Related
EDIT: I have some new information. Check the following thread. http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1439582
BELOW is the original Thread.
RETURN YOUR TF201!!!
I am. Granted I have not just the GPS issue, but BT/WiFi fail as well. But you guys know that ASUS released this device knowing full well that the GPS was not going to work and I can't imagine they didn't catch the BT issue prior to release too. The only way they missed the BT issue is if the BT issue is caused by whatever quick fix they used to solve the initial BT issues reported by a reviewer(s).
By acquiescing, you are telling ASUS and every other manufacturer that this behavior is okay. That when faced with a choice of scrapping a device in the manufacturing stage for a significant loss, or releasing it to the public and letting the cards fall where they may for less of a loss, that they should screw the consumer. Depending on the extent of the issues with the TF201, they would have had to replace the backs of all TF201s at the least, perhaps more. If everyone, or enough people return the device then you are sending a message that this is unacceptable. We Androids know that we aren't getting perfect Apple devices, but we don't accept such blatant insults. I am also going to be reporting this issue to the Better Business Bureau and I think you should as well. Their response to the GPS issue is nothing short of a case of bait and switch.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bait-and-switch said:
Bait-and-switch is a form of fraud, most commonly used in retail sales but also applicable to other contexts. First, customers are "baited" by advertising for a product or service at a low price; second, the customers discover that the advertised good is not available and are "switched" to a costlier product.
The goal of the bait-and-switch is to persuade buyers to purchase the substitute goods as a means of avoiding disappointment over not getting the bait, or as a way to recover sunk costs expended to try to obtain the bait. It suggests that the seller will not show the original product or service advertised but instead will demonstrate a more expensive product or a similar product with a higher margin.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Without internal documents I can't truly prove that they intentionally sold a flawed TF201 with the intent to recover costs incurred before the problem was identified. But one of two things happened.
1. They caught the issue and upon determining it to be unfixable they released the device anyway to recoup whatever costs they could.
2. They are so stupid, which is possible because they released and ALL-ALUMINUM back in the first place, that their testing methods failed to catch the fact the GPS was so **** that even standing in the middle of a road with no obstructions it can take FOREVER to find your location. Until the fix to download GPS coordinates over WiFi, in a week of delivering pizzas the tablet never managed to figure out that Las Vegas wasn't Toronto.
I favor the first possibility because as bad as GPS is for me, I can't see it being possible that they didn't catch it.
For now I am back to my TF101 which works flawlessly for my uses.
EDIT: Now I've gotten my valid raging out of the way. I admit that were I only victim to the GPS issue, I would probably keep the tablet. But I still urge those of you keeping your tablets to file a report with the Better Business Bureau over ASUS' handling of the GPS issue. They advertised a feature and now they simply act as if it never happened and have offered nothing as recompense.
cool post bro..but sorry I can't care less about the GPS and I love prime so no way I'll return it
magicpork said:
cool post bro..but sorry I can't care less about the GPS and I love prime so no way I'll return it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You sir, are part of the problem. I don't care about GPS either. It's the principal of the matter and the precedent it sets. Your 500+ dollars is 500 reasons for ASUS and the next company that has a choice to release a knowingly broken device because people like you will just accept the lubed up rod they have for you.
I am giving ASUS a chance to send me a replacement unit. If they send me one and it doesn't have the BT/WiFi issue my faith will be restored and I will not report them to the BBB and any tech blog/news site that will listen to the story and read/post the correspondence between ASUS and myself. I like my TF101. I want ASUS to make this right
What exactly does this have to do with the future of Android? I can see your point (sort of), but this is a technology issue and has nothing to do with Android. Companies, regardless of their operating system, have done this sort of thing for years. I'm not saying that it's right, but it has nothing to do with the future of Android or any other operating system. Yes, Asus probably should have held this product a little longer for more tests, but they did release the first quad-core device running ICS to the world. It has a few minor defects, but those are to be expected for the first run of products like this. I say, if you're so upset, do the only thing that you can do as a consumer...don't purchase the product. That tells the company that YOU are not happy with it. Posting in a forum like this saying that we need to return a device because you're not happy with it is kind of pointless. Just take it back and get something else.
WasabiWa83 said:
What exactly does this have to do with the future of Android? I can see your point (sort of), but this is a technology issue and has nothing to do with Android. Companies, regardless of their operating system, have done this sort of thing for years. I'm not saying that it's right, but it has nothing to do with the future of Android or any other operating system. Yes, Asus probably should have held this product a little longer for more tests, but they did release the first quad-core device running ICS to the world. It has a few minor defects, but those are to be expected for the first run of products like this. I say, if you're so upset, do the only thing that you can do as a consumer...don't purchase the product. That tells the company that YOU are not happy with it. Posting in a forum like this saying that we need to return a device because you're not happy with it is kind of pointless. Just take it back and get something else.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yea in my rage I forgot to get to my central point. I refer to what these kind of events do to the future of Android. Imagine where the iPhone would be if the iPhone 3G had an identical issue. Imagine all those happy iPhone 2G users selling their iPhone, and going home with a shiny new iPhone 3G only to find out that the GPS didn't work and that they couldn't browse the internet if they were playing music to a set of BT headphones or to some BT setup routed through their home/car stereo. Then if Apple decided to say that it's a phone, not a personal navigation device. Then they announced a new phone 2 weeks later and just released the iPhone 3Gs with the problems solved.. 3 or 4 months later.
Apple would likely have not survived such a fiasco since Apple is built on the premise of things just working and of having a superior end to end service. I blame ASUS for this problem. But the masses, the ones who go to Best Buy and buy a random tablet, would return this and from then on they would think Android was a bad platform. They would likely never learn that it was just the particular device that is bad. These kinds of things can't be allowed to happen if Android is to remain a viable alternative. The issues with this tablet are not your regular first run issues. First run issues are usually few and minor. GPS is all but useless, and for me and many others bluetooth is also useless. Is ASUS going to throw up their hands in another few weeks and say that this is not a dedicated MP3 player and take bluetooth off the spec sheet? If ASUS doesn't find me a tablet with working bluetooth I will be returning it. The point is that if the rest of you just accept the GPS problem, and the BT problem if you have it just because you don't use those features you are going to have the problem with the next device and the next one, or similar ones.
Last. STOP CALLING THIS A FRIGGIN EARLY ADOPTER OR FIRST GEN DEVICE. This is the TF201. The 2 differentiates it from the TF101. This device brings changes to the TF101. It is not an entirely new device.
My hands are itching to type "TL;DR", but unfortunately, I have in fact read all of the thread.
From where I'm sitting (Prime is in preorder, getting it this week), you're a frustrated user, venting your frustration the wrong way.
What did you expect when you created this topic? Did you think people would agree with you en-masse, and send their devices (which many people have been waiting a long time for) back straight away?
The reason I'm asking this question is that I think you didn't stop to think about it. If the product doesn't do what it's advertised to do, you're entitled to return it. If you feel you need to share your experience with the world, you can write a review. Be it to "protect" others, or simply express your outrage, a well written review gives everyone (you, others and the manufacturer) a chance to see your point more clearly.
Thus, I advise you to refrain from going on about this in here and write a comprehensive review, noting both the pro's and the cons. Then let other people decide what they do, instead of telling them what they should.
setite said:
Yea in my rage I forgot to get to my central point. I refer to what these kind of events do to the future of Android. Imagine where the iPhone would be if the iPhone 3G had an identical issue. Imagine all those happy iPhone 2G users selling their iPhone, and going home with a shiny new iPhone 3G only to find out that the GPS didn't work and that they couldn't browse the internet if they were playing music to a set of BT headphones or to some BT setup routed through their home/car stereo. Then if Apple decided to say that it's a phone, not a personal navigation device. Then they announced a new phone 2 weeks later and just released the iPhone 3Gs with the problems solved.. 3 or 4 months later.
