Related
Got my Flyer yesterday. In many ways it's very impressive but I really don't understand some of the design decisions made by HTC.
The unique selling point for this tablet is undoubtedly the pen. Without the pen functionality there are plenty of other tablets (Samsung Galaxy etc) around that are more or less equivalent for about half the cost.
That presumably means that most people who have shelled out the extra cash for the Flyer have, like me, done so because of the pen. The problem is though, that having used the Flyer a couple of days, it has become clear that the pen can only be used with the limited range of bundled apps specifically developed by HTC, so basically the extra money you spend getting a pen enabled device just gets you HTC notes (which is OK but not earth shattering), the kids art package (Zoodle) and the ability to scribble on the screen and take a screenshot (not sure about anyone else but that's not really much use to me).
This creates the ludicrous situation of there being scores of Android Apps that would really benefit from the Pen Input (Handrite, Tabnotes, Writepad, MaplePaint, Magic Doodle, Budgerigar, TapeMachine) etc but if you want to use these apps on the Flyer you've still got to use your finger or a capacative (i.e. fat iPad) stylus!
This makes absolutely no sense to me - doubling the cost just for HTC notes and a kids art package makes the flyer very poor value for money. As things stand all we can do is hope against hope that developers will convert/produce enough apps to support the pen (HTC has released the API) to justify our expensive investment but the problem is they'll be investing a lot of time for a very specific section of the market and so may not get the returns to justify their efforts.
Two questions:-
(1) Why have HTC done this? There is presumably no technical reason why the Pen couldn't have been (optionally) usuable in any app and on any part of the operating system - this is the way Windows Touch tablets (including those using active digitizers like the HP Touchsmart series) have always worked and indeed the way that capacitative pens work on the iPAD. Why couldn't HTC have left the decision TO US as to whether we wanted to use finger or pen input
(2) More importantly, can this be 'fixed' by the XDA community so that the Pen can optionally be used in any app the user chooses?
Consider this the launch of the 'Free The Pen' campaign!
Are you listening HTC?
Well first of all I returned the pen a day after I bought it. Now that being said it was pretty cool for the amount off time its been out. I just didnt really see much use coming from it for me being that I already have two or three styluses (sp? Styli?) keep in mind tho that the other side does work as a regular stylus although it is awkward to use being that is metal so if you do get use(even if its just a little) of the poem side it may still be worth it to you. Give it a few months n im guessing there will be more apps then toy know what to do with. .
Sent from my HTC Flyer P512 using XDA Premium App
Hi,
I've the Flyer now for almost ten days and it was integrated in my usual work on the first day. Since the days of my Apple Newton (like a brick, but back in the 90s a sensation) I wished a device which I can use to make handwritten notes in a meeting, during a call or just during normal work. Making notes with an on screen keyboard does not work well for me. Takes too much time and consumes to much concentration. But with the flyer it's like on paper. And that's for now aboslutely enough for my needs. The flyer replaced my usual paper notebook and gives the power of a full mobile device on top.
Regarding other pen enabled apps. HTC just announced a Sense SDK which will include a SDK for pen apps. So hopefully we'll see some of this apps later this year.
bye
Sven
charalew said:
...
This makes absolutely no sense to me - doubling the cost just for HTC notes and a kids art package makes the flyer very poor value for money
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Doubling? I would agree it would suck if it actually doubled the price but that's not quite the case...
Also, I'm not a programmer but I'm guessing integrating pen functionality might be easy. I'd guess it'd be an option that can be set and if the user doesn't have a pen it won't be activated. Think of it like Qualcomm's game strategy. They help developers optimize games for Adreno GPUs which means that they will look the best they can on Adreno devices BUT they don't prevent the games from running on other devices (unlike Tegra Zone games). This in my opinion is the best way to deal with developers since you help them make a better/more functional product but don't limit them to just one section of the market. I'm hoping pen functionality will be like this, allowing more devs to choose to include it in their apps.
Returned my pen as well. Not worth $80 when a $30 pen from Fujitsu would work on the same 3 apps that are enabled for pen use. The haven't released the api they have only announced it. So it's still useless from a development standpoint.
There are lots of Reviews that show what the Flyer and can't do so there is no reason to buy one and then wonder why it can't do certain things.
Also, here in the UK there are no 7" 3G tablets with 32GB that are half price of the Flyer.
The price of all tablets is higher in the first few months.
jah said:
There are lots of Reviews that show what the Flyer and can't do so there is no reason to buy one and then wonder why it can't do certain things.
