manual. It literally makes no difference. Force stopping and cleaning the cache of the apps doesn't help as well.
While I could live with it when it comes to FB or LinkedIn, I cant have Gmail or FB Messenger holding my messages for so long without notifying me. I need them for my work and sometimes time is of the utmost essence.
Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated
EDIT: I just noticed that I'm having same problems with Google Keep app when using reminders
Please, guys, help!
neverone said:
I know this is a topic existing over internet, I've googled it extensively, but up to now I haven't found a solution.
I've got a non-pro Mate 10, the Chinese version AL-00, rebranded to International/Global ALP L-29.
Approximately two to three weeks ago I got an update from 9 to EMUI 9.1, and maybe a week later, another update as a security patch. The current version of the software is 9.1.0301 (C636E2R1P12).
After the system update, I normally updated all the apps that needed updating and cleaned the phone's cache from bootloader. And although now I once again receive notifications from Google play when an app needs updating (I stopped receiving those a while back for an unknown reason), I stopped receiving notifications for virtually any messaging service or social network, including Gmail app.
To be more specific, when using Gmail, Facebook Messenger, Viber, Whatsapp LinkedIn or some other, I do not get notified of new messages/posts/emails whatever, UNLESS I am using the phone at that particular moment, or unless I am using that specific app at that moment. That also applies for my bank's custom app which should normally notify me instantly as soon as some expense occurs on my card. A few times it even happened that I would receive and reply to a FB message, close the app and like an hour later would receive a notification that that specific person messaged me.
This only started happening after that last update.
I tried turning off battery optimization for each and every single of those apps, I tried switching App launch to manual. It literally makes no difference. Force stopping and cleaning the cache of the apps doesn't help as well.
While I could live with it when it comes to FB or LinkedIn, I cant have Gmail or FB Messenger holding my messages for so long without notifying me. I need them for my work and sometimes time is of the utmost essence.
Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated
EDIT: I just noticed that I'm having same problems with Google Keep app when using reminders
Please, guys, help!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've the same updates like yours but mine has no problem
Sent from my BLA-L29 using Tapatalk
yap.rony said:
I've the same updates like yours but mine has no problem
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Did you make a full system reset afterwards?
neverone said:
Did you make a full system reset afterwards?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you have root? Try freezing powergenie app, it should allow the notifications to come on time. The only issue is there might be a "slight" battery drain from more apps allowed to run in background. That was a dirty fix that worked even in emui 8/9 and peps seemed to have no issues even after the mod.
Since emui 9.1 introduces erofs file system, you'll have to either freeze the app in question everytime you reboot or create magisk module that during boot replaces contents of /system/app/HwPowerGenieEngine3 with empy folder - I'm not sure how removing odex files affects the thermals so I suggest just removing apk file and keeping everything else from the original directory intact if the temps and phone performance behave odly after doing this.
Feel free to give it a try, but I don't think it's actually worth doing it. The old forum post suggesting this mod actually overlooked the importance of power genie when it comes to temps + performance regulations across the board. Without it the temps will rise, phone won't supercharge and the performance will dip.
I'm actually playing around with this rn, trying to remove thermal limits on per app basis, if I come across anything I'll let ya know. Good luck
Have you made test on both mobile network and on WLAN? And what provider do you use with this phone? I see OP1 and VIP in your profile, probably outdated.
Rstment ^m^ said:
Do you have root?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, thanks, and I can see that you really wanted to help but no, I never rooted this phone, so I guess that all the tips you have for me are, unfortunately, in vain
Thanks though, for trying to help!
domy_os said:
Have you made test on both mobile network and on WLAN? And what provider do you use with this phone? I see OP1 and VIP in your profile, probably outdated.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep I did, sometimes switching between WiFi and mobile network does activate the apps to check for new messages/mail, and sometimes it doesn't. I haven't noticed any clear pattern.