Apple would likely have not survived such a fiasco since Apple is built on the premise of things just working and of having a superior end to end service. I blame ASUS for this problem. But the masses, the ones who go to Best Buy and buy a random tablet, would return this and from then on they would think Android was a bad platform. They would likely never learn that it was just the particular device that is bad. These kinds of things can't be allowed to happen if Android is to remain a viable alternative. The issues with this tablet are not your regular first run issues. First run issues are usually few and minor. GPS is all but useless, and for me and many others bluetooth is also useless. Is ASUS going to throw up their hands in another few weeks and say that this is not a dedicated MP3 player and take bluetooth off the spec sheet? If ASUS doesn't find me a tablet with working bluetooth I will be returning it. The point is that if the rest of you just accept the GPS problem, and the BT problem if you have it just because you don't use those features you are going to have the problem with the next device and the next one, or similar ones.
Last. STOP CALLING THIS A FRIGGIN EARLY ADOPTER OR FIRST GEN DEVICE. This is the TF201. The 2 differentiates it from the TF101. This device brings changes to the TF101. It is not an entirely new device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Instead of your iPhone 3G 'imagination', why not look at antennagate.... and as seen then, no one gave a damn (as seen by sales figures) even when it was a critical component, GSM being disrupted due to poor signal and even so Apple claimed that you were 'holding it wrong'. Asus has done no such thing, that imo already raises it far above Apple.
As for first-gen, I agree with the way Angelusz uses it because after all, this is the first Tegra 3 device, fullstop. There have to be kinks to be ironed out and all with a new SoC and there's no device before it using Tegra 3 so the usage is perfectly valid.
No...........
Sent from my SGH-I997 using xda premium
pandaball said:
Instead of your iPhone 3G 'imagination', why not look at antennagate.... and as seen then, no one gave a damn (as seen by sales figures) even when it was a critical component, GSM being disrupted due to poor signal and even so Apple claimed that you were 'holding it wrong'. Asus has done no such thing, that imo already raises it far above Apple.
As for first-gen, I agree with the way Angelusz uses it because after all, this is the first Tegra 3 device, fullstop. There have to be kinks to be ironed out and all with a new SoC and there's no device before it using Tegra 3 so the usage is perfectly valid.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
However, if they 3 days after that released a iPhone 4F(ix) then everyone would..
Unfortunantly many of us are unable to return our devices due to Retail return policies for tablets. I could get mine exchanged but that gets me nowhere.
They are getting mine back too.
I was willing to overlook GPS, but then Wifi turned sour and as a kick in the balls,
asus has announced a new tablet by advertising it as "an improved TF201".
Well Asus, funk that! You lost me!
That we're bringing up Apple devices is interesting, considering that the TF201 has better Wi-Fi performance than the original Wi-Fi iPad according to tests by a user here - Apple, too, made a device with an aluminium back (and the little window doesn't seem to have made much of a difference). How's that iPad's GPS reception? Oh, Apple doesn't put them in Wi-Fi iPads at all. Of course, the original iPad benefited from not having a previous, plastic device to compare it to, but there were still a lot of complaints:
As of late Monday, the thread titled "Weak wifi" led all others with more than 130 messages, and nearly 13,000 views.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9174858/Wi_Fi_issues_dominate_iPad_user_complaints
So Apple made the same decision as Asus, didn't even give the option of GPS, got a lot of complaints, and... the iPad was a massive success. Apple devices, eh?
I do think that it was a bad idea for Asus to announce the TF700T now though. It's going to affect sales of the current device. It would have been better to wait until the end of Q1.
I think this young man makes a great point. Some of you have no use for GPS, I understand, but some of us that spends 500 would like to get our money worth. That means things should work as advertise. It is a bait and switch really. I'm not pissed that Asus came out with a new tablet, I'm pissed that my tablet is compromised and they're not doing anything about it. I can't take mine back because they don't refund. If you let these company do that, they'll continue to do that next time. Rush to release a product and hope that they can update it later, or if they can't, release a new model and let the customers suffer. Also, the hardware and the OS are almost synonymous, if you got a bad device, people will perceive the OS as bad as well. I know this is going to turn many people to getting an ipad even.
Now just as a devils advocate: is anyones gps COMPLETELY NON FUNCTIONING? I don't wanna hear weak, not good, sometimes, NON FUNCTIONING. If it is, you can get it replaced through RMA. Is it working at all? Then Asus didn't lie or make something up that wasn't true. I'm trying to think about this like a lawyer. Since the gps chip is functioning, it does get a signal and can handle most location acquisition tasks. I understand its not a Garmin but there was never a promise of this. GPS was a listed spec. It never made any claims as to its ability as a gps. This is where I see a problem with the Bait and Switch Argument.
Also, if everyones so damn smart here, then why didn't anyone think that the aluminum backing would have problems with signals? I think people are just a little mad maybe because they're so brilliant that overlooked something that everyone already knew would be a "problem"
In a week, my GPS has found exactly one satellite, promptly lost it and never did locate me. Left it in the car all day in a parking lot to see if it could sort itself out, all it did was drain the battery. Willing to look past it however, for the dock and battery life, and otherwise it was satisfactory (haven't tried BT/wifi yet, though, might be a deal killer)
Last night's ICS update gave me banding and market won't finish downloading anything, even post-wipe. Obviously fixable via software, but nonetheless the experience continues to fade. Plus, it's almost a doorstop while I have to sideload everything. Even my hacked-to-death Pandigital novel that I got at Kohls with some socks and 30% discount coupon is more stable than this.
There is no way that this product was conceived solely to make high schoolers pee themselves over frame rates on XDA. Businesses are going to begin equipping employees en masse with tablets of some sort, and thus far this was Android's best shot at heading off Apple, because it is a familiar form factor that Apple doesn't yet offer. I am in a role where I get to have some input on this issue for my Fortune 500 company, and I simply can't imagine showing this mess to the IT stakeholders like I had originally hoped. Keeping mine for now, but I see the OP's point of this being a strike against Android for enterprise, which is where the money has barely been tapped.
setite said:
Yea in my rage I forgot to get to my central point. I refer to what these kind of events do to the future of Android. Imagine where the iPhone would be if the iPhone 3G had an identical issue. Imagine all those happy iPhone 2G users selling their iPhone, and going home with a shiny new iPhone 3G only to find out that the GPS didn't work and that they couldn't browse the internet if they were playing music to a set of BT headphones or to some BT setup routed through their home/car stereo. Then if Apple decided to say that it's a phone, not a personal navigation device. Then they announced a new phone 2 weeks later and just released the iPhone 3Gs with the problems solved.. 3 or 4 months later.
Apple would likely have not survived such a fiasco since Apple is built on the premise of things just working and of having a superior end to end service. I blame ASUS for this problem. But the masses, the ones who go to Best Buy and buy a random tablet, would return this and from then on they would think Android was a bad platform. They would likely never learn that it was just the particular device that is bad. These kinds of things can't be allowed to happen if Android is to remain a viable alternative. The issues with this tablet are not your regular first run issues. First run issues are usually few and minor. GPS is all but useless, and for me and many others bluetooth is also useless. Is ASUS going to throw up their hands in another few weeks and say that this is not a dedicated MP3 player and take bluetooth off the spec sheet? If ASUS doesn't find me a tablet with working bluetooth I will be returning it. The point is that if the rest of you just accept the GPS problem, and the BT problem if you have it just because you don't use those features you are going to have the problem with the next device and the next one, or similar ones.