Also, here in the UK there are no 7" 3G tablets with 32GB that are half price of the Flyer.
The price of all tablets is higher in the first few months.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yep I read a few reviews before I bought it. I took them to mean that there were only a couple of apps that had been developed to specifically take advantage of the pen - I didn't quite realise the pen couldn't be be used anywhere else! The question is WHY have HTC crippled the pen functionality in this way? I don't see any technical reason why they would have had to implement it this way (which is why I wasn't expecting it) and I'm struggling to see what they were trying to achieve by deliberately limiting the pen's functionality.
The current Amazon price for the 3G Flyer is £559.98. The price for the 7" 3G Samsung P1000 is £351.90. I admit that's not quite half the cost of the Flyer - it's actually 62% of the cost.
That's still a massive premium to pay for an extra 16GB of memory (particularly as the Galaxy, like the flyer is expandable with an SD Card) and a pen that can only be used in a couple of bundled apps! For me, the Flyer would be worth the extra money if the pen was usable everywhere but as things stand I don't really think that the price differential can be justified. Nevertheless I'll be keeping it in the hope that more apps appear or better still, that the Pen can be set free!
charalew said:
Yep I read a few reviews before I bought it. I took them to mean that there were only a couple of apps that had been developed to specifically take advantage of the pen - I didn't quite realise the pen couldn't be be used anywhere else! The question is WHY have HTC crippled the pen functionality in this way? I don't see any technical reason why they would have had to implement it this way (which is why I wasn't expecting it) and I'm struggling to see what they were trying to achieve by deliberately limiting the pen's functionality.
The current Amazon price for the 3G Flyer is £559.98. The price for the 7" 3G Samsung P1000 is £351.90. I admit that's not quite half the cost of the Flyer - it's actually 62% of the cost.
That's still a massive premium to pay for an extra 16GB of memory (particularly as the Galaxy, like the flyer is expandable with an SD Card) and a pen that can only be used in a couple of bundled apps! For me, the Flyer would be worth the extra money if the pen was usable everywhere but as things stand I don't really think that the price differential can be justified. Nevertheless I'll be keeping it in the hope that more apps appear or better still, that the Pen can be set free!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My Galaxy Tab was £499.
Youtube video reviews of the Flyer I saw were very clear about what the Flyer can and can't do. Also, comments here are very clear about the Fyler's functionality.
See here: http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=981406&highlight=scrybe&page=2
Samsung has just released the Galaxy Note.
http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/41837/samsung-galaxy-note-ifa-tablet-phone
5.5in screen is a bit small as a tablet, large as a smartphone. I am also no fan of SS's AMOLED and build quality.
But the integrated pen capability in software is amazing (due to the SSg's video). Wonder whether we will have something like that or can get something from that on our Flyers someday.
This might be a stupid question and probably premature right now. I know that the Flyer and the Galaxy Note are completely different devices (CPU, screen, ...). Assuming that SS uses the same n-trig technology in their Note, theoretically is there any chance that we can get Note ROM running on the Flyer?
Tell myself being optimistic, I have just had my Flyer for a month. I like it very much. Hope that amazing and hardworking XDA developers will bring us a lot of extra fun in the future.
Cheers.
Edit: the Note uses Wacom technology due to Cnet.
I really like the way this samsung tablet handles pen integration. After owning my View for a bit now I'm kinda disappointed with it. The pen integration is weak and the note apps is good, not great.
I'll definitely check out this samsung tab when it comes out.
It's nice but i doubt if it can defeat my Phatpad on my old WM05 device.
I hope the application provide option to resize the Page, very annoying if you have you stuck on the screen size when you have a lot of thing to draw.
Check this http://www.pocket-lint.com/news-gallery/41855/samsung-galaxy-note-hands-on/10#image
It has handwriting recognition, bring back memories to oldschool device
Oldschool but usefull .
Wait for Honeycomb for the Flyer and we will probably have the same functionality..
Good point
amf said:
Wait for Honeycomb for the Flyer and we will probably have the same functionality..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I forgot about their hints at a Honeycomb update, and hopefully they are keeping a close eye on what Samsung has done.
This is getting interesting. It'd be cool if the Samsung Tabs had pen support too, and I'd even consider one since I loved my OG Galaxy Tab ... But I am something of an HTC fan. Hmmmm ...
Samsung galaxy note has no n-trig digitizer. It just passive capacitive digitizer. You can just look from the photos and videos that the big line width of the character and only two words per line, telling us that it is only passive technology.