And it must be difference between XDA forums and the app. I swear I switched it when I bought the Mate. But I'm still on VIP/A1
@neverone, go to Settings > Battery > More battery settings and switch on the option Stay connected when device sleeps. I didn't see you mention this somewhere, I switch this on after every factory reset.
domy_os said:
@neverone, go to Settings > Battery > More battery settings and switch on the option Stay connected when device sleeps. I didn't see you mention this somewhere, I switch this on after every factory reset.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No I haven't, but now that I checked, it was turned on all the time. However, knowing that sometimes this actually works, I toggled it off and back on several times and restarted the phone. I'll pay closer attention during the day to see if that helped and report back here. Thanks for the suggestion.
I too have this issue in my M10Pro specially in messenger. sometimes the chat icon doesn't appear even if i have an unread message.
domy_os said:
@neverone, go to Settings > Battery > More battery settings and switch on the option Stay connected when device sleeps. I didn't see you mention this somewhere, I switch this on after every factory reset.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
cheeze.keyk said:
I too have this issue in my M10Pro specially in messenger. sometimes the chat icon doesn't appear even if i have an unread message.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here's an update: Turning off and on the "Stay connected" option did not help at all, the real proof is that i received an email notification of cheeze.keyk replying to this thread, and I only saw it when I logged in on my PC. The phone did not notify me at all.
So the problem still persists, unfortunately. I am really hoping that I won't have to make a factory reset, although it is also uncertain if that would help at all.
totally bummed. my Mate 10 Pro screen just went crazy. It now has a bright green line all across the very bottom of the screen. And the whole screen now has a faint "screen door" effect going on. just enough to be irritating. I doubt I can live with it, but I loved this phone.
jimberkas said:
totally bummed. my Mate 10 Pro screen just went crazy. It now has a bright green line all across the very bottom of the screen. And the whole screen now has a faint "screen door" effect going on. just enough to be irritating. I doubt I can live with it, but I loved this phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm sorry that you're experiencing such issues, but I don't see the link between your issues, and the issues we're discussing here.
agreed. wrong thread. sorry
@neverone, another idea. Have you frozen some system apps, especially Google Play Services? Or maybe disabled in battery app launch or turned on battery optimization for Google Play Services and Google Services Framework?
domy_os said:
@neverone, another idea. Have you frozen some system apps, especially Google Play Services? Or maybe disabled in battery app launch or turned on battery optimization for Google Play Services and Google Services Framework?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
These two screenshots show show which apps I have frozen/disabled and which of the Google based apps have and don't have battery optimisation activated.
This essentially hasn't changed since I bought the phone over a year ago. Do you think I should do something with these apps or change some of their settings?
Send also the complete screenshot of Settings > Battery > App launch > Three dots > Manage manually.
Did you restrict background data maybe? Settings > Wireless & networks > Data usage > Network access > in upper drop down menu switch to Advanced network settings > Tick all apps on both installed and system apps list.
And the last question, do you use Smart Data Saver? Settings > Wireless & networks > Data usage > Smart Data Saver
domy_os said:
Send also the complete screenshot of Settings > Battery > App launch > Three dots > Manage manually.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here you go, attached. Hope you'll be able to read all the apps ?
domy_os said:
Did you restrict background data maybe? Settings > Wireless & networks > Data usage > Network access > in upper drop down menu switch to Advanced network settings > Tick all apps on both installed and system apps list.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, all processes have an unrestricted background data ?
domy_os said:
And the last question, do you use Smart Data Saver? Settings > Wireless & networks > Data usage > Smart Data Saver
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, data saver has been turned off and moreover, most of the apps seem to be ticked as an exception if it ever gets turned on
Hope that you put all checkmarks on Google Play Services and all other apps you have notifications problem.
Well as you can see, considering Google's apps, all is good.
I mean this one in Settings > Battery > App launch > Three dots > Manage manually, have a look on attachment.
So, my Email client, Google Play services, Moj Telekom, Viber and WhatsApp have set all three options: auto-launch, secondary launch and run in background. With this setup, I have no problems at all.