Last. STOP CALLING THIS A FRIGGIN EARLY ADOPTER OR FIRST GEN DEVICE. This is the TF201. The 2 differentiates it from the TF101. This device brings changes to the TF101. It is not an entirely new device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
this did happen with the iphone 4 and the botched antenna. apple just gave out free bumpers and they're doing fine
Mithent said:
That we're bringing up Apple devices is interesting, considering that the TF201 has better Wi-Fi performance than the original Wi-Fi iPad according to tests by a user here - Apple, too, made a device with an aluminium back (and the little window doesn't seem to have made much of a difference). How's that iPad's GPS reception? Oh, Apple doesn't put them in Wi-Fi iPads at all. Of course, the original iPad benefited from not having a previous, plastic device to compare it to, but there were still a lot of complaints:
http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9174858/Wi_Fi_issues_dominate_iPad_user_complaints
So Apple made the same decision as Asus, didn't even give the option of GPS, got a lot of complaints, and... the iPad was a massive success. Apple devices, eh?
I do think that it was a bad idea for Asus to announce the TF700T now though. It's going to affect sales of the current device. It would have been better to wait until the end of Q1.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thx man finally someone who thinks. Was just about to suggest to the thread started to get an ipad. You wont get a better product but marketing makes you believe that everythings fine.
TF700T? I dont see why I should pay another 100-150$ to have some more pixels that i only see when i hold the device 1cm before my eye.
Also the plastic thing on top looks bad.
blah blah blah blah "I'm miserable, so you should be miserable too."
If you're unhappy about how ASUS has handled the situation, then go ahead and go to the BBB...call ASUS....Call the retailer you bought it from. Complaining about it on a forum isn't going to do anything but allow you to vent. After that, it just turns into crying and whining. Sitting here day after day after day complaining about the same thing isn't going to fix a damn thing. If you're that upset about it....do something worthwhile about it.
Believe it or not, some people are not having BT/WiFi issues. I'm not. I really like my Prime....and frankly, I don't want to send it in just to wait for something else that may or may not be coming out in a couple months and may or may not be any better. Maybe they're rushing the next one out as well and it'll have it's own slew of problems. So please, stop telling me if I should be happy with my Prime or not and what I should do with it just because you are having problems.
It's not going to destroy Android. It's not going to hurt Android. If anything, It'll hurt ASUS.
clouds5 said:
Thx man finally someone who thinks. Was just about to suggest to the thread started to get an ipad. You wont get a better product but marketing makes you believe that everythings fine.
TF700T? I dont see why I should pay another 100-150$ to have some more pixels that i only see when i hold the device 1cm before my eye.
Also the plastic thing on top looks bad.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
+10000000000000000000000000000
Cant wait til the trolls are gone
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using xda premium
HuskerWebhead said:
blah blah blah blah "I'm miserable, so you should be miserable too."
If you're unhappy about how ASUS has handled the situation, then go ahead and go to the BBB...call ASUS....Call the retailer you bought it from. Complaining about it on a forum isn't going to do anything but allow you to vent. After that, it just turns into crying and whining. Sitting here day after day after day complaining about the same thing isn't going to fix a damn thing. If you're that upset about it....do something worthwhile about it.
Believe it or not, some people are not having BT/WiFi issues. I'm not. I really like my Prime....and frankly, I don't want to send it in just to wait for something else that may or may not be coming out in a couple months and may or may not be any better. Maybe they're rushing the next one out as well and it'll have it's own slew of problems. So please, stop telling me if I should be happy with my Prime or not and what I should do with it just because you are having problems.
It's not going to destroy Android. It's not going to hurt Android. If anything, It'll hurt ASUS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
'VALUE THE FUTURE OF ANDROID' is like saying returning your Prime will save the world lol. I'm with this guy, if you don't like it call the BBB, Asus, and your retailer and make them take it back but you're *****ing at the wrong people. Even though I've had to RMA mine for screen bleed, I'm still highly impressed with Prime
Ok so this is my question:
If ASUS doesn't recall defected TF201 is it considered illegal?
Now think about this for a second, every year we see on the news that some gadget has some sort of defect and the company that created the product announces a recall to resolve this issue. ASUS has admitted there is a WiFi and GPS issue but is taking measures to deny it. Are ASUS's actions considered illegal since they are selling us products with known defects? Why hasn't the FCC or BBB required them to recall all the tablets that have these defects. My Transformer Prime came in today and I get about 1 bar right next to my router and it can't even keep a stable connection. On top of that, my 8MP camera is more blurry than my Galaxy Nexus 5MP camera. This tablet has severe hardware issues and after considering this, I think there could be a serious lawsuit involved.
Please comment, I would love to hear people's opinion.
Snwspeckle said:
Ok so this is my question:
If ASUS doesn't recall defected TF201 is it considered illegal?
Now think about this for a second, every year we see on the news that some gadget has some sort of defect and the company that created the product announces a recall to resolve this issue. ASUS has admitted there is a WiFi and GPS issue but is taking measures to deny it. Are ASUS's actions considered illegal since they are selling us products with known defects? Why hasn't the FCC or BBB required them to recall all the tablets that have these defects. My Transformer Prime came in today and I get about 1 bar right next to my router and it can't even keep a stable connection. On top of that, my 8MP camera is more blurry than my Galaxy Nexus 5MP camera. This tablet has severe hardware issues and after considering this, I think there could be a serious lawsuit involved.
Please comment, I would love to hear people's opinion.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is an EXCELLENT question that I would love a lawyer or an expert answer because I would love nothing more then to sign up for this class action lawsuit and really stick it to these sons of *****es I am totally fed up with this.
Also you are forgetting the main thing false advertisment for advertising GPS in specs and then taking it out I think this would be the homerun swing here.
Nope, not illegal. gps issue is not a safety risk. Only time they are required by law is if it poses a danger.
However you can get then for false advertising. But, first you would have to make attempt to return the product. If they don't allow return then u can say it was misleading and they didn't make reasonable effort to correct their mistake.
Sent from my Galaxy S2
Your telling me, I had to wait forever just to get a DEFECTED product shipped to me that won't even be fixed. All they do is ship you another with a good 75% chance to have a defect as well. ASUS knows the new back will fix all the issues. I am getting sick of this because now I have to bring this back to Best Buy. Oh did I also mention the entire corner of my box was completely destroyed when I got my tablet...
ravizzle said:
Nope, not illegal. gps issue is not a safety risk. Only time they are required by law is if it poses a danger.
However you can get then for false advertising. But, first you would have to make attempt to return the product. If they don't allow return then u can say it was misleading and they didn't make reasonable effort to correct their mistake.
Sent from my Galaxy S2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But the action is not regarding a safety risk, rather, its paying for a product you didn't fully receive and I am not about to go return mine to get another that is broken; especially since they don't even have them in store at Best Buy. I am not waiting to have one shipped again.
Snwspeckle said:
Your telling me, I had to wait forever just to get a DEFECTED product shipped to me that won't even be fixed. All they do is ship you another with a good 75% chance to have a defect as well. ASUS knows the new back will fix all the issues. I am getting sick of this because now I have to bring this back to Best Buy. Oh did I also mention the entire corner of my box was completely destroyed when I got my tablet...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I never said anything of that sort. Idk if my writing was unclear.