Sent from my HTC Flyer P510e using Tapatalk
How about a port of Lenovo Thinkpad Tablet's pen integration? Lenovo uses the same N-trig technology just like HTC Flyer. I really like how it works with Sketchbook Pro pressure sensitive option, and allows the pen to navigate around like using your finger.
I have just about given up on HTC to give me a tablet I have always wanted.
-E.J.Su
"Talent is worthless without hard work."
Senior Product Designer @ www.tridentcase.com
http://ej-su.deviantart.com
http://gplus.to/ejsu
Sent from HTC Flyer
E.J.Su said:
How about a port of Lenovo Thinkpad Tablet's pen integration? Lenovo uses the same N-trig technology just like HTC Flyer. I really like how it works with Sketchbook Pro pressure sensitive option, and allows the pen to navigate around like using your finger.
I have just about given up on HTC to give me a tablet I have always wanted.
-E.J.Su
"Talent is worthless without hard work."
Senior Product Designer @ www.tridentcase.com
http://ej-su.deviantart.com
http://gplus.to/ejsu
Sent from HTC Flyer
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In Flyer Honeycomb you can use your pen to do everything you do now with your finger, support is massively improved.
P
paulobrien said:
In Flyer Honeycomb you can use your pen to do everything you do now with your finger, support is massively improved.
P
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's awesome to hear, by any chance do you know if the pressure sensitive pen works on Sketchbook Pro?
-E.J.Su
"Talent is worthless without hard work."
Senior Product Designer @ www.tridentcase.com
http://ej-su.deviantart.com
http://gplus.to/ejsu
Sent from HTC Flyer
paulobrien said:
In Flyer Honeycomb you can use your pen to do everything you do now with your finger, support is massively improved.
P
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Amazing, that's a real update. Your comment makes my day, Paul. I am looking forward to the reviews of your leaked Flyer Honeycomb rom. Thanks a lot for sharing.
@d2ey: I still keep my Xperia X1 running WM6.5. Stylus was great in WM.
@iwansuryo: Yes, SS Note does not use ntrig. CNET said that it uses wacom (0'20": http://news.cnet.com/8301-30685_3-20100730-264/samsung-galaxy-note-hands-on/). The pen seems quite precise.
blue blue man said:
Amazing, that's a real update. Your comment makes my day, Paul.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+1.
This is the first revelation that actually has me eagerly looking forward to Honeycomb. Up to now I've been like "Honeycomb... meh."
15 screen shots of the Honeycomb Flyer from thisismynext & Paul:
http://thisismynext.com/2011/09/05/h...e-screenshots/
Waiting for reviews on the pen performance.
Video of HC rom from Neaw: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxFQ3HWGfRc&feature=youtu.be
This is what we can expect from the official Honeycomb Flyer - HTC Jetstream review (pen from 27'): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FEsAjyYDTbU
E.J.Su said:
How about a port of Lenovo Thinkpad Tablet's pen integration? Lenovo uses the same N-trig technology just like HTC Flyer. I really like how it works with Sketchbook Pro pressure sensitive option, and allows the pen to navigate around like using your finger.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sketchbook works on the Jetstream (see the video) so it should work with the Flyer too. I hope that pressure sensitivity will work. since the sketchbook can recognize pressure sensitivity of the Thinkpad pen, very probable that it should behave the same with the Flyer pen.
I'm really interested into the flyer, what features do you miss on this tablet? I would use it for the university and I'm doubting between the trio flyer-jetstream-thinkpad
Hi to all Flyer users,
I am writing this message because despite the fact that I love my Flyer and use it 24/7, I am still not using it for the very first reason that I bought it, to replace my big old tablet PC, for sketches.
When HTC announced the HTC Dev with the Scribe API not so long ago, I was very excited and I thought that we Flyer users would at last have a chance to use it for the main purpose we bought it. But no...
I just wanted to reach out to any coder who is capable of writing an app for the flyer, who understands a word of the coding for the Scribe technology out there. We as artistic Flyer users request an app to let us do sketches and drawings. I don't care at the end how expensive the app will be, because I am pretty sure that the first sketching app made for the Flyer will be bought by many people regardless the price.
If you are a developer who can write such an app, do it soon, because you are going to make lots of money, I'm sure.
I hope nobody finds this message in anyway rude or offensive, it is just that I really want to get full use of my Flyer and since HTC is doing nothing about it so far, XDA community is the only place I know that I can request such a thing.
Thanks to everyone in advance and thanks for understanding.
// I don't if this is even relevant but HTC has uploaded some codes in the HTC Dev website with screenshots of a drawing app, maybe if only those codes are used to make an app //
I feel your pain. I picked up the Flyer for the same reason, unfortunately, it fell short on that one area. The guy that wrote Fresco tried to integrate the pen function, but it hasn't worked.
The good news is, the Honeycomb update supposedly works the same way the finger touch does. Sketchbook Pro supports pressure sensitive pen, I am hoping HTC's pen works in Sketchbook Pro.
I know Fresco and I even tried to help Sean during this process. I respect him for being the only one out there, and doing what HTC is yet to do.
Are you sure that sketchbook has stylus compatibility, pressure sensitivity?
I have just read that the stylus works as a finger does on honeycomb but that does not mean that we will be able to use the pen options (width, pen type, color) still.
Sent from my HTC Flyer P510e using Tapatalk
No, I wasn't sure. I was hoping.
I just flashed Honeycomb myself and tried it for myself. I was not able to find Sketchbook Pro in the market so I tried the Express instead, you may or may not know, it doesn't have that pressure sensitive like the Pro version. Express won't even recognize the strokes. I then tried the Mobile version, this version works fine, but no pressure sensitive option.
So the result is still inconclusive until I actually try the pro version. At least right now I've got a precise pen with better color choices.
I'll still try to figure out how to put SB pro in my new Honeycomb Flyer.
In case you didn't know, Lenovo Thinkpad Tablet pen does have pressure sensitive in SB Pro, and it also use N-Trig pen like the Flyer.
[UPDATE] I had to side load Sketchbook Pro. It doesn't work.
-E.J.Su
http://ej-su.deviantart.com
"Talent is worthless without hard work"
Send from HTC Flyer
Hi everyone. I thought I'd add my agreement to this thread. I sent a message/request to HTC the other day asking for them to seriously consider doing some collaborative work with a leading company such as Autodesk so the Flyer can be what all of us who bought it for; that we should have access to a drawing/sketching /design app that does the Flyer justice, not just scribbling with 5 colours etc, that the pen api should at least have a colour wheel! I went on to say that the Flyer's market would improve greatly if they allowed the pen to be used to it's full potential...
I really don't get why they would make such a lovely thing but then not bother to finish it off properly... It's like making a really beautiful car and not supplying the wheels or something silly...
Sent from my HTC Flyer P512 using xda premium
The sad fact is that there is just not enough paying demand out there for high end sketch applications. HTC was targeting business users with the pen. Users such as doctors that would prefer a high accuracy interface like a pen vs. the finger for entering larger amounts of data quickly. Of course those markets are demanding and complex and won't tolerate a half finished product like HTC's. Professional users want a turnkey system, not something they have to fiddle with to get to kind-of-work. S0 the Pen on HTC has turned out to be more of a novelty than a useful tool, which is sad because it has great potential and I love it for taking notes.
HTC published the Pen SDK and Android 4.0 has native stylus support primitives so someone could realistically write an application that has pro caliber sketch functions. Probably happen later under 4.0 ICS as a port of an existing app. I just don't see enough demand for someone to write a new app.
Okay. I feel you are being the realist here. I don't know zip about Android (the flyer is my first touchscreen gizmo) and have been a Windows sucker for ever so don't know about Linux either, but how much would you think a developer would want for creating a color wheel for the stock stylus app? At least then we could draw with a decent colour range with Scribbler or even just in notes. In my ignorance, please forgive me, but the pen api sdk released by HTC would allow someone to do that wouldn't it? If I knew how I'd be on it like I don't know what...
Sent from my HTC Flyer P512 using xda premium
You would think HTC would have done such a basic feature , but they didn't.
In order to add it, you would need the source code for the current apps. HTC is not sharing that. The SDK provides primitive functions for building new applications. it does not allow you to add features to existing applications.
Sketching...
I am using Autodesk Sketchbook mobile... the sketchbook pro for android doesent work properly. I also have a Cintiq 21 to which the pressure tip is pretty nice.
as for the Flyer I have found if you select the brush tool and play with the settings you can almost get the same feel...
So no apps other then the notes app take advantage of the Pen in GB?
I'v heard that the pen is laggy in HC...
AS far as I know, only the notes app, PDF reader and browser in GB interact in some way with the pen.
Remember that the HC rom is a early beta, I have seen people have different results with the pen on HC, probably depends on what apps you have loaded. IF!!! HTC ever has a final release, I'm sure it will be much more reliable.
So there's no way really of even replacing the stock pen app - the one that pops up bottom-right, with summat better... Unless they were to release the source code for it?...