I said u can return it, but if they don't allow you to get a refund, then u have a claim because of false advertising. Never mentioned exchanges at all.
Edit 6pm PST:
You asked if it was illegal and if they were required to issue a recall.
They don't have to issue a recall. If they want to they can.
Add per my understanding they said they removed gps from the list now, do they made reasonable attempts to address false advertising. If you bought before they did that, then you should be entitled to a full refund. If they deny such refund then you have a good case.
And when I say return, I mean return. Not exchange. If lack of gps is the prob, then the prime just isn't for you, maybe wait for the t700 which has plastic back.
Sent from my Galaxy S2
My opinion is that a handful of people called the Backplate Conspiracy Theorists who are dead set on going up against the Great Evil otherwise known as Asus would look like a bunch of fools.
False advertising that the tablet has......... aGPS? I'm still waiting for someone to show me where Asus advertised the Prime as having a dedicated unassisted GPS unit.
Your box got messed up by UPS, that that issue up with them.
And you return your product to the vendor you bought it from. That would be Best Buy.
IF YOU HAVE A LEMON, RETURN THE DAMN THING.
New back plate has nothing to do with the biggest problem of all.... Primes crash/rebooting and having video issues making them unusable at this point I could care less about the GPS and weaker WiFi signal.
jdbaker82 said:
New back plate has nothing to do with the biggest problem of all.... Primes crash/rebooting and having video issues making them unusable at this point I could care less about the GPS and weaker WiFi signal.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well luckily my prime is fine, but if I was in your situation I would return or exchange my prime as it is obvious you got a bad unit.
Sent from my Galaxy S2
Snwspeckle said:
Ok so this is my question:
If ASUS doesn't recall defected TF201 is it considered illegal?
Now think about this for a second, every year we see on the news that some gadget has some sort of defect and the company that created the product announces a recall to resolve this issue. ASUS has admitted there is a WiFi and GPS issue but is taking measures to deny it. Are ASUS's actions considered illegal since they are selling us products with known defects? Why hasn't the FCC or BBB required them to recall all the tablets that have these defects. My Transformer Prime came in today and I get about 1 bar right next to my router and it can't even keep a stable connection. On top of that, my 8MP camera is more blurry than my Galaxy Nexus 5MP camera. This tablet has severe hardware issues and after considering this, I think there could be a serious lawsuit involved.
Please comment, I would love to hear people's opinion.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If its defective, return it. If it does not meet your standards, return it.
As far as the denying there is an issue part, they have come out and said in official press release that the design of the solid aluminum back degrades the signal. Its more design flaws then defects, not to say people have not had their share of mfg defects.
If customers are not happy they should speak out by not buying the products.
At the end of the day are you happy with what you got?
Loving mine so far, no mfg issues to speak of and wifi range is decent. I have not ran into an issues where I could not connect to wifi.
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using xda premium
Snwspeckle said:
Your telling me, I had to wait forever just to get a DEFECTED product shipped to me that won't even be fixed. All they do is ship you another with a good 75% chance to have a defect as well. ...........
I am not waiting to have one shipped again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You think that 75% of the Primes are defective? The tablets that no vendor can keep in stock? The same tablet you waited forever to get? The one you wont wait to get replaced?
Did I just read someone else thinks they are defective because of the rebooting after the OS update?? You do realize this is happening to a very very small number of devices, right?
Get a grip. Look around. Do some research. MOST of the articles written about problems with the Prime refer right back to here - this site, xda. Almost everything else written, reviews, consumer reactions, buyers, etc are loving their new Primes. We are NOT the average consumer of these types of devices.
Really folks. Put yourself out of this misery and return them for a refund or exchange. You may not want to keep, others do, you can make money on it by selling it on ebay.
Class action law suit over a friggin tablet that reboots after an OS update. Ridiculous. Have the FCC force a recall on a tablet. A TABLET!!!
slugbug2010 said:
Class action law suit over a friggin tablet that reboots after an OS update. Ridiculous. Have the FCC force a recall on a tablet. A TABLET!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The class action lawsuit would be under the false advertising part of removing a GPS from specs. Just curious though from your tone it seems like you think this is not a big deal that roughly 20% of Primes right now have a constant locking up and rebooting issue rending them unusable with no way to fix them not even factory resets?
There could be grounds for a civil suit if ASUS falsely advertised the capabilities of the device and/or breached their implied warranty because the Prime is not fit for the purpose for which it was sold. I'm not a lawyer but I've been in business for about 20 years and that's my understanding of the relevant legal concepts.
I think that for the period of time prior to ASUS changing their marketing of the Prime as including "GPS" (I don't remember any marketing materials specifying aGPS), they could be liable for breach of implied warranty and subject to a class action suit (or individual action, although the costs would likely be prohibitive for most people and not worth the time). Bottom line is that a reasonable and fairly knowledgeable person would assume that the GPS would work well enough for one of its primary common purposes, i.e., navigation, unless ASUS had specified otherwise.
This would only be available to anyone who purchased their Primes before ASUS changed their marketing. It would be hard to prove which customers who purchased the Prime prior to this date were aware of the GPS issue, because it's not as if ASUS sent an email to every registered customer letting them know of the defect and offering a solution. Therefore, a class action suit would likely include everybody who purchased their Prime prior to an established date regardless of whether they COULD HAVE known about the GPS issue within any return period. It's not as if most people visit forums like this one or read the ASUS Facebook page and are therefore aware of the problem. ASUS could post notice of the issue by taking out ads in newspapers, issuing press releases, etc., but to my knowledge they've done none of that.
Indeed, the fact that ASUS did publicly, albeit not widely, admit the design error works against them. They've admitted culpability and haven't yet offered compensation to those who might have been harmed. The generally poor wifi performance contributes to that harm, or at least to evidence of a design flaw that makes the Prime less fit for its purpose as a mobile connected device. Toss in the redesign of the case in the TF700 that's obviously aimed at improving radio performance, and ASUS would have a hard time claiming they're not aware of any issues.
I'm still expecting ASUS to do something, up to and including what they've said they'll do in Taiwan, that is, offer an extended return policy. They could head off a class action lawsuit simply by offering to give everyone's money back who purchased a Prime before they changed their marketing of it. The coverage date remains up in the air, in my opinion, because retailers still list GPS in the specs and the packaging itself lists GPS. It's hard for them to argue that they're no longer marketing it as a GPS-enabled device (again, specifically NOT an aGPS device) when their own packaging still lists it as a feature.
Again, I'm not a lawyer, but I've seen class action suits succeed based on far less clearly justified claims. I would be shocked if there isn't a class action suit if ASUS doesn't respond soon.
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using Tapatalk
slugbug2010 said:
You think that 75% of the Primes are defective? The tablets that no vendor can keep in stock? The same tablet you waited forever to get? The one you wont wait to get replaced?
Did I just read someone else thinks they are defective because of the rebooting after the OS update?? You do realize this is happening to a very very small number of devices, right?
Get a grip. Look around. Do some research. MOST of the articles written about problems with the Prime refer right back to here - this site, xda. Almost everything else written, reviews, consumer reactions, buyers, etc are loving their new Primes. We are NOT the average consumer of these types of devices.
Really folks. Put yourself out of this misery and return them for a refund or exchange. You may not want to keep, others do, you can make money on it by selling it on ebay.