Sent from my HTC Flyer P512 using xda premium
Correct, that is part of the HTC Sense UI , its not just an app, it's tied into the Android framework.
That... sucks bum. Have HTC ever spoke of releasing the Sense UI?
Sent from my couch, with a beer in my hand and an HTC Flyer P512 using xda premium in the other.
With the second HC leak, I can use Sketchbook Mobile with no issues. What I noticed that pressure sensitivity is related to the pen you choose and the images appear to be in line with how you draw. Also the repsonse is quite good, I didn't see any issues.
I'm not sure if you're a professional sketcher but I am not and the result is impressive to me.
One important note: When you use a quality protection film (preferably mat ones) the result is better. With natural screen, the fricton is too less to write accurately but with a good film, you cannot believe how the writing/drawing experience will improve.
Edit: Skitch app becomes very handy in HC too. Actually let me repeat once more: This device is much better with HC (or ICS) due to better pen support.
+1 for Sketch Book Mobile.
The it would be nice if the erase function would work, but otherwise it works great.
kego said:
With the second HC leak, I can use Sketchbook Mobile with no issues. What I noticed that pressure sensitivity is related to the pen you choose and the images appear to be in line with how you draw. Also the repsonse is quite good, I didn't see any issues.
I'm not sure if you're a professional sketcher but I am not and the result is impressive to me.
One important note: When you use a quality protection film (preferably mat ones) the result is better. With natural screen, the fricton is too less to write accurately but with a good film, you cannot believe how the writing/drawing experience will improve.
Edit: Skitch app becomes very handy in HC too. Actually let me repeat once more: This device is much better with HC (or ICS) due to better pen support.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Let me clarify. You are saying that the pressure sensitive pen for the flyer works with sketchbook mobile on the newest HC leak, no extra development needed for the app to add the pressure sensitivity? So this means it doesn't have to use the stock colors and brushes for the native pen?
zendragon6 said:
Let me clarify. You are saying that the pressure sensitive pen for the flyer works with sketchbook mobile on the newest HC leak, no extra development needed for the app to add the pressure sensitivity? So this means it doesn't have to use the stock colors and brushes for the native pen?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's my observation (leak #2). When you choose broader brush, you can differantiate the pressure sensitivity better. It's also valid for the native notes where you choose the big brush.
I'm liking this... I'm no developer and therefore I really appreciate xda developers chat about this... I would like to use sketchbook mobile more with the pen and it's good that skitch works better too. Will be good to see if Fresco works too!
So then, following on... the stock pen part of the Android Sense UI becomes less used because the app itself is supported through support from HC (or ICS?), what can be done for/what good is the stock pen part of Sense UI? Is it potentially more powerful because it's native, in any way (ignorance possibly showing)? In terms of developing, what COULD the pen part of Sense UI do or be used for if it's superceded by the app's integral features? How could the pressure sensitivity of it be improved more.
Or...
Is it too late in on a Friday night for me to talk anything that's not utter trash?
Will have to get a matt screen protector by the way... Thanks for the suggestion.
Sent from the horizontal position, using xda premium.
Ian Rothwell said:
I'm liking this... I'm no developer and therefore I really appreciate xda developers chat about this... I would like to use sketchbook mobile more with the pen and it's good that skitch works better too. Will be good to see if Fresco works too!
So then, following on... the stock pen part of the Android Sense UI becomes less used because the app itself is supported through support from HC (or ICS?), what can be done for/what good is the stock pen part of Sense UI? Is it potentially more powerful because it's native, in any way (ignorance possibly showing)? In terms of developing, what COULD the pen part of Sense UI do or be used for if it's superceded by the app's integral features? How could the pressure sensitivity of it be improved more.
Or...
Is it too late in on a Friday night for me to talk anything that's not utter trash?
Will have to get a matt screen protector by the way... Thanks for the suggestion.
Sent from the horizontal position, using xda premium.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This depends upon HTC. If they develop any better applications for the Flyer, we'll be able to use stock part and full pen function (like erase button).
If HTC would publish (or support a 3rd party whichsoever) a better and more professional notes (something like Quill), and a good paint/sketch app I will definitely buy them. But the question is if HTC will do that.
Hi, the main reason I bought Flyer is the stylus (Magic Pen). But I am very disappointed with the performance.
As you know that Galaxy Note is on the market. I see that the stylus (S Pen) works very smooth.
I am thinking about selling Flyer and buy Galaxy Note as a replacement.
I need your opinions
Thanks and cheers
silverwind said:
Hi, the main reason I bought Flyer is the stylus (Magic Pen). But I am very disappointed with the performance.
As you know that Galaxy Note is on the market. I see that the stylus (S Pen) works very smooth.
I am thinking about selling Flyer and buy Galaxy Note as a replacement.
I need your opinions
Thanks and cheers
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FWIW...I believe the Note employs Wacom instead on N-Trig digitization.
lpasq said:
FWIW...I believe the Note employs Wacom instead on N-Trig digitization.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know, but it is not what I ask, actually
I personally wouldn't want to go below 7" for working with a pen effectively and I also have my doubts about the palm rejection technology on the Note. The HC upgrade which should eventually make it to the Flyer might address a lot of issues people have with pen use.
If you're looking for a tablet that can sustain extensive writing sessions, I'm going to say that the Flyer is probably the better option. If you need a phone, you'll obviously need to go with the Note, unless you're in a non-US market that carries the EVO View variant.
I agree with veethree that going below 7" is questionable as the Flyer is already borderline wonky to write on. However, I don't think palm rejection will be an issue. Both N-trig and Wacom sidestep the need for palm rejection by simply turning off the touch function of the screen when using the pen. There's a lot of confusion about this amongst the user community and techblogs. It's probably just poor communication from OEM's, but this is how it's always been. You have to bring the pen close to the screen first, BEFORE you put your palm down; move the pen away to reactivate the touch screen It's unnatural as most people put their palms down first, but that's how it works. In the absence of active/passive digitizers, software palm-rejection becomes the name of the game.
As far as smoothness of the writing, I think that really comes down to drivers/software from the OEM's. I've used N-trig and Wacom on Windows tablets, and I didn't notice any differences, suggesting the hardware is quite similar.
The Flyer's pen does seem to write smoother in the Notes Mobile app (pulled from Lenovo's Thinkpad Tablet and running on the Flyer), presumably because Notes Mobile uses a different shared library supplied by Lenovo. Again, suggesting smoothness is a software issue.
Finally, in my opinion, the experience is a lot better with the Honeycomb leak installed. Have you tried this?
I don't believe galaxy note using wacom technology. There is no single statement from Samsung that declared they are using wacom. They just saying that they are using their own S-pen technology.
Until now, wacom has never announced it has implemented its technology on android, because their digitizer based on resistive screen.
I suspect that galaxy note still using enhanced capacitive pen based on the software specifically designed for the small screen so it does not need a palm rejection technology. But can you imagine how uncomfortable it is to write to the screen size for daily use?
If you feel laggy using notes on gingerbread flyer, please try to deactivate the keyboard while scribbling with null keyboard. You will feel the smoothness although writing rapidly. So, this is just software problems and not because of the hardware!
Sent from my HTC Flyer P510e using Tapatalk
iwansuryo said:
...Until now, wacom has never announced it has implemented its technology on android, because their digitizer based on resistive screen...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think Wacom uses resistive screens - the ones I have used (tablet PC world) are all active digitizers on non-resistive screens.
iwansuryo said:
I don't believe galaxy note using wacom technology. There is no single statement from Samsung that declared they are using wacom. They just saying that they are using their own S-pen technology.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I suppose that's true; I've only read things at Android Community and CNET that suggest it's Wacom tech.
iwansuryo said:
Until now, wacom has never announced it has implemented its technology on android, because their digitizer based on resistive screen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Again, I think this is more misinformation likely due to OEM communication, or lack thereof. Wacom makes digitizers using either either resistive or capacitive touch-screen layers (my HP tm2t is a capactive touchscreen w/ Wacom digitizer). The touchscreen and digitizer are usually two separate layers, and I suspect the Galaxy Note will use a similar setup. Wacom and N-trig are proven tech on Windows Tablet PC's, so it would be interesting and surprising to see anything else.
iwansuryo said:
If you feel laggy using notes on gingerbread flyer, please try to deactivate the keyboard while scribbling with null keyboard. You will feel the smoothness although writing rapidly. So, this is just software problems and not because of the hardware!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I use a null keyboard too that someone put up on the Market, but I find it only addresses usability and not smoothness of the actual writing. I think HTC just needs to polish their drivers and/or shared libraries to get a smoother experience if the Lenovo implementation can be used as some kind of reference.
Android community has stated that the Galaxy note has wacom technology. Engadget said it has capacitive super Amoled display. On top of that Samsung is going to public the pen SDK in this coming December to encourage developer to create more app for the note. For me, I agree that a 7 inch display is a lot better than a 5 inch display in term of writing experience. But I believe galaxy note will have a lot more support and more great apps. If they had a 7 inch galaxy note right now , I would jump to it right away.