Class action law suit over a friggin tablet that reboots after an OS update. Ridiculous. Have the FCC force a recall on a tablet. A TABLET!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Agreed, I wonder if some of these people threatening legal action ever discovered women at some point in their lives. I wouldn't want these disgruntled cry babies exchanging their "defective" products. I would rather they get their money back and once and for all put an end to their misery.
jdbaker82 said:
The class action lawsuit would be under the false advertising part of removing a GPS from specs. Just curious though from your tone it seems like you think this is not a big deal that roughly 20% of Primes right now have a constant locking up and rebooting issue rending them unusable with no way to fix them not even factory resets?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
unfortunately you cant class action on the false advertising unless they deny u from returning your tablet (within a reasonable time frame) for a refund. This is because asus has gone out and acknowledged and corrected the issue. they made a reasonable effort to correct their mistake.
And also on second thought, the device is in fact equipped with a gps sensor (it just sucks due to aluminum body) so the false advertising isnt really that strong of a case in the first place. The device does get a gps signal (although weak and horribly unusable when not on wifi)
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using xda premium
Lock ups and reboots happen were acting like nothing ever happens when sh*t like this goes out to the masses. All and i mean all updates and os upgrades will have bugs. Ios had them android has them windows has em. Asus has been the only company on the android side that has released more updates to their products than any other company. If you dont like what you got return the damn thing and stop the QQ.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
jdbaker82 said:
The class action lawsuit would be under the false advertising part of removing a GPS from specs. Just curious though from your tone it seems like you think this is not a big deal that roughly 20% of Primes right now have a constant locking up and rebooting issue rending them unusable with no way to fix them not even factory resets?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'd love to know where you guys get your numbers from.
I would much rather ASUS developcement back with the plastic strip like on the TF 700 that could be installed by Best Buy for about $25.00. While it should work correctly out of the box, I would galdly spend $25. to replace the back.
Itaintrite said:
I'd love to know where you guys get your numbers from.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You know that 93.7% of all statistics is made up, right?
---------- Post added at 07:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:01 PM ----------
What is a defected TF201?
Seriously, guys, if you are so passed off with Asus, return it already. It's just a tablet.
joehanratty said:
I would much rather ASUS developcement back with the plastic strip like on the TF 700 that could be installed by Best Buy for about $25.00. While it should work correctly out of the box, I would galdly spend $25. to replace the back.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Two problems with this:
1) It's not just a backplate. It's the back frame, with stuff built onto it. If it were a piece that was pried/screwed off and could be easily swapped out, maybe, but if you go look at the teardowns for this, you'll see this isn't the case.
2) Best Buy?? I wouldn't trust them to replace an external keyboard for a desktop, much less let them tinker inside a tablet, lol. Plus, in addition to their crappy quality of repair services, their prices are horrible. They charged money to pair bluetooth headsets to phones! D:
lol, ranting aside, welcome to XDA and enjoy your stay. Feel free to keep throwing out ideas, and watch out for the trolls. Usually they're pretty reserved, but the Prime situation has them out in force!
Itaintrite said:
I'd love to know where you guys get your numbers from.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its a estimate based on a poll on XDA and its not just a couple its hundreds of Primes effected.
Recently Clove Technology managed to grab hold of some stock of the Asus Prime and with all the issues surrounding the model they decided to carry out extensive tests on the stock they held.
The end result is they are not happy with the overall result and have concluded they will not be selling the Asus Prime at this moment in time.
Personally I think it is a bold and solid message they will send back to Asus and a credit that here we have the only seller who will stand up to Asus by showing although they are not an Asus Sales Partner they do have a louder voice in the selling of Mobile devices. That message will be picked up by the mobile industry at large... A message a lot of us want to pass back.
Great B***s Clove.
Here below is the message Clove are sending to all who pre-ordered the Prime with Clove:-
We are contacting you regarding the interest you expressed in the ASUS Transformer Prime 32GB model.
Stock supply has been a real issue and good levels of stock are not expected until late February/March.
However we have been able to obtain some stock sooner than expected; but because of complaints of faults with the model we took the decision to thoroughly test stock before fulfilling any orders.
We are at this time not satisfied that all units we could provide you with are working correctly, and performing to the standard we expect of the unit.
We have therefore taken the decision until further notice stop selling the ASUS Transformer Prime.
If in time we feel that the situation has changed and we are happy to sell the Prime, we will email you to let you know that we are once again accepting orders.
We apologise that this is the situation but trust you understand our reasons for doing so.
The Clove Technology Sales Team.
Got this too, been waiting for ages, was a bit disappointed but the more I think of it the better...
Didn't want my Prime delivered all the way to Gibraltar for it be a faulty product because returning it/RMAing it is a nightmare from Gibraltar.
I plan to wait till the issues iron themselves out, like that I will be able to save up my money better and not end up skint when I buy it
Bravo for Clove!
It's a tough decision to make when there's such a feeding frenzy over a new device. They've certainly earned my respect by doing this.
Asked them if they were going to blog about the tests they made and the results, they replied and said that at this moment they won't be revealing anything.
neoghio said:
Asked them if they were going to blog about the tests they made and the results, they replied and said that at this moment they won't be revealing anything.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I wonder why?
Absurd! Asus has said that it is mostly your imagination! Remember unless you got some of the first shipments, the boxes dont say GPS,! And who would ever use wifi on a wifi only tablet? Anyone who uses wifi should just go buy a laptop. Tablets aren't meant for wifi.
... and soon they will have to label it "Single Core Tegra 3 chip*"
*with a random possibility that maybe the chipset will supoort operating the other 3/4 cores
I'm not sure I agree with all of this. Not having a go a Clove but just playing devil's advocate here:
- Clove blog about lack of stock and build issues
- ASUS post on FB to ignore Clove and that they are not an official supplier
- Clove can't get stock (either because they have been pushed down the list or because they were never on the 'list')
- Clove email people saying we can't deliver because we're unhappy with the quality. We might deliver next month...
Clove have no responsibility for testing. If buyers have a problem they can return for full refund, or if Clove were too concerned by this they could hold back 20% of stock to cover returns of faulty units.
They also state that they might supply them in time. What will time give them? - ASUS aren't going to rebuild the thing so any faults will be permanent ones.
Sounds to me like sour grapes or a lack of supply that they aren't owning up to.
PS No disrespect at all intended to the OP.
If I were a reseller of any product and I would be made aware of possible issues with the product I would definitely run my own investigation and decide whether I want to carry the product or not.
It's not just ASUS taking the hit on returns, it's also resellers having to deal with the logistics and the dented image.
PS I am not a customer or representative of Clove's, they don't have shops in my country, and I am not certain they actually did what they said but I would encourage all resellers, big and small, to test the Primes prior to dispatching to customers... as best they can.
remics said:
If I were a reseller of any product and I would be made aware of possible issues with the product I would definitely run my own investigation and decide whether I want to carry the product or not.
It's not just ASUS taking the hit on returns, it's also resellers having to deal with the logistics and the dented image.
PS I am not a customer or representative of Clove's, they don't have shops in my country, and I am not certain they actually did what they said but I would encourage all resellers, big and small, to test the Primes prior to dispatching to customers... as best they can.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Except that they won't be revealing anything.
Secret tests with secret results? Our protector or sour grapes?
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using Tapatalk
I, too, would love for them to publish their results. I am a firm believer in the fact that the number of faulty Primes out there (processor, wifi, gps, screen etc) is far greater than Asus would like us to believe. Considering the various polls on this forum it is my own estimation that at least half of the Primes suffer from one or a combination of manufacturing/parts defects.