I hope that HTC will learn from Samsung to attract developer and media for the flyer.
I've watched a couple fo those demo videos of the Galaxy Note, and the Wacom inking support looks a lot like Tablet PC quality (smoothing, pressure, etc). I'm like most here though - 7" is about the bare minimum I would want to write on - but that Super Amoled screen is to die for...
Stylus
Stylus: Wacom E-Pen G5SP sensor
Source: http://www.engadget.com/2011/10/28/behind-the-glass-a-detailed-tour-inside-the-samsung-galaxy-note/
iwansuryo said:
I don't believe galaxy note using wacom technology. There is no single statement from Samsung that declared they are using wacom. They just saying that they are using their own S-pen technology.
Until now, wacom has never announced it has implemented its technology on android, because their digitizer based on resistive screen.
I suspect that galaxy note still using enhanced capacitive pen based on the software specifically designed for the small screen so it does not need a palm rejection technology. But can you imagine how uncomfortable it is to write to the screen size for daily use?
If you feel laggy using notes on gingerbread flyer, please try to deactivate the keyboard while scribbling with null keyboard. You will feel the smoothness although writing rapidly. So, this is just software problems and not because of the hardware!
Sent from my HTC Flyer P510e using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I read that S Note using Wacom
I would skip HC in favor of ICS
dstrauss said:
I've watched a couple fo those demo videos of the Galaxy Note, and the Wacom inking support looks a lot like Tablet PC quality (smoothing, pressure, etc). I'm like most here though - 7" is about the bare minimum I would want to write on - but that Super Amoled screen is to die for...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Actually, that is why I m becoming interested in GS Note..
But, it's just a video. Need to be tested by ourselves
I thank you all for your opinions... I think I will wait GS Note land in my country (it will be in November) and see it whether it is as good as advertized and in the meantime I will stick to my Flyer
Cheers
Wacom E-Pen G5SP
This may help. There is an hardware dissection on engadget of the Galaxy Note, "Behind the Glass"
Sorry to bring this back from the dead, but after much looking around on here the web, I haven't found anything that really answers this very question.
I was looking at the HTC Flyer to replace my rough sketchbook (nothing will really replace my pencil and paper for drawing stuff out, nor am I looking to replace my graphic tablet on my desktop, I'm just looking for something that I can hammer ideas out, thoughts on colour, etc) but after reading the various threads I'm now not so sure if that is a good choice.
There's been a fair bit of plugging for the Galaxy Note and it's S-Pen and wondering if anyone has any experience with both? Did the author for this every settle on a device?
I'm not too concerned about the lack of ICS support for the Flyer (although to be truthful I haven't had much Android experience so I don't really see how much lack of support will effect the device....although being a Windows Phone user from the get go has given me more than enough 'support issues'), nor am I looking to replace my phone.
The size for me would be an issue, but it's not as important as performance of the pen.
Pretty much everything I've read that actually talks about the pens (as opposed to other functions which hold no interest) mainly discuss writing, but I'm looking at this a purely drawing point of view. I've seen some examples of the sketches on the Flyer on a different thread and they looked pretty good, but if anyone could offer an informed opinion I'd really appreciate it, don't want to get lumbered with some half arsed device.
Hi
When I last looked at HTC Flyer some months back, the pen was only working in dedicated applications. Does anybody know whether this has improved? Has anybody installed the inofficial Honeycomb and can report whether the pen now works in all applications?
Cheers
It works on hc in the sense that you can scroll, select buttons, move through home screens etc
When we get Android 4, it will be supported in all applications
Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk
Thanks to both. I look for a device to take notes in meetings and the like. My preferred application is "FreeNote, note everything" from flyable, available in Android Market. Do you anticipate that the pen is recognized by FreeNote, prior to Android 4?
default5 said:
Thanks to both. I look for a device to take notes in meetings and the like. My preferred application is "FreeNote, note everything" from flyable, available in Android Market. Do you anticipate that the pen is recognized by FreeNote, prior to Android 4?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The pen does not work in those apps as now we are on Gingerbread. But it is supposed to work on the next Honeycomb update.
The pen works in all app if you update to HC
ytwytw said:
The pen works in all app if you update to HC
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well , kind of...
not because HC thinks its a pen, but because in the HTC HC ROM , the pen mimics your finger in apps that are not specifically HTC Pen enabled. For example in Freenote, the app thinks the pen is your finger and the pen has no more functions than if you use your finger or a capacitive stylus.
Also, ICS won't do anything magical with the pen unless the app is written to use it. ICS has some built-in pen (digital stylus) primitives, but they are not the same as HTCs SDK and don't just magically work. They will recognize the HTC stylus if a application is written to use them.
DigitalMD said:
Well , kind of...
not because HC thinks its a pen, but because in the HTC HC ROM , the pen mimics your finger in apps that are not specifically HTC Pen enabled. For example in Freenote, the app thinks the pen is your finger and the pen has no more functions than if you use your finger or a capacitive stylus.
Also, ICS won't do anything magical with the pen unless the app is written to use it. ICS has some built-in pen (digital stylus) primitives, but they are not the same as HTCs SDK and don't just magically work. They will recognize the HTC stylus if a application is written to use them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is very helpful information, thanks. It seems you have first-hand experience with Freenote and Honeycomb. Could you share your experience in more detail?
* Is it possible to write in normal size (in Paint mode) at normal writing speed?
* Is it possible to rest the wrist on the tablet while writing with the stylus (i.e., the touch screen gets inactivated when the stylus is in use)?
I played with Freenote a bit on the Flyer Honeycomb, but I don't use it as my primary note taker. I use the HTC notes app which is a custom version of Evernote. It works well and syncs with Evernote in the cloud and on PC. and is specially modified to take advantage of the HTC stylus.
Freenote with the pen works just like it works using your finger to write draw etc. The pen is more accurate, but that's the only difference.
So do those of you that have the pen feel it is worth it?
And I would also like to know if this would be a viable note taking option although I doubt it would be
fiveoneooo said:
So do those of you that have the pen feel it is worth it?
And I would also like to know if this would be a viable note taking option although I doubt it would be
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With the HC update its very beneficial using the scribe pen almost on every app and I only use the notes app which it helps me draw charts, ideas, and record meetings instantly
fiveoneooo said:
So do those of you that have the pen feel it is worth it?
And I would also like to know if this would be a viable note taking option although I doubt it would be
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes.
Yes.
Now for the long answers. I have been a user of Windows tablet PC's for years, all but one with Wacom digitizers (N-Trig on the HP Slate 500). With the addition of Honeycomb and Quill, I now have a note taking machine every bit as good and readable as my high end HP 2740p (with the exceptions of no Onenote - not available for Android, and no direct handwriting recognition). AND it is smaller and almost as thin as the SCREEN on the hP 2740p. I'm not sure what process Quill is using for rendering the ink, but it is a smooth and legible as pen on paper. One caveat, I have the Wrapsol screen saver on my HTC Flyer - one, to protect the screen, but equally important to give an even better writing surface than bare glass.
I haven't battle tested it yet (long meeting, lots of notes) but so far it is better than any solution I've tried (heaven help you if you want to take notes on an iPad with a capacitive stylus). The screen, at 7" is a little cramped, but it is so small and light to carry it is a no brainer to take to meetings or taking notes at your desk. On the issue of handwriting recognition, I feel that is an over-sold concept even on the Windows platform where recognition is excellent - if you have that much to write - you should type. I prefer to save my notes as PDF and store in the files on the server for reference, just like a paper notebook. The incredible advantage of Onenote (please bring it to Android Mr. Ballmer) is that it indexes your notes without conversion, so you can search for any word in a handwritten note. I believe Evernote can do something similar, but have not yet tried it.
Anyway, this is the best $299 (now you can get them at times for $239) I've spent in a LONG TIME on computer gear.
Dstraus--I recognize you name from the old tablet pc days. I have used those and still do since the beginning. I have just got the stock ota update to honeycomb and am excited to try out quill. Also it seems pdf viewer from a quick look will be a pdf annotator type experience on androod---hope so at least
Hi all
I am the OP of this thread. Thanks for your advice. I have just bought a HTC Flyer and installed Freenote. Works great! Taking notes electronically is now truly feasible. I can only support the notion that a capacitative stylus is a no go for serious handwriting. I now also register this second copy of Freenote (the first stays on my larger 10" pad, no pen :-( on that).
One thing that I did not get to work: Editor | Stylus | "Electromagnetic pen only". I thought that the magic pen of the HTC Flyer is electromagnetic, but when switching this option on, neither finger touch nor pen is recognized.
PS to dstrauss: the device is in Switzerland clearly more expensive than $239; but a good investment nevertheless
Is there anything I can do to use HTC stylus pen on my HTC on m8 max. I mean anything, installing any app, hacking anything anything. you can reach me on [email protected]