If a reseller with a decent stock were to carry out extensive tests over 100-1000 units and post their findings I think it would really ruin Asus' claims of "only a small percentage of units display this behavior".
I guess if we bombard their twitter/facebook/google+ we might pressure them to reveal what they did?
Bravo for Clove?
Not really, unless they won't sell because of weak GPS, majority of TF201's work relatively well. Sure they are not perfect devices, but they work.
I wonder if there's some other reason why Clove is not selling, such as simply not having enough stock.
Col.Kernel said:
Bravo for Clove!
It's a tough decision to make when there's such a feeding frenzy over a new device. They've certainly earned my respect by doing this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Quoted for Truth!
Great to see a site standing up and more worried about their Reputation, than selling a hot, but flawed, product. I know some people will swear they have a perfect unit (or one with only minor issues) but many of these devices have shipped with many issues (light bleed, GPS, WIfi, Serial Number Unknown, ICS Rebooting, lockups, etc). If I were a company, I wouldn't sell it right now either.
Life goes on. Asus will still sell primes. They will continue to make money. Everything isn't always what it seems. Might be ore to this story than people think.
remics said:
I, too, would love for them to publish their results. I am a firm believer in the fact that the number of faulty Primes out there (processor, wifi, gps, screen etc) is far greater than Asus would like us to believe. Considering the various polls on this forum it is my own estimation that at least half of the Primes suffer from one or a combination of manufacturing/parts defects.
If a reseller with a decent stock were to carry out extensive tests over 100-1000 units and post their findings I think it would really ruin Asus' claims of "only a small percentage of units display this behavior".
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not likely a big enough sampling to reflect the amount of primes produced. I'm assuming there are 40,000 to 100,000 primes out of the factory already, and will be real mad if it's only 10k
Sent from my Transformer Prime TF201 using Tapatalk
Haha. Good for Clove. Asus just got ***** slapped, and they deserve it.
kristovaher said:
majority of TF201's work relatively well. Sure they are not perfect devices, but they work.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You hit the nail on the head. All of the returns and exchanges are costing resellers a fortune. Why should Asus or the Prime be given any special consideration when compared to other devices? They're all supposed to perform the same and within very narrow tollerances. Something went horribly wrong with the Prime: trouble meeting production targets, spec changes after sales start, devices performing differently from each other in the same lot, display issues (dead pixels, screen bleed, varying color temperatures), random reboots, failed updates, and the list goes on. Clove's profit margin is narrow and if 1/3 of the devices they sell end up returned they'll barely break even. If the return and exchange rates continue in the U.S. I'd expect similar responses from resellers here too.
P.S. - I've bought tons of stuff from Clove. They're one of the best UK resellers to deal with for importing devices to the U.S. They typically do analysis on hot devices and are staffed by people that are really in to electronics. They've never done anything like this before so it would be hard to understand why they would suddenly single out one device unless something's really wrong.
Well god bless the capitalism of the USA (cronnie or not...LOL). Let me decided what to do with my money.
Like thousands of others I am perfectly happy with my Prime, and I am really happy I had the opportunity to get one. I heard all the horror stories at my time of purchase, but thank god i was allowed to decided for myself,
I can understand that maybe they didnt want to deal with ANY returns, and I feel for any of you guys that were waiting for one,
Sent from my fully functional TF201 Transformer Prime
You see in business, the last thing you want is returns. Sure you need it to survive, so customers think it's a good business/store and all, but with returns, it's always a hassle. So I can understand clove not wanting to deal with this as it seems a good number of primes have problems. Hence a lot of returns.
$1 gets you a reply
I was browsing around change.org today and I came across this. A petition to recall the prime and give users a full refund or an upgrade path to the 700. Not sure why no one but the person who started it signed it. I know if you ***** enough asus will refund your $ so maybe that's why the poster didnt pursue the petition?
http://www.change.org/petitions/asustek-recall-the-transformer-prime
edit: I just signed it for ****s and giggles.. I doubt anything will come from it especially since it doesnt seem the person who posted it is really pushing it.
Probably because it was created yesterday.. I believe.
Oh god, here we go again.
detta123 said:
Oh god, here we go again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
what do you mean?? I was just asking if anyone has seen it... so oh god yourself.
actually, there was one created with exact same theme a long time ago. it never really gained any traction as the path to upgrade wasn't realistic from a business point of view. I'm not sure if the one you have linked to is the same one. But I've seen a petition just like that made several months ago. I think when we all first heard of the Infinity Pad. Made alot of people mad..lol
demandarin said:
actually, there was one created with exact same theme a long time ago. it never really gained any traction as the path to upgrade wasn't realistic from a business point of view. I'm not sure if the one you have linked to is the same one. But I've seen a petition just like that made several months ago. I think when we all first heard of the Infinity Pad. Made alot of people mad..lol
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yeah I doubt anything will come from it, Just was wondering if anyone else came across it.
But I do know they are offering really unhappy users refunds (my friend was told by gary he could get a full refund for the tablet and dock)
My way of looking at that is this:
If they refund everyone who is extremely unhappy they have to refund them for the full retail price of the tablet and the dock(and I'm guessing tax?). So they have to dish out the retail price of it when we all know it cost them a fraction of that amount to produce them. I honestly think from a business stand point and upgrade path would be better because then they would only have to replace the tablet(assuming the docks are compatible) which is much cheaper for them then refunding the full retail purchase amount. Even if they didnt upgrade the tablet to the 700 and just replaced the backplate on the prime and maybe the wifi/bt and gps modules it would also be cheaper for them than having to refund the purchase price.
And just let me say again.. I was just asking if anyone has seen it or heard of the one I linked. Not trying to promote, have it gain momentum or start a WW3. Just simply wanted to know if anyone else stumbled on it like I have.
These petitions are always worthless.
You bought a consumer product. If you don't like it or it doesn't meet your expectations, return it to where you got it within the return period.
I have never seen a return period that is less than 14 days, and if it takes you more than two weeks to realize that the product doesn't meet your expectations, there is something obviously wrong with you.
If you waited months for an update to be released in order to make the device meet your expectations, I am sorry but you are a fool. You should always buy a device for what that device is NOW, not for what is may become in the future.
In any event, if you want an "upgrade path" here it is:
Sell the Prime on eBay. If you have taken good care of your device you should get at least $400 for it. Use that $400 to help pay for the Transformer Infinity.
almightywhacko said:
These petitions are always worthless.
You bought a consumer product. If you don't like it or it doesn't meet your expectations, return it to where you got it within the return period.
I have never seen a return period that is less than 14 days, and if it takes you more than two weeks to realize that the product doesn't meet your expectations, there is something obviously wrong with you.
If you waited months for an update to be released in order to make the device meet your expectations, I am sorry but you are a fool. You should always buy a device for what that device is NOW, not for what is may become in the future.
In any event, if you want an "upgrade path" here it is:
Sell the Prime on eBay. If you have taken good care of your device you should get at least $400 for it. Use that $400 to help pay for the Transformer Infinity.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you need to read my post again.. did I say anything about being unhappy? No.. Did I say I wanted an upgrade? No. All I did was ask if anyone came across it... gessh..
I even signed it with this comment:
"I agree there have been many issues with the prime. Not all users have issues but it seems more have them than not have them. I will support this as I do feel the prime wasnt ready to be released. I had issues with my first 2 units. The only issue I have with my current unit is some backlight bleed but my tf101 has worse BL bleed than my prime"
And I do feel the device wasnt ready for prime time. I'm pretty happy with mine. the only issue I really have is the screen bleeding and that's not even that bad and since I have squaretrade I'm thinking of popping it open and fixing that myself.
Hell I was outside yesterday and tried gps for the first time on this unit without the dongle and I got a 12/13 sat lock. Today I tried and I got 8/9. I was pretty surprised by that
graffixnyc said:
I think you need to read my post again.. did I say anything about being unhappy? No.. Did I say I wanted an upgrade? No. All I did was ask if anyone came across it... gessh..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dude, take the bug out of your ass!
Did I say anything specifically about you?
Did I mention you in any way?
My comment was 100% focused on the futile nature of these online petitions, which generally go ignored by manufacturers and which are generally started by people who don't exercise the procedures that already exist that allow customers to gain compensation for purchases that do not meet expectations.
almightywhacko said:
Dude, take the bug out of your ass!
Did I say anything about you?
Did I mention you in any way?
My comment was 100% focused on the futile nature of these online petitions, which generally go ignored by manufacturers and which are generally started by people who don't exercise the procedures that already exist that allow customers to gain compensation for purchases that do not meet expectations.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ok fair enough..lol But the fact that asus is offering refunds to people really unhappy says something as well. It says the company knows they kinda screwed up. Because in most cases: yeah, it is your problem and they dont have to offer you a refund at all. Like you said you have at least 14 days(if not longer) to return to the store. But the fact they are offering refunds to people who ***** enough does say something. Some companies no matter how much you put up a stink wont issue you a refund. A replacement? yes, but how often do they offer full refunds?
Asus should offer a upgrade and make Nvidia pick up the tab for the not ready for prime time T3
Sent from my SPH-D710 using xda premium
graffixnyc said:
ok fair enough..lol But the fact that asus is offering refunds to people really unhappy says something as well. It says the company knows they kinda screwed up. Because in most cases yeah it is your problem and they dont have to offer you a refund at all. like you said you have at least 14 days(if not longer) to return to the store. But the fact they are offering refunds to people who ***** enough does say something.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think any company that is serious about their customers does the same kind of thing. At least, HTC replaced my malfunctioning EVO 4G no questions asked. Samsung has replaced televisions and refunded me for broken televisions with no problems.
Some companies give you the run around when it comes to this kind of stuff (Looking at you Sony) but for most companies it isn't worth the negative press, especially in this day and age of internet blogging and twitter.
almightywhacko said:
I think any company that is serious about their customers does the same kind of thing. At least, HTC replaced my malfunctioning EVO 4G no questions asked. Samsung has replaced televisions and refunded me for broken televisions with no problems.
Some companies give you the run around when it comes to this kind of stuff (Looking at you Sony) but for most companies it isn't worth the negative press, especially in this day and age of internet blogging and twitter.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
you must be good. haha I've never been offered a refund. Replacements I have been offered but never a full refund. Hell I just dealt with an issue with Dell. They replaced my laptop with a refirb(accidental warranty) and started having issues with it two months later. They sent a tech to fix it, he fixed those issues but didnt send him a preloaded HD just a blank one so I have to load everything myself, and after the repair the keyboard didnt fully work. So they come again to fix that, they fix that then one speaker dies.. It took me filing a BBB complaint to have them contact me to give me a brand new system. No matter how much I *****ed before they just wanted to keep trying to fix it.
almightywhacko said:
I think any company that is serious about their customers does the same kind of thing. At least, HTC replaced my malfunctioning EVO 4G no questions asked. Samsung has replaced televisions and refunded me for broken televisions with no problems.
Some companies give you the run around when it comes to this kind of stuff (Looking at you Sony) but for most companies it isn't worth the negative press, especially in this day and age of internet blogging and twitter.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh and sorry for being a little snippy.. It's hot and humid as hell in NYC today and all the garbage is out for collection tomorrow so you can imagine the streets just smell like roses
Technically, refunds aren't given to just any and everyone who asks for it. you have to meet specific criteria for them to even consider it. Mostly just early adopters or people who bought prime before they removed GPS From their official spec, like beginning or first week of January, are eligible. but even then terms have to be met and not all of them can get it. just wanted to clear that up so everyone don't get their hopes up thinking they can get a refund. there's already several reported cases here in xda of people being denied.
I'm still waiting to hear back on certain info that'll clear up alot of things. I think Asus knows even people who have good working tablets might try to get a refund just because infinity pad right around the corner..lol. so they trying to eliminate refunds that have no real basis for getting one. Chances are very high that if you never sent your tablet in for an RMA, then try to come out the blue wanting a refund, they will deny it. They will just say send it in for RMA.
graffixnyc said:
ok fair enough..lol But the fact that asus is offering refunds to people really unhappy says something as well. It says the company knows they kinda screwed up. Because in most cases: yeah, it is your problem and they dont have to offer you a refund at all. Like you said you have at least 14 days(if not longer) to return to the store. But the fact they are offering refunds to people who ***** enough does say something. Some companies no matter how much you put up a stink wont issue you a refund. A replacement? yes, but how often do they offer full refunds?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was just about to comment on this ... I purchased my Prime on December 24th and after trying to, more or less, put up with horrible WiFi, completely non-functional GPS, and a proposed dongle solution that was not satisfactory, I was able to return my Prime (and dock) to Asus for a full refund. As a matter of fact, I just shipped it in last week, so I am still waiting on the refund, but I don't foresee any issues. The reason they let me return it was due to GPS issues, and probably legal ones on their part since GPS was a feature when i bought, but did not work, was removed from the spec list, and the solution was not satisfactory. I said all that, to say that the petition is not necessary. If you have a legitimate reason for requesting to return you TF201, they will probably work with you. On the other hand, people trying to get a refund just to get an upcoming model just need to learn some patience, and not jump on the first generation of something (ie. tegra 3). With that said, if your reason for requesting a refund has to do with the GPS issue, I was finally able to get someone with the authority to authorize one in what he said was the "Transformer Prime GPS issue department."
So my tablet was cursed with the flicker issue from day one and turned permanent a couple weeks ago. Sent it to Asus for RMA hoping they would understand that hardware is not related to an unlocked bootloader, but they didn't and I'm now stuck with a $300 repair bill despite hours of fighting and complaining.
Do I:
1) Pay the bill, keep the tablet?
2) Pay the bill, try to sell the tablet/dock and look to the nexus 7 or something else?
3) Decline the repair, cut my losses and attempt to sell the dock separately then buy something else?
4) Other...?
Keep in mind I also own the dock so I have a bit of an investment.
Thoughts?
Btw the reason I'm nervous about repairing and keeping it is because of the plethora of other issues I keep reading about. I don't want this thing to turn into a money pit...
that unlock bootloader is a *****, even if it didn't cause the issue. Unlocking your tablet was their sweetner so they wouldn't be obligated to fix your already flawed tablet for free.
Asus customer service is just some of the worst I've ever seen.
Moral of the story
Don't unlock your device until the warrenty runs out.
Simple really.
---------- Post added at 11:04 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:02 PM ----------
wifesabitch said:
Asus customer service is just some of the worst I've ever seen.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why do you say that?
He know what he was getting into when he decided to unlock his Prime.
If he had not unlocked it Asus wouldn't have charged him a dime to fix his hardware issue.
It's possible but unlikely that I would still be using the prime as my daily driver after a full year... Yes, I accepted the warning when I unlocked it, but no I didn't actually expect Asus to follow through with such a ridiculous policy. HTC had the same policy and had no problem sending me a brand new phone when the power button broke on my old unlocked Nexus One.
I obviously expected too much from their customer service.
How can anyone justify a company voiding a customer's entire warranty (including hardware) for an unlocked bootloader? Have you ever installed a new OS on your computer at home? How would you feel if you could no longer get any support for any of the parts on your computer afterwards? It's bonkers.
Hell it wouldn't even be so bad if they even budged a bit on the cost, or offered free return shipping (since I can get it back free if I decline the repairs anyway) but they're being super dinks about it.
theandies said:
Moral of the story
Don't unlock your device until the warrenty runs out.
Simple really.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Or purchase an extended warranty for it via Squaretrade when you buy it... and use them to process the warranty claim for 'damages'. (I'm talking REAL damages like his bad screen, not self induced.. though they cover those too)
Shadowlore said:
Or purchase an extended warranty for it via Squaretrade when you buy it... and use them to process the warranty claim for 'damages'. (I'm talking REAL damages like his bad screen, not self induced.. though they cover those too)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I always think about getting those warranties but never actually follow through, I've been pretty lucky with electronics...
Definitely something I'll be looking into the next time I spent $500+ on anything.
Sorry bro. Asus is a complete garbage company. I hate them with a passion.
caseyc said:
So my tablet was cursed with the flicker issue from day one and turned permanent a couple weeks ago. Sent it to Asus for RMA hoping they would understand that hardware is not related to an unlocked bootloader, but they didn't and I'm now stuck with a $300 repair bill despite hours of fighting and complaining.
Do I:
1) Pay the bill, keep the tablet?
2) Pay the bill, try to sell the tablet/dock and look to the nexus 7 or something else?
3) Decline the repair, cut my losses and attempt to sell the dock separately then buy something else?
4) Other...?
Keep in mind I also own the dock so I have a bit of an investment.
Thoughts?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ask them on what grounds do they reject your warranty (besides unlocking). Tell them you need proof that the cause of the flicker is indeed caused by unlocking.
leppie said:
Ask them on what grounds do they reject your warranty (besides unlocking). Tell them you need proof that the cause of the flicker is indeed caused by unlocking.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Tried that, the response I've gotten 3 times in a row:
"Currently there is no warranty on the unit and thus all repairs would be charged for parts and labour."
They don't care how it happened, all they are looking at is a black or white "warranty: yes or no" on a screen. This is the disappointing thing, there's no human touch or understanding at the other end at all.
I've asked at least 5 times today to talk to a supervisor and every time I've been denied outright. I don't even know if that's allowed for them to do, but I mean even if the supervisor just came on the phone and told me the same stuff I don't care. Just give me a damn chance!
what are your local customer protection laws? In the UK, I think their action would be unsupportable in law (the warranty actually provides lesser protection in the UK than statutory protection, I suspect).
nyijedi said:
Sorry bro. Asus is a complete garbage company. I hate them with a passion.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Why? Because them mean exactly what they say? The OP is basically saying, to paraphrase "I knew the policy, I saw the warnings, but I did it anyway because....I did not believe they really meant it."
I would normally say the OP is in the wrong, as he knew Asus' policy. However, Asus really is screwing customers here by not having a decent, working stock firmware available over 7 months after releasing this terribly flawed device. They're almost forcing people to break their warranty if people don't want to be stuck with an ANR'ing, laggy POS. It's not right.
ratman6161 said:
Why? Because them mean exactly what they say? The OP is basically saying, to paraphrase "I knew the policy, I saw the warnings, but I did it anyway because....I did not believe they really meant it."
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Companies ask you to agree to all sorts of crazy things, that doesn't mean it's right (or even legal) for them to do so.
BBB and small claims court are probably your best bet. It's a hassle and you might not even get the results you're hoping for, but you might as well inconvenience them for trying to stick to this ridiculous policy. I like Asus as a whole, but their outsourced repair operations are pretty bad.
bedoig said:
Companies ask you to agree to all sorts of crazy things, that doesn't mean it's right (or even legal) for them to do so.
BBB and small claims court are probably your best bet. It's a hassle and you might not even get the results you're hoping for, but you might as well inconvenience them for trying to stick to this ridiculous policy. I like Asus as a whole, but their outsourced repair operations are pretty bad.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't think I'd have a leg to stand on in small claims or anything, plus it'd cost more to go through that process than to just repair the tablet.
You hit the nail on the head, that's my feeling exactly - just because they enforce it doesn't make it right.
caseyc said:
I don't think I'd have a leg to stand on in small claims or anything, plus it'd cost more to go through that process than to just repair the tablet.
You hit the nail on the head, that's my feeling exactly - just because they enforce it doesn't make it right.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm no lawyer, but my understanding of consumer protection law in the US is that the burden of proof is on the warrantor if they are trying to invalidate your warranty. It's up to Asus to prove that your actions directly caused the failure in the affected part. Look up info on the Magnuson–Moss Warranty Act.
Small claims filing fees are usually pretty low as well. Not sure that it's worth your time, but it's one possible avenue you could take.
Edit - sorry, just noticed you're from Canada. I have no idea about consumer protection in Canada, but maybe there is an equivalent.
bedoig said:
I'm no lawyer, but my understanding of consumer protection law in the US is that the burden of proof is on the warrantor if they are trying to invalidate your warranty. It's up to Asus to prove that your actions directly caused the failure in the affected part. Look up info on the Magnuson–Moss Warranty Act.
Small claims filing fees are usually pretty low as well. Not sure that it's worth your time, but it's one possible avenue you could take.
Edit - sorry, just noticed you're from Canada. I have no idea about consumer protection in Canada, but maybe there is an equivalent.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, I'd like to believe there is some sort of protection act here too but it'd be more of a time investment than I'm willing to make.
The other unfortunate part of all this is that Asus must have a pretty tiny warehouse or a whole lot of repairs on the go because they will only give me 2 business days to decide if I want it fixed before they ship it back un-repaired. Free shipping, mind you... unlike if I were to opt for them to repair it in which I'd be on the hook for $35 in shipping. Because that makes sense.
Blah.
caseyc said:
I don't think I'd have a leg to stand on in small claims or anything, plus it'd cost more to go through that process than to just repair the tablet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I presume you are from Edmonton Alberta. I've just spent 5mins on Google to locate your provinces FAIR TRADING ACT and in view of the cost of the item/repair you should at have a go at Asus/the shop using :
(3) It is an unfair practice for a supplier
(a) to enter into a consumer transaction if the supplier knows
or ought to know that the consumer is unable to receive
any reasonable benefit from the goods or services;
(There have been known problems from day 1)
(c) to include in a consumer transaction terms or conditions
that are harsh, oppressive or excessively one-sided;
(This is what Asus are now invoking because you attempted to remedy faults that were known by the vendors. The conditions are harsh...... because they make no distinction between the action of the software and the mechanical integrity of the device and they give no grounds to challenge the warranty e.g "If in the view of Asus the damage is as a result of .........."
Please don't let them get away with it.
ratman6161 said:
Why? Because them mean exactly what they say? The OP is basically saying, to paraphrase "I knew the policy, I saw the warnings, but I did it anyway because....I did not believe they really meant it."
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Bit of a stretch really, but you're mostly right. I had hoped they would be better than that and decide when to enforce it, not blanket every case with the policy.
Better yet, I had banked on the tablet living up to the rest of the electronics I've owned and last longer than 6 months (purchased January 26th) before having a MAJOR defect that's not covered by the manufacturer...
I can live with replacing a $400 tablet after a year or whatever, but 6 months seems a bit short especially since there really haven't been any better tablet releases since.